Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

Butcher block as vice face?

Posts

Butcher block as vice face?

#1

Butcher block as vice face?

Dominic in Buck's County PA

>Hi gang,

I got a couple short sections of 3" thick maple butcher block and was wondering if there woould be any problem with using them as a vice face for my twin screw vice. I have a smaller piece that could be used as a face for my Record No53. I was just concerned that the orientation of the "lamination" seam might be a problem.

Photobucket

Take a look at the photo above. It would be the piece that is at the top of the pile. What do you think?

See ya around,

Dominic

Re: Butcher block as vice face?

#2

Re: Butcher block as vice face?

ThomD

>I don't think the seams will be a problem if they are properly glued. If perpendicular to the contact faces they will be irrelevant, and if parallel they will add strength. To the extent there is a problem it comes from the random grain orientations, or tendency for surfaces to becom non-co-planar due to different expansion ratios. But the reality is that solid wood also has these problems if for other reasons. Carefully evaluate, then go for it.

Re: Butcher block as vice face?

#3

Re: Butcher block as vice face?

wilbur

>"a couple short sections"

I guess that would be accurate if by "short" you mean 6+ feet, and by "couple" you mean a truck load, right? *wink*

It shouldn't be a problem. If you couldn't glue up wood to make a face vice, you wouldn't be able to glue up wood for anything. What problems were you anticipating?

Re: Butcher block as vice face?

#4

Something to mull over

Wiley Horne-- So. Calif.

>Hi Dominic,

What Thom said on the lamination question.

Do you have an LV twin screw, or something else? Either way, there is a bit of a trap one can fall into using really thick wood for jaws. Especially the rear jaw. The thicker the rear jaw, the greater the distance between the main screw nut and the front jaw. Which means the front jaw is cantilevered further from its support (the screw nut) than it needs to be. Which in turn makes the front jaw more likely to sag. Unless you mortise the nut into the rear jaw, in order to reduce the cantilever distance.

Also, the thicker the front jaw, the heavier the load out on the end of the cantilever, which also contributes to sag.

So. I would suggest either reducing the thickness of the jaws, down to 2" or a bit more, or else mortising the supporting nut well into the rear jaw, for the reasons given above.

I mention this stuff because it's a bit counterintuitive. It seems like the studlier the jaws, the stronger the vise. However, when you think about the leverage in the system you're building, you may conclude that 2" jaws will lead to a stronger vise than 3" jaws.

Wiley

Re: Butcher block as vice face?

#5

Re: Butcher block as vice face?

Gene DiNardo

>Dom. I used some of BallyBlock cut-offs for both

my face and end vices. Been using them for a few years and no problem.

Gene

Re: Butcher block as vice face?

#6

Re: Something to mull over

Dominic in Buck's County PA

>Thanks Wiley. What you and Thom said makes sense. I am of a mind to resaw the block down to 2" and take it from there.

Re: Butcher block as vice face?

#7

Re: Butcher block as vice face?

Dominic in Buck's County PA

>Thanks Gene!

Re: Butcher block as vice face?

#8

Re: Butcher block as vice face?

Dominic in Buck's County PA

>Wilbur,

I was thinking that the forces imposed on the vice would stress the glue joints. But from what I'm hearing, it's not a big deal.

Truthfully I have a couple of choices here. I can use the butcher block and resaw it down. Or I can use some cherry I slabbed up back in 2004 and resaw and plane that to thickness. Either way will work.

Re: Butcher block as vice face?

#9

Thanks Thom!

Dominic in Buck's County PA

>

Re: Butcher block as vice face?

#10

Re: Something to mull over

ThomD

>I agree with what Wiley said. I do have about a 4" thick jaw on my LV twin screw tail vise and it works fine because they have these anti-sag alignment pins, and I rarely need to open the rear jaws all that wide. The rear jaw looks really beefy, but other than that I am not sure of the advantage. I also have a beefy jaw on the bench side, and that causes problems just because the hardware suppliers never really contemplated that much thickness, but it does mean that the job has to be evaluated on it's own merits, there are a variety of issues I had to work around, without going into everything here.