We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
>I recently spent a couple of days with a friend of my wifes husband checking out antique shops for Stanley hand planes. While we there, he purchaced a couple, and passed on some others. This was a new experience for me, and I really enjoyed it. Since I am brand new to this, I was wondering if there are any web-sites or books that would show the value of the different numbered planes in their various conditions. I would hate to purchase a plane, and then find out that I paid way to much for it.
>Rob Lee's suggestion, I believe, is focused mainly on the collector market. If you're looking for a plane to use, you might be better off finding out what the uses of different planes are, what different years are considered good, and so on.
The link below is to an online guide to the various Stanley models. Good reading, and a good beginning, though it's more about the object than its uses. Useful books to find out what planes actually do include "The Hand Plane Book," which your local library may have, and "Planecraft," which it probably won't, but which is about $12 at Woodcraft (www.woodcraft.com, which includes listings of local Woodcraft franchise stores, if you'd like to go look at the book). Also, check out whatever books your local library has on hand tool usage.
There are online dealers from whom you can find cleaned and "vetted" planes at prices higher than you'll find in flea markets - but you can have more confidence in what you're buying.
Or, if you're comfortable cruising flea markets and garage sales and making some mistakes on the way to learning, you can save money at the expense of time (and, as I say, mistakes). On bench planes, the basic plane (Stanley models 1 - 8 - you should look for a No. 4 or 5 to get started), I look for (this is for Stanley planes):
1. Full oval tote. The tote is the handle at the back. Wrap your thumb and index finger around it. If the shape they describe is an oval, rather than a race track with flat sides, keep looking.
2. A screw at the base of the frog, the part the cutting iron sits on, in front of the base of the tote. If you find three screws here, you've got a Bedrock plane, a Good Thing if the price is good.
3. The word "Bailey" on the plane body.
4. No cracks or chunks missing.
5. A fairly shiny cutting iron at the end toward the cutting edge.
>Values are fickle at best. And a lot of it depends on condition, model, type, etc, etc. The best advice I EVER got (RIGHT HERE AT WC !)when I started down the slippery slope was to get familiar with Patrick's Blood & Gore. Education is your greatest weapon in this game. Untill you're familiar, REALLY familiar with The Beast, knowing values is useless.
I think what you are asking is 'what are fair prices to pay for Stanley planes.'
There are two basic options. One is online dealers. The other is ebay. I have done much business with Sandy Moss (www.sydnassloot.com), and his prices are fair. You will note that there are a zillion Stanley planes and they come in all ages and conditions--all of which affects price. Perhaps someone could list Walt Quadrato's website as well.
The other option is ebay. I would suggest you not use ebay at this time, because doing so effectively requires some knowledge of what you are looking at. There are excellent sellers who know their tools, show good photos, and disclose the information you need to know about them. And then there are other sellers who don't. So ebay is good for the experienced.
Regarding price discovery. There is an excellent feature of ebay which would help you right now. And that is the 'completed auctions' feature. Search 'stanley plane', or 'stanley 4 plane', etc, as you desire, and then when the search comes up, click on 'completed auctions'. Completed auctions which show you a whole bunch of what you searched for, and will show you what they sold for. By studying the photos (of the well-presented planes), you will see a pattern emerge as to what the top specimens sell for, and also what rust, broken totes, fractured sides, etc, sells for. Big advantage of using ebay for price discovery: You will never see a larger selection of Stanley planes anywhere.
But for buying, at this time I would suggest you avail yourself of a recommended online merchant.
>Others have given you good advise as to what books to get and web sites to look at, and checking Ebays completed auctions is always informative.
With buying tools there are basicaly two ways you can do it...Go out and hunt for them yourself in the wild or pay sombody else to find them for you while all you do is excersize your credit card.
Sounded like you enjoyed looking in the antique shops for the planes. To me just as important as actually getting the thing is the thrill of the hunt and knowing you have the knowledge you need to be good at it and to get a good price.Sort of like hunting a deer or just buying your beef at the store..of course nothing wrong if you like others to do your work for you so you can get what you want.
No matter which way you choose you still have to know what you are buying and what you should pay...With few exceptions If you buy off of ebay you will mostly likly be paying what the item is "worth" retail esp. if you buy off of knowledgable dealers that describe and photo the thing well.Unlike hunting in the wild you probably won't get a bargin but not to likley to really overpay either because after all the price is being set by the bidding public and not the seller. If you pay $20 at least sombody else thought it was worth $19, eh?
Lots of on line dealers,.. some may have very fair prices but in my experance many also have what I consider to be very over priced prices too compared to what the same tool would sell on ebay for [never mind in the wild].Many of these dealers also sell on the ebay and common sense will tell you if they think they could get more for thier stuff on ebay...well they would be selling it on there now wouldn't they?
Again it is YOUR job to know what you are buying and what it is worth, Never believe what a seller tells you somthing is worth, chances are he wouldn't believe you if you told him what it is worth, instead do your home work and know....Todd
Re: Stanley planes--Having second thoughts now *LINK*
Wiley Horne--So. Calif.
>Hi All,
Disclosure: I like ebay, and have 200+ feedbacks. Been screwed twice--my own fault in each case for going against common sense.
Background: In the preceding post, I said that ebay was for experienced (only). After I read Todd's post below, I went to ebay and did a couple searches. It's been a while since I shopped Stanley planes on ebay.
Findings: What I found changed my mind. The link below is a 'completed auctions' view of the search string 'stanley 4 plane'. I really don't remember the auctions being presented so well a few years ago. Right away, I found a half dozen Stanley 4's presented well enough to pose minimal risk in buying, even for a newbie.
So I am thinking that someone new to the game could do well on ebay--contrary to what I said above--if they are guided by a a simple rule.
The simple rule is 'Pick planes in good shape and pay the price. Don't try to pick diamonds out of the rough--that is for experts. Buy only planes where the seller has presented detailed photos and descriptions of condition--the more detail the better.
Of course, there are still risks. Someone dropped the plane and there's a hairline crack. A frog screw is stripped. You buy rust, and there is a crack in the plane body under the rust.
In my experience, though, the wood doesn't lie. If the wood is in good shape--meaning clear rosewood, no crack at the waist, no busted tote horn, no dings in front knob, paint specks OK, original shape rather than overhauled and refinished--the plane will be in good shape. Don't bother with rust--too many good ones that aren't rusty.
Some really nice No. 4's that went in the ballpark of $25-35.
And Todd's right--an auction price is as close as one can get to a fat-free retail price.
>I said, "If the shape they describe is an oval, rather than a race track with flat sides, keep looking." I meant, keep looking at this plane to see if it's worth buying. Full oval totes are a good thing.
Also, if you follow the link to the Wood Central Marketplace, you'll find Woodcraft there. If you're buying "Planecraft" (or anything else) from them online, buy through this link, and Wood Central gets support. Another good thing.
>Ditto what the above posters mentioned re: finished auctions on ebay. I've seen some planes that go for outrageous amounts, but generally they're in such beautiful condition, it's little wonder. There are many new woodworkers who will only buy a tool if it's new... or looks new.
As for value... what a plane is worth is entirely up to you. If you're a collector, there are different things to be concerned with. But for me, I like using em, and I bought way too many stanley planes of varying descriptions for a few years while I was in school. I guess I was something of a vein slapping iron junkie. Here's a short list of things I look for in a plane on ebay...
-SW or sweet heart. It's not always mentioned in the description, but you can sometimes see the emblem on the blade. Among other desirable features in a plane, a sweetheart iron is made with laminated steel... a good thing. It means they laminated a harder tool steel onto the blank, and they take and hold a really nice edge.
-If there are pictures of the frog, I look for a flat surface that has not been "relieved." Starting around WWII, stanley started making frogs that have a raised pattern... and new stanley, or bailey style knock-offs have this pattern still. If the surface of the frog is completely smooth, it's an indication of an older vintage, and they're generally a little nicer to use.
-rosewood handles. More recent ones have painted wood, I'm not a fan. The rosewood just feels nicer. Once in a while, you'll find a plane with a tote that's cracked at the bottom. It's an issue for some people, but I don't mind taking a little bit of effort in gluing it back together... the whole thing is clamped together by the bolt that holds the tote down anyway. Sand to 400 grit, and wax up the tote, it's a beautiful thing. Or shellac if that's your thing. I don't go for totes that are cracked up top, or chipped knobs.
-Low knobs look more like mushrooms than like a light bulbs, and they're from earlier vintage planes, too.
-Collectors will worry about original blades and whatnot, or having lots of life left in the blade. Me, I like the SW blades, as I mentioned, but if I'm looking for a user, the blade is secondary to the rest of the plane. You can find a replacement blade in A2 or carbon steel, or other premium recipes, from Lie-Nielsen or Hock, or others, and it will do a lot for your plane in the way of making it a really great user. Hock's chip breakers are wonderful, too.
-If a plane has been welded or brazed, I would generally leave it be. It's had a useful life, and maybe someone else will find it appealing, but it's a sign of bad treatment, and there may be other issues involved.
-Dust is fine. Surface rust is fine, sometimes. But if you can't really see a lot of the details, then you can't really see what you're buying.
-One last thing... Once you have your new plane, I'd look for Vol 1 of the David Charlesworth books... he has a very in-depth article on plane tuning that helped me immensely. I own Lie-Nielsen planes, and old stanleys that I tuned per his articles. With aftermarket irons, steel being equal, I can't tell any difference in performance. If I buy Lie-Nielsen now, it's usually because the plane has some feature I can't find on an old stanley... higher pitch frog, low angle jack, rabbet block plane, that sort of thing.