Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

Phil Kootnz and Jake's Holdfasts

Posts

Phil Kootnz and Jake's Holdfasts

#1

Phil Kootnz and Jake's Holdfasts

Bjenk Ellefsen------WebKitFormBoundaryAAk3AAy9AAf+

>I ordered a pair of Holdfasts from Phil and Jake, fantastic blacksmiths that they are, and I received them last week. I think they were sent out to me the same day I ordered! Unbelievable!

I have to say that I am impressed and shocked by the craftsmanship. I mean, look at them! I was not sure if they would work in my bench top at 1 3/8" but they work beautifully. I have used them to push a molding and I am smitten by how well they work.

I can only recommend that you try them for yourselves as this kind of work must be kept alive. We are extremely lucky to have access to Hand forged Holdfasts like these.


img

Re: Phil Kootnz and Jake's Holdfasts

#2

Re: Phil Kootnz and Jake's Holdfasts

Todd O. Cronkhite Maine Native, Presently Away

>Yup, I set of 'em as well several years ago as a Christmas present to myself and they are some of the best money I ever spent on a tool. If I ever got into a bind and had too sell off my tools I can well tell you that these holdfasts would be the last things to go. I wouldn't hestitate for a second to reccomend them to somebody else either.

T.O.

Re: Phil Kootnz and Jake's Holdfasts

#3

Re: Phil Kootnz and Jake's Holdfasts

Paul M.

>I ordered 4 (two for me and two for a friend) a few years ago. We've both beaten the crud out of these and have had absolutely no issues with them at all. They are beautiful and functional at the same time. Win-win!

Our's are Jake's by his makers mark.

Re: Phil Kootnz and Jake's Holdfasts

#4

I'm sold. But.....

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Where does one order these?

I was in a demo by Alan Breed and he mentioned breaking some imported models and there were comments from the audience that others had broken them too. I think he said they offending hold fasts were Woodcraft.

Re: Phil Kootnz and Jake's Holdfasts

#5

Re: I'm sold. But..... *LINK*

Todd O. Cronkhite Maine Native, Presently Away

>Bill,

If I flop on posting the link go to Google and plug in Galena Village Blacksmith Shop. You'll see it.


Jake The Russians Holdfasts

Re: Phil Kootnz and Jake's Holdfasts

#6

more info.....

Todd O. Cronkhite Maine Native, Presently Away

>Once you get to his site hit the "contact us" button at the upper right of the screen, this will take you to Phil's e-mail address. From what I understand Phil takes the orders and passes them along to Jake The Russian as Jake dosen't speak English.

Phil's email is phil.koontz@gmail.com

Phone number if you wish to call instead is: 907-656 2328

Mind you, that's in Alaska, so it might be a long distance call.

He offer two versions last I knew, a short one and a long one. More then likely you'll want the long one, but you can discuss that with him.

T.O.

No $$$$$$$$ interest in Galena Forge.

Re: Phil Kootnz and Jake's Holdfasts

#7

thanks

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>glad you added the additional info as I went there, became bewildered and quit. I would imagine the cost of these holdfasts will leave my knees weak?

BTW, how in the world did you find out about this place!?!

Re: Phil Kootnz and Jake's Holdfasts

#8

Re: thanks

Bjenk Ellefsen------WebKitFormBoundaryAAk3AAy9AAf+

>Bill,

They cost about 100$ for a pair. I heard about these from Chris Schwarz.

Re: Phil Kootnz and Jake's Holdfasts

#9

Re: Phil Kootnz and Jake's Holdfasts

ThomD

>The very first holdfast I made (with the Schwartz article in hand) turned out perfectly. I may have had to tweak the bend to get it perfect, or maybe it came out perfect as a result of the angles given in the article. Those leaves can be made with a stamp though they are usually positive in that case, or hand tooled. Abama site has details. Go give it a try. In fact it was the very first blacksmithing I did once I got my anvil and forge together.

Re: Phil Kootnz and Jake's Holdfasts

#10

Re: I'm sold. But.....

James Watriss

>I've seen those particular holdfasts mentioned on Chris Schwartz' homepage before, and seen him use them in a demonstration. I think he said at the time that one of his favorite things to do was to use this very old school technology to hold boards down while he used a Festool Domino to join them.

And yes, the cast ones at Woodcraft and Rockler break so easily... cast iron is not very flexible, as any old stanley plane owner knows. So why they'd use it to make something that's meant to be flexible is beyond me.

Hand forged ones are out there, but another source is tools for working wood... the gramercy holdfasts work pretty well, though they do need to be roughed up when you first get them. I know I enjoy mine.

Re: Phil Kootnz and Jake's Holdfasts

#11

Re: thanks

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>Phil Koontz has been a member of the Oldtools list since the beginning more than 10 years ago. He writes some fabulous posts about life along the Yukon River.

Bruce

Re: Phil Kootnz and Jake's Holdfasts

#12

Re: Pointer to article?

Dave Mount

>Googling got me to the Chris' blog entry on the holdfasts, but I didn't see any of the design info you mention there, or elsewhere. Can you point me to that?

Also, what kind of steel did you use? Seems like spring steel would be in order. . .

Thanks.

Dave

Re: Phil Kootnz and Jake's Holdfasts

#13

Yes, but...

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>Having to put a wood pad underneath the holdfast every time is aggravating to me, kind of defeats the purpose of having a quick clamping system. I attached semi-permanent pads on my forged ones (local blacksmith, I can replace the wooden pads as needed), making for much faster setup.

I posted pics of these a while ago, if I can find them in the archives I'll put a link.

DC

Re: Phil Kootnz and Jake's Holdfasts

#15

Re: Pointer to article?

Chris Friesen

>The article in question is probably "The mystery of holdfasts" from the Autumn 2005 issue of Woodworking Magazine.

Re: Phil Kootnz and Jake's Holdfasts

#16

Here's the blacksmith

Bob Demers

>The Blacksmith name, that did a bunch of holdfast for our association (Ottawa Woodworker Association) is Tony Walsh.

I also have a pair, of course, and they work just fine

Since then Terry has arranged a few blacksmithing courses given by Tony to our members.

Bob, OWA member at large due to military's comitments


img

Re: Phil Kootnz and Jake's Holdfasts

#17

Re: Yes, but...

Bjenk Ellefsen------WebKitFormBoundaryAAk3AAy9AAf+

>Its funny, I think, that you would find placing a small piece of wood under the holdfast aggravating. It takes, what, 2 seconds? Its not like I have to rummaged for 15 minutes to find a pad. They are just there laying around. Playing with a vise and the screws and adjustments is much more aggravating to me. I just put my piece there on the bench, slip the pad under and *TWANG* hit the head and get to work.

Its a matter of what you get used to, I guess! :)

Re: Phil Kootnz and Jake's Holdfasts

#18

Yup, that's the one

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>Hey Bob, got the snow tires on yet? :-)

DC

Re: Phil Kootnz and Jake's Holdfasts

#19

Re: I'm sold. But.....

Dean J in MN

>Bill --

I have the holdfasts from Phil as well as a set from Tools for Working Wood. (The Gramercy holdfasts).

Both work very well, and I can't see breaking either. I have a soft spot for the handcrafted beauties from Alaska, but the factory made ones work as well.

Just an option for those looking for holdfasts.

-Dean

Re: Phil Kootnz and Jake's Holdfasts

#20

Re: Yup, that's the one

Bob Demers

>Not yet Denis, but it was -1 C the last time I drove thru the park earlier this week, soon, very soon...

Bob, up in the great white north