Re: Obsession
ThomD
>I agree with a fair bit of that. Scraping is the technique used to perfect metal surfaces so that in harmony they will produce accuracy in the .001" range. For that you need to get nearer the .0001" range. so gross removal of material may not be required. The other feature of scraping is that it produces an uneven surface marking that allows the surface to carry necessary oil. The uneven surface is sometimes referred to as "frosting", and is prized by machinists rather as we admire dovetails. It can look a bit like burl.
A horizontal mill will not make a surface grinder because it isn't fitted to the accuracy of one. The grinding wheel is not the operative part where accuracy is concerned, except to the extent that when working in tens it will take a cut while most metal cutters would not. But since you won't be working in that range, almost certainly, you might as well just use a milling bit. Machinists would also decry this procedure since it would spray grit all over the place and ruin you HM's remaining accuracy. Though you could work around that. Not sure how the SG gets around that problem though they do have dust shoots sometimes. Horizontal mills are great fun, and often quite pretty.
There isn't any reason why a wood plane can't be held to finer dimensions than a metal one. Both systems have instability problems, and the wooden plane is trivially easy to correct. Which is a good thing since it may not always hold the dimensions it was set at. Over dozens of wooden planes over decades, only two were really troublesome, mostly they are more docile than seems to be imagined. Most of what goes into Norris planes is just stuff designed to make up for a bad design. There really isn't much about them that is particularly well designed. They are just something people really like and therefore lavish enormous amounts of time on perfecting. With relatively little instruction you can get people with minimal woodworking skills to turn out hand planes in wood that will get into the tens. So it isn't really surprising that with tens of thousands of dollars worth of equipment and a budget of some thousands more, experts can turn out Norris that does as well.
Planing falls into different categories, from hacking away material to developing cross sections, to planing to dimension, fitting joints, and refining surfaces. Some of these tasks do not require extreme accuracy, while others do. Accuracy is not really greater in most metal working projects than it is in woodworking. It is normally tackled in different ways, but the requirements are similar, and it is a mistake to believe that woodworking does not require accuracy while metal working does. It's true that most cabinet jobs are not going to be done to the accuracy of a shaper, but then most metalworking does not require that accuracy either, or we would need something more accurate than even a shaper.
"Sorry to get on a soap box, but as long as the sole is reasonably flat, the area around the mouth is true and the cutter is right,I assert that the limiting factor is not the sole of the plane."
I'm sure you are right since you are regulating the key points of the sole anyway. But there are times where high sole accuracy in the contact points is required. An example I use is jointing guitar faces, or similarly proportioned bookmatched panels. These panels are too wide relative to their other dimensions to be brought together with clamps, or they would either build in stress, not come together, or create too dry a joint. They will require a very fine shaving to get the right spacing in the joint, and they will require good longitudinal accuracy. This is not a common situation, and depressingly for plane lovers a simpler method exist with sandpaper... But it's still a possible scenario, and there are others.
With the wonders of CNC, makers are now making fine tools that come out of the box with excellent accuracy, so this business of sandpaper and such is getting to beanother one of those things we did for a few years as the craft was being rediscovered, and bad tools abounded. Heck, tools even come sharpened.