Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

Sometimes I think we fuss too much

Posts

Sometimes I think we fuss too much

#1

Sometimes I think we fuss too much

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>I drilled some extra dog holes in my bench today - the existing spacing was too great, so I drilled holes halfway between. I was in a hurry (seems like I always am anymore), so I just put a forstner bit in a drill and went at it. Unfortunately, I fairly consistently slanted the drill toward me a bit, so the bench underpinnings interfered with the holes on the bottom; so I went back (forstner bits are great for this) and reamed out the holes.

Lee Valley round dogs, by the way.

End result: the only part of the holes that's 3/4" is the very top. The rest of the hole is not round, but gives more the impression of a wolverine chewing its way out of a box. I can wiggle the bottom of the dog around a good 1/8" on some of the holes.

But so far, using them to hold boards on which I was doing some pretty vigorous planing (boards clamped between dog and Record end vise), they work fine.

This isn't what I'd want to do on a permanent benchtop, but this bench is moving toward replacement in a year or so, so I feel free to fool around and get the job done. It was a useful lesson. We may get too fussy sometimes.

Re: Sometimes I think we fuss too much

#2

Re: Sometimes I think we fuss too much

Richard Jones

>Amen, brother.

I like a new looking bench as much as the next guy. But I guess I'm more into performance than looks. If the holdfast/dog works, who cares? Whatever is being held sure doesn't!!

Sort of like I tell folks starting out in USPSA style shooting: Those fancy guns are sure pretty, but when the buzzer goes off, you still have to pull the trigger and hit the targets, no matter what you're using.

Hope you have a great day.

Rich (who has grandbabies this weekend!!!) in VA

Re: Sometimes I think we fuss too much

#3

Nice driveby, there, Rich

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>well, not really a driveby - maybe "nice boasting" is better.

Do you mean that you just acquired grandbabies this weekend, or that they're at your place so you can spoil them?

Any shoprats in the group yet, or are they too young?

Re: Sometimes I think we fuss too much

#4

Re: Sometimes I think we fuss too much

Todd O. Cronkhite Maine Native, Presently Away

>Ha! That's funny bill 'cause I was thinking of doing the same thing today with my dogholes. Mine are spaced at 11" on center, and are IMO spaced to far apart.

Mine are also round and I bore them out with a spade bit. Mine also have a peculiar "slant" to 'em as well. }:~[ Fortunately it doesn't seem to affect the use of 'em. Coarse, with what little woodworking I do, it doesn't really matter. Now that it's cooling off a bit lately I may be able to get out into the shop more.

I think my bench is also going to under another transformation, I'm not happy with it's base/leg arrangement.

So what's your new spacing?

T.O.

Re: Sometimes I think we fuss too much

#5

Re: Sometimes I think we fuss too much

ThomD

>One thing I like about Forstners is one can tell they are straight at the begining by whether they take an even bite. Unfortunately they not only cant but slip sideways. If you really wanted to be casual, I brace and an auger would be a very nice combo.

Re: Sometimes I think we fuss too much

#6

4-1/2" apart

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA------WebKitFormBound

>a kind of random spacing.

Re: Sometimes I think we fuss too much

#7

Re: Sometimes I think we fuss too much

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Hi Bill,

I think it was Yogi Barra who said, "Good enough is good enough".

Among other things, he also told a pizza guy when the guy asked if he wanted his pizza cut into 4 pieces or 8, Yogi said, better make it 4, I can't eat 8 pieces. Makes perfectly good sense to me. LOL

Marv

Re: Sometimes I think we fuss too much

#8

Re: Nice driveby, there, Rich

Richard Jones

>Have them for the weekend, daughter and s-i-l are going trout fishing today...........

Oldest one was in the shop just a few minutes ago with me while I cobbled up a dragonfly net out of a coathanger and some cheesecloth.

Spoil them? Me? :)

Rich

Re: Sometimes I think we fuss too much

#9

Re: Sometimes I think we fuss too much

"RJ" Whelan

>Bill ... I did exactly the same thing on my bench (well over 20 year old now).

It always bothered me that some positions were angled and sloppy so I spent a few hours drilling out all of the holes to 1-1/4"; turned a piece of maple to a tight fit; pounded the plugs in with a little glue; planed everything flush; redrilled all of the holes straight.

In the grand scheme of things the bench doesn't work any better, but the end-grain maple is kind of nice to look at and my OCD need for consistency is satisfied and I can now obsess about something else - like the three, bookmatched cherry panel I cut 1/2" undersized on Saturday (about $200 down the drain if I can't find another use for them .... rj

Re: Sometimes I think we fuss too much

#10

Re: You are not the only one...

Glenn Madsen near San Francisco

>I did that with maple cabinet doors late last spring...