Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

Drawers per hour, English style

Posts

Drawers per hour, English style

#1

Drawers per hour, English style

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Someone asked some time ago how long it took to build a drawer.

This weekend I spent a delightful 2 days in a class and lectures with Allan Batty. Allan began apprenticing in England at 15 in the wood trade. His tales of the trade shops and apprenticing were fascinating. Imagine how good one got after turning 160 Queen Ann legs, and how bad one felt after centering the off-set off by 90 degrees so they pointed the wrong way. He entertained us with tales of the English long bow, Samurai sword theory(most relevant to turning) and English history.

It was a treat learning from someone that earned a living putting out product. No philosophical mumbo jumbo about tree souls and the like. It became clear that the typical, or maybe any, amateur is never going to match turnings made by a master parts turner. You do learn details after making a 1000 of something that you never learn doing 4. I offered him some bun feet for critique. Not bad he said, then chucked one in his lathe, recentered it WHILE SPINNING (I have no idea how he accomplished this task just by bashing it with a hammer) and by taking a whisker of here and there and a finish cut everywhere, it became obviously more attractive and it was ready to apply finish, right from the tool!

Anyway, he said the expectations "in the trade" (a phrase he repeated 100 times during the class) were a Windsor chair leg in less than 2 minutes and 6 drawers a day (1/2 drawer per hour). I am falling short by something not quite 2 orders of magnitude.

Well its off to the lathe to try making better bun feet for the trunk.

Re: Drawers per hour, English style

#2

Re: Drawers per hour, English style

ThomD

>You are lucky indeed!

"It was a treat learning from someone that earned a living putting out product. No philosophical mumbo jumbo about tree souls and the like."

Keep in mind that traditionally people who did production work like this certainly in different cultures that ours perhaps, would repeat such things. One could probably srgue something to the effect that calling a thing that self-evidently isn't a "foot" a foot, is the recognition of some essential form.

"It became clear that the typical, or maybe any, amateur is never going to match turnings made by a master parts turner. You do learn details after making a 1000 of something that you never learn doing 4."

When I started out I used to do production work, 35 years ago, 45 cents a piece. particularly fly tying, and some turning. Without being paid I can't face the repition of even finishing four legs these days. I wonder at times whether that accounts for the three legged stool. :)

"I offered him some bun feet for critique. Not bad he said, then chucked one in his lathe, recentered it WHILE SPINNING (I have no idea how he accomplished this task just by bashing it with a hammer)"

Same principle as you would be wacked by the high point if you stuck a finger in there while it was spinning.

" and by taking a whisker of here and there and a finish cut everywhere, it became obviously more attractive and it was ready to apply finish, right from the tool!"

Ah he found the soul/essence of your foot for you! It was in there just waiting for the chraftsperson to release it.

Re: Drawers per hour, English style

#3

Re: Drawers per hour, English style

Wiley Horne-- So. Calif.

>Bill,

Tbanks for the great post! 6 drawers per day--holy cow. Although I make that to be about 1-1/2 hours per drawer, based on 9 hours of actual production, and an hour downtime, in a 10-hour day.

I googled Allan Batty, and he is a busy guy! Gets rave reviews from many sources. He has 2 DVD's out--would you recommend them?

Wiley

Re: Drawers per hour, English style

#4

Re: Drawers per hour, English style

ThomD

>Have to get him up against FK and his 20 minutes.

Re: Drawers per hour, English style

#5

Allan's videos

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Alan said he worked 12 hour days as an apprentice.

I don't know anything about his videos but I can say that he is one of the best teachers I have experienced. Many times he said "I want you to understand why you do" this or that. He believed that if you understood why you would remember the point better. A man after my own heart.

I have been examining an English drawer, made during the time of Alan's apprenticeship. Its dovetails vary from 9 to nearly 14 degrees, obviously laid out by eye and by someone not highly experienced.

The first apprentice task was to learn, by doing, the tool sharpening, on a wet wheel running off a line shaft. Allan hated these chores as it threw water and gunge upon the apprentice (perhaps by design). Take note, those that think hollow grinding is a modern fad.

Re: Drawers per hour, English style

#6

Re: Allan's videos

Dean J in MN

>... Take note, those that think hollow grinding is a modern fad.

I'll add -- Even good old Moxon describes hollow grinding. Nothing new, nor modern about it.

-Dean

Re: Drawers per hour, English style

#7

Re: Drawers per hour, English style

Dave Anderson NH

>Sounds like a great class Bill. I can identify with the Windsor Chair leg time of 2 minutes. Each year at our demo tent at the Sunapee NH Craftsman's Fair one of our guild members, Peter Scheffer, turns legs for 9 days. He will stand there all day carrying on a converstaion with the audience or with other demonstrators and turn out a leg ready for finishing in 2-4 minutes depending on how long he's been demoing that day. He does the demos because he's out in the fresh air, has folks to talk to, and it prevents him from getting bored. Over the 9 days he'll turn out his whole year's requirement of legs. When folks ask how he can do it so fast his answer is that it's easy after you've done 9-10,000 legs. Practice makes perfect, but it also makes things a drudge on that kind of production basis.

Re: Drawers per hour, English style

#8

Repetitive work

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>I have spent a good part of my life doing production hand work. Usually it takes a few repetitions to get going and decide on techniques etc. Then after about a dozen times through the boredom really sets in. You look at the pile of material and think "how am I ever going to do 90 more of these?"

But after 20 or 30 some changes occur. You notice the stuff looks better even though you haven't changed anything. The whole operation gets smoother, even the awkward things. There are no headaches and you start really enjoying the work. Then when you are almost done you wish there were more of the same because it is so relaxing. Repetitive work is really valuable for developing your eye and smooth technique.

Is an amateur going to match a professional? There are plenty of professionals whose work is not much to brag about. Here is why you can do fine work, Bill. You are observant and discriminating. You look at the work of others. You do not mind experimenting. And you seek out advice and instruction.