Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

Coping saw blades - set question and best/worst?

Posts

Coping saw blades - set question and best/worst?

#1

Coping saw blades - set question and best/worst?

John Aniano - in NJ...

>Hello All,

I bought an old package of Disston coping saw blades thinking they would be great. I was disappointed. They have virtually no set, so they cannot be steered to make a curved cut. I thought the word "coping" sort of equated to "curved", but for these Disston blades, this was not the case.

Others here have suggested adding set to coping saw blades - I question "How"? My basic saw set (Stanley) cannot bear down on the teeth to get any set. The blade is simply too narrow. I've used this saw set many times on regular blades without issue. Thus, how does one put set in a coping saw blade shy of a saw wrest or a pair of needle-nose pliers?

If I can't easily add set to these "gems", what brand coping saw blades are best in the view of folks here? Olsen? Any other brands? I need to cut curves in ~1/2" thick tropical hardwoods.

Thanks,

John

Re: Coping saw blades - set question and best/worst?

#2

Re: Coping saw blades - set question and best/wors

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>John, you can add set by putting the blade on a medium density wood (I think I used poplar last time) and hitting each tooth with a punch. The harpsichord maker at Williamsburg demonstrated this technique in January, though I think he used a harder wood with a slight bevel where he wanted the bend. Dull blades also have trouble with curves.

Mail order companies have the annoying habit of switching suppliers over time, frustrating regular users. I am currently using blades from Lee Valley. They refused to identify the manufacturer (so if they change again you are out testing brands again), but I suspect they are Olsen. They are adequate, but they do not work until you sharpen them.

Re: Coping saw blades - set question and best/worst?

#3

Re: Coping saw blades - set question and best/wors

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>Warren,

You wrote "and hitting each tooth with a punch.", don't you mean every other tooth?

Stephen

Re: Coping saw blades - set question and best/worst?

#4

Re: Coping saw blades - set question and best/wors

Ray Gardiner

>Hi Stephen,

You have to hit every tooth, every other tooth gets hit from the other side.

Welcome to pedant's anonymous. (or is that pedants' anonymous) :-)

Regards

Ray

Re: Coping saw blades - set question and best/worst?

#5

I prefer Sandvik/Bahco coping saw blades *LINK*

David Barnett - SW Florida

>About a dollar apiece and range from 14 to 32tpi. 32tpi are 3.99/5.


Sandvik/Bahco 32tpi coping saw blades

Re: Coping saw blades - set question and best/worst?

#6

And a tip...

David Barnett - SW Florida

>You can radius the back edges of coping saw blades with a coarse diamond bench stone or diamond files for easier turning and control. Much easier to saw 'in place' when attempting sharp angles. Backs out of a cut nicely, as well.

Re: Coping saw blades - set question and best/worst?

#7

Re: Coping saw blades - set question and best/wors

Tom Colligan

>Warren (and others), are you serious that coping saw blades can be, or need to be, sharpened?

I can't imagine how this can be done. I do a reasonable job at sharpening handsaws but how would you hold a coping saw blade? Tia, Tom.

Re: Coping saw blades - set question and best/worst?

#8

Re: Coping saw blades - set question and best/wors

MikeW

>Do it in the frame. I place the frame in a vise with a block of wood that is cut to fit within the frame, supporting the back of the blade, laying on the top of the vise.

And a needle file will fit well.

Take care, Mike

Re: Coping saw blades - set question and best/worst?

#9

Rip?

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>

Re: Coping saw blades - set question and best/worst?

#10

Re: Setting coping saw blades...

John Aniano in NJ...

>Warren, et. al.,

Of course - just hit the teeth with a punch! I should have remembered! Yes, I'll try that on the Disstons. And thank you David about the rounding over tip for the back. I'll do both and report back.

John

Re: Coping saw blades - set question and best/worst?

#11

Re: Coping saw blades - set question and best/wors

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>I put the coping saw blades in my saw vise. I made two shallow grooves in the jaws to accommodate the pins in the saw blade. Years ago I got blades that were sharp enough. However, many blades on the market today have visible rounding of the points and are not near sharp enough for serious work. I will try the Bahco blades that David suggests.

Re: Coping saw blades - set question and best/worst?

#12

Re: Rip?

MikeW

>Hi Stephen,

I file mine what I call a strong cross cut. Enough rake I know it is there (I shoot for 10 or a bit more degrees) and angle the file just off of 90 degrees to the blade. But towards the tip, I file progressivel more fleam to make it easier on the thin, narrow blade tip so it doesn't bind as easy.

Filing with progressive fleam is easy to do. The hand holding the file handle simply doesn't advance as much as the hand holding the tip of the file. Subtle difference. A loose planting of the one hand if you will. On something as small as a coping saw blade tkes more concentration because the teeth are so close together.

When we moved the shop, I uncovered the package of 5 blades I bought with the frame. There are still 3 blades left. I believe I bought the frame in 1970 or so when I was carving for cutting out waste areas.

Take care, Mike

Re: Coping saw blades - set question and best/worst?

#13

Re: Rip?

MikeW

>OK. End of a long week, combined with having just answered a question about keyhole saw sharpening led to my brain's demise in answering Mr. S the first go round. One half of the ol' mind was thinking coping saw blades, the other keyhole blades.

I do add a bit of fleam on my coping saw blades. The rake is still pretty stiff, though I am sure it is more relaxed than compared to how my blades originally came. Clear as mud now? Feel free to beat me about the head if it isn't.

Mike

Re: Coping saw blades - set question and best/worst?

#14

Re: Rip?

Bob Demers

>Wow i'm amazed that people actually sharpen and reset their coping saw blades! and if I didnt hear it from Mike, I may have dismiss the idea out of hand, but I highly respect the Wenzloff's saw maker and their saws, so 'tabarnouche' I must try that :-)

I personnaly have used Olson coping blades and small marquetrie blades from LV for years. Still got enough supply to last me a while. Im happy with them, and never even dream of the need of sharpening them.

As a carver, I rely a lot on my bandsaw (oups, manual powered of course, says he with fingers cross behind his back :-) and my coping saws, fret saws, and jewellers saws. Yap, got an assortment of each, didnt think I was going to keep switching blades did you?

Bob, still in amazement about the idea of sharpening coping saw blades....

Re: Coping saw blades - set question and best/worst?

#15

Re: Rip?

MikeW

>Hi Bob,

I look at blades (except the Bahco ones mentioned) as coming pre-dulled. They benefit from a tickle right off. They will cut smoother and faster--which means less effort and a bit more ease in turning. Someone mentioned rounding the backs and I highly recommend that as well if the saws are going to be used for tighter radii.

I have, er, a couple frames in the shop as well. The one that is mine is the original junk one I bought years ago. I use that saw for cutting out the waste of DTs these days. The back on it is heavily rounded (to the point of being noticible). The others we just knock the sharp corners off of.

I "sharpen" them enough to see fresh metal gleaming at me on the face/back of the teeth. Really light passes. And it is only a once in a great while process. I doubt I touch up the one I use the most (the DT one) more than once in a couple years and probably longer. I am fairly date challenged. When I used it during carving, I did it probably once a year or so. The ones I have are pretty hard steel.

Take care, Mike

Re: Coping saw blades - set question and best/worst?

#16

Re: Rip?

Dean J in MN

>To follow up on Mike's advise. Not only do they come pre-dulled, they often come with a crazy rake angle. Some with the teeth leaning forward! I relax the rake on my blades so they aren't impossible to use smoothly.

-Dean