What is in a name?
Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret
>'Strike Block Plane' or 'Straight Block Plane', mentioned in Moxon, Nicholson and Mercer and Salaman. Does the term 'strike' mean that it is for endgrain?
Stephen
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
What is in a name?
Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret
>'Strike Block Plane' or 'Straight Block Plane', mentioned in Moxon, Nicholson and Mercer and Salaman. Does the term 'strike' mean that it is for endgrain?
Stephen
Whelan says....
Wiley Horne-- So. Calif.
>Hi Stephen,
This doesn't answer the question, but Whelan in The Wooden Plane says as follows (p. 62), in regard to Moxon's 'strike block' plane:
"Both the plane and the name seem to have been borrowed from The Netherlands, where the STRIJKBLOK was in use earlier [NB: than 1703]. The pronunciation is very similar, but 'strijk' refers to ironing or smoothing, not striking. One suspects that puzzlement over what the English name meant led to the variant STRAIGHT BLOCK."
Whelan then goes on to describe the strike block as an early miter plane, bedded at 45 or less (BD).
Perhaps one of the European neanders can shed further light, or else the ever-knowledgeable Don McConnell.
Wiley
Re: What is in a name?
Bob Rozaieski
>Stephen,
This is one of the definitions of strike (as a verb) from Merriam-Webster:
to level (as a measure of grain) by scraping off what is above the rim b: to smooth or form (as a mold) with a tool
From this definition, I would interpret the strike block as a tool to "level by scraping (or planing) off what is above the rim (or struck line?)". In other words a tool to trim your stuff to your struck line.
With regard to straight block, my guess is that it refers to the lack of a tote. My second guess (in the likely event that my first guess is wrong) is that it could also mean to make straight, again referring to straightening to your scribed line.
Just a guess on my part.
Re: What is in a name?
Don McConnell
>Wiley et al,
I have just been carrying on a conversation with a friend in Ohio about this topic, and, sadly, I can't say that we have arrived at a completely satisfactory answer.
However, the usage Bob pointed out, namely the verb "strike" meaning "To level, as a measure of grain, salt, or the like, by scraping off with a straight instrument, what is above the level of the top [of the measure]." In line with that, the straight instrument is also called a strike, or strickle.
It seems to me that the use of the strike block plane, in conjunction with a miter jack, to bring a miter to the desired length/level, is somewhat analogous to the use of a "strike" (straight instrument) to level, or strike off, a measure of grain or salt. Further, an alternative, and possibly older, name for the miter jack is a miter block, or miter shooting block. One conjecture would be that this, or a similar, appliance may have, at one time, been called a "strike block" (which can be used to shoot miters or end grain), in keeping with this analogy. As I said, this is conjecture.
Another possibility is that this term may have to do with preparing printing blocks. Since such blocks/type can be used to "strike" an impression, this may warrant further scrutiny. Does anyone know if printing blocks were ever called "strike blocks"? Additionally, the verb strike can also be used in conjunction with masonry, "To cut off, as a mortar joint, even with the face of the wall, or inward at a slight angle." Finally, in conjunction with foundry work, "strike" can be "An instrument used for smoothing the surface of a core." These last two seem pretty analogous to the grain strike usage.
I'm currently leaning toward the conjectural usage of the plane in conjunction with a "strike block," as it seems more consistent with the entire phrase. Any explanation that the term "block" refers to the plane stock/body itself doesn't seem very convincing to me. Most wooden stock bench planes of that time were of rectangular form, yet they weren't referred to as jack block planes, or jointer block planes.
Don McConnell
Eureka Springs, AR
Re: What is in a name?
Charles
>2. An instrument with a straight edge for leveling a measure
of grain, salt, and the like, scraping off what is above
the level of the top; a strickle.
[1913 Webster]
Re: What is in a name?
Charles
>Striking removes a strickle, a little bit, as in you'd never leave a LOT of endgrain to remove (since you can crosscut close to the line).
You strike the strickle - remove the endgrain just to the knifed line.
Re: What is in a name?
Charles
>I'll add this too.... my very first job in woodworking, in a millwork shop, involved working around a guy in his early 80s who was of course a magnificent woodworker. I never heard him call a block plane anything other than a 'strickle' plane. He was in his 80s and said the male members of his father's side of the family were woodworkers as far back as he knew. I figured he picked the term up from them.
Re: What is in a name?
Charles
>Previous post cut this off:
trike block - Collaborative International Dictionary of English v.0.48 :
Strike \Strike\, n.
1. The act of striking.
[1913 Webster]
2. An instrument with a straight edge for leveling a measure
of grain, salt, and the like, scraping off what is above
the level of the top; a strickle.
[1913 Webster]
Re: What is in a name?
Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret
>The word 'strike' has about 2 pages of definitions in the Oxford Universal Dictionary, I can imagine what it would look like in the OED.
Stephen
Some derivation from the Dutch.... *LINK*
Wiley Horne-- So. Calif.
>See link.
Greber says...
Marc in Luxembourg
>Stephen and all,
Greber refers (Die Geschichte des Hobels p. 254 chapter IV.3.h) to Moxon when he speaks of the "stricke block" as a small jointer (picture 83,B3 for those who have the original book). Greber quotes: "The strike block has an exactly even and straight sole. As it is handier as the long jointer, it is used to joint short boards and produce miters of picture frames." The worker, Greber points out, faces the toe to himself in order to work.
On the Moxon plate in the Greber book, one can guess the length of the strike block 2/3s of the jointer - if one plane is true to scale to another. It has no handle, no tote the heel is heavily rounded.
Marc
Oops - "Strike" means "shoot" IMHO
Marc in Luxembourg
>