Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

Workbech finish

Posts

Workbech finish

#1

Workbech finish

Svante Nilsson

>Hi,

I am building a traditional Scandinavian work bench in solid maple (but with Veritas twin vice). I have put in a lot of work (and love) with hand cut dovetails in the drawers and it has tured out to be a fairly nice piece of furniture. I have planeed to use boiled linseed oil and wax but am afraid it will turn out to be too yellow.

Any suggestions?

Re: Workbech finish

#2

a suggestion for the best "bench top finish"

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Oil it like many working benches are treated. Before it turns yellow and gets dings, stains, glue blobs etc. that a working bench will get, build a fine piece of furniture on it. The fine piece of furniture will provide something to be proud of and something to show off. The bench can then become another tool in the shop to be used to make more fine furniture to show off and be proud of. Wife, if you have one, will then value your hobby more than she does today. Friends will envy this wifely support, and your hobby that returns valuable products as well as satisfaction. Ever hear a wife brag about her husbands golf score?

A few weeks ago the opening picture on Woodcentral was Mack Headly Sr.'s modest bench, a bench I took a class on. What made that bench something to be admired was not its finish or dovetails, but the magnificent furniture that was made on it.

The new woodworker in this class went straight for the new "white" maple bench. I went for Mack's, though I didn't know it was Mack's at the time. It was over in a corner by itself and didn' t look like it had been used recently. Too old and yellow perhaps. I remember buying my first sheep breeding stock. The farmer said, "buy some old ewes. They know what they are doing and you don't yet. " It was sage advice for sheep but it doesn't work for benches, I found. Still it was a treat using it and I could imagine the dovetails I cut on it were better.

Re: Workbech finish

#3

Re: Workbech finish

Dean J in MN

>I'd suggest not using wax. The last thing you want in a bench is a slippery surface. No finish is one route, simple oil is another.

A bench turning dark is a good thing! It is a tool, and will show signs of use and love with its darkening over time.

-Dean

Re: Workbech finish

#4

Re: Workbech finish

Hank Knight

>Svante,

I built my bench of maple also. I finished it with tung oil rather than boiled linseed oil for several reasons: (1) tung oil yellows a little but not nearly as much as BLO, (2) unlike BLO, it builds to a nice thickness with repeated coats and affords a little more protection than BLO, and (3) it's easy to repair - just sand or scrape the problem area and reapply.

I've been very happy with the tung oil finish; and, by the way, I wax my bench top periodically to give it a little protection and to improve it's looks. Best of all, glue doesn't stick to it when it's waxed. I've never had a problem with it being too slippery.

Pure tung oil sometimes takes a long time to cure. I used McClosky's Tung Oil Finish. It has some dryers added to improve the cure time. It was easy to apply.

Hank

Re: Workbech finish

#5

Re: Workbech finish

ThomD

>I would second some kind of drying oil. You can mix tung and BLO, and add enough drier to it to get it to dry ovenight. That can be very beautiful. Another good finish is Watco, if you have a local supplier.

If you want something with a little build do the Blo, tung, varathane in equal amounts, a very good finish for looks.

I don't think once you go to hardwood, put on a finish, that adding wax will hurt much. There is something to be said for a raw pine bench, something with some stick to it. But finished maple is going to be slipery, at least with wax you will not have the glue blobs adhering.

From a finishing perspective it is hard to get something on light maple that doesn't darken and yellow it. That is where you get into stuff like white shelac, and restorers wax. You could do that on a bench but at the end of the day maple gets nailed with all kinds of colours, just look at violins. If you don't want it to be yellow, the solution there is to go amber, which many finishes naturally are. I have a little bottle of amber instrument dye that I add to stuff like valspar diamond finish that dries with a blue tint. Just the minimum to edge the finish to an appealing tone. I have pieces I sprayed that look like they were oiled rather than frosted with sugar. The spray won't go in and get the deep colours up, but one doesn't always want that either.

Re: Workbech finish

#6

Re: Workbech finish

kees------WebKitFormBoundary7GLpVOF80sMVTD+Y------

>why not use some tungoil and finish with a -hot - floorwax. Floorwax is not slippery.

Re: Workbech finish

#7

Non detergent...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>30 Weight motor oil. Soak it in it, rub it out. You're good to go...

That is unless you use water based finishes.

Re: Workbech finish

#8

now there is a lot of wisdom in a few words

roninkokomo

>

Re: Workbech finish

#9

Re: Don't shoot the messenger.

ThomD

>That's an interesting idea, though me chilldhood recollection of polishing the wood floors with tied on rags is that is was wonderfully slippery! There are sticky waxes like bowling ball wax, maybe. Still wonder how sticky they are compared to a piece of finish planed wood. It all comes down to the dogs in the end.

I just watched Charlesworths shooting board video. Didn't learn anything except important stuff about how to be a better presenter. His bench hook design runs the plane on the bench, so there is an example of where a wax finish might actually help. His plane was leaving a lot of black marks on the bench.

Actually Charlesworth's video shows an unfinished bench top. I assume just because he touched it up. That is a serious option. A good design would have the top so it could be constantly planed. The moment the finish goes on I never feel like touching it with the plane. Oh sure it would be easy to plane it flat and then refinish, but in my shop that doesn't seem to happen. My most recent fancy bench, got a coat of oil out of a 5 gallon can. Rust had coloured the maple so it looks quite dark. It is very pretty, but any removal of the finish would be very obvious and I find myself not wanting to touch it even moreso than usual. A lot of folks like those "stable " cast iron planes, but a planing job is only as good as the underlying bench. Don't see too many of those in cast iron.

Re: Workbech finish

#10

Re: Don't shoot the messenger.

kees------WebKitFormBoundary7GLpVOF80sMVTD+Y------

>a highsolid floorwax is not slippery. Although developed for spraying or applied with a machine

a small surface like a bench can be rubbed by hand. I think you don't even have to oil it.

btw think I read somewhere, Brian Boggs - the chairmaker- finishes his chairs with hotwax.

Re: Workbech finish

#11

Re: Don't shoot the messenger.

ThomD

>Interesting. Are there any brand names for consumers, or is it all institutional.