Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

DON'T SCRAPE SOLES FLAT! *LINK*

Posts

DON'T SCRAPE SOLES FLAT! *LINK*

#1

DON'T SCRAPE SOLES FLAT! *LINK*

paul womack

>As one of the major proponents of not-lapping, I seem to have failed in at least one regard.

Whilst the method I advocate was inspired by conventional precision engineer's scraping, actual scraping is too slow when working with typical plane-sole errors.

My site expounds my use of both files and AlZi abrasives as the metal removal method (NOT SCRAPERS), whilst still using the highly accurate blue-on-a-flat surface aspect of scraping.

The other thread appears to be ignoring this (I think important) difference.

BugBear


sole flattening

Re: DON'T SCRAPE SOLES FLAT! *LINK*

#2

Just don't touch them at all...

Alan DuBoff

>Paul,

Not sure if my post inspired this from you or not, but scraping is actually a very good way to get a flat surface. IMO, it would be an excellent exercise in tool making. Using a old style scraper would allow one to do the job much easier, those are primarily acquired as antique machinery these days, but they do have their use such as broaching odd pieces, and this task as well.

What most folks would find is that scraping doesn't give them the desirable surface finish they would expect with a flat/shiny bottom, and to some it would be undesirable.

The bottom line is that because wood doesn't have the same tolerances as metal, you can do perfectly fine work when the sole of the plane is not 100% flat anyway. "Close enough for Rock-N-Roll" seems to fit this task well.

I am intrigued with your comments and/or what you are actually trying to tell folks, scraping is an art in working metal, and a hand plane is metal. For those inclined to understand metalworking, there is absolutely no harm in the procedure, and it could be related to working metal by hand or by machine in the same way wood is.

I don't have any problems with my planes, actually, but am more intrigued with the scraping aspect. I also have a horizontal mill which I could put a grinding wheel on and have a poor man's surface grinder...the answers are out there if you need them, but scraping is just way cool in the sense that you can get a flat surface by working metal by hand.:-)

FWIW, I think files present as many problems also. *g*

Re: DON'T SCRAPE SOLES FLAT! *LINK*

#3

Obsession

David Miller from Iowa

>Flatness is way overated. The following is the "David Miller Theory of Planing Hierarchy"

#1 - good wood. The old timers had clear, long grain, old growth wood and they could do anything they needed, in damn good style, with a wooden plane that probably wasn't as flat as most iron planes. Spend as much time selecting your wood as you do messing with the plane and life will be much easier. Now, if you are going against the grain on quilted maple, you may need a plane upgrade to a Norris or equivalent, but this is not a flatness issue. As Alan suggests, I would switch to scrapers before blaming the plane on problematic wood.

#2 - plane tuning. If one wants to obsess, do it over the cutter edge (obsession not neccessary, but better directed).

#3 - technique & patience. A bad carpenter blames his tools. It is easier to presume that the sole flatness is the problem than to seek wisdom on improving technique.

#4 - flatness. I have had really "good" planes (like Bedrocks) that didn't work worth a damn no matter what I did. I once paid $75 to have a plane flattened at an engine grinding shop and flatness was not the problem. I switched to a different, barely tuned plane and had no trouble.

Sorry to get on a soap box, but as long as the sole is reasonably flat, the area around the mouth is true and the cutter is right,I assert that the limiting factor is not the sole of the plane.

Re: DON'T SCRAPE SOLES FLAT! *LINK*

#4

Re: Obsession

ThomD

>I agree with a fair bit of that. Scraping is the technique used to perfect metal surfaces so that in harmony they will produce accuracy in the .001" range. For that you need to get nearer the .0001" range. so gross removal of material may not be required. The other feature of scraping is that it produces an uneven surface marking that allows the surface to carry necessary oil. The uneven surface is sometimes referred to as "frosting", and is prized by machinists rather as we admire dovetails. It can look a bit like burl.

A horizontal mill will not make a surface grinder because it isn't fitted to the accuracy of one. The grinding wheel is not the operative part where accuracy is concerned, except to the extent that when working in tens it will take a cut while most metal cutters would not. But since you won't be working in that range, almost certainly, you might as well just use a milling bit. Machinists would also decry this procedure since it would spray grit all over the place and ruin you HM's remaining accuracy. Though you could work around that. Not sure how the SG gets around that problem though they do have dust shoots sometimes. Horizontal mills are great fun, and often quite pretty.

There isn't any reason why a wood plane can't be held to finer dimensions than a metal one. Both systems have instability problems, and the wooden plane is trivially easy to correct. Which is a good thing since it may not always hold the dimensions it was set at. Over dozens of wooden planes over decades, only two were really troublesome, mostly they are more docile than seems to be imagined. Most of what goes into Norris planes is just stuff designed to make up for a bad design. There really isn't much about them that is particularly well designed. They are just something people really like and therefore lavish enormous amounts of time on perfecting. With relatively little instruction you can get people with minimal woodworking skills to turn out hand planes in wood that will get into the tens. So it isn't really surprising that with tens of thousands of dollars worth of equipment and a budget of some thousands more, experts can turn out Norris that does as well.

Planing falls into different categories, from hacking away material to developing cross sections, to planing to dimension, fitting joints, and refining surfaces. Some of these tasks do not require extreme accuracy, while others do. Accuracy is not really greater in most metal working projects than it is in woodworking. It is normally tackled in different ways, but the requirements are similar, and it is a mistake to believe that woodworking does not require accuracy while metal working does. It's true that most cabinet jobs are not going to be done to the accuracy of a shaper, but then most metalworking does not require that accuracy either, or we would need something more accurate than even a shaper.

"Sorry to get on a soap box, but as long as the sole is reasonably flat, the area around the mouth is true and the cutter is right,I assert that the limiting factor is not the sole of the plane."

I'm sure you are right since you are regulating the key points of the sole anyway. But there are times where high sole accuracy in the contact points is required. An example I use is jointing guitar faces, or similarly proportioned bookmatched panels. These panels are too wide relative to their other dimensions to be brought together with clamps, or they would either build in stress, not come together, or create too dry a joint. They will require a very fine shaving to get the right spacing in the joint, and they will require good longitudinal accuracy. This is not a common situation, and depressingly for plane lovers a simpler method exist with sandpaper... But it's still a possible scenario, and there are others.

With the wonders of CNC, makers are now making fine tools that come out of the box with excellent accuracy, so this business of sandpaper and such is getting to beanother one of those things we did for a few years as the craft was being rediscovered, and bad tools abounded. Heck, tools even come sharpened.

Re: DON'T SCRAPE SOLES FLAT! *LINK*

#5

Re: Obsession

Alan DuBoff

>Thom,

Your probably right about the horizontal mill, I'm not sure. There were models that did in fact have grinders on them, from the factory. My Nichols is accurate to .001" easy I believe...

And speaking of frosting, here's a pic of the ways that the knee rides on...there's another set of hand scraped ways that the table rides on...this is a pic when I was refurbishing it back to life. It only weighs about 1200#...*yikes* It is amazing to think that these were all done with a scraper, by hand!

I could be wrong, but this mill seems every bit as accurate as a surface grinder. Has a 1" horizontal arbor that measures less than .001" run out. Seems pretty accurate to me, I don't see why it wouldn't work as a surface grinder, Nichols did in fact sell them as grinders in some configurations. Just need the right wheel.


img

Re: DON'T SCRAPE SOLES FLAT! *LINK*

#6

Re: Obsession

ThomD

>Those are nice ones. There is a difference between having a wheel mounted, which I am sure you could do, and the thing running at surface grinder precision, which would be better than 001, Heck I can hand plane to that and then some. Of course I would be perfectly happy with .001, and if your plane sole was very nearly that good and needed a half thou taken off you would probably only pick they up with an abrasive, or a shaper if you had one possibly. A horizontal mill is just a mill, and if every mill could surface grind we wouldn't need surface grinders. But you are undoubtedly right that you could make something happen with the stuff you have on hand. Whether the end result will be better than you could cut with a mill is another mater. I probably should have phrased it not so much as what you could or couldn't do, but what might be easier on you and the machine for the same end result, pretty much.

Re: DON'T SCRAPE SOLES FLAT! *LINK*

#7

It's a continuum

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>There are indeed metal and wood bodied planes that are so far out of acceptable that even a good mechanic* can't use them well. My first jack plane was one of those, and I gave it away, to someone who's unlikely ever to have actually used it but who liked the symbolism of having a plane (something I knew at the time I gave it away).

But I suspect many planes fall into the middle of the bell curve, and I agree: time spent sharpening the iron is WAY more productive than time spent flattening the sole of the plane. I say this, having yet to flatten the sole of any of my planes, and not knowing how much better it might be...

*I learned the use of the word "mechanic" when I was briefly in the trades, and have appreciated its nuances ever since.

Re: DON'T SCRAPE SOLES FLAT! *LINK*

#8

Re: It's a continuum

David Barnett - SW Florida

>Wanna be a great engineer? Hire a great mechanic.

Wanna be a great conductor? Hire a great orchestra.

'Mechanic' has come to mean one skilled at repair/maintainence, usually in a specialty. Used to mean one skilled at operating machine tools, fine tuner of machines and tools, skilled toolmaker, and repairer/maintainer.

Mechanics could, and often were, both specialists and generalists.

A friend of mine (an engineer) used to say engineers have education, mechanics have talent.

Re: DON'T SCRAPE SOLES FLAT! *LINK*

#9

Re: Just don't touch them at all...

paul womack

>Not sure if my post inspired this from you or not, but scraping is actually a very good way to get a flat surface.

Triggered might be a better word than inspired.

I was led to my approach by reading about scraping, but since some of my metal planes have been badly "off", scraping them flat would be possible, but dumb.

So the core of my page, the executive one line summary for the time-poor, is that marking by reference to a blued surface, then using localised removal, *IS* an effective, reliable and ultimately accurate process.

I note some comments about "not having enough equipment". A #4 can be effectively flattened using a sheet of 12mm or thicker glass, some blue, and 1" strips of SiC wrapped around 1" rubbing blocks.

A proper surface plate (9x12" from Enco 15 dollars right now) gives more confidence that your reference is completely trustworthy (and hence that you're are indeed working towards flatness).

A surface plate is not necessary however, especially for small planes, and many people are only flattening smoothers. One of the features of my process is that the reference is not under load (and hence distorted) when it's used.

BugBear

Re: DON'T SCRAPE SOLES FLAT! *LINK*

#10

Re: Obsession

Charles

>Right on all points.

Re: DON'T SCRAPE SOLES FLAT! *LINK*

#11

Re:need...

paul womack

>Flatness is way overated.

Probably. On my index page (that leads to the technique page) I say:



One of the other FAQ's is "does my plane need to be exactly flat, and how do I make it so?". I can't answer the former (it's been the heart of many a juicy flamewar) but here's my best shot at the latter.


Some people simply want every aspect of a tool be as good as it can be, regardless of need.

BugBear

Re: DON'T SCRAPE SOLES FLAT! *LINK*

#12

Re: Obsession

Alan DuBoff

>Thom,

Your absolutely right, and I could do that, but it's just another tangent to go off on...I'm happy with my planes the way they are, although I do appreciate a new LN plane and the ability to fine tune easily where the old Stanleys I have are sometimes a bit sloppy, they still do fine.

Most all folks would do themselves a lot of good investing in sharping the blade, as long as the sole of the plane sits flat and doesn't rock, it will be a fine tool.

Metalworking is another vortex for me, it's always waiting to suck my interest and time into it...:-)