Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

Well, shut my mouth!

Posts

Well, shut my mouth!

#1

Well, shut my mouth!

Neal in San Jose

>Last Thursday was the annual hand plane seminar for my wood club (Bay Area Woodworkers, or BAWA for those in the San Francisco area). During my part of the presentation, I stated that it is possible to close the mouth opening on a bevel up plane by honing a back bevel on the blade. Someone challenged my claim, and offered the opinion that it would only be possible to close the opening a small amount. I have seen planes where this had been done, but I had never measured before/after. So, this weekend I got my trusty old maroon Stanley 220 out and put a back bevel on the blade, making before/after measurements.

The plane was set for a fairly coarse shaving, around .002, and I measured the mouth opening. It was a dismal .088, almost large enough to throw a dead cat thru and certainly doing very little to enhance the plane's performance. It did vary from side to side somewhat- it is post WWII production after all - but the .088 was as close to the center as I could eyeball it. I then honed a 5/64 back bevel (2 mm for the inch challenged) at about 10 degrees. My Lap Sharp angle jig only goes down to 20 degrees, so I had to eyeball it, but checking with a Woodcraft angle gauge, I now have a 35 degree included angle; a 25 degree primary bevel and the new 10 degree back bevel. I then set up for a similar shaving and remeasured the mouth opening. It had closed down to .041! Over a 50% improvement. Still nothing to brag about, but a huge improvement. I ran out of time, but later this week plan on enlarging the back bevel and closing the mouth even more. Stay tuned (pun intended)!

Neal

Re: Well, shut my mouth!

#2

Curiosity

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>Interesting research, Neal, and a good use for a late model 220 plane. At some point, you would run out of back bevel space, yes? I don't know how much back clearance is necessary behind the bevel - in theory, I suppose, you could get by with 5 degrees or so. If a 220 is, as Patrick Leach says, identical to a 203 but for size, you've got about 23-24 degrees of bedding, so you've got maybe 60 degrees of theoretical back bevel available - more than I thought when starting this post.

It'll be interesting to hear more about your research.

Re: Well, shut my mouth!

#3

Re: Well, shut my mouth!

ThomD

>I did a cad version of that, which worked out that with your 5/64" back bevel, and my plane having a .1" opening in the mouth. the 0 back bevel plane blade would have the same .1" opening, and the 5/64" BB would have a .06" opening. This is at a zero shaving condition which has the advantage of no difference of get from different honing conditions. The back bevelled blade will be sharper all else being equal.

Percentage reductions are harder to talk about because simply starting with a wider mouth will reduce the change the same BB on a blade effects, vs. another setting with a smaller mouth. For instance in this case. we got a 40% improvement, but if we had started with a .04" mouth we would have had a 100% change.


img

Re: Well, shut my mouth!

#4

Re: Well, shut my mouth!

ThomD

>Oh, I forgot to mention I mocked mine up one a 20 degree bedding angle.

I did a drawing of the amount of blade thickness it would take to eliminate full .088 mouth. It would take 30 thou of thickness and result in a 173 thou of back bevel.

I looked it up, and the Stanley has a 21 degree bedding angle, wouldn't change much.

Re: Well, shut my mouth!

#5

Re: Curiosity

Jack F

>The angle of the back bevel used will make no difference in closing the mouth. It is the length of the back bevel (or actually the vertical amount of the blade steel removed) that will move the cutting edge forward. Take the back bevel far enough and you have yourself a tight mouth in a bevel down plane!

Jack

Re: Well, shut my mouth!

#6

Re: Well, shut my mouth!

Neal in San Jose

>As promised, I widened the back bevel tonight. As Thom predicted, 5/32 closed the mouth almost completely. I'll have to back off some by sharpening the "regular" bevel to remove some of the back bevel as I can now only make a shaving on about half of the plane. The other half of the mouth is completely closed. Nice to know, but I don't know what practical use this infomation has. It was a fun exercise.

Neal

Re: Well, shut my mouth!

#7

Let's not forget...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>The 220 has a slightly higher bedding angle than other Stanley BUBP. Now add a back bevel...