Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

Help with Varnish on table

Posts

Help with Varnish on table

#1

Help with Varnish on table

John Hoffman

>Hi guys,

I used General Finishes Arm R Seal Urethane top coat, for my table top. I used 5 thin coats and let it cure for 4 weeks or so.

My kids and friends were using permanent markers on paper which bled through onto the top. I could not get the markers off. I eventually sanded it off and have to re-coat.

I called General Finishes and they said that permanent markers would do this. Does this make sense and if not can anyone recomend another product to use on the table?

Thanks

John

Re: Help with Varnish on table

#2

Re: Help with Varnish on table

MikeW

>John,

I suspect that what ever the volatile carrier is int he markers disolves into the finish.

Take care, Mike

Re: Help with Varnish on table

#3

Re: Help with Varnish on table

Bob Barkto

>Most finishes are attacked by the solvents in those things.

Some acrylic resins are better at resisting them.

Varathane Diamond WB Poly is one. You can remove Sharpie ink from it with a little MS and a bit of elbow grease.

But it looks a little more like lacquer than varnish. It's water clear.

Re: Help with Varnish on table

#4

Re: Help with Varnish on table

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>Use real varnish, try McCloskey's Marine Spar Varnish, great stuff. I thin it with turpentine and rag it on.

It is durable, easy to repair, don't know about modern inks, but it does resist iron gall ink, sympathetic ink and India Ink wipes off with alcohol or turpentine.

Stephen

Re: Help with Varnish on table

#5

yes reasonable

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>I would expect that any permanent marker formulated with dye would penetrate any finish. Its not that the ink solvent dissolved the finish but the other way around. The colored dyes are soluble in the solvent. The solvent is soluble in the finish. Solvent penetrates finish carrying dye with it. A highly cross linked finish (like urethane) could be better at slowing the penetration rate and a finish that was a poor solvent for the marker solvent would also be better. This problem is a performance criteria for finishes and if you were able to obtain the technical data sheets, like what is available for commercial finishes, for a proposed product you could assess the finish's resistance to markers.

Re: Help with Varnish on table

#6

Re: Help with Varnish on table

John Hoffman

>Stephen,

How are the fumes with that product? Are they harsh?

Thanks

JH

Re: Help with Varnish on table

#7

Re: Help with Varnish on table

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>John,

The fumes are not harsh, even with turpentine, but that is to my nose. I don't mind the smell at all and the product is excellent.

Stephen

Re: Help with Varnish on table

#8

Re: Help with Varnish on table

Bob Lang

>Hi John,

There are some commercially available catalyzed finishes-Sherwin-Williams Kemvar is one-that you can write on with permanent marker and then clean the marker off with acetone. They look too much like plastic to me, are expensive and must be sprayed, but they are used on solid wood furniture and kitchen cabinets.

Personally, I'd go with a good varnish and watch the kids.

Bob Lang

Re: Help with Varnish on table

#9

I wouldn't recommend spar varnish

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>While I have no experience with this particular product, in general the properties of spar varnish are not ideal for a table. Spar varnishes, at least historically, were formulated to be flexible. Flexible translates to less print resistance, not ideal for a table top. I don't know anything about the water based finishes, but for a solvent based finish the best durability will be a urethane. However, I would think that a water based finish useful for floors would be good for a table.

when I am looking for a durable finish I visit the stores and find one of the sample pieces. Then I discretely try to dent the finish with my thumb nail. A hard durable finish can not be dented. This is the sort of finish I would want for a work table(or floor). One could similarly test with a marker, discretely of course. .

If you are bothered by fumes, the best finish would not be attractive to you. The original urethanes that cured by reacting with water vapor become exceptionally durable. But the EPA made them less available because of possible fume toxicity. But they last forever on a floor.

Re: Help with Varnish on table

#10

rebuttal

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Kemvar is my favorite finish. I buy it by the 5 gallon pail and finish everything I can with it.

If you have used this product and the result looked like plastic then you didn't know how to use it in a way to achieve the result you desired. I can't tell any difference in appearance from nitrocellulose lacquer when applied equivalently. Thinned and with delusterant I can get an appearance that looks like a close-to-the-wood oiled finish(see PIC). With more build and less delusterant it looks like lacquer. Sprayed in heavy coats it looks like varnish. We like being able to wash this table as needed.

At the last SAPFM meeting I overheard an exchange between one of the former Cartousch winners and someone admiring a pie crust table he had brought for the show. When asked what it was finished with he replied "polyurethane". The questioner recoiled in horror at this response. The maker went on to explain that this was a table they used regularly and they needed it to be durable. He had two others finished traditionally. He went on to say that during a recent visit by woodworkers he asked them to pick the urethane finished table from the traditional finished tables. The guests could not reliably make a distinction.

Which goes to show that how a finish is applied determines the appearance to a far greater degree than the product itself. Applied thick and not delustered by rubbing or otherwise, any finish can acquire the so called "plastic look".

Agreed, Kemvar must be sprayed and it is somewhat harder to learn to spray than lacquer(but easier than water based and shellac). But if one builds much stuff, learning to spray becomes essential.


img

Re: Help with Varnish on table

#11

Re: I wouldn't recommend spar varnish

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>Bill,

You wrote "While I have no experience with this particular product, in general the properties of spar varnish are not ideal for a table. Spar varnishes, at least historically, were formulated to be flexible."

What is the matter with a flexible finish on wood that constantly moves? Now while I use varnish on everything I make (most of which is pine), spar varnish offers plenty of protection and is harder than the pine.

A friend with a commercial cabinet shop makes conference tables mostly mahogany crotch veneers and he uses spar varnish as it is a better finish that any of the modern spray lacquers or varnishes.

You should give it a try before dismissing it out of hand.

Stephen

Re: Help with Varnish on table

#12

Re: Help with Varnish on table

Glenn Madsen near San Francisco

>I use that same varnish with naptha regularly. Not harsh smelling, and the vapors flash off more quickly, something I appreciate in the more humid environment (than Stephen's) in which I live...

Re: Help with Varnish on table

#13

Nice table!

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>Love the top and I like the pigeon toe look too!

Re: Help with Varnish on table

#14

Re: I wouldn't recommend spar varnish

ThomD

>I don't think he was saying it wouldn't survive wood movement as well, but that soft varnish is, well, soft. Another thing that you want with spar varnish is recoatability. In the warmer climes where boats are fun, spar varnish needs recoating several times a year. I wouold just be guessing, but if it remains open to more coats it might boand easily to the markers. Also it is ripe with UV blockers which also block the visibility of the grain, even though I would admit a spar coated product does look awesome.

In brief, high UV, quarterly recoatability, extremes of wood movement, don't sound like typical boardroom conditions, and I have spent a lot of time around fancy boardroom tables. None of which was really all that nice, even in major world banks.

Re: Help with Varnish on table

#15

Re: Help with Varnish on table

ThomD

>Two points:

Since you have the table finished, and all the damage is limited to the coatings, I would just leave it. Wait till they grow up to refinish. In the meantime, you might apply a heavy coat of beeswax polish, natures teflon. Wax is a lot more effective at this kind of thing than most any varnish. I made a small shaker table for my daughter when she was first exploring her art. I finished it with tung oil, and it got royally trashed through two kids, it was thick with crayon and markers. When they had outgrown it, the idea was I would refinish it and apply a new finish. A few strokes with the plane. Worked great until the 3rd kid came along 10 years later.

My second thought is that nobody should write on real furniture with only a piece of paper on it. If you are going to spend the time to make real furniture, you may need to educate people on how to use it. Nice stuff requires different use than crap.

Re: Help with Varnish on table

#16

Concur

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>I used spar varnish, on the recommendation of a local homeowner's store, on the backboards of our wooden kitchen counters. My plan was to rub it out to match, or at least blend with, the low gloss finish on the commercial maple countertops. It never did get hard enough to do that very well; I've been able to rub out other varnishes within a few days of application.

Fortunately for our kitchen, LOML put so many things on the back edge of the counters that you can't see the backboards anyway. Too bad in some ways, because I'd picked out some birch with a really nice swirly pattern (locally available maple all looked like it had been pecked by a flock of very, very angry parakeets).