Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

Dunlap planes?

Posts

Dunlap planes?

#1

Dunlap planes?

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>I know Dunlap was the second line for Sears, but does anyone know who made them? I picked up a jack today for about twice what I should have paid ($2 instead of $1). It actually looks like a decent if simple plane.

Re: Dunlap planes?

#2

Often times Millers Falls

Patrick Gibbons, Katy, TX

>

Re: Dunlap planes?

#3

Or Sargent *LINK*

Bob Demers

>Dunlap was a brand name used by Sears, similar to Companion and Fulton, to differentiate from the Crafstman brand.

Who made Dunlap tools? The answer varies by year of manufacture and the specific tool, whomever won the bid for that year so to speak.

Lots of them were made by Sargent. In order to identify your specific tool, just post a picture of it, preferably with the blade removed to see the frog and I should be able to identify its maker

Bob


DUNLAP story

Re: Dunlap planes?

#4

Thanks, Bob

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>The seller threw the rust in, no extra charge.

This is, of course, an opportunity for Todd Hughes to ask why I paid this much for the plane...something I'm wondering, myself, today. Seemed like a good idea at the time. The cutting iron is actually cleaner than it looks, and the mechanical parts seem sound.


img

Re: Dunlap planes?

#5

About your plane

Bob Demers

>Look definitively more like MF than Sargent, judging by the frog shape.

The yoke is of steel split construction? and the tab at the end of the lateral lever is folded on one side only?

Adjuster nut solid or recessed?

Another pic of side view of adjuster would help narrow it down

How old is your plane?

The Dunlap brand was supposedly named after Tom Dunlap, the manager of the Sears hardware division during the 1930s. Dunlap tools began appearing in the Sears catalogs around 1938 or 1939, and continued to be offered at least into the late 1950s.

Power tools with the Dunlap brand was first used in 1941, replacing the earlier Companion brand.

Your plane lever cap has the old style keyhole which Stanley changed to the now familiar kidney shape one in the 30s. However that does not mean that your plane is from 30s vintage, that kidney hole shape was patented by Stanley, clone makers would have to wait for the patent expiry before switching. I could be wrong, but I dont recall seeing a MF plane with kidney shaped hole lever cap

MF switched to a press steel yoke (fork) depth adjuster in 1936-1941

This Dunlop branded plane is probably from MF mid line and economy bench plane models: Mohawk-Shelburne 1936 or V-Line 1956.

Im guessing yours is from later models, 50s near the end of Dunlap run.

Worth a buck or two? You bet :-)

Bob

Re: Dunlap planes?

#6

Re: About your plane

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>Wow. Thanks for the information. This group has so many people who are so knowledgeable.

You asked and I'll answer,

"The yoke is of steel split construction?" YES

"and the tab at the end of the lateral lever is folded on one side only?" WHY YES, how'd you guess?

"Adjuster nut solid or recessed?" Recessed.

So, if it is from a mid-line or econo model, did they scrimp on the cutting iron quality too, or mainly on the casting and frog details? I did notice right away that they used birch or something similar on the tote and knob - some $$ savings right there.

Picture attached; sorry for cutting off the top of the lateral lever; my little point-and-blur camera is horrid with parallax for anything close.


img

Re: Dunlap planes?

#7

Re: About your plane *LINK*

Bob Demers

>Thanks Bill

Well I didnt really guess about the yoke its faintly visible in your first pic and the tab? well that was an educated guess, more like a deduction since everything else pointed to a Miller Falls orphan :-)

So what did they skimp on for the econo line you ask? I could tell you but it would be better to point you to the best site of info on MF

eveything. Bookmark it, and refer to it like the Blood and gore site on Stanley.

Bottom line, its not a bad plane, and the rust may look bad but to me it look mostly superficial and should clean up good.

Bob, glad to be of any help


Randy Roeder MF's page

Re: Dunlap planes?

#8

Thanks. Interesting Info

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>

Re: Dunlap planes?

#9

Re: Dunlap planes? *LINK*

Walt

>quick rule of thumb for plane id...at least for cast frogs...stamped steel frogs are a whole 'nother animal and best left behind...

lateral lever designs were patented and can generally get you to a manufacturer quickly, there are a few other variations but these are the ones you regularly find....

I did a quick page at the link

walt Q


img

quick field guide for laterals

Re: Dunlap planes?

#10

Re: Dunlap planes? *LINK*

Bob Demers

>Very Good Walt, thats basically my first clue I look at too.

By the way, if anyone wonder why the frogs shown on Walt's link are called the 'good ones'...pay attention to the top part.

These are before Stanley switched to the ogee shaped top, which indicates a major changes in the frog surface: in order to save on rising machining cost, they have depressed areas, hence less surface to machined, but unfortunately it also translated into less support behind the blade. Does it really make that much differences? Debatable, but thats the primary reason most users prefer type 11s

By the way MF always had the earlier full machined surfaces frog, and the earlier Sargent and Record (look for Stay Set (SS)) lever cap)also had similar full machined frog surface, but they too swith to the cheaper type later.

See pic at bottom of link for frog comparison

By looking at the lateral lever, the top part of the frog, the color of it (MF were often red) and the amount of cutter sticking out past the lever you can quickly learn a lot about the plane in any pic

Bob, back from a frustrating day at work...thank god for WW to keep one sanity :-)


MF type study

Re: Dunlap planes?

#11

Wandering afield...

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>I picked up an early (low knob) Stanley No. 4, NOT marked "Bailey," which has the fully-machined frog surface, but seems to have a frog that does not rest on the base casting on the front - I can slip a feeler gauge between frog and body casting. Is this a second-line plane, or did Stanley's early frogs not rest on the body at the very front?

This plane explains why Stanley moved to the high knobs, by the way - the low knob is so tight in the body that I can't figure out how to grip it. Too bad, because the low knobs are so much prettier. I love the low knob on my No. 8.

Re: Dunlap planes?

#12

Re: Wandering afield...

Bob Demers

>Is this a second-line plane, or did Stanley's early frogs not rest on the body at the very front?

Well not really, the frog should rest solidly on the bed casting.

However....how much of a gap are we talking about?

I presumed you checked for interference (dirt, rust etc) which may prevent it from sitting correctly?

I too have an affinity for the low knobs, but the smaller sized Stanley's (No 2, 3 and even No 4 if you have big hands) can get akward to hold comfortably, or do they really?

Who says we have to wrap our finger around the knob, is there a right way to hold it?

To me the right way is whatever feel comfortable in my hands yet afford control and tactile feedback.

A highly personal thing for sure. Food for thought or debate? :-)

I'll get the popcorn ready, just the same

Bob, back in from the shop. Making mindless shavings is very therapeutic..ahhhhhhhhh

Re: Dunlap planes?

#13

Re: Wandering afield...

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>I double-checked - the front of the frog and the corresponding part of the base casting were clearly never machined to fit each other. The front of the casting falls off as it approaches the mouth; the frog casting has a similar shape, but there's NO machining on either. The machined surfaces are at the "step" where the normal two screws hold the frog in place, where there's a central land machined on each. I can fit a 0.020" (managed to remember to put in the zero before the two that time) feeler gauge into the gap.

The frog's got a Stanley lateral lever, with Stanley type patent information on the lever, and the iron has a Stanley logo, apparently dating from 1891-1904, according to Bob Kaune's site. Thus, I have no reason to doubt its Stanleyness.

The only easily visible mark on the body is "No 4" across the front, in front of the knob. "Bailey" is nowhere in sight.

Ironically, when the frog is set coplanar with the leading edge of the back of the mouth, the plane's got an incredibly tight mouth for a Stanley; it's got a really sensual rosewood tote and a large iron adjusting knob; and the face of the frog (where goes the iron) is a flat, machined surface. If it had a better frog...unless someone tells me this is likely to score big time on deBay, when and if I finally get a round tuit, I'll probably clean it up, screw down the frog with some bedding of some sort under (JB weld or something, unless I figure out something reversible), and put it to use as a smoother. I have a feeling it would work well if the potential chatter from a cantilevered frog were addressed.

Re: Dunlap planes?

#14

Frankenplane??

Bob Demers

>double-checked - the front of the frog and the corresponding part of the base casting were clearly never machined to fit each other.

Does not sound right...substituted frog?

snip

The frog's got a Stanley lateral lever, with Stanley type patent information on the lever, and the iron has a Stanley logo, apparently dating from 1891-1904, according to Bob Kaune's site. Thus, I have no reason to doubt its Stanleyness.

OK so you have a genuine Stanley frog and blade, that in itself does not meant it belong to that plane

The only easily visible mark on the body is "No 4" across the front, in front of the knob. "Bailey" is nowhere in sight.

The word Bailey was only cast on Stanley's plane starting with type 9

The plane No all by itself was on type 5 to 8

Starting at type 7, the distance between No and the actual plane number increase to 1 inch

For quick reference:

Type 5 1885-1888

Type 6 1888-1892

Type 7 1893-1899

Type 8 1899-1902

Type 9 1902-1907

Lateral lever start at type 5, and you mentioned that your iron dated 1891-1904

snip

The frog/iron combinaison sound right, and the type study dates seem to fit your description, but your first sentence throw me right off:

the front of the frog and the corresponding part of the base casting were clearly never machined to fit each other.

That sentence rings alarm bells in my head, something smell fishy..

I dont suppose you could put up pictures?

I have a feeling it would work well if the potential chatter from a cantilevered frog were addressed.

You bet!

Bob, the plane detective from NPIS

(National Plane Identification Service :-)

Re: Dunlap planes?

#15

Frankenstanley plane frog - 2 *LINK*

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>Here's a picture of the frog off the plane, and the frog seat. You can see that the area of the frog and base right behind the mouth are not machined, nor could they mate - they slant, roughly parallel to each other, and, as the frog moves forward and back, would be more or less close to each other.

I think it is a Stanley plane - scroll down to the discussion of the Stanley No. 3 in Patrick Leach's Blood and Gore (linked). A ways down in that, there's a picture of four frog designs. It looks to me like I've got the second from the left.

Which, of course, raises the question of whether I've got a fabulously valuable plane here...

Side note: this marks my first download of a picture from my camera to my new computer, AND my first upload from the file to the web. Without even too awfully much pain!

Previewing the post tells me I've now got one of those cool WebKitFormBoundary computers. Fortunately, I can edit that out before posting.

I think the paint's dry on the siding pieces I'm installing...time to get back to work.


img

what I mean

Re: Dunlap planes?

#16

Hey Bill, No link and no pic...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>Gotta love a new computer eh?

Re: Dunlap planes?

#17

Link and picture issues

Dan Donaldson

>Both the link and the picture have the webkitformboundary issue. I would fix them, but am not sure what they actually should be. That stuff is interspersed in both the link and the pic url's. I think part of the problem is with Safari if you are using that. You might want to try using Firefox on your computer and see if that fixes it. (I assume that you are using a MAC)

Re: Dunlap planes?

#18

Yep, It's a mac. Bill just got a new one!

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>

Re: Dunlap planes?

#19

Re: Frankenstanley plane frog - 2

Bob Demers

>I 'see' you are still experiencing computer's joy :-)

From your description of the frog and the referenced picture on Patrick's Blood and gore, your frog matches the correct time frame, that is type 5 to 8.

Sorry, only the first 3 types are anything valuable, and types 4 somewhat. 5 to 19 are more common hence not especially valuable.

type 9 to 11 or even 13 are the prefered users, hence they can fetch a tad more even if they are commun.

If you want to narrow down further your specific type, check the distance between the No and 4 on the toe of the plane.

if its about one inch, you got a type 7 or 8.

So far, everything sound right, I.E. pure Stanley, but the discrepancy between the frog and its matching bed seems odd.

Could very well be another frog of the right type from a donor plane

Bob, who spent lots of time on Shorpy today, thanks to Dan :-)

Re: Dunlap planes?

#20

Re: Frankenstanley plane frog - 2

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>I haven't been clear in earlier posts - the frog and bed are machined to match, and do so just fine. However, I am used to the later Stanley (and other) planes in which there's a machined section just behind the mouth, with matching machining on the frog, to provide good bedding at the very front of the frog. This plane lacks that, with the two surfaces being unmachined and deliberately not touching each other.

I've been picturing finding some shim-thickness lead stock that would squish into the space between as I tighten down the frog. It would work just once - the frog would have to be set in one position - but, if I set it for a tight mouth, this should be fine (it is a smoother); and it would be reversible, when this plane type becomes valuable in 50 years.

Re: Dunlap planes?

#21

Mystery solved

Bob Demers

>AH! OK now I follow you, I'm slow in my old age :-)

OK, that would be normal because yes, on the earlier one that was the case, somewhat hit and miss.

What you have is a bonafide Stanley type 5-8. Did you identified it as a type 7? (spacing between No and 4)

I never bother much with adj the frog, I always set them flush (coplanar) with the rear lip of the mouth. That way I get most support where it count the most, near the cutting edge.

If I feel the need for a tighter mouth, I simply swith plane in my arsenal, yes, I have a 'few' :-)

Bob