Re: Standards of work
Dave Mount
>Hi Wilbur--
I think overcut baselines look sloppy so I try not to. It happens by accident occasionally, but I try to hide it when I do. The main criterion I judge my work by is whether I like it. I would not look to have my work judged by someone whose standard is compliance with 18th Century techniques. That's cool if that's what they're into, have at it. But I have no reason to use that as a standard for my work. I like a lot of historical furniture (generally more than modern furniture)and use a lot of historical furniture elements in what I build, but I'm generally not trying to reproduce, or even copy historical pieces, I'm building new furniture that draws from some of the pleasing (to me) forms of the past.
Not having weighed in on the great hammer mark and plywood controversy of 2008, I'll say that it surprised me how many of the comments seemed to reflect some unstated standard of work as though there was only one definition. Since the historical methods and context are of importance to many people, there is reason for them to debate these issues. But sometimes it seems like this morphs into an implication that that's how woodwork "should" be done. I like old tools and, given the same (or at least adequate) functionality, I'd generally rather use an old tool than a new tool just because the connection to the past is kind of fun. But for me, that doesn't extend to needing to do everything exactly as it was done when the tool was made. But that could change too, a lot about my woodworking interests has changed over time.
I used to leave the scribe marks on my dovetails because it showed (or so I thought) that the dovetails were hand cut. Truth is, the only people that saw it that way were other woodworkers, and they could tell anyway from the narrow pins. To everyone else, they were just wondering why I left those weird scratch marks on the drawer boxes when I'd taken such care in finishing the rest of the piece. I no longer think that hand cut dovetails are a big deal, and now scribe lines look sloppy to me (again, just my current standard of work, not a historical statement). But so far it seems the joints with scribe lines are holding together just as well as those where I removed them.
I remember the days when Total Quality Management was the rage in the business world. For the most part it was just another management craze, but one tidbit that I think endures is the definition that "quality is conformance to requirements." When I first heard this, I recoiled in horror because I thought one should always put out the best product they can. However, over the years I've realized the wisdom in that definition. Some of the plywood discussion seemed to presume there's some kind of absolute standard on whether the use of plywood is appropriate. This obviously depends on what the intent of the work is, and judgements made by any group about what is/isn't acceptable has underlying assumptions about the "requirements" are. If the purpose is to make a historically inspired (as distinct from a "reproduction") piece of furniture that is durable and likely to hold up over time, then plywood can undoubtedly be effectively used. If the standard of work is mimicing the composition, or even the methods of work, well, that's a different matter (and it's a continuum, not a categorical distinction).
So Wilbur, if overcut baselines look sloppy to you, then don't do it. If it looks sloppy to you now, it seems unlikely that just hearing that someone else, now or in the past, does/did it doesn't seem likely to really change that feeling. Instead, get a couple beater 1/4" or 3/8" bevel edge chisels and grind them into a pair of skews (if you don't already have them). They'll make quick work out of any stray fibers hiding down in the corners of your dovetails. Might take an extra couple moments compared to overcutting the baselines, but if the result is more pleasing to you, why not? (caveat -- from what you've posted before, my understanding is that you're doing this for fun, not to make a living)
Best,
Dave