Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

New source for Imai sword steel chisels *LINK*

Posts

New source for Imai sword steel chisels *LINK*

#1

New source for Imai sword steel chisels *LINK*

wilbur

>I know that there are fans of the Imai sword steel chisels that haunt this forum. It looks like Iida Tool is carrying them. No price, but they've quickly answered emails in the past.

If nothing else, you can see a nice large photo of one of them.

And, of course, the regular Imai chisels are available from Hida Tool.


img

Iida Tool Imai sword steel chisel listing

Re: New source for Imai sword steel chisels *LINK*

#2

That's good news. Thanks.

Hank Knight

>

Re: New source for Imai sword steel chisels *LINK*

#3

Coupla suggestions

Wiley Horne-- So. Calif.

>Fujihiro is the brand offered through Hida in white steel No. 2. Imai's 'sword steel' line was white steel No. 1, with lots of hand work in it. It would be worth asking Tomohito-san--and without prompting him--what steel is in these chisels. The answer you want to hear is White steel No. 1.

Also, the original handle maker is Mokusei. That handle is not Mokusei (IMO). I would suggest anyone thinking of ordering from Tomohito-san ask for Mokusei handles.

Wiley

Re: New source for Imai sword steel chisels *LINK*

#4

questions

Howard Pollack

>Hi- What would the difference, in terms of function, between the Imai chisels sold by Hida and by Iida? Thanks -Howard

Re: New source for Imai sword steel chisels *LINK*

#5

Re: questions

Wiley Horne-- So. Calif.

>Hi Howard,

I don't own any of the Fujihiro brand chisels sold by Hida. I will quickly add that I have acquaintances who are Japanese tool experts, and who have a high regard for these chisels.

The Imai chisels I have are from the line which was sold at one time by Misugi Designs. These were identified as 'sword steel' or 'special white steel'. The only point of my post was to suggest that people interested in buying the Imai chisels from Iida-san (Tomohito) might wish to ask him about the steel and about the handling--if their purpose is to obtain the original 'sword steel' product. You want to get what you're paying for.

That said, I believe the Fujihiro chisels sold by Hida to be functionally excellent, judging from the opinions of people that I know who have owned and used these chisels for a long time.

And just a philosophical point....Comparisons between chisels are necessarily going to be anecdotal--small samples, different test situations, etc. So peoples' experiences differ, even for what appears to be the same article. For example, my experience with the Imai sword steel chisels has been that they are remarkably tough customers, and I have done lots of mortising with them in figured hardwoods at bevel angles less than 30 degrees, and without babying them at all. On the other hand, Jim Shaver showed a photo on this forum within the last two months of an Imai sword steel mortise chisel which lost a big chip out of the edge while he was chopping into a burr section of white oak (if I remember correctly).

Wiley

Re: New source for Imai sword steel chisels *LINK*

#6

Steven Antonucci

Is Damascus a good idea for a chisel?

steve antonucci

>I don't know what they specifically cost, but as a hobby knifemaker, I know what the cost for good raw damascus is. I'll assume that they're good steel, and not inexpensive.

My question is simple: Aside from the provenance and prettiness quotient, do they work any better than standard chisel? Sharper I assume? For longer? Would it be competitive with a high tech knife steel like ATS34? Is it the steel or the maker that makes them expensive?

Steve

Re: New source for Imai sword steel chisels *LINK*

#7

Just aesthetic

John in NM

>The damascus billet is welded to blue or white tool steel for the cutting edge. I think I'd spend the money on a chisel before a knife if I was looking for damascus tools, I'd probably never use the knife, too afraid of damaging it!

Re: New source for Imai sword steel chisels *LINK*

#8

Re: Is Damascus a good idea for a chisel?

ThomD

>It's not damascus, it's a pattern welded backer with a hard homogenous steel cutting surface. In comparison to US knives that retail for 100 an inch on damascus, or more. These things are a bargain. The welded steel backs are atistic. My only beef is that from some brands I have seen the really pretty and expensive chisels were not held to good QC. They were laughing at us assuming anyone who bought them was a jerk. Also on impact chisels a lot of the pretty woods are not good for the purpose. I don't have any problem with them arting the tools up. I buy tools to art up the woodwork in my life. But the tools shouldn't just be tourist grade. I tend to go with the idea that form follows function and I generally wouldn't buy the pimped out tools. I did that and have the T-shirt.

Damascus does not outcut regular steel in knives, best case it might be even, and of course might have better deformation performance, though that is pretty doubtful over 52100, etc... The way around that is to include a hardened edge in the damascus. A San Mai treatment, which is similar to what you see here.

Re: New source for Imai sword steel chisels *LINK*

#9

pretty

paul womack

>Since the cutting edge is "normal", the Damascus is purely cosmetic.

I have no argument with the cost/labour equation (on the production side), but would question the cost/benefit equation (on the use side)

BugBear

Re: New source for Imai sword steel chisels *LINK*

#10

Re: pretty

ThomD

>It is just a question of whether it is ever justifiable to make anything nice or whether everything should be purely utilitarian (also can be nice). Some of these tools are masterpieces, others are getting slipped past the punters, which can mean they are less satisfying than the utilitarian stuff. Over here we have a long tradition of beautiful tools and makers having nice tool collections to position their status. The fly in the ointment is whether and in what regard that practice existed in Japan. To what extent these things are like tea sets with the anniversarry of the coronation painted on them.