Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

Calling Scott Burr

Posts

Calling Scott Burr

#1

Calling Scott Burr

MikeW

>Hey Scott,

I thought of all people you would see the humor in the etch on a saw.

Your words ("sick little monkey"*) in a thread a couple years ago have been used here at the shop--with much humor--from one to another of us. It morphed into the official name our shop. That was my mom's contribution as she thought the phrase was funny too not to be used.

So this one's your fault...the last picture...the first time it's been officially used...




Take care, Mike

*I had to be told by someone else the "sick little monkey" line was from Ren & Stimpy. I have no excuse for my lack of cultural awareness as I had a TV in the 1990s...

Re: Calling Scott Burr

#2

Re: Calling Scott Burr

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Hi Mike,

Nice look'n saw!

What does the word "extra" pertain to?

Is the phrase "Sick Monkey Saw Works" a one time thing or will you be using it on lots of saws? Some how at first glance, it seems to carry a negative connotation. I can see the humor in it, but perhaps not everyone who sees it in the future will realize it is meant to be humorous. Having said that, I doubt very much that it will effect your sales in a negative way.

Marv

PS...that handle sure would look nice with some wheat carving on it. :-))

Re: Calling Scott Burr

#3

Ahhhh Man I'm Honored... Mike Ineed one!

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>Actually you can't thank me. It's a line from Ren & Stimpy on NICK (tv that is) Never the less, I WANT ONE! Please drop me a line...

I need a DT saw than can blow through ganged 4/4 stock!

Re: Calling Scott Burr

#4

Re: Calling Scott Burr

MikeW

>"What does the word "extra" pertain to? "

You would need to ask Harvey Peace, Marv!

He only used it on X types of saws he made. I liken it to other makers' use of the word "Best" etc. that seem not to tie into other words or phrases well.

The Sick Monkey Saw Works etch will make it onto other saws. There is also a more benign "Corenelius Saw Works" version. The reality is nearly anything can be etched on a blade. Some have been customized and or personalized in the past. Some are period or maker specific designs that will begin showing up on saws like the Kenyon hand and panel saws soon.

Take care, Mike

Re: Calling Scott Burr

#5

Re: Calling Scott Burr

Ray Gardiner

>Hi Mike,

Ha! I like the name, it has a certain ring, that appeals to my warped

sense of humor, I trust you are aware of the IMPS, Infinite Monkey Protocol Suite, which is an official ietf standard. The RFC is here..

http://www.ietf.org/rfc/rfc2795.txt

I always wondered what "USE" meant on Grove's saws, and many other saw makers have similar inexplicable text, I think you are keeping up an age old tradition tool makers everywhere.

Regards

Ray

PS Great looking saw by the way.

Re: Calling Scott Burr

#6

Next time...

John in NM

>The handle should be monkey pod!

Re: Calling Scott Burr

#7

Re: Next time...

MikeW

>"The handle should be monkey pod!"

Hey John,

That has been recently discussed! A great thought.

I have other plans, though. We'll spin some up for Berea in November if we have any time to prepare. The time needed is not looking good, but ya never know.

Take care, Mike

Re: Calling Scott Burr

#8

Re: Calling Scott Burr

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Hi Mike,

When I see the word "extra" included in the etch of some Disston saws for example, I take it to mean "extra taper" plus other extras that involved more time spent by the smithies tempering the plate. The extra taper was advertised by Disston to indicate that the saw could be used with zero set in the teeth and produce a super smooth cut. I would think the same when I see the word on a Harvey Piece saw. These saws will also have an X stamped on the upper back end of the plate inside the handle that can't be seen unless the handle is removed.

Of course, much of this kind of information is acquired through reading and not personal experience in spite of my age. :-))

So to see the word "extra" on a backsaw, caused me to say to myself.....hmmmmmmm, hence my question.

Marv

Re: Calling Scott Burr

#9

Re: Calling Scott Burr

MikeW

>Well, Disston also used it for the London spring steel saws (at least some/most). But the steel wasn't any different from the other saws. It was still in use after 1900 when the finishing wasn't necessarily any better, either.

Disston also used it on back saws. The #77--but not all the 77s have the word from what I have seen. Later ones at least do when they dropped the real fancy etch from earlier. Though I have never seen a really good fancy etch on one, so maybe it is there just not vieable on the two examples I have seen.

One needs to remember most of these descriptors are part of the marketing blurbs. An ad on every saw.

The marketing aspect of Disston et al is an interesting diversion to me. Placed in the context of the day, it was quite impressive.

Take care, Mike

Re: Calling Scott Burr

#10

Re: Calling Scott Burr *LINK*

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Mike,

I just got back from a visit to the Disstonian website. They have a new page that features both the No.77 handsaw and the No.77 backsaw. Some interesting information regarding how the teeth were filed and what the saws were meant to be used for. Both saws include the word "extra" in the etch. Perhaps the word "extra" was used to indicate something special about the saw. Both the handsaw and the backsaw was meant to have zero set.

Marv


Disston No.77 saws

Re: Calling Scott Burr

#11

Re: Calling Scott Burr

MikeW

>Marv,

Nothing special about some of them (the hand saw models with the word under discussion).

Sorry. I don't subscribe to the notion that what Disston did was any different than other makers by and large. The etches, despite the hype and info they contain, are simply the nibs of artwork.

Take care, Mike

lunchtime is over...

Re: Calling Scott Burr

#12

Re: Calling Scott Burr

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Mike,

So, are we to understand that when we see the word "extra" on an old handsaw, we should consider it meaningless and merely advertising hype? Or is there some way to tell when it is and when it isn't?

Now I'm going to have to get my micrometer out and go measure the thickness of some saw blades.

I noticed on your website that you only offer taper ground saws upon request. Is this because you feel that taper grinding is unnecassary? I have been with the thought that a taper ground blade can function quite well with much less set or even no set at all, hence a smoother cut and less effort to work the saw. Would you mind commenting on this aspect?

Thanks,

Marv

Re: Calling Scott Burr

#13

Re: Calling Scott Burr

MikeW

>You need to read what I wrote, Marv.

There is hype and honest to goodness information in them. This applies to all the etches by all the makers, not just Disston. Seperating the information into meaningful, quantifiable bits is a little harder than taking the words at face value. For instance, Disston's use of the various steel designations. A load of crap. It was the same steel.

One way to read the web site would be as you intimate. Another would be the offering of non-taper ground blades on the Peace panel saw for less money. The others simply have taper-grinding without the option of not being taper-ground. Same with the Kenyon saws: they are taper-ground only.

Heck, it's alway been my intention to bring out a line of non-taper ground bladed hand and panel saws for as little as I can. More easily affordable and certainly usable especially if one understands the ramifications going into it.

My personal view of taper grinding is that in certain cases, the bit of extra set a non-taper ground blade requires versus a typical taper-ground blade is moot. As well, the shorter the blade (with the shorter height) the less that taper grinding is required.

But does it help lessen expended effort to saw? Sure it does to varying degrees depending on what one is cutting and how coarse or fine the hand saw is. But the main factor to me is in the finish of the cut. Less set allows a better finish on moderate to higher ppi saws plain and simple.

Wanna test the two preceeding paragraphs? Take the best 26" to 28" Disston (or whatever) 4 PPI cross cut saw you have and go cross cut a 10" wide 2" or 3" thick piece of dry Cherry. Try it with a low-line, no-name saw with as little taper-grinding you can find. The set can be the same, which is typically a bit on the moderate or heavy side. They will cut identically all sharpening factors the same.

Try the same thing using both a 26" 10 ppi cross cut using an "Extra" Disston saw and a no-name, little taper-ground saw. Take a 1" thick piece of Cherry 10" wide and see what you can get away with using very little set. The "Extra" Disston will cut much better than the no-name.

Have fun mic'ing saws. Done a bunch. The older you get in the Disston line the more varied it will be. There's a reason that I will let you discover.

Take care, Mike

Re: Calling Scott Burr

#14

Re: Calling Scott Burr

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>"I always wondered what "USE" meant on Grove's saws..."

Clearly, he was getting out in front of the debate as to whether a future owner should polish up a newly acquired saw and display it, paint bucolic scenes on it, or use it as the maker intended - to cut wood with it.

Amazingly prescient.

Re: Calling Scott Burr

#15

Re: Calling Scott Burr

Ray Gardiner

>The accepted explanation, (from the authoritative Old Tools List) is that Richard Groves was at one time in partnership with the evil Don Terwilliger, who used to stamp his personal tools "DON.T" After the acrimonous breakup up of the partnership, Richard Groves started stamping "USE" on his saws, so that the evil ex-partner's saws now would read "DON.T USE"

I imagine similar learned explanations of "sick monkey saw works" will appear in 200 years time..

Regards

Ray

Re: Calling Scott Burr

#16

Re: Calling Scott Burr

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Mike,

Thank you for taking the time to explain your reasoning regarding your taper ground saws and those that aren't.

I have been aware of the crucible, versus cast, versus spring steel as having little or no differences and how Disston used the words in their etches to imply that there were. But using the word "extra" to indicate something is different about the saw compared to another saw that looks the same might have more merit. Using the word on the No.77 backsaw is a good example. What was different about that saw compared to,say, a No.4 was the 45 degree bevel angle on crosscuts and 5 degree on rips and the claim that the saw would run without set.

Back to my original question about using the word "extra" on your Sick Monkey saw....you are including the word only to adhere to an old tradition or is there actually something special about the saw that is not obvious? I'm not being critical here, just curious.

What you explain about a 4PPI and a 10PPI in regard to taper ground saws and those that aren't makes good sense.

I find this discussion interesting. Thanks for your indulgence. I have found that I learn more from my stupid questions.

Respectfully,

Marv

Re: Calling Scott Burr

#17

Re: Calling Scott Burr

MikeW

>"Back to my original question about using the word "extra" on your Sick Monkey saw....you are including the word only to adhere to an old tradition or is there actually something special about the saw that is not obvious? I'm not being critical here, just curious."

In a word, yes. The original Peace uses the word "Extra" on the etch. As this saw is our recreation of the Peace saw in general--including the etch with the obvious modifications--we too use the word "Extra."

If I desired to spin the use of the word, I could. But why? There are practical differences between this and an original.

"But using the word "extra" to indicate something is different about the saw compared to another saw that looks the same might have more merit."

No, I don't think there is necessarily any merit. I think that we will have to agree to disagree here.

"Using the word on the No.77 backsaw is a good example. What was different about that saw compared to,say, a No.4 was the 45 degree bevel angle on crosscuts and 5 degree on rips and the claim that the saw would run without set."

The Disston model #77 back saw isn't "special" because of the way it was filed. Any back saw can be filed thus. It is the *very* slight taper grinding of the blade. It did make for a marginal difference on the cross cut version. Try cutting a deep tenon cheek with one filed rip.

If you desire to investigate this further? Compare the model #9 hand saw. When etching first began being used, replacing stamping which was a fairly limiting process as to inclusion of extra verbage, the word "Extra" was used for what I believe the first time. The previous model of the #9 hand saw that was stamped I don't believe used the word "Extra." Did something all of a sudden change about the saw? Nope. Same steel, same smithing. Heck, same workers as far as I know. But there's the word showing up on post Civil war #9 hand saws.

Or, it might be better to cmpare the #8 and #9 hand saws. The same steel was advertised as being used. Same degree of linishing following taper grinding resulting in a shinier saw plate than the #7 (which while advertised as using cast steel, was the same as the London Spring at least following 1850s when Disston began making his own steel).

The #8 never used the word "Extra" while the #9 did. Why? My position is that Disston simply charged more for the #9 than the #8. Enough more so that any linishing differences between the two (extra labor) cannot fully account for the price difference. Same steel (despite the etch), same practical amount of work. Different pricing.

But the same steel, same degrees of taper grinding. Nearly the same amount of work on the Apple handles--the #8 actually took more work in my opinion. Nearly identical saws. Different price. Different etches (once etching began). "Extra"? Nah, I don't think so.

Take care, Mike

Re: Calling Scott Burr

#18

Re: Calling Scott Burr

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Hi Mike,

The #9 is more comparable to the #12, but without the wheat carving.

The #8 is the same as the #7 except for the apple handle. The #7,s always had Beech handles and none that I've ever seen had the word "extra" above the etch. Price wise, the #7 was a lower priced saw and didn't have the extra taper as did the #9 and #12, at least according to the etch. Not having the shinier blade helped to sell the #7 for less. For others who might be reading this, the #8 we are referring to here is not to be confused with the Disston D8.

The #77 backsaw in discussion here does have some obvious differences with the pitch of the teeth. Except for 1-1/4" at the toe end, the pitch is 8PPI while that last 1-1/4" is 12PPI. The information in the Disstonian description didn't specifically mention that the blade was taper ground. Perhaps Ray Gardiner has some knowledge of this that wasn't printed in the Disstonian article. 8PPI seems to be a bit course for a tenon saw and still expect to get a cut smooth enough to dispense with having to plane the sawed surface as was advertised.

Thanks Mike,

Marv

Re: Calling Scott Burr

#19

Re: Calling Scott Burr

MikeW

>You are missing the point of my mentioning the models #s 8 and 9.

Point was, they (and the #7) were the among the first hand saw models Disston made. What exactly distinguised the two (Nos. 8 and 9)? Why such an increase in price from the 8 to the 9?

The reality is that there was little difference. The etch on the 9, however, tells the prospective customer it is special. It is "Extra." It has "London Spring Steel."

I think I am done with this thread. I think we need to agree to disagree as to the relative merits of Disston and other maker's intentions as regards an etch.

Mike

PS, the model 77 hand saw was the saw with graduated PPI, not the model #77 back saw.

Re: Calling Scott Burr

#20

Re: Calling Scott Burr

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>The #77 backsaw did have graduated teeth. Go to the link I posted up above and scroll down to the listings from old catalogs.

This is what it says below the picture of the saw....from a catalog dated 1914.

"These Saws are particularly adapted for fine cabinet work, sawing mitres, and where rapid and smooth cutting is required, the use of a plane can be dispensed with, as they will cut a joint sufficiently smooth to glue without planing. Regularly made 8 points to the inch, except for about 1�" at the front where the teeth are 12 points to the inch. In filing use a 4�" slim taper file."

I'm not trying to be argumentative. Sorry if it is coming across that way. I got your point regarding the #8 and #9. I was merely trying to make a couple points of my own.

After our discussion regarding etches, I will be adjusting my thinking about them.

Thanks

Marv