Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This is the most versatile work station you will ever use

Dovetails: cutting to or past the baseline? *LINK*

Posts

Dovetails: cutting to or past the baseline? *LINK*

#1

Dovetails: cutting to or past the baseline? *LINK*

wilbur

>I just watched this video. The one thing that I saw that I had never seen before (or, completely ignored) was the suggestion to run the saw cuts a little (about 1/16") below the scribe line after marking the tails or pins. This is mentioned at 33:37 into the video. It's to aid in chiseling by breaking the grain in the corner, and that the small amount of overshoot gets hidden in the finishing steps.

Does anyone else do this? I try to hit the scribe line when I saw.


Podcast: Hand-Cut Dovetails with Robby Pedersen

Re: Dovetails: cutting to or past the baseline? *LINK*

#2

Re: Dovetails: cutting to or past the baseline?

Hank Knight

>I try to hit the scribe line too, but I miss more often than not. I don't like the look of visible saw cuts, but I've seen many old pieces with visible saw cuts, some pretty dramatic. I don't think the old guys paid much attention to this.

Re: Dovetails: cutting to or past the baseline? *LINK*

#3

Uh oh

Paul Kierstead

>

Re: Dovetails: cutting to or past the baseline? *LINK*

#4

Let the games begin. :)

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>

Re: Dovetails: cutting to or past the baseline? *LINK*

#5

Popcorn anyone?

Dominic Greco in Richboro PA

>

Re: Dovetails: cutting to or past the baseline? *LINK*

#6

Does this have to be controversial? :@)

wilbur

>Is this really going to be this controversial? I had never heard of this practice before, and if no one here on the WC neander forum uses this technique, that probably says a lot.

As would a comment like, "I used to do this, but my dovetails all came out looking like Wilbur made them, so I stopped."

I mean, it's not like I brought up the metallurgy of hand forged Japanese tools. :@)

Re: Dovetails: cutting to or past the baseline? *LINK*

#7

My thoughts exactly. What's the controversy?

Hank Knight

>

Re: Dovetails: cutting to or past the baseline? *LINK*

#8

Missing the scribe line

wilbur

>Hi Hank,

When you say that you miss the scribe line when trying to hit it, are you talking more about stopping short of the line, or going past it?

Re: Dovetails: cutting to or past the baseline? *LINK*

#9

Re: Missing the scribe line

Hank Knight

>Wilbur,

Unfortunately, I do a little of both. I've gotten better by paying more attention. I've been using a rip dozuki for a while and, for some reason, I do better hitting the line with it than with a Western dovetail saw. It is indeed easier for me to get clean corners when I go past the line. I just don't like the sloppy look of saw kerfs below the scribe line.

Hank

Re: Dovetails: cutting to or past the baseline? *LINK*

#10

Influence of time and place and ......

Wiley Horne--So. Calif

>Hi Wilbur,

To be fair to the man, he is replicating what was done in 1875 midwest shops, as best he knows what they did. I would be interested in Stephen's take on whether overcutting the scribe line is typically what they did then. He says that nobody notices once the finish goes on--well, optically it is very noticeable when finish hits a sawcut. I think what he's really saying on that score is that slightly overcut corners were expected, and nobody notices because the overcut is 'normal'.

My experience is that I have to slow down and pay attention not to overcut a little. It's the viewing angle--I'm looking down and with a sharp saw I'll be a little beyond the scribe line, unless I slow down and bend over and take care with it. I don't like the overcut look--having done it--and so I slow down, bend over and watch the saw approach the line, and take pains not to overcut. But then I have time for the niceties. if I were cutting dovetails for money in 1875 Iowa, I might favor speed and do what he does. If I go fast and natural, I overcut a little too.

Wiley

Re: Dovetails: cutting to or past the baseline? *LINK*

#11

Re: Influence of time and place and ......

wilbur

>Hi Wiley,

I did think of the 1875 reenactment issue. But my take on his presentation was that he was not overcutting because it was historically accurate. He stated that was overcutting to aid in the removal of waste from the corners, and I was just curious as to whether anyone else did that.

If anything, this video will probably make me less tentative in approaching the scribe line when cutting dovetails, since for me the rate limiting step in dovetail making is cleaning out those corners.

Re: Dovetails: cutting to or past the baseline? *LINK*

#12

Re: Popcorn anyone?

Ray Binnicker

>We aren't going to talk about saw nibs, are we? (:-)

Ray Binnicker

Re: Dovetails: cutting to or past the baseline? *LINK*

#13

Re: Dovetails: cutting to or past the baseline?

Dean J in MN

>On carcass dovetails I error on the side of speed, if I go past the baseline I go past the baseline. I don't try, but I don't care if I do, these joints will be covered with moldings anyway.

On half-blind (lap) dovetails, I cut far beyond the baseline on the pin board, and inch or more depending on thickness the drawer front.

On the tail board I don't try to cross the baseline, and will take a little more time than when I'm knocking out carcass joints. But if I go over a little, I'm not ashamed.

-Dean

Re: Dovetails: cutting to or past the baseline? *LINK*

#14

Re: Standards of work

Dave Mount

>Hi Wilbur--

I think overcut baselines look sloppy so I try not to. It happens by accident occasionally, but I try to hide it when I do. The main criterion I judge my work by is whether I like it. I would not look to have my work judged by someone whose standard is compliance with 18th Century techniques. That's cool if that's what they're into, have at it. But I have no reason to use that as a standard for my work. I like a lot of historical furniture (generally more than modern furniture)and use a lot of historical furniture elements in what I build, but I'm generally not trying to reproduce, or even copy historical pieces, I'm building new furniture that draws from some of the pleasing (to me) forms of the past.

Not having weighed in on the great hammer mark and plywood controversy of 2008, I'll say that it surprised me how many of the comments seemed to reflect some unstated standard of work as though there was only one definition. Since the historical methods and context are of importance to many people, there is reason for them to debate these issues. But sometimes it seems like this morphs into an implication that that's how woodwork "should" be done. I like old tools and, given the same (or at least adequate) functionality, I'd generally rather use an old tool than a new tool just because the connection to the past is kind of fun. But for me, that doesn't extend to needing to do everything exactly as it was done when the tool was made. But that could change too, a lot about my woodworking interests has changed over time.

I used to leave the scribe marks on my dovetails because it showed (or so I thought) that the dovetails were hand cut. Truth is, the only people that saw it that way were other woodworkers, and they could tell anyway from the narrow pins. To everyone else, they were just wondering why I left those weird scratch marks on the drawer boxes when I'd taken such care in finishing the rest of the piece. I no longer think that hand cut dovetails are a big deal, and now scribe lines look sloppy to me (again, just my current standard of work, not a historical statement). But so far it seems the joints with scribe lines are holding together just as well as those where I removed them.

I remember the days when Total Quality Management was the rage in the business world. For the most part it was just another management craze, but one tidbit that I think endures is the definition that "quality is conformance to requirements." When I first heard this, I recoiled in horror because I thought one should always put out the best product they can. However, over the years I've realized the wisdom in that definition. Some of the plywood discussion seemed to presume there's some kind of absolute standard on whether the use of plywood is appropriate. This obviously depends on what the intent of the work is, and judgements made by any group about what is/isn't acceptable has underlying assumptions about the "requirements" are. If the purpose is to make a historically inspired (as distinct from a "reproduction") piece of furniture that is durable and likely to hold up over time, then plywood can undoubtedly be effectively used. If the standard of work is mimicing the composition, or even the methods of work, well, that's a different matter (and it's a continuum, not a categorical distinction).

So Wilbur, if overcut baselines look sloppy to you, then don't do it. If it looks sloppy to you now, it seems unlikely that just hearing that someone else, now or in the past, does/did it doesn't seem likely to really change that feeling. Instead, get a couple beater 1/4" or 3/8" bevel edge chisels and grind them into a pair of skews (if you don't already have them). They'll make quick work out of any stray fibers hiding down in the corners of your dovetails. Might take an extra couple moments compared to overcutting the baselines, but if the result is more pleasing to you, why not? (caveat -- from what you've posted before, my understanding is that you're doing this for fun, not to make a living)

Best,

Dave

Re: Dovetails: cutting to or past the baseline? *LINK*

#15

Re: Dovetails: cutting to or past the baseline?

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>I think Pederson was generally sloppy about the baseline, as well as silly about a couple of others techniques. Silly first: 1) You only need place a sacrificial board under the board to be chopped, no need to hang it over the edge or telegraph your chops; 2) there's nothing particularly desirable or virtuous about going slowly; 3) there's no need to clamp the board with a wooden clamp, all sorts of dog holes, etc. for holding the work.

Sloppy: 1) Cutting the tail board to allow for the half pins using a horizontal motion, much easier and surer to cut this vertically, may even take less time to cut, reclamp, cut again since you can cut so accurately with vertical motion; 2) chopping from the baseline first since there's nowhere for the waste to go, leads to messy bases mucked up by chisel movement; 3) the bit you asked about (well, I had to watch the whole video :), I don't recall ever having a problem with a small bit of wood in the corner, never tore out on me, but I use sharp chisels of the right size.

Pam

Re: Dovetails: cutting to or past the baseline? *LINK*

#16

Re: Influence of time and place and ......

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>Well, Wilbur, I am glad you brought this up. I just looked at and photographed a cradle, made of walnut, probably from the South (Kentucky I think) made 1840-60 maybe earlier and a few of the many dovetails go beyond the baseline on the outside. Several more go beyond the baseline on the inside. I would consider this piece a high end cradle, well constructed with a hinged netting fly over the head of the cradle, nice brass knobs on the side to tie the baby into the cradle, all the good stuff.

I have also seen a number of pieces where there is just a bit of a nick from the saw below the line. When sawing dovetails that show, more care appears to be taken but a few arrant cuts appear, even on nicer pieces.

Now on drawers, especially the backs, sawing beyond the baseline is very common. Most times it is not much but on occasion you will see some that go well beyond the base line.

We probably expect better today, I think it is a modern mind-set, machines make stuff fit perfect (or that is the theory) and that is what we expect.

Look both on the money side (the one that shows) and the other side on old pieces and these people worked fast, and with experience worked good.

You can also do a lot with putty, mastic, filler, hot shellac sticks and wax to fill imperfections, as was done in the past.

I think I tend to cut beyond the baseline on a regular basis, I try and get close, but it is easier to remove the stock and get the work done if I don't have to fettle with each inside corner. On a chest of drawers (a bureau in the nineteenth century) you could have over a hundred dovetails, and that is way too much fettling.

Stephen

Re: Dovetails: cutting to or past the baseline? *LINK*

#17

The NH Furniture Masters' approach

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>I remember reading in an article about the NH Masters that their philosophy is "the best that can be done with today's standards" (quote might not be verbatim), i.e. finished insides and back, no cutting DTs beyond the baseline, etc. There was a fellow who applied (I think it was for the League of NH Craftsmen) who submitted a piece for a second time, over the objections of the initial jury, claiming that "this is the way craftsmen did it two hundred years ago". For an answer the jury stuck business cards in all the joints :-)

Time was money in the past as well as it is today, and I'm sure craftsmen of the time didn't waste any time on construction details that the customers (I would surmise that most of them didn't have a clue as to what constituted "good" woodworking) didn't pay attention to.

DC

Re: Dovetails: cutting to or past the baseline? *LINK*

#18

Re: Influence of time and place and ......

wilbur

>"Look both on the money side (the one that shows) and the other side on old pieces and these people worked fast, and with experience worked good."

Hi Stephen,

Have you noticed a pattern of sawing where the money side was consistently closer to the line than the other side?

Re: Dovetails: cutting to or past the baseline? *LINK*

#19

Re: Influence of time and place and ......

MikeW

>And I am sure it is my personal preference--a modern one I cannot divorce myself from--writing here.

I believe it takes as much time (or nearly so) to hide errant cuts with whatever one's choice is than to simply stop at or on the baseline. As well, it takes no more real effort to choose one stopping point than another relative to a line. The exception in my mind is that at least if the goal is at or on the line, it removes the vagaries of judgment.

I think it all boils down to work ethic combined with not being stressed out if a cut does go beyond the intended stopping point.

Though it would be difficult for me to over cut DTs in the situatino Dean describes as regards carcasses (I have treated them like drawers), I can acknowledge it would matter less to me than a drawer.

Take care, Mike

Re: Dovetails: cutting to or past the baseline? *LINK*

#20

Re: Dovetails: cutting to or past the baseline?

ThomD

>I couldn't watch for 33 minutes to see it either. In fact mine didn't come with time info.

I sometime use a Japanese keyhole saw as a rule to check the joint before assembly. If there are any fibers I just cut them with the saw, which works really well. Of course chisels work well also.

This practice does remind me a bit of the overcutting carpenters do with circular saws, often severely reducing part strength. I don't do that myself, but I do see it as a reasonable strategy when a person knows what material is required to gain the strength they need. One thing in all this talk about the 18th century is that the techniques being employed aren't pushed out to the .00000003% wood working fringe, they are the production techniques of the day, and they are also used in areas we largely wouldn't consider them for today. Take the example of Taig Frid's dovetailed door frame. The competant worker had a responsability to have at his disposal a variety of methods that would offer improved performance in approprate situations. They couldn't just haul out the biscuit jointer and drywall screws.

Re: Dovetails: cutting to or past the baseline? *LINK*

#21

Re: Influence of time and place and ......

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>Wilbur,

The only time I really look closely at dovetails on old pieces is every time I look at another old piece of furniture, so I look at all of the joinery I can. What I do notice is than on occasion even on the best pieces an arrant saw cut, I have seen it on cheek cuts on the top shoulder where it didn't show.

More importantly in most cases the work is excellent but it is never perfect, and this is not from wear through time, these are original marks. I think dovetailing was done by counting strokes. Like counting the number of times to turn a brace to drill a hole of particular depth.

Now counting strokes works well but on occasion, the wood might be softer or harder and a cut can go beyond the line. I have seen individual pieces where the money side dovetail cut was perfect and more than one on the money side goes beyond the scribe line. I have seen pieces where they got to the line and didn't go over on either side.

What brings this discussion up is when there is a cut that goes far enough beyond the line to be noticeable (with modern eyes). And for some reason we get all concerned and start speculating. It may or may not have bothered the builder, it obviously didn't bother the customer as it appears they bought it anyway. They were happy to have the furniture, it meant a lot more to them back then, larger investment of personal wealth, etc.

Stephen

Re: Dovetails: cutting to or past the baseline? *LINK*

#22

Peanuts and a cold one Dom!

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>

Re: Dovetails: cutting to or past the baseline? *LINK*

#23

There we go Dave!

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>