We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
>I built a bench years ago and never got around to putting dog holes in it. Dealing with the alternative of clamps has become intolerable and I am determined to have at drilling dog holes. For sake of discussion, if the vise opens 12" how far apart is optimum for dog holes? I was thinking half the vise opening, or 6", but having never worked at a bench with dogs I would like to take advantage of the available experience in this matter.
>I concur with half the vise travel. When I drilled dog holes in my bench, I drilled them at the vise travel, and regularly encounter boards that won't quite fit, requiring shims.
Depending on your vise design, you may have trouble with the first hole - my Record vise won't permit a hole in the region of the vise travel itself (that is, from the back jaw to travel) without the vise interfering with the dog.
Here's my data point. I put mine at 5" OC. Still seems like more wheel spinning than I want to do sometimes. My vise travel is 3/16" per turn. 5 turns per inch. Statistics says otherwise, but it's amazing how many 10-turn vise closures actually happen.
So I think 6" apart is too distant, unless you have a quick release vise, in which case it would be just fine. I have an aversion to drillling holes in my bench, but if I had it do over, I would go probably 4.5" apart. One thing I always thought would be great about a true tail vise, is that you could put dog holes 3" apart in the front jaw, which would totally solve the problem.
Bill alluded to the other issue--placement of the first hole. Get it as close as the physical situation permits.
>like the LV dogs, for instance, you might get by for close-up dog hole spacing with either the short LV dogs (and some way to get them out of their holes once in - they can be the devil to remove if you can't reach below and push them up - I speak from 20 minutes of cursing experience), the plastic dogs that are sold for use with the Black & Decker Workmate, or your own made from 3/4" dowels glued into pieces of plywood of different thicknesses. The Workmutt dogs are only about 1/2" high, and surprisingly sturdy for a handy homeowner tool part - and, since they're plastic, you don't need to fret if a tool hits them.
>Consistent spacing doesn't make sense to me. I think you want holes as close to the edge as you dare, then many holes close together for a foot or so. The reason for this is dealing with short stock. It's advantageous to have the stock on the bench, not hanging over the gap. So if the work piece is 4" long and you have a doghole at 1" and 3", you might be able to place that stock against the 3" dog and only have 1" (probably less) unsupported. Make sense?
>Not really to me. One can alwys use a pusher stick behind it, I would have to do a lot of that kind of work before it would mater to me.
I have the squares spaced close enough together that it isn't a pain to open the vise. One may have a quick action vice, one may have walls or furnishings in the way.
If you want a regular spacing of some sort, then one needs to look at where the holes will fall around the supporting legs, and other hardware, you don't want there to be a hole where some part of the face vice stops the stops from going through, etc... So I would do a little figuring or laying out relative to all the parts before settling on any formulas that may only work our for someone else anyway.
>When you are working with small stock, adding scrap wood can be an exercise in frustration. An angled plane pass and the work spins wildly out of control.
Scrap is what we must do when we have no choice. But it's silly to plan for it if you don't have to.
>Scrap is just the most basic option. I am open to all the evidentiary pictures anyone wants to produce of benches, traditional or otherwise, swiss cheezed to the max with holes increasing in number at the tail vice. I'm a little surprised at all this sudden interest in tail vice function, as this crowd normally lectures on how they are not necesary, Roubo, Roubo and nauseum... :)
>I think there's a time for minimalism. And a lot of this crowd would agree.
But I also think that if you're going to add a new feature, you really ought to do it right, and think about things like this before you start drilling holes.
My own experience with shimming with scraps is that inevitably, either the scrap or the work falls into the vise, or through, and it really is a hassle. I agree that bench dogs should not interfere with the function of the vise, but gripping small stock is a specific function that does require some thinking, because usually small pieces are there for detail, and detail has to be done right. Sure you can plan on having craps. Or making specialized fixtures to help hold the work in a certain way... I use stuff like that regularly, but usually it's improvised, and if an extra hole or three can eliminate the need to improvise, then that can save a lot of time.
I like the idea of multiple small holes up front. Moving away, I don't think they're as necessary. And with round holes, it's really less necessary anyway... you can always slide one end of the board forward or back, and the resulting diagonal can take up some of the inevitable screw spinning work. It's not always optimal, but it's a surprisingly useful trick sometimes.
The other option... drill a few holes now, drill more as you need them. It's not a highly technical skill, and it may turn out that there are certain sizes or intervals that make a lot of sense to you, the bench owner.