Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

Shared Safety Learning

Posts

Shared Safety Learning

#1

Shared Safety Learning

David Miller from Iowa

>A few of you knew I was laid off from my "real" job due to the economy, but I had no problem walking right into a carpentry job - and was glad to have it to make ends meet.

I was working 12 hour days to meet a deadline and on the last window jamb cut of last Wednesday night I lost concentration and hand met tablesaw (I know this is the hand tool board). Let's just say it was pretty bad but could have been worse.

Notwithstanding the somewhat permanent nature of the injuries, and that I can't do carpentry for several months and have no disability insurance and can't finish the job I was contracted to do, the non-medical insurance covered costs (so far) were about 4 times what I made since I began the job.

Just goes to show - safety first.

David

Re: Shared Safety Learning

#2

Re: Shared Safety Learning

James Watriss

>Jesus David.

I can't think of anything better to say than "that really sucks." The english language really fails me at times like this. I don't even know you that well... but I know of, or have heard of, too many instances where things like this really screw up people's plans.

I hate hearing stories like this. I'm sorry I can't say anything more cheery or reassuring than that. I really hope something better is around the bend for you.

Re: Shared Safety Learning

#3

Re: Shared Safety Learning

Scott in Douglassville, PA

>Hey, David -

Sorry to hear it. Having been through it before, I'll say that you get used to sleeping with the hand on a stack of pillows, and percocet's a good thing.

I hope your injuries weren't as bad as mine. If you need to vent, drop me a line.

Scott

Re: Shared Safety Learning

#4

Re: Shared Safety Learning

Alan DuBoff

>Really sorry to read this post David. I think it's good for all to think about the safety in the shop, being responsible, and being as careful as we can.

I think/hope that is why you posted it. It's a good time for all to remember about safety. With hand tools as well, sharp edges are dangerous...a chisel is only an arm length away at most...

You are here to talk and educate the rest of us, so that in itself is goodness, many accidents happen that folks aren't that lucky.

Mend quick, and thank your lucky stars, it could have been worse, and hope your life gets back on track soon.

Regards,

Alan

Re: Shared Safety Learning

#5

What a horrible shame

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>I'm really sorry, David. No words for it. Hope things get better.

Re: Shared Safety Learning

#6

Re: Shared Safety Learning

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>My heart goes out to you, David. I had a contest with a table saw almost 30 years ago from which I still have scars on my left middle finger and a general numbness. I did manage to avoid painkillers, though, be careful.

Pam

Re: Shared Safety Learning

#7

Table saw and Motorcycle safety

Adam Cherubini

>These things seem like motorcycles to me. Everyone I know gets hurt on them. And it doesn't seem to matter how careful you are you. Frankly, I'd like to use both. But thanks you you and others like you, I'm now too afraid to use either, which may be the best safety tip. The just don't seem to be worth the risk.

The human body is amazing in it's ability to heal. You may have pain now and depression later, but don't loose hope. No matter how bad your injuries seem or are, you can overcome. And craftsmanship isn't really in your hands after all.

Adam

Re: Shared Safety Learning

#8

Re: Table saw and Motorcycle safety

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>This is a fallible conjunction. They are no more alike than any device that can cause harm in a moment's distraction, say cars, bicycles, food, stoves and other appliances, scissors, almost everything we touch and/or eat.

Motorcycle safety? Don't drive until you have 10k miles under your belt. Keep your mc tuned up, inflate tires properly, etc. I practice what I call a healthy paranoia for driving anything on our roads: I assume everyone is trying to hit me and my job is to make it impossible.

Pam

Re: Shared Safety Learning

#9

Re: Table saw and Motorcycle safety

Todd O. Cronkhite Maine Native, Presently Away

>Gee David, I also am at a complete loss of words to express how badly I feel for you. In this current economy having such an injury is certainly very bad timing. :~(

Sure hope you heal up quickly and completely.

T.O.

Re: Shared Safety Learning

#10

Re: Shared Safety Learning

ThomD

>I understand you were under pressure to produce, and for that I admire your drive. I would never, however, push hard were a TS is concerned. Been there and been hurt. But that's just my luck to have been able to avoid it for the most part. In fact over a period of years, after my worst accident, which was not that bad in the scheme of things, I got rid of the saw, and I don't use them.

All I can add to the broader discussion is to listen to little voices. Most of my worst injuries including the plane crash, were preceeded by little tip offs. Some normal "maybe I should leave this till tomorow" thoughts, and in several cases things so weird I wonder whether I dreamed them. In most cases I ignored the warnings and took the hit. It is hard to alter priorities for feelings.

One experience I had in which nothing bad happened was I was flying on a Dash 7, and I am no engineer, but I think about structures. Anyway as we taxied in at the end of the flight. I noticed a crack on one of the props. The blades have various line on them for various structures and protective coatings, but this one got my attention, and feeling like fool I mentioned it to one of the flight officers while I left by the stairs. He started to say some pro-forma excuse, and then his eyes came to rest on the prop, that was on our side of the plane. He went silent in mid sentence and looked kinda pale. Never hear the end of that one. But it pays to listen to the warnings.

Re: Shared Safety Learning

#11

Re: Shared Safety Learning

Joe Rogers, Northern Virginia

>I second Scotts message as I have been there too. I was covered by workmans comp. and still almost lost my house. My condolences and I wish you a speedy recovery. My injury wasn't woodworking related but it SO dosen't matter how you get hurt. Good luck!

JR

Re: Shared Safety Learning

#12

Ellis Walentine

So sorry

Ellis Walentine

>This is the second tablesaw injury report today. I wonder if there's something in the air? One thing in the air is the economic situation and it sounds like you're already dealing with that on a personal level. I'm not sure of the best way to avoid distractions that can hurt you, but I have one observation that has come with great frequency and at great expense over the years: Watch out for the "last" one of anything. If I had to develop a rule from this, it would be that a lot of accidents come when our minds are already halfway out the door. This would be a good time to be wary of carelessness.

Not much help at this point, but I always try to make sense of senseless things. You folks are like a big family to me and I can't stand it when anybody gets hurt. Please mend well and keep your spirits up. We're here to help if possible.

Ellis Walentine, Host

Re: Shared Safety Learning

#13

Re: Tips

ThomD

>That "last" rule would cover a number of my accidents. Once while doing kindling and another time when cutting with a knife. At one moment I was thinking "time to give this up for the day", and then I was thinking "I just have a few more to do to finish the job". It's what I think of as the little voice that gets ignored. But then who really walks away from a pile of wood leaving the last two pieces unsplit?

As far as table saws are concerned there is a particular trap for our crowd in that saws over here often aren't laid out that well, or sometimes they seem a little biased to thin materials like plywood. The safety features on european saws are at least worth understanding to see the pitfalls on our saws. We have some cool aftermarket devices, like better fences and guards. But that should tell us something. One of my beefs is that the replacement fences push one several inches further back from the arbor making workpiece control harder still.

I remember also a Comment by Ashley Isles from when he worked in a pattern shop, or around pattern makers, that none of them was missing a finger, and they never put pieces through the saw without using some sort of push stick.

I have been hurt twice from kickback, once by the ejected piece, and it was amazing the violence of the blow. The other was the kind of thing where the piece just mysteriously disappears and your hand is left feeding itself into the cutter.

There is a temptation to have the 3HP router, or table saw. If the jobs are small enough that one can do them oneself, there is a lot to be said for lower power machines.

Hand tools have their own surprises. One advantage to the kneeling position when sharpening, is there isn't a long way to the floor. I remember once dropping a plane blade after sharpening while standing, and sticking my foot out to save it from the concrete floor. Wasn't aware there was anything wrong until later, when I noticed a sloshing sound coming from my sock.

Re: Shared Safety Learning

#14

Moses Yoder

Re: Table saw and Motorcycle safety

Moses Yoder

>My opinion is that a table saw and a motorcyle are no more dangerous than a car or a house. If you were driving a car down the road and never learned how to drive one you would eventually get injured. If you lived in a house and never learned how to take care of it, sooner or later you would either get injured or freeze to death. The thing about cars is that people realize you need to learn safe driving habits and then follow the habits. This is not always true of a table saw. I have given up on telling the guys at work how to run a table saw because they won't listen to me. They already know how to run a table saw. I learned safe table saw habits in high school shop class and in the 22 years since then have used a table saw about every day and never cut myself on one. The point is that if you don't learn table saw safety and then make it a habit, sooner or later you will get bit, and that goes for a car and a house just as well as a table saw. I know that accidents occasionally happen and I know how tough it is when they do and I feel bad for the people they happen to, but accidents can be prevented.

Re: Shared Safety Learning

#15

Bummer Dude...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>You heal up quick!

All my best to you,

Scott

Re: Shared Safety Learning

#16

Re: Table saw and Motorcycle safety

Tony - Memphis

>Well put. I've been sawing for around 14 years or so and I learned safety in a continuing ed class (Thanks Ron Day!). But, I always listen and read the safety articles and such. I sometimes learn something new and it also just makes me more aware. I have enjoyed reading Marc Adam's articles in PW.

Let's be careful out there folks!

Tony

Re: Shared Safety Learning

#17

Re: Table saw and Motorcycle safety

ThomD

>"but accidents can be prevented."

That is a much deeper debate, and without being argumentative because I am buying your point, I still don't think they begin to teach a person in shop class what you need to know to avoid all problems.

The easy stuff to understand:

- Most US saws are unsafe, and date back to a time when a child seat in a car was someone's unbelted lap in front of a dash made of wood. Expect no greater safety features.

- Most US saws have been altered in unpredictable ways to improve either safety or performance.

- Many comon practice on table saws are dangerous and yet are repeated all the time. which would seem to mean there is a probability of accident that is unavoidable.

When I was a kid I did a lot of rock and ice climbing, and thought at length about what danger was and how to survive through it. One basic issue is whether it is possible to do the right stuff and survive; or whether it is all just down to probabilities even when doing all the right stuff; and whether even it is is possible to beat the odds whether it is only the extraordinary person who can do so.

Examples in other fields would be the stock market. Scientific opinion seems to be that it is random, and unpredictable, but then we have Warren Buffet. On the other hand does the existence of a "Buffet" (if true) do anything to take the rest of us out of the casino? There are similar examples throughout life. My basic observation of climbers was that a depressing number of those who hung it out there were eventually killed, but there was the odd person who seemed to push it and remain unscathed. Which is essentially a pattern that in rough terms fits various theories.

One recent study indicated that older motorcyclists overrated their experience and level headedness and tended to have as many or more accidents than younger riders. Physical abilities were the limiting factor. So the very group that should have had better judgement, had their own judgement problems, they were just different than getting liquored up and trying to impress the girl/boyfriend.

The water gets deeper when there are several overarching priorities that are simultaniously in play, like physical and economic survival. There is no point in even being in front of the saw except to make money where a paying job is the point. It isn't a fun job any more, so right from the begining safety is compromised. Practically, commercial work on table saws should be contracted out to people who don't value their safety and don't get paid much. That's an ethical dilemna, but I'm not going there for now.

Re: Shared Safety Learning

#18

Moses Yoder

Re: Table saw and rock climbing

Moses Yoder

>A table saw is a pretty simple tool. The difference between a table saw and a rock climbing experience is that the saw has extremely limited capabilities, whereas rock climbing is essentially an infinitely variable experience. A rock climbing accident is very easy to avoid, and I doubt that I will ever have one of those either; I am not a climber ;) I suppose that anyone who actually lives will always encounter some risks and the probability of an accident happening increases with the risk. As I frequently tell my wife, "If you can't die doing it, it's not much fun!"

Re: Shared Safety Learning

#19

Thanks!

David Miller from Iowa

>I really wasn't looking for sympathy (although your kind thoughts are appreciated) - just wanted to give you folks the benefit of my mistake.

David

Re: Shared Safety Learning

#20

Re: Table saw and rock climbing

ThomD

>"A rock climbing accident is very easy to avoid"

There are suprisingly few of them. I always felt that people adjusted for risk level. You see the dimension when someone makes a break-through and within days everyone else is up to speed. People were holding back, until someone led the way, and yet it didn't feel like it. Same kind of deal when all of a sudden everyone can cut dovetails.

In my day, there were a number of people killed walking off the tops of climbs. Climbing shoes are like slick tires and can be super treacherous when on the wet grass one gets at the top of cliffs on rainy days. That's a lot like the accidents one gets at the end of a day with a saw.

I know what you mean about stuff not being fun if it can't kill you. On that basis old age should be a riot. The number of things that can now kill me, like breathing, is expanding exponentially.