Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

Another holdfast querry

Posts

Another holdfast querry

#1

Joe McMahon

Another holdfast querry

Joe McMahon

>I ordered as set of Jake's holdfasts today as I have a difficult time holding things on my bench with just the face & tail vice. My Ulma bench has square dog holes that only go along the front of the bench. It will hurt but I'm going to have to bore holes in my bench for the holdfasts. Now on to my questions:

What size hols should I bore?

Where in the top is the best place to bore them? (If there is a "best place" to bore them)

TIA, Joe

Re: Another holdfast querry

#2

Re: Another holdfast querry

Adam Cherubini

>I have a few preferences.

The first hole to bore places the holdfasts shank in alignment with the business side of the planing stop. So if you are working a wide board for a carcass side you can place a batten across the planing stop and the holdfast's shank and the batten will be square with the long edge of the bench. I place this hold fast so that it's foot can sit on a 1"x12" when the 1x12" is engaged against the planing stop.

Then I think it makes sense to place a few holes every two or three feet from there. I stagger them to be in line with the first stop, and then closer to the front edge of the bench such that the shank will contact a 1x12.

If you do this, there are a ton of tricks you can employ to hold all sorts of odd stock sizes by using cheap pine 1x12's from your local home center. I'm not just thinking of planing 1x12's but using them as make shift sticking boards.

Most benches are pretty good at holding long boards with square edges. I find holding short wide boards, boards with non square ends, or thin or narrow stock is the real trick. End vises generally aren't good for any of this stuff.

Not sure how you guys bore holes in your benches. I use ship augers or fine lead brace augers.

Good luck,

Adam

Re: Another holdfast querry

#3

Most are designed for a ...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>3/4" Diameter hole.

Re: Another holdfast querry

#4

Don't drill the hole until...

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>you have the holdfast in hand. For a thinner bench top a tight hole is preferred, thicker tops will take a slightly larger hole.

As for location, drill one first then decide where you need the next. Take your time, you don't need to drill all the holes at one time, especially if they are the wrong size.

Take a piece of wood the same thickness as your bench top and try different size holes to see which is right.

Stephen

Re: Another holdfast querry

#5

Re: Another holdfast querry

Wiley Horne-- So. Calif.

>Adam answered the original question, and then said,

" I find holding short wide boards, boards with non square ends, or thin or narrow stock is the real trick. End vises generally aren't good for any of this stuff."

One suggestion in this regard is to hang onto those dovetail practice pieces, and make planing stops out of them. For example, say you do a practice joint with two pieces from the shorts pile (or off the floor!), maybe 4-6" wide. When you're done with the practice joint, you have an L which is 4-6 inches wide. Saw a V into one wing of the L. Clamp the other wing of the L in the end vise--end vises are good for holding planing stops--with the V projecting onto the bench. The point: narrow sticks that are not easy to clamp to the apron will slide into that V and will sit upright for edge jointing, supported by the benchtop. Of course, you could just glue the L up out of two short pieces, but if the dovetail practice joint is right there.....

Wiley

Re: Another holdfast querry

#6

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: Another holdfast querry

Jack Guzman from Maine

>Joe,you want the hole just a little bit bigger than the holdfast. I keep a brace with the correct size right near my bench and when I need a hole I drill it.

My bench isn't a piece of art,it's a tool and I want it to fit my needs.---Jack

Re: Another holdfast querry

#7

Re: 11/16" shaft for a 3/4" hole

Dave Mount

>In my correspondence with Phil the other day he said his are made from 11/16" rod for use in a 3/4" hole, as most bench holes are that size. However, the advise to wait to be sure is probably best.

Dave

Re: Another holdfast querry

#8

Joe McMahon

Re: Another holdfast querry

Joe McMahon

>Guys, thanks for the great information. I will have a 3/4 bit ready but check it first. Also, I'll wait to see where I actually need the holdfast before cutting the first hole.

Re: Another holdfast querry

#9

Re: Chucking reamers

ThomD

>Drill it in a scrap piece you hold in your vice, etc... Then you can tune hole size to tip thickness hardness, geometry etc...

I don't doubt most aren't as stupid as me, but with benches there is a lot going on, be sure you have the correct clearances, and top thicknesses where you will be drilling. You want to avoid stuff like stretchers, threaded rod. vise hardware.

One thing I have become enamoured with are chucking reamers. If you want a 3/4 hole, get a slightly smaller bit, around here there is usually a metric size that is smaller, or a fraction. Then when you have the hole in, you can run the chucking reamer through it and get a more accurate and polished hole, though you should check that out in a scrap too.

Re: Another holdfast querry

#10

Joe McMahon

Re: Chucking reamers

Joe McMahon

>What is a chucking reamer?

Re: Another holdfast querry

#11

Re: Chucking reamers

ThomD

>Basically a reamer that fits in a chuck, In metal work when you want a perfect hole, perfect size, smooth walls you may ream the hole. Another example would be if you want a hole that would take a 1.000 shaft then you would ream it to 1.001. They do cut nicely. really clean walls mean more contact surface area and less grooves to mash down.

http://www.victornet.com/cgi-bin/victor/productlist.html?subdepartments=Machine+Chucking+Reamers+.376%22+to+1-1%2F2%22%3A1214%2C1215

Re: Another holdfast querry

#12

Joe McMahon

Re: Chucking reamers

Joe McMahon

>ThomD, thanks for the tip! I'll check out a 3/4 reamer.

Joe