Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

18th century workmanship contd:

Posts

18th century workmanship contd:

#1

18th century workmanship contd:

John Hoffman

>Not wanting to inflame anyone, which I think I should say after reading the thread that included Adam's pic of a chair with hammer dents, I would like to throw my thoughts out there on a similar subject.

I was watching Norm build a copy of a tall clock that was made by the Dominy's and is at Winterthur. I have seen this clock in person. Anyway, as Norm completed the project and put a Quartz movement in it, I noticed that the back of the clock was made from plywood.

At first I thought "you have to be kidding me?" Build such a nice reproduction why not use real wood for the back? Then it occured to me, why not? Wouldn't an 18th century Master use plywood if it was available? Isn't this the equivalent of using poplar or pine with knots?

Just a thought from a person that really would like some other opinions?

Peace

JH

Re: 18th century workmanship contd:

#2

guidelines for reproduction work

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>I just returned from SAPFM meeting where there are experts that have sage advice on this matter. Every professional that offered an opinion had the same philosophy.

Unless specified different by the client........All surfaces that are visible must be done as they would have been at the time of the original. Everything else can be done by the best way as judged by the builder. No doubt there are deviants from these guidelines, but they are the exception.

So veneering over plywood with a vacuum bag and modern adhesive is acceptable. Plywood in a clock back is certainly not.

Re: 18th century workmanship contd:

#3

PS

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>be back in a week . Taking a class to make a Federal French footed cabinet with the objective of learning some of the tricks to make the "unseen" parts go more smoothly. It will be a mix of power and hand.

Re: 18th century workmanship contd:

#4

Re: PS

John Hoffman

>Where? You must post pics and thoughts when you are done!

Re: 18th century workmanship contd:

#5

Re: Plywood - king of woods.

ThomD

>The problem with plywood is that it is dimensionally stable so it can add to problems in cetain situations. Also, the different structural properties can be pros or cons. Other than that, I don't see a problem with using it. It comes in different grades and one should use an appropriate grade. I also don't have a problem with creating a piece with an all around finish level that is consistant. But if a piece is going to have a wall side might as well be rational about it. Of course one also has to keep in mind the potential audience that may have prejudices on material sellection.

I is hard to see how a product that might include flawless veneers of 1 mm, perfectly pressed into dimensionally accurate panels compares to some crap like knotty pine. Take something like 9mm "mahogany" with 7 layers, that is over 200 square feet of veneer. To me that is like the oil business - find some people who will sell you for 4 bucks a barrel something you can make way more for, right through to the end user. Unbelieveable.

Re: 18th century workmanship contd:

#6

Talk about a real drive-by!

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>Yea, you better explain all this when you get back.

Re: 18th century workmanship contd:

#7

Re: Plywood - king of woods.

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>Plywood was developed for Carriage work in the early nineteenth century; 3 layers of 'whitewood',sometimes layed up on a curve. These were lightweight panels for the carriages and stage coaches.

I owned an 1806 Collard & Collard pianoforte that had a plywood panel on the front covering the portion under the keyboard. It consisted of two thin layers of rosewood veneer, one on each side of the walnut core.

Stephen

Re: 18th century workmanship contd:

#8

Re: 18th century workmanship contd:

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>I suspect that if you looked at both Norm's work and the Dominy clock in person the plywood back would be the least of your criticisms. People who use plywood today are generally careless or insensitive about issues that are much more important than the back. I have not seen plywood on a reproduction that I thought was first class work, but I think that if all the other elements were in place, I could overlook the back.

Eighteenth century workers varied quite a bit in the care they took with hidden parts. The really sloppy ones tend to stick in one's mind, but some did careful preparation with good materials. I think some would have retrieved fake wood paneling from a dumpster and stapled it on the back had these options been available.

Re: 18th century workmanship contd:

#9

Re: 18th century workmanship contd:

MikeW

>Hi John,

I think...a couple things.

I believe as you mentioning in te second paragraph that Norm was building a copy. Indeed, I believe that word (copy) and the phrase "this is our version" is what is used on Norm's show. I think those words/phrases as juxtaposed with the word "reproduction" is an important distinction.

Nothing I have hitherto built would I use the word "reproduction." I think Stephen's current blog entry still has a topic of a broader subject, but two paragraphs I think are relevant:

"I make reproduction nineteenth century furniture, using the same tools, similar materials and traditional techniques of the originating craftsmen, whose furniture I am copying. I don�t add anything that they didn�t have into the mix, but one thing I can not quite get is the mine set of cabinetmakers of 150 years ago. If I step on a nail, I will get a shot, I drink clean water and have antiseptics, things not available to our ancestors.

...

If we make reproduction furniture it needs to be done using the same methods as the originating craftsmen in terms of materials, techniques and tools in order to call it reproduction furniture, if we don�t, it isn�t..."

My sincere apologies to Mr. S for bringing his blog into a public discourse. If you disagree, shoot me, not him. They are my sentiments as well.

Now, what an early 19th century person would use (or have available for use) as regards tools and materials would be different than the 18th century maker which is the subject of your thread.

Is the distinction in words/phrases important? I think so. It isn't what we think a maker would use back in a given period if it were available. It is, what did they have to use in all of its import. That, I think, is what the mindful maker of today seeks to answer if they wish to build faithful reproductions. Else, they are like me--or Norm--who seek to make "our version."

Take care, Mike

Re: 18th century workmanship contd:

#10

Depends

David Cockey

>The answer to what materials and techniques to use in building a reproduction depends on the purpose of the reproduction, the desires of the builder, and the desires of the eventual customer (if built to be sold). There is no single answer.

The answer Bill provided sounds like the accepted one for one group of folks, a number of whom have to consider economics. For a craftsman/scholar who is studying the techniques of an earlier period use of all period type tools and materials is essential. For a museum display (including personal "museums") then identical on the outside is probably sufficient. And for someone who wants a neat looking old clock for their house and doesn't want to pay much for it or take too much time building it then just looking about the same may be sufficient. Norm's projects look to me to fit in the latter category. It doesn't make them good or bad, just different than those with other purposes. I personally couldn't see investing the time/money for a clock case built "exactly" as original, and then putting a quartz movement (or cheap mechanical movement) in it. But others might think that was great.

This is different than the question of what standards did craftsman of an earlier period work to.

Re: 18th century workmanship contd:

#11

Copy, not reproduction

David Cockey

>I should have said copy or replica, not reproduction, in my note above. I agree with Mike that reproduction should be limited to copies which are very faithful to the original.

Re: 18th century workmanship contd:

#12

Reproduction is not possible

David Cockey

>Exact reproduction is not possible. We can come close, but no reproduced piece of furniture will be 100.0000...% identical with the original. To start with wood available isn't exactly like the wood used in the original. Finishes won't have exactly the same composition. And the exact technique/method used generally isn't completely known.

So that leaves the question of how close is close enough to use the term reproduction, which ultimately is a judgement call. I suspect most folks would take Stephen's description as close enough.

Re: 18th century workmanship contd:

#13

Reminds me of a question I waa wondering about...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>First off I can't see using plywood all that much in the things I build. 'Ceptin I'm typing this on a desk made from birch ply... go figure.

Do you think the Shakers would have used plywood if it was available to them?

Re: 18th century workmanship contd:

#14

Re: Reminds me of a question I waa wondering about

ThomD

>"Do you think the Shakers would have used plywood if it was available to them? "

Possibly when they got around to building aircraft... They developed the Table saw. Plywood is a prety good material for making machine tools out of, once they understood it they might have got with the program.

http://www.air-and-space.com/19801029%20Long%20Beach/2%2030%20Hughes%20Flying%20Boat%20N37602%20left%20side%20floating%20sunset%20l.jpg

http://www.multihulldesigns.com/images/charter/36chcat_4.jpg

I know it doesn't compare that well to those 19th century sock and clock containers, but still...

Re: 18th century workmanship contd:

#15

Absolutely yes

David Cockey

>Shakers would have used plywood if available if they thought it was the best choice. The Shakers were very progressive with technology. Several of the Shaker communities were the first folks in their areas to have electricity, and the first to have cars. However, by the early 20th century Shaker communities were shrinking, and in general had a surplus of furniture. So by the time plywood became commonly available they were not building much furniture.

Re: 18th century workmanship contd:

#16

Re: 18th century workmanship contd:

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>If I step on a nail, I will get a shot, I drink clean water and have antiseptics, things not available to our ancestors.

This is quite an assumption. Antibiotics and clean water occur in nature, and they were available to the population, we've forgotten a lot. In the 17th century, westerners in the Americas were hanging around with natives, who knew a lot of this stuff. Now there was a lot they didn't know that we do, such as disease causes and cures; but I'd bet if a craftsman stuck a stick in his arm there'd have been, most times, cures.

Pam

Re: 18th century workmanship contd:

#17

Re: 18th century workmanship contd:

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>Pam wrote:

'This is quite an assumption. Antibiotics and clean water occur in nature, and they were available to the population, we've forgotten a lot. In the 17th century, westerners in the Americas were hanging around with natives, who knew a lot of this stuff. Now there was a lot they didn't know that we do, such as disease causes and cures; but I'd bet if a craftsman stuck a stick in his arm there'd have been, most times, cures.

Pam

You are correct what few Native Americans were left after they came under the seven deadly diseases, Europeans introduced, we did learn a great deal. They used syringes, introduced the enema and willow (aspirin) is a wonderful thing.

However in the time period people were very careful, they didn't even eat with a fork, as they were expensive to make, sharp and pointy (to hold food while you cut it with a knife), associated with the Devil and if you poked your mouth and it went septic, you were usually dead.

My cardiologist is the one that said clean water and antiseptics were what allowed the world to flourish, but the mortality rate was still great. Cholera, small pox, measles, bubonic plague, yellow fever, child birth, all took there toll.

I think the greatest advancement in the nineteenth century was the introduction of Sodium Bicarbonate, baking soda as both a leavening agent and more importantly the first antacid.

Survival of the fittest.

Stephen

Re: 18th century workmanship contd:

#18

It's been a while since I read the article

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>but, as I understand it, an incredible percentage of the deaths from Civil War battles were from sepsis and other infections post-wound or post-surgery.

Re: 18th century workmanship contd:

#19

Re: It's been a while since I read the article

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Yeah, but this was during our forgetting time, during the industrial revolution, between the old ways and 1950+ (when doctors started doing more good than harm). We were stupid, still are, but getting it back.

Pam

Re: 18th century workmanship contd:

#20

Re: 18th century workmanship contd:

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>However in the time period people were very careful, they didn't even eat with a fork, as they were expensive to make, sharp and pointy (to hold food while you cut it with a knife), associated with the Devil and if you poked your mouth and it went septic, you were usually dead.

I don't know much about this. Were they made of lead?

My cardiologist is the one that said clean water and antiseptics were what allowed the world to flourish, but the mortality rate was still great. Cholera, small pox, measles, bubonic plague, yellow fever, child birth, all took there toll.

Except for death in child birth and maybe some cholera on a small scale, the other diseases were all European, had no effect on the native American population until...

I'll bow to Jared Diamond on these issues (see Guns, Germs, & Steel).

I think the greatest advancement in the nineteenth century was the introduction of Sodium Bicarbonate, baking soda as both a leavening agent and more importantly the first antacid.

Heh, heh, you know, I've never in my life needed to take any antacid.

Pam

Re: 18th century workmanship contd:

#21

Re: 18th century workmanship contd:

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Survival of the fittest.

I wanted to separate this statement because it smacks of social Darwinism. Was that the intent? Do you seriously think that because Europeans infected native americans with smallpox, sometimes intentionally, that the natives weren't as fit?

Pam

Re: 18th century workmanship contd:

#22

Re: 18th century workmanship contd:

Charles

>Regarding the hammer marks on the chair: so what, one example does not indicate the standard of craftmanship for the period. So one guy whacked the hell out of chair using his steel hammer. Maybe he jumped off the tallest bridge he could find the next day. Should we all join him?

Re: 18th century workmanship contd:

#23

Good answer...

John in New Mexico

>Especially the taxonomy if you will. If one is shooting for a real period reproduction, using tools and techniques of the period, it is self defeating to use modern materials like plywood and ball bearing drawer guides. I would even argue against using non period glues and finishes in that case, but that is more open to debate. But I think if plywood had been available to period makers, they certainly would have used it, as it has many advantages. There is nothing inferior about it as a material, especially plywoods like baltic birch. They just don't fit in the period.