Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

What I had in mind...

Posts

What I had in mind...

#1

What I had in mind...

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>was to buy a Japanese laminated chisel, which I did and to alter it to 'look' like a Western Chisel. No really Derek. I know it won't look exactly like the old laid steel chisels, but it is a laid steel chisel and that is what I want!

The photograph below is just as I got it, a before picture if you will. I put it to the coarse stones this morning and it was a lot of work and I am not done yet, but I only spend a half an hour. The flat behind the tip is over a 1/4" long but I am working the entire underside, just not all at once. I also sharpened it and did some work on a curly maple replacement handle.

Now I just need to figure out how to remove the handle, if possible without having to resort to splitting it off, any suggestions?

It appears that there is plenty of steel on this one and judging from a picture that Wilbur put up of one of his chisels that has been sharpened down to next to nothing and still has steel, so I am not worried.

As for re-hardening, it doesn't look like this needs it as the steel is very hard, however the backing can easily be cut with a file.

If it is possible to get something similar to the old Western laid steel chisels by modifying a Japanese chisel then I think it would be a good exercise for those wanting original style tools.

I also think Western (Modern) tool makers to consider offering a line of traditional laid steel chisels and gouges, I would pay for real tools.

Stephen


img

Re: What I had in mind...

#2

Re: What I had in mind...

Wiley Horne-- So. Calif.

>Stephen,

To remove the handle, hold the chisel by the blade and rap the chisel handle down sideways on your bench. You have to use sense (which of course you will) and not put a big moment on the steel. Make sure the whole handle hits at once on the bench, so that the shock is distributed. If only the end of the handle or ring hits, the shock will reflect back down the chisel looking for a thin part of the steel. Takes a sharp rap to do this, but not bashing.

Wiley

Re: What I had in mind...

#3

Re: What I had in mind...

ThomD

>And I wouldn't do it on your bench since it will probably dent it. You will have to rap it over and over from different angles. Often the chisel does not reassemled properly should it come to that.

Re: What I had in mind...

#4

Suggestion

wilbur

>Before you start dissecting your new chisel, get a beat up old one on eBay, and mess with it first. There are usually a good number of them available.

Re: What I had in mind...

#5

Now you tell me!

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>Wilbur,

Just kidding. I wanted to purchase a chisel that is readily available on the market, just in case this works out. I am impressed with the hardness of the steel.

I don't like hooped handles, although my big ungainly Sorby 1/2" mortise chisel is hooped but I don't use it much. All of my chisels save one big 2" firmer chisel with a turned handle, have octagonal tapered handles, so the tools don't roll off my bench, and they all match.

Thanks for all of your support and taking all the grief I have given you about Japanese tools.

Stephen