Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

Yet another Japanese Chisel Question

Posts

Yet another Japanese Chisel Question

#1

Yet another Japanese Chisel Question

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

>So folks, currently my "good" bench chisels are LNs. They are nice chisels but I am thinking of getting a new set with a wider range of sizes. I have some nice Japanese mortising chisels and I like them quite a bit. So I am favoring a set (10 piece)of Japanese bench chisels.

Ok, so I would love a set of Tasai damascus chisels. But honestly the price is hard for my budget to swallow. So I am looking at the Matsumura white steel chisels.

I don't doubt that the Tasai chisels are worth the money. But are the Matsumura chisels a giant step down? Any insight would be appreciated.

Tom

Re: Yet another Japanese Chisel Question

#2

Re: Yet another Japanese Chisel Question

wilbur

>I like the Fujihiro chisels made by Imai, available from Hida Tool. They run about $50 each, which is about the same price as the Lie-Nielsen chisels. A set of 10 actually is more than buying the chisels individually, as they come in a nice wooden box, which you get charged for. Just a different way of price structuring, I guess.

I would just get the sizes you need, instead of a whole set, though. I've found that it's nice to have a good assortment in the smaller sizes, but that you probably don't need all the sizes above 1" (24mm).

Re: Yet another Japanese Chisel Question

#3

Re: Yet another Japanese Chisel Question

Wiley Horne-- So. Calif.

>Hello Thomas,

People that have the Matsumura's like them, though I think most have the blue steel ones. Here is a thread from another forum that discusses Steve Wargo's experiences with them, and note down at the bottom the estimable Hank Knight brings in some insight from his own experience:

http://www.sawmillcreek.org/showthread.php?t=70145&highlight=matsumura

Years ago, I had several of the white steel dovetail chisels from JWW that are still sold at about the same price point as the Matsumura white steels. They gave good service under considerable abuse, since I used them for everything, including chopping mortises some times (nobody ever told me I couldn't do that). Tough chisels that served well, and did everything I asked of them.

Just a thought, you might consider buying the chisels you really want, but buy them in two's and three's, starting with the most used sizes. That spreads the financial pain, and you get what you really want, though not 10 at once. Like Wilbur, I mainly use the smalls, which means that (for me at least) the larger and most expensive chisels in the set get used the least. Also, if you want Tasai, doesn't need to be Damascus. Get the 'migaki' or 'black'. You can see the differences here (click on chisels, duhh):

http://www.japan-tool.com/

So-san is a good guy, and carries brands we don't see in the US much, so it's an interesting site.

One thing about getting what you really want now--you'll do it eventually anyway. And another thing about a set: there will be ones you don't use, plus you may find yourself wanting to fill in the gaps in the set, so you're then looking for singletons anyway.

It's all good, though. Go for it.

Wiley

Re: Yet another Japanese Chisel Question

#4

Re: Yet another Japanese Chisel Question

Hank Knight

>Thomas,

I a big fan of the Matsumura blue steel "cabinetmakers" chisels sold by the Japan Woodworker. I've had a set of them for a while and they are my favorites for just about everything except heavy chopping. They have more of a traingular shape than the Matsumura white steel bench chisels and, in my mind, they are better suited for fine joinery work, including dovetails. The shape is not a complete triangle like a "dovetail" chisel, but it's close; and I've found them very satisfactory for dovetails. I decided I needed some heavier bench chisels; so, when I learned Kayoko was returning to Japan last year, I ordered 5 Imai sword steel bench chisels (Imai calls them "finish" chisels) . They are truly beautiful tools - ebony handles and all - but, after using the Matsumura cabinetmakers chisels, I find them a little heavy; so I still use my Matsumuras for most things. They take an incredible edge, hold it a long time and I love the balance. That may answer your question about whether the Matsumuras are a giant step down from the Tasai's you are considering. My Matsumuras are certainly a huge step down from my Imais in beauty, craftsmanship and maybe even in the quality of the steel, but in daily use, it doesn't matter - at least not to me. At some point I think those differences are simply esoteric. I love my Imais, they are fabulous, but the Matsumuras are great too and they are my chisel of choice for most things.

My $.02

Hank

Re: Yet another Japanese Chisel Question

#5

Re: Yet another Japanese Chisel Question

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>My problem with buying chisels from JWW is that they specify inches and I've standardized on mm. Do you know if the sizes they state are approximations, simply converted from mm? Or are they truly inch sized?

Pam

Re: Yet another Japanese Chisel Question

#6

Re: Yet another Japanese Chisel Question

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Damascus/woodgrain chisels add nothing to performance. Sets add nothing beyond a nice paulownia box, which you could make yourself. I started buying Tasai edges and love them, also Funahiro and Imai - all one or two at a time. I've found that, with the one set of 12 I did buy, I never use most of them, they actually get in the way.

At least you don't want to buy them to turn them into chickens. :)

Pam

Re: Yet another Japanese Chisel Question

#7

Re: Yet another Japanese Chisel Question

Hank Knight

>Pam,

I think the Japan woodworker sizes are are approximatons of the english system. They appear to be metric sizes, but they are close enough for me. I will measure them to be sure and get back to you.

Hank

Re: Yet another Japanese Chisel Question

#8

Re: Yet another Japanese Chisel Question

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>In the lastest FWW Chris Gochnour reviewed 23 chisels, among them the Matsumura blue and white steel chisels. What came out of his review is that the white steel chisels had "good" edge retention (on par with the average of western chisels tested), while the blue steel ones had the best edge retention of all the chisels reviewed. Take it for what it's worth (LNs were rated "good")...

I don't have any experience with the Matsumura chisels, but I've never read any negative comments from those who own them. How much of a step down from the top dogs I can't tell.

As for damascus vs. regular line, I don't know about Tasai, but the Imai chisels use better steel in the "sword steel" line (both it and the "regular" line are white steel). And there's a well known infill plane maker who swears by the Imai sword steel chisels, something to think about, and he uses the chisels on ebony, blackwood, rosewood, etc., a good test by any means... I know I love mine, however they are detrimental to my sharpening ability as they seem to go forever between sharpenings, I lose practice :-)

DC

Re: Yet another Japanese Chisel Question

#9

Re: Yet another Japanese Chisel Question

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Hey, I'm just quoting Japanese tool vendors, American & Japanese. I've also looked at the tools used by expert Japanese tool users, not a wood grain or damascus in sight. So there.

Pam

Re: Yet another Japanese Chisel Question

#10

Thanks, Hank.

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>

Re: Yet another Japanese Chisel Question

#11

Re: Yet another Japanese Chisel Question

wilbur

>Misugi Designs also used to list sizes of chisels, plane blades, and saws in inches, but whenever I gave Kayoko a call, I'd just tell her that I wanted a 9 mm chisel, or whatever, and that's what I got.

Re: Yet another Japanese Chisel Question

#12

Thanks Folks

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

>Some really excellent advice here and I appreciate that. You have opened my eyes to different and perhaps better options. Whatever I end up with I'll post a report.

Tom

Re: Yet another Japanese Chisel Question

#13

Re: Yet another Japanese Chisel Question

Manny

>The side of the box that the chisels ship in has the metric size imprinted on it. The size listed in the JWW catalog is an approximation. The order number number will clue you in to the metric size. For example the order number for the blue steel Miyanaga 1/2" bench chisel is 16.300.12. The last number is the metric size in mm. In this case 12mm. The closest inch size to that is 1/2". However, this only works for older stocked items. For newer items they have gone to a new numbering system where the last three digits of the order number indicate the decimal equivalent of the inch size. For example, the order number for a 1/2" Kinikei bench chisel is 10.301.050. A 3/4" inch Kunikei is 10.301.075.

If you've ordered custom stuff in metric sizes from Kayoko then chances are you have recieved metric sized chisels. However, if you are like me and have sword steel Imai bench chisels that were from her old stock then they are actually sized per the Shaku system. So, the one that was sold to me as 15mm is actually a little bit off from that measurement. But if you put it against a Shaku square (Sashigane) it is spot on 5 Bu. For those that don't have Odate's book - 10 Bu = 1 Sun, 10 Sun = 1 Shaku. A Shaku is about 1/16" short of 1 Ft.

It makes sense that they actually make/size them in the Shaku system. It makes it easier to layout joints when your sashigane and chisels are on the same scale. Also the sashigane is exactly 5 Bu wide so the 5 Bu (15mm) chisel can be "slaved" to the sashigane in this way. This helps when we layout some of the oblique joinery in our timberframe projects.

Sorry, probably more info that want to know.

Manny

Re: Yet another Japanese Chisel Question

#14

Re: Yet another Japanese Chisel Question

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Thanks, Manny, makes perfect sense now that you've said it. I'll have to go compare my chisels to the Sashigane. The precise size usually doesn't matter since I take most important measurements directly from the chisel, but now and then...

Pam

Re: Yet another Japanese Chisel Question

#15

Re: Yet another Japanese Chisel Question

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>That's also been my experience; but I've long drooled over a few chisels from JWW and didn't buy because of the inch thing.

Pam

Re: Yet another Japanese Chisel Question

#16

Re: More sizes

ThomD

>I prefer imperial sizes to inches, it is worth checking whether the chisels really are inches, or just a case of 9mm is sold as 3/8th. I'm sure you are talking from accurate experience, Pam, I am just saying I have seen both realities out there.

On price I would buy the best non-tourist chisels you can find. Best makes, white or blue steel, white oak handles etc... None of these chisels is going to make you cut better dovetails or whatever, but they are fun to have. If the LN didn't do it for, and you have to have Japanese ones too, then the likelyhood is a person in that situation will be back to the tool store again. Buy the best this time no half measure. The best chisels have real handles and real steel. There is usually a reason for the reputation of the better makers.

Another thing, is that as sensible as it is to buy nice sets. If what you really want are more inbetweens, then I would buy extra LNs and have them ground to inbetween sizes. Or do it yourself. if you want to be between 9mm and 12, grinding 1,5 mm off the sides is not a big deal even in the home shop. This is not a thing where thous count, though if they did it would be doable. Some makers will make sizes for you as it is extra chisels for them, and their process is OK with it. Barr will, don't know about LN. usually no extra cost.

At the end of the day I am not sure more sizes are a help but one doesn't necesarilly get there until one already owns them.

I have a set of 14 Ouchi chisels and it has a few that are like 1.5mm or 4.5. But I also have several sets of ten chisels which means a lot of the same sizes, more stuff to keep up with and sharpen. It looks like a UN of woodworking in my shop. Here is about a 1/3rd of my Japanese chisels, you can see the odd sizes from the white handles.


img

Re: Yet another Japanese Chisel Question

#17

Re: Yet another Japanese Chisel Question

ThomD

>That's the first FWW chisel review I haven't read, but all the ones in the past were pretty flawed, in methodology and results. It doesn't sound good if the best Western chisels are up to the standard of good white steel chisels, but not blue steel chisels. There always used to be a big difference in the edge retention between Japanese white and western. And not everyone prefers the blue steel chisels.

Anyone else out there think that finding is credible? I can certainly see people prefering one format over the other. I really like my Barr chisels and their edge retention is comparatively pathetic. They are a nice chisels to use though. And I would have to be working some nastier woods than I can cut locally to care that much. If I had to choose working with a chisel with a narrow transition to the handle vs. one that was stout, I would probably take the stout one even if it was a step or two worse in edge retension.

Re: Yet another Japanese Chisel Question

#18

White steel vs. western steel

Wiley Horne-- So. Calif.

>Thom,

I haven't read the FWW piece. As for methodology, N = 1 is the first thing that comes to mind. How did Gochnour control for initial sharpness of the chisels under test? In a comparative test, initial sharpness is important. Also, what bevel angles were used?

If LN's were in the test, then there is some mix of A2 and O1 among the western chisels, being compared to the Matsumura white and blue steel. Apparently LN's A2 was rated the same in edge-holding ('good') as Matsumura white steel.

I like white steel a lot. But it requires more precision and timing in smithing than does blue steel (see So's site, for a brief discussion of this). In keeping with this, I have noticed a lot of variation in both hardness and edge holding among different smith's white steel work--moreso than with blue steel. The alloying of blue steel (tungsten) is a factor which tends to suppress grain growth, and also suppresses the formation of competing and unwanted species (e.g., pearlite, bainite) as the steel quenches. There are only so many smiths now using charcoal and lots of hot work to limit fire heat and to control grain growth in the white steel.

If you buy the above (and not all might), then the odds would seem to be that--at a given price point and especially at a lower price point--the blue steel is likely to be better than the white.

Has to be remembered that the guy smithing the white steel has got to overcome the inherent edge-holding advantage of the tungsten carbides in the blue steel, and the various alloy carbides in A2. Some of them can, but not many (IME).

Thirdly, I think I am observing that blue steel (including super blue) has more marketing clout in the west than does white steel--even very good white steel. And this is going to affect the quality of white steel that we get. To take just one example, Funahiro-san's top end blade steel in the US (his 'genju' line, from HIda Tool) is super blue steel. But in Japan, his 'genju' line is a very clean vacuum process white steel--we can't even get that product here at retail, and his waiting list for it is a mile long from his Japanese customers.

Wiley

Re: Yet another Japanese Chisel Question

#19

Re: White steel vs. western steel

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>Hi Wiley,

I have the article in front of me, so I'll try to answer some of your questions.

All the chisels' backs were flattened up to 2000 (CAMI) paper on a granite plate. The bevels were all done to 30 degree using stones up to 8000. The Japanese chisels and those made of A2 were done at 35 degree. For the edge retention test, all chisels were tested at a 30 degree bevel, and the test was trimming 1/32" off the end of three 10" wide boards (one each of pine, cherry and white oak).

Hope this helps,

DC

Re: Yet another Japanese Chisel Question

#20

Re: White steel vs. western steel

ThomD

>Interesting points. All the Japanese tools were modestly priced.

I had a look at the article and it seemed to be full of inaccuracies, though maybe there is less standardization in these things than I would imagine. The recipee for both blue and white steel seemed wrong, and the characterization that HSS didn't sharpen well, but had recently been improved is at odds with 30 years of Japanese tools, not to mention turning tools.

Re: Yet another Japanese Chisel Question

#21

FWW chisel comparison

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>I see FWW as a woodworking version of Consumer Reports and National Geographic. For the average user/buyer they all provide useful ratings/information; but for the person who knows a thing or two about the subject/product, they're all wrong, they recommend the mediocre product/provide mediocre, non-nuanced advice/knowledge. You can't imagine how much reading time I freed up 30 years ago when I realized this.

Pam

Re: Yet another Japanese Chisel Question

#22

Re: More sizes

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>I'm assuming that most of your post isn't intended for me. I truly don't need any more chisels, have all the 4.5/7.5 mm I need for shoji, piles of inbetween, some real good ancient western and top notch Japanese. What I am interested in from JWW is the Tasai temple builders chisels and perhaps a couple of crank neck depending on when/if I get around to a project I have in mind. In both cases these chisels are sized in inches in the catalog.

Pam

Re: Yet another Japanese Chisel Question

#23

Re: More sizes

ThomD

>I think I am creating modest havoc with where I position my responses. I don't think you need my advice on chisels.

I like those timber chisels also, and would probably buy them except for not currently being able to foresee a project. At one time I figured there would be a lot more of that kind of stuff in my future, but I don't see myself starting anything much new now. What would you consider the correct metric sizes for this work, or better yet the correct Japanese sun etc... Even metric doesn't get me out of the soup entirely since I have Japanese style measuring scales.

I do think about the prices going ape with a possible devaluation of the dollar. But oddly that didn't happen in the 80s. There was a 2 or 3 fold devaluation of the dollar, yet prices remained similar in catalogs like JWW. The regular stuff seemed to leave catalogs of the general woodworking supply companies, that used to sell stuff like rounder planes and marking gages or plane blades. Those things disappeared for a while, like 20 years. I never really knew whether that was prices or disaffection.

Re: Yet another Japanese Chisel Question

#24

Re: FWW chisel comparison

ThomD

>I wish I could say the same about online boards.

Another classic coment in that article was that the dovetail type chisels wheren't comfortable to hold by the blade because of the spine. Alrighty then.

Re: Yet another Japanese Chisel Question

#25

Re: FWW chisel comparison

Dean J in MN

>Pam -- Thank you for bringing this up, I couldn't agree more. It is quite frustrating, but there is little we can do I suppose.

-Dean