Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

Birch as a benchtop?

Posts

Birch as a benchtop?

#1

Birch as a benchtop?

Dominic in Buck's County PA

>Hi gang,

I have a chance to pick up some BIRCH butcher block bench tops. Now I've used Maple before and really liked that. I have no experience with Birch.

How do you think Birch would hold up? I'm not making a new bench, just getting a top for my auxillary bench and one for my rolling lathe tool cart.

Later,

Dominic

Re: Birch as a benchtop?

#2

Re: Birch as a benchtop?

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>Considering that I've been working successfully on a benchtop made from a solid core door with a pine/fir/hemlock core and masonite top; and that my revered grandfather made more furniture than I'm ever likely to using a bench made from coarse Douglas fir, I would think birch would be just fine - especially if the price is good.

Re: Birch as a benchtop?

#3

Steven Antonucci

It's only wood.

steve antonucci

>I have an old benchtop that now serves as my desk (feet up on it everyday), and my benchtop is tempered hardboard over MDF. Why? Cause it's cheap and heavy and I don't care what it looks like. I just replace the hardboard when it gets to beat up.

Now, Dom- I know you, and you're not like that. You probably alphabetize your woods in the rack, don'tcha? ;-) I'd think birch would be just fine for most light duty benches, but I can still see you obsessing over sanding it to 12000 micromesh and that first nick or stain.

Just playing with you, buddy. Price is right, take it.

Steve

Re: Birch as a benchtop?

#4

Re: Birch as a benchtop?

Dave Anderson NH

>Hi Dominic, I'm currently in the process of building a new bench. The base is completed and I picked up the material for the top yesterday. I chose white ash since around here I bought it at $2.66/bdft in 8/4. In spite of all of the birch trees in NH, the stuff is about $4.50 or more /bdft and hard maple is worse in 8/4 at $5.40. It galls me that I could order hard maple from PA at a lower price than I can pick it up locally where it grows plentifully. One of my lumber yards is also a concentration yard, a sawmill, and has his own kiln. I've watched then ship truck loads of maple logs leaving for PA. End my rant on prices.

In any event, consider ash. It's stiff, hard, and cheap.

Re: Birch as a benchtop?

#5

Re: Birch as a benchtop?

Alan S

>The birch I've worked with is very similar to hard maple. I think it would make an excellent bench.

Re: Birch as a benchtop?

#6

Re: Birch as a benchtop?

Dominic in Buck's County PA

>Hmmm, build my own or buy one for about $50? Which to choose, which to choose..... :>)

Thanks for the input Dave. If I was going to build my own I'd probably just use local grown maple. I've got a couple sources that are too way out of line price-wise.

See ya around,

Dominic

Re: Birch as a benchtop?

#7

Thanks for the input

Dominic in Buck's County PA

>Thanks for the input everyone. I think I'll go for it! I'll see what they look like and get back to you. Hopefully with some photos.

later,

Dominic

Re: Birch as a benchtop?

#8

Are you planning...

Scott in Douglassville, PA

>...a Bally run? ;^)

Re: Birch as a benchtop?

#9

Why yes,...now that you mention it

Dominic in Buck's County PA

>Scott,

Yup! That's what I'm doing! My buddy wants to build a bench, and my big brother does as well. Both have been itching to go to Bally's after I've described what I got there. Me, I earned a day off doing "Guy stuff" (plus I called in my "oh come on! It's my birthday next week!" marker) and I'm acting as the tour guide for the ride. Plus I might just pick up some tabletops for myself while I'm at it. :>)

Later,

Dominic

Re: Birch as a benchtop?

#10

Re: Why yes,...now that you mention it

Edward in Vancouver

>Might be sacreligous to mention it, but have you considered doing a "Sweden" run, i.e Ikea?......

Hold on! Force sheilds up! They offer solid countertops in the "kitchen planning dept", 11/2" thick in (all solid laminated, no crud) beech, birch or oak, comes in 24" and 36" widths, and starting from 6' and there on in every two feet lengths.

Price wise it is something to think about, and if you want a thicker top, sandwich some ply or mdf under the top and put a nice skirt around it.

Re: Birch as a benchtop?

#11

Re: Why yes,...now that you mention it

Scott in Douglassville, PA

>Ah, wish I was going, too. Hmm - I don't need another bench, do I? ;^)

Re: Birch as a benchtop?

#12

Re: Why yes,...now that you mention it

Dominic in Buck's County PA

>Bally Block sells "seconds" of their butcher block tops for about $50. What they call a second is usually nothing that would bother us as wood workers. Dark grain, or a split at the end that can be cut off. On numerous occasions I've gotten 2" or 3" thick tops for under $60.

I think that sort of negates the possiblity of me buying an Ikea top for $200 top, right? :>)

Dominic

Re: Birch as a benchtop?

#13

Sorta off topic here, but...

Victor Parisian

>Several years ago I had the privilege of doing some hiking on Isle Royal in Lake Superior, and noticed that the birch logs rotted from the inside out leaving behind an empty tube made up of birch bark. Pretty cool to see, and I'm sure the home to a lot of woodland creatures.

What this has to do with your birch workbench is zilch, but still cool.

Victor - back to work cutting up storm debris.

Re: Birch as a benchtop?

#14

Re: Sorta off topic here, but...

ThomD

>Cut down a tree hew it up, forget about it for a few years, and voila.

I wouldn't have any qualms about Birch but I wouldn't pay much for it. I also wouldn't buy a strip lamintaded top if I could avoid it. There is always someone around selling wood for a few bucks a foot. tree services, woodturning clubs, mills. Wood is basically free once you tap into it.

Re: Birch as a benchtop?

#15

"Wood is basically free..."

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>Nothing is free. Free wood usually comes with the price of converting it, hauling it, etc. This non-monetary price is worth it to some, not to all.

Re: Birch as a benchtop?

#16

Re: $50.00?

Edward in Vancouver

>Fifty bucks?

I'm in. When are we going?

Re: Birch as a benchtop?

#17

Re: "Wood is basically free..."

ThomD

>We still call wood "lumber" and if you open yourself up to it there is allways someone who has too much. Converting it is required no matter what. Most pieces are either a little too big or a little too small. What one has to do to use natural sources isn't always worse than what you have to do to buy it, and when it is you are usually getting a piece that is nor available at any price. And you pay extra for exercise in some neighbourhoods. I would agree there are costs but often the cost of materials is zero, whether the cost of processing is greater than another means of acquisition is an open question. For instnace when I made my dumbhead it was easier to saw away the excess material than it would be to laminate up planks, and the result was more satifying also, the wood was free. We all have to look for good sources and no reason why some of them can't be free.

Another example was recently my dishwasher was really proving a pain, it was approximately 20 years old and ready to be switched out, but the guy who did the kitchen, built it in in such a way that it was not a simple swap, so I have always avoided doing anything. To say the least, it was important to get the same washer or one very similar, if there was to be any hope of getting it in the space. Anyway, after looking around at HD etc... I looked on Craigslist, and found a free dishwasher of the same brand, 2 years old. When we got it, we found it to have the plastic chrome protecting film still in place, and otherwise it looked new. It looked like it might have come form one of those mega kitchens that are really nice, but where the owners eat out most of the time. For our requirements a new dishwasher would not of been any better, because at least this was the same brand which we hadn't even seen locally at our appliance stores. Free is something you actually have to look for and may not find if it isn't part of the search. There are people who would find that gross and want all new appliances, but they probably eat out a lot like most people and goodness only knows what hygene they are regularly making use of. Sometimes stuff really is free.