Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

Reproduction Furniture Standards

Posts

Reproduction Furniture Standards

#1

Reproduction Furniture Standards

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>I would like to put together a list of standards for making reproduction furniture. I am proposing 3 categories:

Authentic Reproduction, one that is correct in every way to the period of the piece.

Faithful Reproduction, one that is correct with different but appropriate tools, materials and techniques.

Machine Reproduction, one that is machine made and hand finished.

I think each category could have a couple of grades. Hopefully a standard could inform and educate customers as to what they are getting for their money. I think it could also go a long way to clarify this murky area. Any suggestions?

Stephen

Re: Reproduction Furniture Standards

#2

Re: Reproduction Furniture Standards

john j

>I admire your interest in this... I have really been having difficulty getting my arms around some of this though. Seems like some of the "technique" involved is an educated guess as to what was really done in period shops. Someone can assail other folks' "authenticity" depending on their interpretation of undocumentated processes. I have seen internet photos that to my eye really miss the mark in proportion, while purporting to demonstrate "authenticity"- so what's more important? et cetera...

Re: Reproduction Furniture Standards

#3

Re: Reproduction Furniture Standards

john j

>Undocumentated? Guess I should proofread...

Re: Reproduction Furniture Standards

#4

Re: Reproduction Furniture Standards

Jim in VA

>Unfortunately, I think that any classification based primarily on the tools and technique used is probably unworkable. Where do you draw the line? For example, if the mahogany I use to make an 18th century style tea table arrives by 18-wheeler instead of a sail-powered wooden ship, can it still be considered an "authentic reproduction." If that's okay, what if I use a power bandsaw to help rough dimension the stock? Can it be authentic if I do all the dimensioning with Clark & Williams planes? While great tools, their irons aren't the same as 18th century plane irons. With so much knowlege lost to history, could anything be considered an authentic reproduction under such a classification?

I don't think these factors lend themselves to fitting into neatly defined categories. While some clients will pay extra to own a piece of furniture that was made "authentically", I think the best one can do is describe the extent to which that occured without attempting to put a label on it.

I think a more fruitful area for categorization involves considering the design, construction, look, and feel of the completed piece. These factors could involve more objective measures and, indirectly, reflect how the piece was made. For example, beads cut by hand will never be as consistent as beads cut with a router. In my eye, machine cut beads (or flutes, or whatever) are too perfect, too sterile. It is the slight variations that breathe life into a piece of furniture and make antiques desirable. So maybe considering whether the proportions are "right", the dovetails are correct for the period and the geographic area, and the surface finishing of the seen and unseen areas would yield a more useful classification system.

But in the end, I'm not even sure that approach would be universally useful. If I build my 18th century style tea table with modern (hand or power) tools and could set it beside an identical table built in the 18th century and magically transported via a time machine to today, and the two are indistinguishable from one another, does it matter how each was produced? For some people yes and for others no. Is it the destination or the journey? It depends on the purpose.

Ouch. My head hurts now. I think I'm going back to building furniture, reading history books, and trying to understand how and why things were originally built...and leave this classification business to folks who are smarter than I am.

Re: Reproduction Furniture Standards

#5

Re: Reproduction Furniture Standards

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>Just tell your American friends it's the Australian spelling, your Australian friends that it's the Canadian spelling, etc. If you're quick enough on your feet, you'll get a reputation for being a real internationalist.

Re: Reproduction Furniture Standards

#6

Re: Reproduction Furniture Standards

Alex Yeilding

>Jim in VA captured most of my reaction. I think the focus should be on the product, not the process. In some cases the line may blur, such as "final surface showing signs of hand-planing". But to add to Jim's examples, if the "spec" for a piece calls for saw-cut dovetails, does it make any difference to the piece of furniture if those are cut with a western-style dovetail saw, and Japanese saw, a frame saw or a band saw? While a craftsman may derive some satisfaction from identifying what kind of saw was commonly used in the shop that created the original and using the same kind of saw, does that make any difference in the product?

I think that each level should specify which materials must be the same, and whether that means merely same species or similar grain and board width. This could make some reproductions more expensive than the antique, given the cost of very wide highly figured boards similar to those used 200 years ago. I have seen some reproductions that are beautifully made and of the same species as the original, but which look drab next to the original because of the beautiful grain patterns of the original.

One level that would be of interest would require adherence to the original design and identical treatment of all show surfaces and exposed joinery, but allow alternate materials and joinery when such substitution is at least as structurally sound as the original. So, for instance, this would allow a veneered piece to use plywood as a substrate rather than glued-up pine, to use a machine-cut sliding dovetail for attaching a shelf rather than the original's dado, but would still require hand-cut dovetails for the drawers. It would be nice if this level of reproduction was accompanied by a disclosure statement telling what the craftsman changed. Then the knowledgeable buyer could evaluate whether the trade-offs were appropriate for them. E.g., a buyer may agree that the use of plywood for drawer bottoms is appropriate, but may not like another craftsman's choice to use UF glue rather than hide glue.

Re: Reproduction Furniture Standards

#7

When does it become Forgery

Ray Gardiner

>Hi Stephen,

I am wondering, if a piece is authentic in every way, indistinguishable from a (possibly valuable) antique. Should something be introduced deliberately (like a mark in some place not readily visible) To discourage some unscrupulous furniture dealers passing a piece off as genuine either now or at some point in the future.

Put another way, it seems to me to be more "honest" to make a piece that is in someway obviously "not genuine"

Regards Ray

Re: Reproduction Furniture Standards

#8

Re: standards

paul womack

>I would like to put together a list of standards for making reproduction furniture.

.

.

.

Hopefully a standard could inform and educate customers as to what they are getting for their money.


Unless it is likely that such a standard is widely adopted by makers, and well publicised to customers, any effort at definition is just a rambling chat in a forum - to which I have no objection.

BugBear

Re: Reproduction Furniture Standards

#9

Re: Reproduction Furniture Standards

Paul Kierstead

>So, lets say you are trying to make a veneered piece which is accurate on all surfaces. However, you care about lasting quality and decide that the solid wood cores in the original which almost inevitably result in the veneer cracking over time should be replaced with a more stable core. You even go through the trouble of laying up your own plywood. What category does that kind of thing fall into?

If your veneer is machine cut with a big-assed knife, but your target era used hand sawn veeneers, where does it qualify?

I think these kinds of rule sets are very troublesome and, at the end of the day, I am not sure what they accomplish.

Re: Reproduction Furniture Standards

#10

Re: When does it become Forgery

Alan Schwabacher

>I would expect a true reproduction would be hard to mistake for the original, for quite a while, because it will look new. "Distressing" the surface intentionally, or adding color to a finish to make it look old, would fit into my idea of the authentic reproduction category.

But because people have their own opinions about what are the critical features, it makes sense for people to try to explain what their intent was in making the piece. Unfortunately, I don't think three categories will cover these, though some kind of standards might be helpful.

A description would need to address three separate aspects: design, materials, and techniques.

Is the design a close copy of an existing piece, a standard type with sizes and perhaps parts adjusted, or an original design intended as a particular style?

Are materials as close to the original as possible? What does this mean anyway? Is it reused wood harvested in the target period? Wood matched for species, growth rate, size? Is secondary wood matched as well? If so, what does that mean? If the original was made using whatever secondary stock was cheap and readily available, is it truly more authentic to pay a large sum to obtain the same species (possibly with decidedly different growth) than to do what the original builder did and use what's available? I guess this drifts into the last category.

One can try to replicate techniques, or one can focus only on result. If stock is riven rather than sawn, there will be a significant difference in appearance and perhaps strength. But if you are taking sawn stock to flat and smooth, machines followed by a smoothing plane can meet the appearance. If a customer wants an all hand tool approach, use of machines would be a disappointment. But if a customer does not care about that, the price difference may be convincing.

All in all, this reminds me of the difficulties in good translation from one language to another. How do you translate a pun or a poem? Is the general idea, the meter, or the specific meaning of the words the best translation? And how do you categorize the different approaches to translation? It's not quite so simple as literal vs free.

Re: Reproduction Furniture Standards

#11

Re: When does it become Forgery

Alan Schwabacher

>Oops. I left out a word that switches the meaning:

"... to make it look old, would NOT fit into my idea of the authentic reproduction category."

Re: Reproduction Furniture Standards

#12

Re: When does it become Forgery

"RJ" Whelan

>Ray �.. I once built a table for a client that was a very close replica of a Greene & Greene piece in the Gamble House (in Pasadena, CA). It was a hall table made from mahogany (stained to darken) and ebony. I had become acquainted with a preservationist who did a lot of preservation, replication and restoration at/for the Gamble House, so I was able to make accurate measurements of all components.

Being the builder of the piece, I was able to see the areas where I deviated from the original (either intentionally or due to talent deficit), but most of the people who viewed the piece (some of whom were fairly knowledgeable; others just casual observers) thought it was an original.

To make a long story short, the client passed away and his heirs decided to sell off a lot of the furnishings in his home. The table ended up in an antique shop on consignment and was represented as �authentic Greene & Greene�.

Now I�m like a mama bear: I always recognize my babies. I knew immediately it was a piece I�d built. When I informed the manager of the shop that it was a copy, and how I knew to a certainty it was a copy, she became quite upset and swore it had been authenticated. Rather than argue with her I went home and retrieved a couple of photographs and the invoice and returned with my �proof�. She still insisted that I was mistaken.

I was finally able to contact my late client�s widow and informed her of the situation. I don�t know what the final outcome was, but I vowed then and there to include my mark and the year of construction on any future reproductions.

rj

Re: Reproduction Furniture Standards

#13

Re: When does it become Forgery

Joel

>As I am periodically (somewhat facetiously) reminded - there is more 18th century furniture around now than there was in the 18th century.

It's a forgery if you sign it with a name other then your own. I bet the original G+G peices had marks on them and your copy didn't - so the dealer could find out if she wanted too. But as a rule dealers don't.

For more information read: "Born to Trouble" by Eric Hebborn.

Re: Reproduction Furniture Standards

#14

Re: When does it become Forgery

Todd Hughes

>I think it becomes a forgery when it is passed off as the real deal and you can tell it is a fake. If you cant tell then how do you know?

...I always say there are 3 types of fakes, ones you can spot right off the bat, ones that you have to look at close ...and then ones that you just cant tell....but if you can't tell then how do you know ?

...I know a fellow that makes antique wooden duck decoys, his work is so good you just cant tell they are not right. Even goes so far as to use old lead paint. His decoys have fooled big time experts and sold at auctions for prices that you could buy a new car for. He is always careful to not attribute any maker to the birds....the buyers and "experts" do that.

...Don't know how some not readly visable mark would do anything....don't you think that sellers would just remove or cover it up?

...In my experance most people get stuck with fakes not so much because the fake is made so well but rather because the buyer doesn't know what he is buying and is excited about getting such a good deal [and so screwing the "uninformed" seller]....Hard for me to feel to sorry for folks like this or worry about them either

I once almost bought a little axe I had made myself several years back thinking it was an old antique! I just couldnt tell since it had been used hard and was rather rusted and of course I made to many to remember it. I figured if I, it's maker , couldn't tell it wasn't old then no one could , ...so might as well be an antique.....Todd

Re: Reproduction Furniture Standards

#15

Re: When does it become Forgery

ThomD

>If it is authentic, might it not have some maker's mark? Or if it was truly authentic would it have the current maker's style in it just as in the olden days different makers had an individual style.

I don't personally care about the difficulties of collectors, though I wouldn't actively try to pass my stuff off as somthing from another age.

Re: Reproduction Furniture Standards

#16

Re: Reproduction Furniture Standards

ThomD

>A lot of these responses fall into the "how does one draw a line" type. In practice it is as easy, as it is arbitrary, to draw lines. You need some kind of organization that sees the need of these rules to set some standards for it's own memebers. These standards, in this case, probably have to be driven with the needs of the customer and producer in mind. I tend to believe the customer doesn't care about stuff he can't see, and may not care about some stuff he can see, though that is just a guess. I would expect to see an organization driven by these priorities marginalized, as in some respects crafts are maginal in comparison to arts.

Re: Reproduction Furniture Standards

#17

Wadda bout the painted cat....!?!

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>Or the fake wood cat... Sorry all I'm feeling a bit cockey tonight!

Re: Reproduction Furniture Standards

#18

Re: When does it become Forgery

Ray Gardiner

>Hi rj,

Your example illustrates perfectly the point I was trying to raise.

The question of the "intent" of the creator of the piece, needs to be separated from the "intent" of the dealer.

I have no wish to generalize and say that antique dealers are more or less prone to deception that any other areas of society.

I would probably trust an good reputable antique dealer to be honest and deal with customers fairly.

What is at question is, :- do **we** (those reading this are more likely to the ones creating a piece) have a responsibility to ensure our work is not (easily) passed off as genuine?

I wont tackle the moral question, you would have faced in the example cited if you knew someone was about to buy your work (being passed off as authentic G&G) Should you intervene and tell the buyer?

I can imagine the conversation...

Pardon me sir, are you aware that piece is not genuine?

How do **you** know? (and who are you to interfere)

Because I made it!....

..pause..

Are you aware that is forgery?

..longer pause...

I didnt intend that, when I made it. (should sound good in court)

Regard Ray

Re: Reproduction Furniture Standards

#19

A funny forgery story

Todd Hughes

>I used to make these little miniture gooswing axes. Had a guy order one from me, I meet him at a tool show to deliver it , show it to him and he tells me he is short and doesnt have the money to buy it now. I put it in the shows auction and this guy buys it at a bit less then what he agreed to...and I have to pay a commison now too..OK, was my choice but Im not to happy about this

....Fast forward about 6 months and I am at another show and Im walking down the isle and here is a friend of mine in the process of buying the little axe off the guy who was set up at the show. My friend has just gave him the check,[ Guywas just putting it in his wallet] turns to me and asked me what I thought about the axe....Now Im Clueless as to what was happening I told him that it was one of the better ones I had made...OH OH! Things get real quite all of the sudden. Seems that the seller had just sold it to him as an antique axe for a bunch of green. Talk about bad timing, eh? When asked I told my friend the history of the axe and when I had made it. Things got heated between the two and I just walked away. After threating to void the check the axe was accepted back. The seller then had the nerve to confront me acusing me of blowing his sale and telling me I should buy the axe because of it !....On the Moon to think that was going to happen.

Will point out here that I have been in the antique field for over 20 years, and have seen many many misrepresented, redone and down right fake items of course for sale. In my experance Tool Sellers and Dealers are by far the worst at this then any other antique field dealers....Don't know if it because they may be more handy and as such do more "work" on what they sell, or maybe buyers are not as astute and can be skinned easier......Todd

Re: Reproduction Furniture Standards

#20

Moses Yoder

Re: Reproduction Furniture Standards

Moses Yoder

>A large portion of the value of a piece is the way the owner of that piece feels about it. You can't really put a price tag on that, but it is there. So if the person who is buying the piece values history it matters a lot to them how it was made. The piece might look almost identical if it is built entirely with machines but the owner of the piece would not feel the same way about it as they would if they knew a large portion of the work was done by a real craftsman and not just a machine operator.

Re: Reproduction Furniture Standards

#21

Re: Reproduction Furniture Standards

Alex Yeilding

>"done by a real craftsman and not just a machine operator. "

Moses, I have to respectfully disagree with this dichotomy. All of us in the forum are presumably here because we value the process or results of work with hand tools. But David Charlesworth does initial stock preparation with power planers and thicknessers (using UK names) and cuts dovetails on a bandsaw. If he does that in creating a reproduction, I'm not prepared to dismiss that reproduction as being done by "just a machine operator" rather than a craftsman!!

IMHO, craftsmanship is defined by standard of work, not by tools or processes used.

Re: Reproduction Furniture Standards

#22

some comments

Ian in Sydney (on his notebook again)

>Stephen

"Authentic Reproduction, one that is correct in every way to the period of the piece."

AKA a fake or forgery

Timber would be sourced from old doors, barns and the like so the age (and tightness of growth rings) would be "right"

drawer bottoms would be split to immitate age and runners worn

the issue of hand vs machine tools (or wood vs metal planes) would be largely irrelevant

or

Authentic Reproduction could be like a typical Japanese temple where the use of the historicaly correct tools and techniques and design is the most important factor in producing an exact copy with the wood used being largely secondary.

The maker is allowed to use copies of 18th century wooden planes, but not the 21st century Veritas or L-Ns

Faithful Reproduction, one that is correct with different but appropriate tools, materials and techniques.

here I think it's accepable to

- substitute ply or MDF as a veneer substrate

- prepare stock and cut joints with power tools, heck even finish it with a power sander

BUT the moldings should match the original, and not something "simplified" so it can be cut with a standard router cutter

Machine Reproduction, one that is machine made and hand finished.

I think drop "machine" and stick to Reproduction

I'd expect details like moldings to be "simplified" but otherwise not much change from Faithful eproduction"

I think a good illustration of the differences is tombstone doors

Authentic -- timber is right and a close inspection shows the sweep marks of the gouge

Faithful -- mostly cut with a router but with the inside corners squared out, possibly by and

Reproduction -- the inside corners are curved

just my thoughts

Re: Reproduction Furniture Standards

#23

Re: Reproduction Furniture Standards

john j

>I just got done looking at a slideshow about the Irion Co. Furniture makers. I have seen almost nothing that Adam Cherubini has made, so I have no idea what he makes- decent work? lousy? Who knows. However, when I see the Irion furniture (and a few others), I am really inspired, and the chit-chat on the web sounds like "blah blah blah" to me...

Re: Reproduction Furniture Standards

#24

Re:marks

paul womack

>but I vowed then and there to include my mark and the year of construction on any future reproductions.

Best do it in a way that's hard to remove, too.

BugBear

Re: Reproduction Furniture Standards

#25

Re: some comments

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>Ian,

I like your thoughts and would like to incorporate them in my possible list.

Stephen