Re: Table saw and Motorcycle safety
ThomD
>"but accidents can be prevented."
That is a much deeper debate, and without being argumentative because I am buying your point, I still don't think they begin to teach a person in shop class what you need to know to avoid all problems.
The easy stuff to understand:
- Most US saws are unsafe, and date back to a time when a child seat in a car was someone's unbelted lap in front of a dash made of wood. Expect no greater safety features.
- Most US saws have been altered in unpredictable ways to improve either safety or performance.
- Many comon practice on table saws are dangerous and yet are repeated all the time. which would seem to mean there is a probability of accident that is unavoidable.
When I was a kid I did a lot of rock and ice climbing, and thought at length about what danger was and how to survive through it. One basic issue is whether it is possible to do the right stuff and survive; or whether it is all just down to probabilities even when doing all the right stuff; and whether even it is is possible to beat the odds whether it is only the extraordinary person who can do so.
Examples in other fields would be the stock market. Scientific opinion seems to be that it is random, and unpredictable, but then we have Warren Buffet. On the other hand does the existence of a "Buffet" (if true) do anything to take the rest of us out of the casino? There are similar examples throughout life. My basic observation of climbers was that a depressing number of those who hung it out there were eventually killed, but there was the odd person who seemed to push it and remain unscathed. Which is essentially a pattern that in rough terms fits various theories.
One recent study indicated that older motorcyclists overrated their experience and level headedness and tended to have as many or more accidents than younger riders. Physical abilities were the limiting factor. So the very group that should have had better judgement, had their own judgement problems, they were just different than getting liquored up and trying to impress the girl/boyfriend.
The water gets deeper when there are several overarching priorities that are simultaniously in play, like physical and economic survival. There is no point in even being in front of the saw except to make money where a paying job is the point. It isn't a fun job any more, so right from the begining safety is compromised. Practically, commercial work on table saws should be contracted out to people who don't value their safety and don't get paid much. That's an ethical dilemna, but I'm not going there for now.