Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

Lie Nielsen Faux Pas

Posts

Lie Nielsen Faux Pas

#1

Lie Nielsen Faux Pas

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Just got back last night from an incredibly information rich class in the "Mack Headley and Sons" shop in Winchester, VA. Taking a class of 4 in a working reproduction shop is a world different from the typical "classroom" classes offered elsewhere. All the jigs and tools from the past 50 years of cabinet making in this shop (the original burned) are hanging about to explore and learn from and the amount of learning was awesome. I worked my project on Mack Sr.'s bench and that gave me some pause. But more on that later...........

Jeff Headley, son of Mack and one of the mentors for the class, had recently been to a show and wanted to try a LN dovetail saw. He picked up the saw and while sawing a few lines he was informed by the LN demonstrator that he was not sawing correctly.

Before judging the technique it is best to wait to evaluate the result.

Re: Lie Nielsen Faux Pas

#2

Re: Lie Nielsen Faux Pas

john j

>Looking forward to hearing more... I would like to take a class from him some time. Not many others on my list, maybe Al Breed and Charlie Bender...

Re: Lie Nielsen Faux Pas

#3

Interesting Bill. Care to share more?

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>What exactly did the he say and did he offer any tips?

Re: Lie Nielsen Faux Pas

#4

You would think

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>that a salesperson would have long since learned how to guide the customer in a positive way. "You might try this," rather than "you're doing it wrong."

And, of course, "wrong" is such an interesting concept when applied to woodworking...we're working a bundle of fibers that must be cut across one way and along another - but from that starting point, about 1,000 roads diverge, many of them getting to the same destination.

Re: Lie Nielsen Faux Pas

#5

class

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>I will post more details on the class later when I get notes and pictures organized. You may email me off line for class details if you wish.

I took a short seminar class at SAPFM from Al Breed. He is a good teacher, and I have found that to be a rare skill in any field. Al struck me as a results oriented sort of person. He floored the audience when he said he wasted out the recess for tea tables and trays with a CNC router. His response to the gasps was that he preferred carving to busy work. The class I took had the same attitude. If your goal is learning practical approaches to building stuff, either class will push you up the learning curve a long ways in a short time. You may have to go home and practice what you learned, but at least you will be practicing a proven practical approach.

Re: Lie Nielsen Faux Pas

#6

dovetail approach

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Start saw on front corner and saw a ways down the front scribe line. (this establishes vertical saw track) Next, in a smooth motion while sawing, tilt the saw horizontal and saw along the top scribe line. (this establishes the left/right orientation of the saw track. Alternate to complete dovetail.

Warning! if you eschew electrons read no further!

However............When the shop is making dovetails for a commission piece the tails are first sawed entirely on a band saw with a dull blade, about 6 tpi(dull meaning little set left). By entirely I mean even the waste is nibbled out with the band saw right up to the base line. You have to see it to believe it. The pins are then scribed and hand sawed as described above. The results are dovetails as perfect as I have ever seen, and needless to say, quick.

I'll post the neat trick for parts alignment while pin scribing later. The class was a blizzard of these practical tips.

Re: Lie Nielsen Faux Pas

#7

Thanks Bill, Looking forward to it!

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>

Re: Lie Nielsen Faux Pas

#8

Re: dovetail approach

Peter Hyde

>Thanks Bill it's nice to know I'm not alone :-) Iuse a jg on the BS and starting from the center just flip the board over for each cut. Results are good and it is quick.


img