Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

Perfect handled chisels? *LINK*

Posts

Perfect handled chisels? *LINK*

#1

Perfect handled chisels? *LINK*

Wiley Horne-- So. Calif.

>See Chris Schwarz' blog at link.


Chris Schwarz re Stanley chisels

Re: Perfect handled chisels? *LINK*

#2

Re: Perfect handled chisels?

kees

>yes, but there's also uncle Bob.

"Men against Schwarz"

http://www.woodcentral.com/articles/smalser/articles_366.shtml

Re: Perfect handled chisels? *LINK*

#3

Re: Perfect handled chisels?

ThomD

>That's one step above a cold chisel. Whoever designed that didn't like wood, didn't trust it or was afraid their clients would abuse it. There is a reason for hitting a wooden handle to split into a piece of wood. It works better. Less bounce more of a dead blow. Just like those spliting wedges in iron that have a hole for a stick of wood that takes the blows.

I look at their new line and it makes me want to say "I wonder where they got those ideas"? Though really one could perpetually turn from one of the usual suspects to the next while spitting out the same words.

I do like the lever on their new shoulder plane. That one could be a winner.

Re: Perfect handled chisels? *LINK*

#4

New #4 is a puzzle

James Watriss

>So, the frog is molded into the body of the plane. The depth is controlled (I'm assuming) by the norris style adjuster. There's a knob for tightening down what used to be the lever cap... and I like this idea, I miss that feature on a record plane I used to have...

But it looks like there's a knob behind the iron, too. But it doesn't seem like there's much left to adjust. So that begs the question, what does it adjust? Is this going to be an adjustable pitch plane?

Re: Perfect handled chisels? *LINK*

#5

planes' designs surely look stolen from LV!

HC Sakman

>Except the shoulder plane.

Chico...

Re: Perfect handled chisels? *LINK*

#6

Re: planes' designs surely look stolen from LV!

ThomD

>Who originally sold the LN low angles, who might have been aware of the Stanley originals...

Re: Perfect handled chisels? *LINK*

#7

Re: planes' designs surely look stolen from LV!

Todd Stock

>LN started with the Stanley designs, as did LV - no debate there. Same thing with lateral adjusters and the other key elements here...all prior art on tools made well before Lie-Nielsen or Lee Valley even dreamed of entering the hand tool market. I'm just hoping that Stanley goes with a more contoured handle, as that has always been the least comfortable and least attractive element of the LV designs.

Re: Perfect handled chisels? *LINK*

#8

Re: Perfect handled chisels?------WebKitFormBounda

kees------WebKitFormBoundary7GLpVOF80sMVTD+Y

>I once was in the room of a surgeon....... waking up, half halucinating and guess what I saw hanging on the wall: made in USA (as a lot of medical instruments?)

------WebKitFormBoundary7GLpVOF80sMVTD+Y

Re: Perfect handled chisels? *LINK*

#9

Re: planes' designs surely look stolen from LV!

kees------WebKitFormBoundary7GLpVOF80sMVTD+Y------

>Stanley is outperformed by the chinese and it's now Bahco in EU.

Re: Perfect handled chisels? *LINK*

#10

Re: Perfect handled chisels?

Hank Knight

>A agree with Thom, the new Stanley chisels look like expensive construction grade chisels to me. They are clearly a new iteration of Stanely's old Everlasting line. I bought my first Everlasting chisel years ago and fell in love with the heft and solid feel of the thing; and it had really good steel. I went on something of a binge and bought a bunch of them. After using them for a while I found myself gravitating back to my socket and tang chisels because, IMHO, they are lighter, easier to manupulate and less tiring to use. I've since become a fan of Japanese chisels for the same reasons. But If I have some tough chiseling to do, I pull out the Everlastings and whale away with a steel hammer. It's kind of liberating and the chisels can really take the punishment. These new Stanleys look to me like they would be excellent for rough work but a little on the heavy side for good cabinet makers chisels. Too bad Stanley didn't choose to resurrect the old 750 line with good steel and a nice finish.

Hank

Re: Perfect handled chisels? *LINK*

#11

Re: planes' designs surely look stolen from LV!

Chris Friesen

>Yeah, but the overall "vocabulary" of the design for the bevel up planes looks like a stripped-down version of the Veritas planes.

Take the Veritas, remove the setscrews for the blade, remove some of the side hollows, add that bent metal thing under the front knob, remove one of the two handle bolts on the jack, and you get something that looks awfully close to the Stanley.

Re: Perfect handled chisels? *LINK*

#12

I agree but...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>I like the old Everlasting's also. If Stanley re-vamped the 750's they be going up against LN.

The planes sides look like the old Defiance planes. I always like the lines of them. Looks like they mixed a few thing from other plane makers as well in these designs.

Re: Perfect handled chisels? *LINK*

#13

my thoughts too

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>They do look like spiffy construction chisels. It seems that one mostly needs a dovetail chisel, which for me means short and light so as to not be top heavy (I tend to hold them near the bevel for this operation) and a paring chisel, which is long with a comfy grip. The handle on these looks like it would be top heavy for the way I dovetail and the blades too short for ideal paring.

If customers knew their steel it would not be hard to compete with the LN's by making a similar paring chisel in a quality carbon steel. And a dovetail chisel with the heft and balance of the Japanese chisels but with western styling I think would be an attractive product.

Re: Perfect handled chisels? *LINK*

#14

Re: planes' designs surely look stolen from LV!

Alex Yeilding

>But, on the other hand, the LV looks like a "stripped up" version of this, so it's had to claim that Stanley stole LV's design!!


img

Re: Perfect handled chisels? *LINK*

#15

Re: my thoughts too

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>I, too, would not be tempted by this look.

One assumes that these renderings are accurate representations of the final version. Of course they may just be theoretical.

I do like the inlayed PH look. If I were to offer a recommendation to Stanley (who are listening, of course!), it would be to s-t-r-e-t-c-h the handle a little and make the overall look slimmer.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Perfect handled chisels? *LINK*

#16

I agree but for one thing

Wiley Horne-- So. Calif.

>The thought of hitting one of those with a steel hammer gives me the willies. Just hate that steel on steel thing, unless it's hammer on nail. I hope they remember not to harden the butt end of it. Or at least to anneal it after hardening.

Wiley

Re: Perfect handled chisels? *LINK*

#17

Stanley vs. Lie-Nielsen

Hank Knight

>I'll bet new Stanley 750s with good O1 steel at $25 TO $30 a pop could give LN a run for the money.

Re: Perfect handled chisels? *LINK*

#18

Re: planes' designs surely look stolen from LV!

Tony Zaffuto

>Go back a few more years and take a look at the Stanley Gage, for the design of the body.

T.Z.

Re: Perfect handled chisels? *LINK*

#19

variation in the UK

paul womack

>Ward and Payne Aristocrat

Note the BOLT holding the handle to the blade.

BugBear