Re: Calling Scott Burr
MikeW
>"Back to my original question about using the word "extra" on your Sick Monkey saw....you are including the word only to adhere to an old tradition or is there actually something special about the saw that is not obvious? I'm not being critical here, just curious."
In a word, yes. The original Peace uses the word "Extra" on the etch. As this saw is our recreation of the Peace saw in general--including the etch with the obvious modifications--we too use the word "Extra."
If I desired to spin the use of the word, I could. But why? There are practical differences between this and an original.
"But using the word "extra" to indicate something is different about the saw compared to another saw that looks the same might have more merit."
No, I don't think there is necessarily any merit. I think that we will have to agree to disagree here.
"Using the word on the No.77 backsaw is a good example. What was different about that saw compared to,say, a No.4 was the 45 degree bevel angle on crosscuts and 5 degree on rips and the claim that the saw would run without set."
The Disston model #77 back saw isn't "special" because of the way it was filed. Any back saw can be filed thus. It is the *very* slight taper grinding of the blade. It did make for a marginal difference on the cross cut version. Try cutting a deep tenon cheek with one filed rip.
If you desire to investigate this further? Compare the model #9 hand saw. When etching first began being used, replacing stamping which was a fairly limiting process as to inclusion of extra verbage, the word "Extra" was used for what I believe the first time. The previous model of the #9 hand saw that was stamped I don't believe used the word "Extra." Did something all of a sudden change about the saw? Nope. Same steel, same smithing. Heck, same workers as far as I know. But there's the word showing up on post Civil war #9 hand saws.
Or, it might be better to cmpare the #8 and #9 hand saws. The same steel was advertised as being used. Same degree of linishing following taper grinding resulting in a shinier saw plate than the #7 (which while advertised as using cast steel, was the same as the London Spring at least following 1850s when Disston began making his own steel).
The #8 never used the word "Extra" while the #9 did. Why? My position is that Disston simply charged more for the #9 than the #8. Enough more so that any linishing differences between the two (extra labor) cannot fully account for the price difference. Same steel (despite the etch), same practical amount of work. Different pricing.
But the same steel, same degrees of taper grinding. Nearly the same amount of work on the Apple handles--the #8 actually took more work in my opinion. Nearly identical saws. Different price. Different etches (once etching began). "Extra"? Nah, I don't think so.
Take care, Mike