Bench top thickness -- diminishing returns?
Dave Mount
>This is probably a tired subject, but I have a fairly specific question. I've decided this winter is time to replace my makeshift bench. I'm going to use white oak for the top because I already have a bunch of 7/4 oak and it only makes sense to use it rather than buy something else. The stock I have was all sawed the same nominal width and is generally a little over 5.5" wide.
I have enough material to make the bench with that full width as the depth, but I would use a lot of wood and the slab would be so heavy as to be very difficult to manage during construction and assembly. I figure a 2' x 7' x 5" top would weigh about 350 lbs. However, making anything thinner really doesn't do much except create waste wood, unless I go thin enough to split the stock in two, from which I would probably manage a finished benchtop 2.5" thick.
I suppose I could get carried away and do things like edge join two pieces then rip them down into three pieces (for a top maybe 3.25-3.5" thick). I have white oak 4x4's for legs and other thick stock so I can make a fairly massive base.
So, given these parameters, how would you balance the alternatives? I do intend to use holdfasts on this bench, so having enough thickness for them to work is important.
As a related question, some of the stock is pretty long (9-12') and the bench will probably be 6.5-7', shorter than the stock but not half as long. I don't see a reason one couldn't make use of shorter pieces by having butt joints in the middle of the glue up, sandwiched by full size pieces on both sides, or am I missing something?
TIA for any suggestions,
Dave



