Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

Panel, rip, or cross cut?

Posts

Panel, rip, or cross cut?

#1

Panel, rip, or cross cut?

Edward in Vancouver

>I'm looking to buy my first "real" Western style saw, but am unsure what category the panel saw falls under. Is the panel an "all purpose" saw, or should I be buying separate, dedicated, rip and cross cut saws?

Re: Panel, rip, or cross cut?

#2

Re: Panel, rip, or cross cut?

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>"...should I be buying separate, dedicated, rip and cross cut saws?"

What, there's a question here? The basic lesson of this forum is Always Buy More Tools.

On a more sensible note: I was taught that a crosscut saw can rip better than a rip saw can crosscut. There's been some dissension from this dogma here on the forum, though.

You might consider which cut you're more likely to be making. If you're really talking panels, I should think you can size the panel's width closer to final and plane the excess more easily than you can size it to length and cross-cut the excess.

Re: Panel, rip, or cross cut?

#3

But, as I should have said, eager to find out

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>what I missed in my thoughts here.

Re: Panel, rip, or cross cut?

#4

Oh Edward... Bill, pass the peanuts, I have a...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>Cold one for Ya.

Hi Ed, Depending on what your cutting this is a serious affliction. Panel saws are on the range from 18-28" from what I've seen. They range from the 20's down to 8 or so TPI or TPP.

BTW, I'm long from being someone that knows what their talking about...

Re: Panel, rip, or cross cut?

#5

Re: Panel, rip, or cross cut?

roninkokomo

>What will you be sawing?

Are you talking stock prep or joinery?

Re: Panel, rip, or cross cut?

#6

Re: Panel, rip, or cross cut?

Neal in San Jose

>My understanding is that a panel saw is simply a smaller saw, say 24 inch blade or less. For one thing, this allowed easier fitting into a tool box. Thus a panel saw can be either a rip or a crosscut.

You've gotten some good advice; define your usage and let that guide your purchase decision. One thing to consider is that you will see many more crosscuts than rips. My guess is that it is about 5 to one. The people that made their living with these things apparently had a much higher need for crosscuts; you may as well. HTH Neal

Re: Panel, rip, or cross cut?

#7

Re: Panel, rip, or cross cut?

Todd Hughes

>Ive looked at many hundereds of old saws and in my experance it is very rare to see a rip small pannel saw...not saying they weren't made and used just saying very uncommon.

I think for what small rip work that was done a cross cut pannel saw was pressed into service. Any big jobs were done with a large rip.

Since good older high quality small pannel saws are pretty easy to find on the cheap , even in the old tool hell I live in most are priced at $5 or so, why not just get two one of which you can sharpen rip...Todd

Re: Panel, rip, or cross cut?

#8

Re: Panel, rip, or cross cut?

Edward in Vancouver

>Thanks for the advice gentlemen. I guess what I'll be doing mainly is stock preparation with the saw, which would be more crosscutting than ripping. I was and still am, confused with the term "Panel saw" as I had read in a few books that it could be used for either task. The saw I'm looking at has 10 tpi and is 22" long.

I guess I'm looking at "economical" methods of expanding my tool inventory, as I don't want to plunk down double the amount of money for two saws. Then again, I'm the kind of guy who'll save up and get a LV BU Jack plane to augument my collection of garage-sale smoother and fore planes...

BTW I did finish up my tool chest and am now in the process of french fitting some of the drawers. I still can't figure out how to compress j-peg images to show on this site, and every time I ask my 15 yr old daughter to help, she just rolls her eyes at me......

Re: Panel, rip, or cross cut?

#9

Re: Panel, rip, or cross cut?

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Hi Edward,

A "panel" saw is generally very similar to a regular handsaw except it is smaller, usually the blade as well as the handle. Any handsaw that is 24" and shorter is considered to be a "panel" saw. Like Todd said, they are usually cross-cut and will usually have more teeth per inch for finer, smoother cutting. The handles will be held on with one less screw-set. If you can find one for five bucks that is freshly sharpened and ready to do a good job of cutting, grab it. Maybe Todd has a couple dozen you can choose from. As for ripping with a panel saw, the fact that it will usually have a higher number of teeth per inch, say 10PPI, it will do a fine job of ripping as well as cross cutting. As Todd said, it's a good idea to have both though. Most any handsaw can be filed either cross or rip no matter the number of points per inch.

One point to be made here, (pun intended) whether you buy a 24" panel saw or it's larger brother/sister, with a 26" blade, the larger saw will do just as good a job as the shorter saw, it's all about the number of points per inch and how it is sharpened. And the handle will be a little larger if you have a large hand.

Marv