Re: Yet another Japanese Chisel Question
Wiley Horne-- So. Calif.
>Hello Thomas,
People that have the Matsumura's like them, though I think most have the blue steel ones. Here is a thread from another forum that discusses Steve Wargo's experiences with them, and note down at the bottom the estimable Hank Knight brings in some insight from his own experience:
http://www.sawmillcreek.org/showthread.php?t=70145&highlight=matsumura
Years ago, I had several of the white steel dovetail chisels from JWW that are still sold at about the same price point as the Matsumura white steels. They gave good service under considerable abuse, since I used them for everything, including chopping mortises some times (nobody ever told me I couldn't do that). Tough chisels that served well, and did everything I asked of them.
Just a thought, you might consider buying the chisels you really want, but buy them in two's and three's, starting with the most used sizes. That spreads the financial pain, and you get what you really want, though not 10 at once. Like Wilbur, I mainly use the smalls, which means that (for me at least) the larger and most expensive chisels in the set get used the least. Also, if you want Tasai, doesn't need to be Damascus. Get the 'migaki' or 'black'. You can see the differences here (click on chisels, duhh):
http://www.japan-tool.com/
So-san is a good guy, and carries brands we don't see in the US much, so it's an interesting site.
One thing about getting what you really want now--you'll do it eventually anyway. And another thing about a set: there will be ones you don't use, plus you may find yourself wanting to fill in the gaps in the set, so you're then looking for singletons anyway.
It's all good, though. Go for it.
Wiley