Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

Bench top thickness -- diminishing returns?

Posts

Bench top thickness -- diminishing returns?

#1

Bench top thickness -- diminishing returns?

Dave Mount

>This is probably a tired subject, but I have a fairly specific question. I've decided this winter is time to replace my makeshift bench. I'm going to use white oak for the top because I already have a bunch of 7/4 oak and it only makes sense to use it rather than buy something else. The stock I have was all sawed the same nominal width and is generally a little over 5.5" wide.

I have enough material to make the bench with that full width as the depth, but I would use a lot of wood and the slab would be so heavy as to be very difficult to manage during construction and assembly. I figure a 2' x 7' x 5" top would weigh about 350 lbs. However, making anything thinner really doesn't do much except create waste wood, unless I go thin enough to split the stock in two, from which I would probably manage a finished benchtop 2.5" thick.

I suppose I could get carried away and do things like edge join two pieces then rip them down into three pieces (for a top maybe 3.25-3.5" thick). I have white oak 4x4's for legs and other thick stock so I can make a fairly massive base.

So, given these parameters, how would you balance the alternatives? I do intend to use holdfasts on this bench, so having enough thickness for them to work is important.

As a related question, some of the stock is pretty long (9-12') and the bench will probably be 6.5-7', shorter than the stock but not half as long. I don't see a reason one couldn't make use of shorter pieces by having butt joints in the middle of the glue up, sandwiched by full size pieces on both sides, or am I missing something?

TIA for any suggestions,

Dave

Re: Bench top thickness -- diminishing returns?

#2

Re: Bench top thickness -- diminishing returns?

Chris Friesen

>I'm almost done building a bench with hard maple strips salvaged from a bowling alley. It's roughly 2.5" thick and it has many butt joints (with the joints staggered as much as possible) as only about a quarter of the strips ended up being long enough to span the bench.

The top is still in two slabs and isn't yet bolted to the end assemblies. While the slabs are very strong, if I clamp one to the end assembly and pound on it in the center or at the end, there's just a bit of "springiness" to it. Over the legs it's absolutely dead.

I don't have enough experience to know if this is going to be a problem, so I'm curious to see what others think. In your case if the cost of the wood isn't an issue, I'd be tempted to go with the full thickness. That benchtop would then likely outlast your grandkids.

Re: Bench top thickness -- diminishing returns?

#3

Re: Bench top thickness -- diminishing returns?

Dean J in MN

>As a related question, some of the stock is pretty long (9-12') and the bench will probably be 6.5-7', shorter than the stock but not half as long. I don't see a reason one couldn't make use of shorter pieces by having butt joints in the middle of the glue up, sandwiched by full size pieces on both sides, or am I missing something?

Why are you not using the full length for the bench? 6.5-7' bench is really short if you plan on making moldings. I'd go for as long as you can. 9' would be great, 12'fantastic if you have the space in your shop.

-Dean

Re: Bench top thickness -- diminishing returns?

#4

Jim in Burlington Ont.

Couple of downfalls

Jim in Burlington On

>Attaching a vise onto it will be tricky. Might be a bit of a bear to ever move. Otherwise I'd make one that thick in a heartbeat.

Re: Bench top thickness -- diminishing returns?

#5

Re: Bench top thickness -- diminishing returns?

ThomD

>I agree, if you can manage it, you are best off to make a bench at least 8 feet long. In the real world 7 seems to have been some kind of standard, so how bad could it be. My first bench was a 5 footer a la Frid. It is certainly fine enough for all kinds of things, but then it is well to remember he not only taught in an industrial setting but personaly did stuff like used router jigs to plane long pieces and belt sanded others. if you put an 8' piece on a 5 foot bench you can belt sand it while it would be pretty tough to plane it, inless it was thick enough to be a bench in it's own right. 8' or a little longer makes sense because of ceiling heights we can have things that are 7 or so feet tall, so why not be able to hold them. Benches are like lathes, there is an overall length, and what you can hold between centers.

Sounds like the wood you have would be fine for the base, depending on design, or with some modest lamination. It would also be fine for the top in infil areas, many benches are not the same depth throughout. I wouldn't go as deep as 5 inches, it will be terribly heavy and particularly on a short bench, unecesarilly thick. The ideal is proabaly 3-4 inches with as few joints as possible.

I wouldn't butt pieces lengthwise for reasons, structural, aesthetic, wood movement, and so forth. But it would probably work if you did. To me a bench is something of a display piece and I wouldn't do that in pieces I made so I wouldn't do it for me, but then others might. If I had to, I would be joining the pieces endwise, with epoxy by some means or other to keep differencial shirkage at bay. Good candidates would be scarphs or hardware bonding (rebar dowels, lots of epoxy). If you do the butts plan it out carefully so you don't end up with stuff like a dog hole needing to pierce the last inch of one of the boards.

Re: Bench top thickness -- diminishing returns?

#6

Re: Bench top thickness -- diminishing returns?

Hank Knight

>Dave,

How about a compromise? My bench top is made from a laminated maple slab 24" wide and 3" thick. I glued two 2" X 4" strips to each side for my dog hole strips plus a 3/4" X 4" apron or finishing strip, so the outside 5" on each side of the bench top is 4" thick. The 3" thick, 24" wide center section is plenty stable. I'm sure I could have done with a 2 1/2" thick center secton and gotten pretty much the same stability because the 4" outside strips add to the stiffness of the top. 2 1/2" is plenty thick enough for hold fasts and similar fixtures. Most of the pounding and heavy work happens on the outside 4" thick dog hole section. It's VERY solid and it's easy to clamp stuff to the bench top.

My $.02

Hank

Re: Bench top thickness -- diminishing returns?

#7

Re: Constraints

Dave Mount

>Thanks to everyone for their thoughts. My plan is for this bench to be freestanding, with room to work all around. My current bench is against the wall and has limitations because of it. Squeezing down to 7' was to keep from pinching myself for space around the ends. Maybe I should revisit the layout again. . .

Best,

Dave

Re: Bench top thickness -- diminishing returns?

#8

Re: Bench top thickness -- add a stiffener?

John Aniano in rainy (thankfully) NJ...

>Chris, et. al.,

Might you install a lateral stiffener, say an oak 2x6 on edge, under the bench top along it's length? This would stiffen the top and prevent the springiness you mentioned. I realize that a single stiffener would allow the top to twist, a la the Tacoma Narrows bridge, but the base (legs, etc.) should prevent twisting from occurring.

I've wondered about this for a long bench, for the following reason. I have an oak plank ~20" wide and 3" thick for a planned 10 foot long French-style bench (any day now...). When finished, if I feel the need for it, I'll attach just such a lateral stiffener down the center of the top. I can see no reason why it will get in the way for any clamping tasks I have used or plan to use in the future. In fact, I see no reason why 2 stiffeners couldn't be there and beef up a thinner top...

Just my $0.02,

John

Re: Bench top thickness -- diminishing returns?

#9

Re: Bench top thickness -- diminishing returns?

Bob Lang

>I'm kind of a cheapskate, so I would opt for 2-1/2" thickness. Other than looking extremely impressive, I don't see much benefit in making it really thick. There is a point that will be "stiff enough" and going beyond that will have more downsides than benefits.

My new bench is 3" and Chris Schwarz's is 4" and there isn't a lot of difference in use. He may get a better "thunk" when he pounds on it, but both are really solid.

When we tested holdfasts for "Woodworking" magazine a few years ago, we found that there was a range between 2" and 3-1/2" in thickness that worked really well. Above 4" they tend to not work. The legs in the Roubo are 5" and I don't think Chris has found a holdfast that will grab in the leg.

Bob Lang

Re: Bench top thickness -- diminishing returns?

#10

Moses Yoder

Re: Bench top thickness -- diminishing returns?

Moses Yoder

>I think Mr. Schwartz was using a Lee Valley holdfast in the leg that has a kind of angled cam at the bottom that grips as a knob on top is tightened.

Re: Bench top thickness -- diminishing returns?

#11

Moses Yoder

Re: Bench top thickness -- diminishing returns?

Moses Yoder

>As was mentioned I don't think going over 3-1/2" thick has a lot of value, and you would have hold fast problems. I think I would make the front 10" or so 3-1/2" thick, using the cut offs elsewhere, and then make the rest of the bench 2-1/2" thick, cutting the boards in half. The end caps on the bench top would hide the difference in thickness.

Re: Bench top thickness -- diminishing returns?

#12

Re: Bench top thickness -- diminishing returns?

Bob Lang

>Sorry if I wasn't clear. Yes, the kind that work that way will work in any thickness as tightening the knob expands the base to grab the perimeter of the hole. I meant the kind that you smack with a hammer, like the ones from Phil Koontz or Tools for Working Wood.

Bob Lang