Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

a question about cutting edges

Posts

a question about cutting edges

#1

a question about cutting edges

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Alan said that they honed the tool edge to a high degree of refinement for turning pine but for oak they used the tool straight off the grinder because such an edge cut oak better. His explanation was that the rougher edge sliced the oak better. While I am not questioning the conclusion, I am not understanding the phenomena. Anybody have any ideas?

Re: a question about cutting edges

#2

How about....

john in NM

>Friction? The edge right off the grinder is more like a serrated knife and is less likely to skid off the surface of the harder wood. I rarely use oak for furniture, but I did recently make a vanity out of it and was very surprised at how hard the top was when I was planing it. Between that and the lack of tearout, I can see why its been so popular.

Re: a question about cutting edges

#3

Re: a question about cutting edges

ThomD

>I don't think there is much magic at play here. If you have planed oak, their brown oak being dark in colour but otherwise a bit like white oak, you don't get a perfect shaving, there are parts that fall out and so forth. Often even a little dust, particularly with our red oak. Pine on the other hand can finished to such a high polish off a plane that you can read the lightbulb in an overhead fixture when looking at the surface of the the pine. Pine shavings will hold together down into the tens. That kind of finish pays off with pine, which it can be argued for certain used doesn't even need additional finish, while Oak will never get that good, and one can proceed directly to the finishing process. It's not that the surface on oak wouln't be better with a great plane, or turning tool, it's that the result after finishing is possibly not an improved surface.

The same thig applies with sanding. There are some materials and finish combination that can be sanded to 150 and coated, while others like 8000 grit. Depends one whether the surface is finished, and even then, what happens when the finish goes on. Some metal surfaces need bondo, and some woods need filler.