Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

Shavehorse design question

Posts

Shavehorse design question

#1

Steven Antonucci

Shavehorse design question

steve antonucci

>I've been thinking about making one for a couple of years, and I was looking for the collective wisdom of the handtools group.

I've seen a bunch of good designs, and I have this overwhelming desire to make mine "natural"- no 2X lumber- in the bench area. So my questions are as follows:

1.) How thick does the seat need to be? 2"?

2.) How long should the bench be for the horse to be functional?

3.) How wide should the saddle area be? Is it dependent on how wide I am?

I hope to start the process in a couple of days, and plan on using white oak and leaving the horse outside for the most part. I also plan on not using any glue, just screws and joinery. Good idea or not?

Steven

Re: Shavehorse design question

#2

Shavehorse design?

john j

>What will you use it for? What design are you using?

You can use either the old FWW Drew Langsner design or John Alexander's design from Woodwork with great success. For an average person, no significant deviations from either plan are necessary.

Good Luck!

http://www.greenwoodworking.com/shorse.htm

http://countryworkshops.org/Images/horseplanspix.jpg

Re: Shavehorse design question

#3

Steven Antonucci

very helpful

steve antonucci

>I had sort of planned on it being a lot wider, but both plans have much narrower benches than I would have guessed.

As for it's use, I really don't have one yet. I've always kicked around the idea of making chairs, so I figure you need one for that. No doubt I'll make it for one idea, and use it for another...

Steve

Re: Shavehorse design question

#4

Re: Shavehorse design question

Dave Mount

>Hi Steve--

Here's a blurry pic of the one I built. This followed the plans in Drew Langsner's Chairmaker's Workshop book (Bill T, I haven't forgotten). This one follows what I understand to be a more German style, with the wide, wedge-shaped dumbhead. He has another pattern on his website that is more English with the gripper being a bar style frame.

As I recall, the plans left the overall length as an open question. I made mine fairly long with the idea that I would be able to work longer workpieces by sitting back further. What you quickly find is that your ability to sit back is limited by the reach of your foot up to activate the dumbhead (duh!), and of course the reach of your arms to work the wood. If you would want me to measure this one and report back, I could do that.

The legs on these things take a lot of abuse, racking and twisting. In this design, there are no stretchers and the only thing holding the leg in place is the mortise in the bench (I did wedge the tops of the legs). Mine have held up OK thus far, but I'm always aware of the stress I put on those legs sometimes. If you're going to leave yours outside, I would be concerned about the legs loosening up with wet/dry cycles if you use through mortises as I did; that would expose the end grain to a lot of moisture. I might think of doing a couple things differently, perhaps putting a stretcher between the two front and two rear legs. Also, one could add strength by either adding on an additional block to the bottom of the bench where the leg enters or by making the whole bench out of thicker stock (this one is about 1-5/8" thick if memory serves). If you do a blind mortise for the legs (i.e., don't put the hole all the way through), which I think might be advisable for an outdoor horse, this would be another reason to have plenty of depth where the legs enter so you don't lose rigidity. You could still fox wedge the legs even if the mortises were blind.

Green woodworking is a lot of fun, get busy and build your horse!

Best,

Dave


img

Re: Shavehorse design question

#5

Re: very helpful *LINK*

Greg B�tit, Vergennes VT

>I've found that many shave horses are made too short. You want plenty of clearance between the ground and foot pedal, and the longer the latter is, the more leverage you get.

Also consider the Brian Boggs design. I like the work table being right at the front, allowing work on some odd shaped components.

Lie Nielsen sells a Brian Boggs designed shavehorse.


Lie Nielsen's shaving horse

Re: Shavehorse design question

#6

Or there's...

Scott in Douglassville, PA

>...the Shave Mule. Not sure how comparable this one is to the LN version, but it's got Boggs' twist in the design, too.

Scott, still using a Shave Pony...

Re: Shavehorse design question

#7

Re: Shavehorse design question

Alan S

>Mine is not beauteous, but it works fine, and it's not made of 2x stock. I chose the dimensions based on the small log I had, and what I found on the web. A hewing hatchet and a brace and bit were about all it took.


img

Re: Shavehorse design question

#8

Hi Greg

john j

>That is the kind of horse I have, a Boggs style made about 10 years ago by John Kennedy in Berea, Ky. I was trying to link to useful free plans, but I forgot that FWW had an article by Brian Boggs on how to make that exact horse. I might make one like Drew Langsner's Swiss style, out of oak and dimensional SYP...someday...

Re: Shavehorse design question

#9

Re: Shavehorse design question

jimbo58

>Steve, I happen to be in process of making a horse to the basic european design, but am extending the base to accomodate a mount on the end for my woodcarving vise. I sometime carve stuff that is more comfortable when sitting as opposed to standing and the horse bench provides a base for doing so. I have no pics but am using white oak wlhich is 2 inch on base with the rest to be about 1 1/2 inch stuff. Just a suggestion in case you do similar things.

Re: Shavehorse design question

#10

Steven Antonucci

But I couldn't put that outside

steve antonucci

>It's too pretty. I'd have to put it in the living room and watch TV on it, and my wife said no...

Still, some good idea from the design to add to the hopper...

Thanks

Steve

Re: Shavehorse design question

#11

Boggs

roninkokomo

>The Brian Boggs design is excellent. I have usewd mine for 8 years or so.

Re: Shavehorse design question

#12

Re: The numbers

ThomD

>"1.) How thick does the seat need to be? 2"?"

If you carry it around, lighter is better, Keep in mind the surface you will place it on if it is really slick, you need more socket joint at the bench than otherwise. Check windsor chairs for reference. Species and quality make a difference, check split resistance. As long as it doesn't flex when you sit on it you are fine. Self-testing should determine more than someone elses number.

2.) How long should the bench be for the horse to be functional?

I depends on the design. Some of them have more out front than others. The boggs is very short overall, because both the seat and the bench are compact. You can rest the rear on something and play with it until you are sure relative to your height. Then attach the legs.

3.) How wide should the saddle area be? Is it dependent on how wide I am

Sorta. Your sit bones do the sitting, the rest of width is based on your "overhang" The sit bones are rather narrowly placed. Wider isn't always a more comfortable design because you are moving, getting on and off, and possible carrying it around.

Stiffness of the plank is proportional to width, and the cube of thickness, so these can be altered from known designs to suit your use.

Your choice should probably be based on the kind of work you do. A big part of that is the length of pieces.

I have two, one is a dumbhead from Drew's chair book, which has an excellent design. Tamarack and red oak. The other is a maple version of the Boggs chair from about 10 years ago when it appeared in FWW.

Re: Shavehorse design question

#13

Second the boggs design

James Watriss

>The tilted seat saves a LOT of back pain after a long day. It also makes it easier to push on the treadle without sliding back on the board. I suppose you could just add a tilted board to the back of a traditional design (I ended up doing that at one point) but there are other virtues of the boggs horse that are very, very worth looking into.

There's an article around somewhere, I'm sure someone in here will find it soon... that has Brian explaining the design points he found to be critical. Very good read, and very informative... and he's built a lot of chairs. There's a reason he designed it the way he did.

Last but not least... don't worry about leaving it outside. There are ways to make one such that it can be folded up and stored somewhere very easily.

Re: Shavehorse design question

#14

He also specifies its advantages in his dvd.

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>

Re: Shavehorse design question

#15

Re: Masterclass

ThomD

>That was in FWW, or at least that is the first place I saw it. It was a Masterclass. I have that issue. One can search the idex online, and since he hasn't written much for them it should pop up easily.

The boggs one isn't a dumbhead design, and I may have missed something in this thread, but I didn't notice the use specified. It's a great design, but if a person were doin rakes, scythes, long stools, etc... I think the dumbhead is prefereable, and all around good anyway. They are both good, but for inside the shop and small parts the boggs is preferable, and for out of doors where there is presumably space, and longer or shorter stuff the dumbhead has the edge. I suppose there could be a Boggs Dumhead design, I thought about it before I built mine but the nicest bit, the ratchet table is tough to build into a dumbhead or so I figured. I built my dumbhead entirely out of wood I cut out of the woods. I used dry wood for the bench, and I used wet wood for the head and lever. No problems so far.