Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

Strange Transitional Plane

Posts

Strange Transitional Plane

#1

Strange Transitional Plane

Mike G.in SC

>Hi Folks.Well it seems like when it rains, it pours. After buying the Lignum coffin smoother the other day, I saw what I thought was a Stanley transitional plane in almost mint condition. After closer inspection, I found no marks at all on the wood body. The only mark at all was on the tapered iron. It said " Oak Tree". The iron and cap iron as well as the lever cap was in what I would call excellent+ condition. I'm talking fresh off the shelf condition. Has anyone else heard of this brand, and would it be worth buying for less than 50 bucks?

Thanks, Mike G. in SC

Re: Strange Transitional Plane

#2

Re: Strange Transitional Plane

Glenn Madsen near San Francisco

>There are two reasons to buy a plane: To collect them or to use them.

Would you use it?

Are you a potential collector?

Some of us are qualified to comment on these for you. I'm not.

Re: Strange Transitional Plane

#3

Re: Strange Transitional Plane *LINK*

Bob Demers

>Never heard of Oak tree and a quick search of my usual suspects turns up blank.

There is however a WW store in Indiana called Oak tree, and Robert Larson firm, a dealer on woodworking tools, has a somewhat stylised tree as a logo see www.rlarson.com. Picture is their logo

But the real question is why? any good planes under $50 is cheap. Oh sure you can buy a decent Stanley No 4 or a good clone for a lot cheaper but monetary value aside, if you collect and want it, buy it.

If you are a user, a transitional at any price is not your best bet

Bob, a user at heart, but who seems to aggregate more tools than he uses


img

Oak tree WW store

Re: Strange Transitional Plane

#4

Re: Strange Transitional Plane

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>Depending on how long it is, I'd want to know if it's straight. I once owned a Stanley transitional jointer that had been optimized for planing spirals.

Re: Strange Transitional Plane

#5

Re: Strange Transitional Plane

cooper suter

>Hard to say what you have based on your description and w/out a pic.

Off the top of my head, it doesn't ring a bell.

The people who do collect transitionals demand near perfect condition, and will pay prices that reflect that.

In my experience, with a few exceptions, transitional planes in the condition you describe are really the only bankable "collectable" transitionals.

I'd just make yourself comfortable it is a manufactured plane, not a well executed reworked plane, or one that has had it's toe cut-off.

coop

Re: Strange Transitional Plane

#6

LOL planning spirals, I love that!

Bob Demers

>

Re: Strange Transitional Plane

#7

Re: Correction... Strange Transitional Plane

Mike G. SC

>Hi Folks,

I must make a correction on the transitional plane. The trademark is Oak Leaf with _M Enders above and St Louis,MO. below. The body is 8 inches long and coffin shaped. Tapered iron and the frog is adjustable. Do transitional planes have adjustable frogs?

Thanks, Mike G. in SC

Re: Strange Transitional Plane

#8

Can you post a pic?

Bob Demers

>

Re: Strange Transitional Plane

#9

This one's sounding really intriguing

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>More, more! Pictures - not just one.

Re: Strange Transitional Plane

#10

Re: Correction... Strange Transitional Plane

cooper suter

>Oak Leaf was a brand name used by Simmons Hdw. of St. Louis, a big national hardware distributor going back to the later 1800's.

Simmons is best known for their Keen Kutter line, they also had a hand in distributing Winchester stuff for a while. Another name commonly associated w/Simmons is Shapliegh.

An 8" transitional is not a big deal in and of itself, but there are collectors of both minty transitionals, and Oak Leaf stuff.

The plane is likely a Stanley or Ohio Tool Co. manufactured plane that was imprinted w/the Oak Leaf brand.

Coop

Re: Strange Transitional Plane

#11

EC Simmons Hardware *LINK*

Bob Demers

>Ah yes, EC Simmons, thanks, I missed that one...

They had tools made by leading manufacturers (very much like Sears and Montgommery Ward does) but used a lot of various trade names.

Here is a sample from Rose tool's website roseantiquetools.com Sure enough, buried down there is Oak leaf....

Suggest checking the collectors of Simmons Hdw stuff for possible value. See link

Bob

E.C. Simmons & Co. was a wholesale hardware dealer which marked all types of tools. Although they were not a maker per se, the company did acquire controlling interest in the Walden Knife Co. in the 1890�s and had some of their tools made by that company. They were bought out by the A.F. Shapleigh Hdw. Co. n 1940. Besides their best known brand name KEEN KUTTER, some other brand names they used not necessarily before 1900 were: ARKANSAS (splitting wedges), AXTEL (horse rasps), BAY STATE (hatchets), BLACK JACK (various tools including a wrench with a 14 JAN. 1896 patent), BLACKSNAKE (saws), Blue Brand or B.B. (squares and others), BULL DOG (braces and tool sets), CHIPAWAY (axes, planes, hammers and other), CLAY BANK (shovels), COLUMBIA (saws), CUMBERLAND (axes), DEFIANCE (saws), DELMAR (coffee mills), DRIVEWELL (punches), DUCK BILL (wrenches), ESSEX (wrenches), EUREKA (rakes), FARMER BOY (scythe stones), FAST MAIL (saws), W.M. FINCH (saws), HERCULES (wheelbarrows), HOWARD (axes), KEYSTONE (forks), KLICKER (various tools), KLINCHER (pliers), KORN KRUSHER (corn mills, LIGHTNIN, LONE STAR (hoes), H.M. MEIER (saws), MESQUITE (axes), MOGUL (shovels), MONARCH (saws), NEVER SLIP (wrenches), OAK LEAF (various tools), OHIO BOY (rakes), OHIO FALLS (axes), OZARK (splitting wedges), POLAR (ice saws), RED JACKET (hatchets), RED LINE (rules), RED TOP (scythes), ROYAL (axes), RUN EASY (plows, lawn mowers), SMILEY�S (saws), SURE GRIP (braces, vises, wrenches), SWIFT (saws and saw tools), TRUE BLUE (axes), UTILITY (saws, wrenches), VANGUARD (saws), WINNER (lawn mowers), WOOD PECKER (axes), ZULU (axes), WM. ENDERS (various tools) information obtained from the EAIA Directory of American Toolmakers book which you can visit thier website at this link http://www.eaiainfo.org/


The Hardware Companies Kollector Klub