So why are they called...
Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret
>Jack Planes? Or Fore Planes? I understand Joiners and Smoothers their names have some indication of their use.
Stephen
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
So why are they called...
Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret
>Jack Planes? Or Fore Planes? I understand Joiners and Smoothers their names have some indication of their use.
Stephen
Re: So why are they called...
Paul M.
>My completely uninformed guesses:
Jack = Jack of all trades. Usefull for almost everything
Fore = long as a fore-arm? Sounds good to me.
From Moxon, ca. 1703
Wiley Horne-- So. Calif.
>Moxon mentions the jack plane, and goes in some detail into the Fore Plane. Here is some of the discussion:
JACK PLANE. "Jack-Plane, called so by Carpenters, but is indeed the same that joyners call the Fore Plane.. (Moxon, in the Glossary on House Carpentry)."
FORE PLANE. "...It is called the Fore Plane because it is used before you come to work either with the Smooth Plane, or with the Joynter. The edge of its Iron is not ground upon the straight, as the Smooth Plane, and the Joynter are, but rises with a Convex-Arch in the middle of it; for its Office being to prepare the Stuff for either the Smoothing Plane, or the Joynter, Workmen set the edge of it Ranker than the edge either of the Smoothing Plane, or the Joynter; and should the Iron of the Plane be ground to a straight edge, and it be set never so little Ranker on end of the the edge than on the other, the Ranker end would (bearing as then upon a point) in working, dig Gutters on the Surface of the Stuff; but this Iron (being ground to a Convex-Arch) though it should be set a little Ranker on one end of its edge than on the other, would not make Gutters on the Surface of the Stuff, but (at the most) little hollow dawks on the Stuff, and that more or less, according as the Plane is ground more or less Arching. Nor is it the Office of this Plane to smooth the Stuff, but only...to prepare it, that is, to take off the irregular Risings, whether on the sides, or in the middle, and therefore it is set somewhat Ranker, that it may take the Irregularities the sooner off the Stuff, that the Smoothing Plane, or the Joynter, may afterwards the easier work it Try. The manner of Trying shall be taught, when I come to Treat of the use of the Rule....." ( pp. 65-66, Moxon).
Wiley
Fore? Probably "before."
Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX
>
Oops, sorry, didn't read all before posting.
Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX
>
Jack plane
Patrick Gibbons, Katy, TX
>I read somewhere that it is called a jack because it is jacked, or cut down in size. While the use was the same as a fore, a carpenter had a shorter version for easier carrying, presumably to fit in a tool carrier. I don't vouch for this, just repeating another story. Wonder if it's true?
Re: So why are they called...
John W
>In Whelan's book The Wooden Plane he says "The English roughing plane of 1700 and earlier was called the FORE plane, as Moxon (1703) tells us, because it was used before the others. The same plane was called a JACK plane by house carpenters".
He goes on to say "The word jack was a general term frequently used to convey the feeling that something was common, everyday, usual. It is therefore not surprising that the most common plane came to be called the jack. If a household had but one plane, it was a jack: if a tool kit was purchased that had only one plane, it was a jack.
It's a great book, more info. on wooden planes than in any other one place.
John
fore plane - confusion
paul womack
>The meaning of this word has changed, as words sometimes do over time.
The meaning that Moxon ascribes to it gave way (at some point) to "fore plane" being a synonym for "panel plane" - an accurate stock preparation plane for large surfaces, but not so large as a (edge)jointer.
This, regardless of any interest in old texts (an interest I share), means that using the term "fore plane" in the Moxonian sense without qualification is to invite misunderstanding.
BugBear
Re: fore plane - confusion
Wiley Horne-- So. Calif.
>Hi Paul,
Probably you are referring to my post.
In the original post, Stephen asked what is the origin of the term 'fore plane', and also 'jack plane'. Moxon is an early source who gave a straightforward derivation of the term fore plane--that it was used "before" you come to work with the smooth plane or joynter. Moxon further developed this thought with an extensive description of the use of the fore plane ahead of the smooth plane or jointer. Moxon's answer seems to fit Stephen's question, especially given Stephen's interest in early usages.
Did you intend to say that 'fore plane' became synonymous over time with 'panel plane'? Salaman assigns 'panel plane' two usages--one is the Spiers and Norris infills of the late 19th/early 20th centuries; the other refers to the genre of panel raising planes, including badger planes. It strikes me that the cambered-blade fore plane became indistinguishable over time with the jack plane, as indeed it appears to have been in Moxon's day! Depended on whether you were a joiner or carpenter. But it seems a reach to say that the fore plane morphed into either the straight-bladed infill panel plane, or the panel raising plane.
You are surely correct that the meaning and usages of words changes over time (let alone 300 years), nevertheless, Moxon doesn't sound at all confused as to his meanings ca. 1700. I believe his text answers Stephen's question in re fore plane.
Wiley
fore plane - confusion
paul womack
>Did you intend to say that 'fore plane' became synonymous over time with 'panel plane'? Salaman assigns 'panel plane' two usages--one is the Spiers and Norris infills of the late 19th/early 20th centuries; the other refers to the genre of panel raising planes, including badger planes. It strikes me that the cambered-blade fore plane became indistinguishable over time with the jack plane, as indeed it appears to have been in Moxon's day! Depended on whether you were a joiner or carpenter. But it seems a reach to say that the fore plane morphed into either the straight-bladed infill panel plane, or the panel raising plane.
Intend to say? I thought I was pretty unambigous:
The meaning that Moxon ascribes to it gave way (at some point) to "fore plane" being a synonym for "panel plane"
I'm saying the usage of a word changed, not that a tool evolved into a different tool. It is extremely common in catalogues and instructional texts to find a Baily #6 called a foreplane, which I would deem to be the Norris "panel plane" meaning.
Further, your text from Moxon says that the tool he calls a "fore plane" is also called a jack plane by Carpenters. It appears that this usage has continued pretty much unchanged to the present.
BugBear
Re: fore plane - confusion
Wiley Horne-- So. Calif.
>Paul,
I'll finish up with this quote, by Bishop Joseph Butler, English theologian (1692-1752). Joseph Butler:
"Everything is what it is, and not another thing."
In this line of reasoning, I suggest that a Stanley No. 6 is what it is, and not a panel plane.
Wiley
Re: fore plane - confusion
MikeW
>Hmm, interesting exchange.
I think I see both sides of the argument. Which I sum up as:
Paul--a #6 metal plane is a panel plane. Used for final smoothing of flat surfaces one chooses not to use a smaller upon.
Wiley--a #6 metal plane is a foreplane. Used for roughing surfaces to thickness et al prior to final work using a try and or smoother.
I think in Paul's English tradition, the #6 indeed was used as one would use an infill panel plane on.
However, where it breaks from that tradition would be if one configures it for more roughing work with a cambered iron--which was also done. It then breaks away from how one *can* use an infill panel plane.
I have never read a text in my limited reading that suggests a metal #6 be used as a panel plane used for smoothing surfaces. So I cannot argue with Paul as to whether it exists in print. If the texts he refers to explicitly equate foreplane to panel plane in function, there there ya go. I would think it would be limited to perhaps English writers, the home of the planel plane.
fwiw, I had two #6 metal planes. One was configured as a foreplane. But the other was used precisely as a panel plane. Final smoothing on largish tops mainly but also on longish wooden pieces parts.
Take care, Mike
Re: fore plane - confusion
Wiley Horne-- So. Calif.
>Hi Mike,
Thanks for a good discussion! My only disagreement with Paul is that I didn't think there had been any confusion in the thread (to that point). Now I regret taking a tone about it, and I do apologize to Paul.
I agree entirely with Paul on his main point, which I take to be as follows: That at some point in time after Moxon (ca. 1700) the word 'fore plane' parted ways with its Moxon function. The term survived, and the function survived, but not together. Whelan (The Wooden Plane) discusses the terminology of long planes, and how they evolved in Europe, Britain, and America. Greber (History of the Woodworking Plane) does the same, though this book is about impossible to obtain now.
In America--judging from the Greenfield catalog of 1872, the Sandusky catalogs of 1877 and 1925, Hermon Chapin prices in 1859, and Chapin-Stephens catalog of 1925--what emerged was the threesome of jack, fore, and jointer. The 19th century American fore plane was 18-22" in length,and jacks were to 16" or so. Jointers 26" to 30". Thus, the early _function_ of the fore plane seems to have migrated to the jack plane; while the _name_ 'fore plane' seems to have come to mean a short jointer. And indeed, Stanley characterized its No 6 metal plane as a 'short jointer', according to Patrick Leach's B & G. The term 'trying plane' was not used in America during this period.
Nomenclature in England, as described by Whelan, also evolved over time, differently than in America. After 1800, there were jack, try, long, and jointer planes, the terms variously appearing and disappearing. The latest reference I can find to 'fore plane' in Britain was in Neve's 'Builder's Dictionary', 3rd Ed. (only!) of 1736. Whelan says that Neve described an 18" fore plane as a surface prep. plane, and also described a 24-inch 'long plane' which goes ahead of the smoother on faces and ahead of the jointer on edges. The metal-shod, wooden-infill panel plane of Spiers and Norris, 13-1/2" to 17-1/2", was late-19th century, unless one includes the Roman infill found at Silchester!
It's interesting you have cambered one of your No. 6's--perhaps others are doing similar! I have 18" and 20" cambered blade wooden fore planes (C&W) which I recommend unreservedly for initlal stock prep. Not only do they cut down the high spots, but they're good flatteners too, leaving only a little work for the try plane or jointer.
Wiley
Re: fore plane - confusion
MikeW
>Hi Wiley,
I cannot imagine I am the only American idgit to camber a #6 iron. I found that the two of them were great for the moderate roughing and subsequent smoothing.
I have since sold them and replaced them with wooden planes. I do miss the weight of the one I used for smoothing. Which is why our Canuck friend will one day make me a panel plane...but it will be shorter/narrower. I cannot envision myself building long, wide panels again.
Take care, Mike
Narrower
Wiley Horne-- So. Calif.
>Mike,
Me too! I'm down for 'narrower'. Metal or woodie. Like 2" smoothers, rather than 2-1/4 or 2-3/8. Was talking with C&W folks a couple years ago, and they had come across an olde narrow try plane--2" width by 26" long. I ordered one and that plane is a great favorite for edge jointing single boards. It is the handiest thing, IMO/IME, for 4/4, 5/4.
Our mutual friend in the Great White is right now drying the ebony for a narrow panel--2-1/4" rather than 2-1/2". Maybe 16-1/2" long.
Do you recall that there are folks who swear by the old-style 5.5's, that came with 2-1/4" irons. What are they--15" long?
You gotta tell us about the saw bidness sometime.
Wiley
Re: Narrower
Paul Kierstead
>When I had him make me a smoother, I went for 2" (and chip breaker less .. his first!). I really love the narrower format. Some day I'll get the scratch together for a panel plane from him....
Re: Narrower
Wiley Horne-- So. Calif.
>Paul,
Konrad told me about that plane when he was making it (though not who it was for)! Brazilian rosewood No. 4, right? Looks like 50 degree bedding? He really was stoked about it! I thought it looked very, very clean without the cap iron, and of course with the tight mouth, you kinda have to back off the cap iron anyway, so why have it?
Wiley
Re: fore plane - confusion
paul womack
>That at some point in time after Moxon (ca. 1700) the word 'fore plane' parted ways with its Moxon function. The term survived, and the function survived, but not together. Whelan (The Wooden Plane) discusses the terminology of long planes, and how they evolved in Europe, Britain, and America. Greber (History of the Woodworking Plane) does the same, though this book is about impossible to obtain now.
Yep. Just for completeness, Moxon also said that Carpenters (in Moxon's time) called the "fore plane" a jackplane, and this name/function/design combination has come pretty well straight down the centuries.
It's just "foreplane" that branched.
BugBear
Re: Narrower
Kevin Adams
>Paul--
How do you like it without the chip breaker? That's most likely the way I will go as well. I remember Konrad was pretty excited about it last winter when we discussed it. What bedding angle is yours?
Thanks.
Kevin
Re: Narrower
Paul Kierstead
>It is fabulous. It is bedded at 52.5 degrees and is, indeed, rosewood.
I really like the breaker-less design; it make clearing the throat much easier and, even better, less necessary (they tend to leap out of the plane) . The surface left is impeccable; it is hard to imagine it improving with a breaker with the types of shaving taken with this plane. The other day I was smoothing out a fairly complex face frame (numerous sub sections) where you inevitably end up planing against the grain; it is essentially unavoidable. I couldn't really tell the difference. The coffin shape is almost ideal for very controlled usage. I started out wanting a panel plane, he downsold me to a coffin smoother and I thank him deeply for it. Fabulous plane to use.
Re: Narrower
Kevin Adams
>Thanks, Paul. I am planning to go with 52.5 degrees as well (in ebony). I have really begun to favor planes without chipbreakers (my Terry Gordon planes are perhaps my favorites right now). So simple in terms of set-up, no issues of clogging, and a great surface. I should probably check with Konrad to see how close my number is to coming up so I can start budgeting...
Kevin