Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

The reason for the saw nib.

Posts

The reason for the saw nib.

#1

The reason for the saw nib.

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>As related by Allan Batty during class. Someone noticed a bit of relief ground from the tip of Allan's skew and asked about it. Turned out it was to prevent a rub mark on the end grain whilst making a cubic element on a spindle on a period turning (orthogonal end grain cut). (I don't remember the period as it was a minor one that I was not fond of). Allan went on to comment that things like the reason for this tool feature get lost with time. Because these kinds of spindles are seldom done now days the apprentices no longer make this relief on the skew. He went on to make the analogy with saw nibs. The Diston representative would come around to the tradesmen and demonstrate how a Diston saw could be bent with the end tucked through the handle without damage to the saw blade. Debate raged at times as to the purpose of the saw nib on the older saws (sound familiar). All the current theories were popular then too. So one day someone at the shop rung up the current Mr. Diston and asked, "what is the purpose of the saw nib"? "We don't know" was the reply.

Re: The reason for the saw nib.

#2

Re: The reason for the saw nib.

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Bill,

I hear tell that the nib is for starting a saw cut.....uhhh....perhaps you have already heard that...*smirk*

Disston only added it to their higher priced saws. Perhaps they felt they needed to add something to justify the added cost. The No.7 saw was their first saw they put on the market. It had a nib. Their No.9 had a nib and then the No.12. Most of their other saws didn't have a nib. Their skew back saws didn't have a nib, only the few straight back ones did.

Marv

Re: The reason for the saw nib.

#3

Re: The reason for the saw nib.

Mike G. in SC

>According to an older carpenter I know,the nib was used to clear sawdust out of the cut. I can't see it myself,but I've only got 30 yrs exp.as a carpenter whereas my friend had almost 50.

Mike G. in SC

Re: The reason for the saw nib.

#4

Re: The reason for the saw nib.

Joe Rogers, Northern Virginia

>Didn't that older carpenter notice that the sawdust was ejected from the kerf with each saw stroke by the saw teeth??? :-)

JR

Re: The reason for the saw nib.

#5

"only added it to their higher priced saws."?

Don in Northern Arizona

>How come a #7 got it. It was the cheapy.

Don

Re: The reason for the saw nib.

#6

You are right, I stand corrected.....

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>

Re: The reason for the saw nib.

#7

"To make little boys (and girls) ask questions."

James Watriss

>

Re: The reason for the saw nib.

#8

Re: The elusive nib

Bjenk Ellefsen------WebKitFormBoundaryAAk3AAy9AAf+

>Bill is right in saying that the true function of the nib has been lost. It is pure speculation now that Disston themselves don't know.

The idea that is was to start a cut is not very plausible. You will break the nib at some point trying to do that. The nibs do snap off as I have seen it happen.

A more plausible explanation has a lot to do with the time at which they were designed. In the Victorian era, it was quite common to add decorative features to the tools a manufacturer would produce. It attracted customers by having something special that would add to the looks of the tools. Tools were prized possessions and in a tool market it made sense to ornate them.

Other than that, I believe we are speculating just like Bill noted.

Re: The reason for the saw nib.

#9

a good thought

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>If it had no purpose then it would follow that none of the explanations for why it was there would make sense today(as they don't in my mind). Following on the discussion by Allan of why the skew tip was relieved (indeed I tested the explanation this AM and not to my surprise I demonstrated its utility for this specialized cut) the nib either had no useful purpose, it was used for something that is no longer done with a hand saw, or it was an artifact of the manufacturing process.

Re: The reason for the saw nib.

#10

Re: a good thought

Bjenk Ellefsen------WebKitFormBoundaryAAk3AAy9AAf+

>I could not have summed it better than you did Bill.