Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

motise and tenons rules of thumb (long)

Posts

motise and tenons rules of thumb (long)

#1

motise and tenons rules of thumb (long)

Jerome Bias

>I guess this is an off shoot of Adam's interview and comments about expectations of reproductions made with hand tools.

I wondering what are some of the historical rules of thumb for the dimensions and configurations of tenons and the mortises that match them? Or at least where I can go look up some options.

In his article in Woodworking magazine Chris Schartz suggested a couple of rules of thumb that I used in the blanket chest that I am building. I tried them and I didn't love the results.

To make things more confusing I just toured the Museum of early Southern Decorative Arts (Mesda) during the Society of American Period Furniture Makers (SAPFM)(they have to work on these names. they are entirely tooooo long) conference. During the tour the museum allowed us to do just about everything but turn the pieces over and shake them to see if anything would fall out. Their acceptability was amazing.

In looking at the pieces in the collection it seemed that none of the pieces were following the conventions that Chris suggested. Most of the tenons went all of the way through, I couldn't discern any pattern of when people would decide when a single tenon needed to divided into multiple tenons, I couldn't tell a consistent pattern of how far from the edge of the boards that folks were starting their tenons (not face of board but edges of the board).

I don't know if what I was seeing was a matter of needing to take better notice of the evolution of these rules of thumb over time, or possible differences in ethnic background and the resulting differences in design and construction aesthetic. I know that the English tried to hide everything and the Germans tried to peg the daylight out of many things. To say the least a visible through tenon was probably not considered a horrible sight. Also it didn't seem to be a matter if the furniture was made in the back country or an area that had a high concentration of highly skilled cabinetmakers, ie. Roanoke River Valley

Unfortunately I didn't think to ask any of the experts what their opinions and rules of thumb were? So I'm asking y'all.

Jerome Bias

Mebane, NC

Re: motise and tenons rules of thumb (long)

#2

Re: motise and tenons rules of thumb (long)

Christopher Schwarz

>Jerome,

I'd be very interested in hearing about the troubles you had with your joints' proportions. The "rules of thumb" I've suggested in several articles aren't mine. They're ones I've culled from several sources, including Charles Hayward, George Ellis and Joseph Moxon.

I have found that with a mortise-and-tenon joint that these "rules" are good starting points, but that there is a wide range of proportions and details that will work. It's my opinion (key word) that a well-made mortise-and-tenon joint can be overkill -- much like a well-made dovetail joint.

Chris

Re: motise and tenons rules of thumb (long)

#3

Re: motise and tenons rules of thumb (long)

Wiley Horne--So. Calif

>Hello Jerome,

Here's just one data point. This is a summary of the double-tenoning practices of John and Thomas Seymour, who were cabinetmakers in Boston during the Federal Period, say 1790 to 1815. This information is from the book, "Furniture Masterworks of John and Thomas Seymour", by Robt. Mussey, Jr., published by the Peabody Essex Museum, Salem MA, in 2003.

The broad context in part is that Federal furniture tends to be fairly 'fine boned', and hence getting the most out of the joinery is important. Secondly, the Seymours were English transplants, from the Ax area (anyone know where that is?). Mussey says that their joinery methods were very high quality, to the point of being fussy, compared to the other Boston cabinetmakers--Mussey attributes this to their English roots. Mussey also says that the Seymours did not pin their tenons in their Boston work, although earlier in Maine they did make liberal use of pins. This is not explained, but of course would be related to their decision to double the tenons for many types of joints.

I am inferring from what Mussey says that the Seymours doubled their tenons on particular types of joints, as opposed to keying on the thickness of the pieces to be joined.

Quoting from Mussey, p. 118,

"...The Seymours followed English habits in frequently using two or more mortises and tenons for key joints of case and seating furniture. This at least doubled the amount of glue surface and therefore potentially doubled the strength of the joint. They employed these to join the drawer rails (blades) to case sides; chair legs and sofa mid-legs to seat rails; short vertical stiles to join horizontal drawer rails; sofa table stretchers to vertical support shafts; the stiles of sofa backs to rails; and medial interior case panels to join case bottoms, tops, or backs. Case side and back panels are also normally tenoned to the legs with multiple evenly spaced blind tenons. Some of these employ through tenons that are readily visible, but most are hidden and only visible through partial disassembly or x-rays......"

Hope this helps,

Wiley

Re: motise and tenons rules of thumb (long)

#4

OT

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>That was one awesome tour of the museum. It was not the welcome (lack of) I got the last time I went there.

I liked the part of the meeting when Alan breed said he wasted the field of tea tables and the like on a CNC router. Two people behind me nearly had a stroke.

It was clear that every professional presenter used the best available technology to prepare lumber and furniture to accept final finish, veneering, inlay, etc. What is seen by a client is authentic reproduction; what can't be seen is the best modern way to get the job done.

As far as your mortise question...if its in the museum, it obviously survived. I was intrigued by the dovetails. There was every angle, spacing and size imaginable. Again, they all worked.

Re: motise and tenons rules of thumb (long)

#5

Overkill?

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>So what would choose in those situations a well made M&T is overkill? What are those conditions? Or is it that you're saying a poorly made M&T is OK at times?

Pam

Re: motise and tenons rules of thumb (long)

#6

Re: motise and tenons rules of thumb (long)

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>The tallest tenon I'll make in furniture (all bets are off for timber framing and other large efforts) is 2.5-3". If the pieces to be joined are sufficiently larger to require a taller tenon, I split them. Even 3" is pushing it, I'll think long and hard before splitting it into two 1.5" tenons.

Pam

Re: motise and tenons rules of thumb (long)

#7

Kinda like a Whitesnake song...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>Well here we go again down this road...

Re: motise and tenons rules of thumb (long)

#8

What are you talking about?

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>

Re: motise and tenons rules of thumb (long)

#9

Re: Overkill?

Dan Donaldson

>I am going to guess that the overkill statement references the fact that the joint is a lot stronger than "required" for the application, which does not mean that it is wrong. (nor that a poorly made joint is OK) From an engineering standpoint, there are probably many other ways to make the connection that would work fine for the application, but are not as strong as the mortise/tenon would be. Biscuits come to mind (ducking and running;-)) as well as possibly splines, or even, in some cases a simple butt joint. Neither of those may be esthetically pleasing, but might work fine for the application. I am an engineer by trade, and I have a tendency to "overengineer" a lot of the stuff I do, which is just the way I do it, neither inherently "right" or "wrong". ;-)

Re: motise and tenons rules of thumb (long)

#10

Re: Overkill?

Christopher Schwarz

>Pam,

What I mean by "overkill" is that a theoretically perfectly made mortise-and-tenon joint probably has more surface area for gluing than is necessary for some applications. A pegged through-tenon in a small door joint (which I've seen in a lot of Western Shaker work) would be one such example.

This extra surface area allows (perhaps) some imperfection in the fit of the joint from hand cutting.

You can also see the way this works on the power-tool side of the world. How does the Domino get away with such small floating tenons? Maximizing the surface area for gluing with precision machining.

Like I said, I'm floating opinion here based on my work and observation. No data points were created.

Chris

Re: motise and tenons rules of thumb (long)

#11

Re: motise and tenons rules of thumb (long)

Jerome Bias

>I know that your suggestions are your opinion and preferences. I prefer to learn from other's successes. I think it is neat that as I develop and try what others prefer I slowly develop techniques that work well specifically for me.

I was working from the suggestions in the Spring 2007 issue of Woodworking.I ran into the problem that Fred Tieg (well slaughtered spelling) suggested would happen. I found that there were at times a small visible gap where the tenon was cut short of the edge of the rail.

Jerome

Re: motise and tenons rules of thumb (long)

#12

Re: Overkill?

Jerome Bias

>I like the idea that the overkill might allow for hand cut some minor imperfections in them. While sloppy is not okay, absolute perfection was not required when cabinetmakers in the 17th an 18th century were trying to crank out as many pieces as they could. Time is money. And if your furniture easily falls apart clients don't come back.

Jerome

Mebane, NC

Re: motise and tenons rules of thumb (long)

#13

on topic but on to dovetails

Jerome Bias

>I really enjoyed seeing drawers having a single dovetail and a nail in the middle of it to hold a drawer together. I reduced my anxiety over dovetails.

I don't have to be that sloppy. But depending on the piece,and it's expected usage, I don't have to be perfect either.

Jerome

Mebane, NC

Re: motise and tenons rules of thumb (long)

#14

Re: What are you talking about? *LINK*

wilbur

>By "Here we go again down this road", Scott is probably referring to an old song by Whitesnake.

I would say, "bad Whitesnake song", but that's actually redundant. :@)

Here's the video of the song. Warning: lots of bad 80's hair, and ridiculous writhing about on expensive cars.


"Here I Go Again", by Whitesnake

Re: motise and tenons rules of thumb (long)

#15

Re: motise and tenons rules of thumb (long)

ThomD

>If there are no rules, then there are no rules.

Early on when bicuit joiners became available I reluctantly made a few pieces of shop furniture using them. made two krenov style, hurdle like saw horses. These have no bracing, and as a result heavily stressed joints, material section was about <1.75" x .75", not beefy

Instead of mortices these had bicuits in them. Biscuits have inoptimal: grain orientation, penetration, mechanical locking, twist resistance, dimensional thickness, species, gluebond area, scaling, etc... You just wouldn't believe the abuse these took over the years. I still have them, they did require partial repair. The worst overuse was using them as one of four things my 25 foot yacht hung from during construction. This did not convince me on buiscuits since over the long haul they don't stand up to moisture cycling that often tears appart dowel joints also, but over the short haul of 1/2-1 lifetime they are OK.

So I suppose when looking for the ideal set of rules of thumb that would deal perfectly, with the various structural, wood expansion, ease of construction, and aesthetic concerns, with zero compromise, I would not worry too much about strength.

Re: motise and tenons rules of thumb (long)

#16

Re: What are you talking about?

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Many thanks, Wilbur, can't figure out if the lead is about to take a chance on a new woman or is about to buy a used car.

Scott apparently thinks I'm repeating myself; but I don't remember Chris' every saying that good M&T's are sometimes not required. Oh, well.

Pam

Re: motise and tenons rules of thumb (long)

#17

Yeah, biscuits came to my mind, too. :)

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>

Re: motise and tenons rules of thumb (long)

#18

Re: Overkill?

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Thanks, Chris. I always look for opportunities to not use glue; so mechanical joinery such as pegged M&T is attractive. However, I don't consider these joints as weaker than other well made M&T's, they're probably a lot stronger ultimately.

I'd also agree that there's some room for slack; but the strength of a given M&T joint is, to a great extent, proportional to the number and placement of great heaving maws.

I'm floating opinion here based on my work and observation. No data points were created.

Just trying to help. :)

Pam

Re: motise and tenons rules of thumb (long)

#19

Re: What are you talking about?

wilbur

>I actually think that in this song the singer (David Coverdale) is having a psychotic break. After all, he's singing:

"Here I go again on my own

goin' down the only road I've ever known."

when there's clearly someone else in the front seat of the car. :@)

Not to mention that the song loses points for using the phrase, "lonely street of dreams".

Re: motise and tenons rules of thumb (long)

#20

Re: motise and tenons rules of thumb (long)

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>I'm amazed that your biscuited saw horses have held up so well, will file this away.

Pam

Re: motise and tenons rules of thumb (long)

#21

Re: What are you talking about?

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>I feel blessed that my eighties weren't despoiled by these guys. :)

Pam

Re: motise and tenons rules of thumb (long)

#22

Similarly....

John in NM

>I tend to split them in the 4 - 6" range, depending on how the proportions work out. Thats for hardwood of course, I'd probably split them sooner with soft, but I have a real aversion to small tenons - I've had them break in tension when working mesquite. Though it was an extreme case, it was a pain to fix, so I try to always keep the tenon wider than about 1 - 1 1/4".

Re: motise and tenons rules of thumb (long)

#23

Re: motise and tenons rules of thumb (long)

ThomD

>To be frank (didn't think it affected what I was saying really), those joints had two biscuits in them With a spacer under the machine one can stack 2 in there with about equal thicknesses of material on the faces and between the biscuits. But still, without glue there is zero anything holding it together. That is what is good about wedges, eventually the joint's glue breaks. I know some 19th century doors that need a shove and a tap to tighten them every so often, but they woould have fallen appart if assembled by stubs.

I have installed biscuits by hand. I did this stand for a Koto that needed to break down and be made of light material. I did a scarph type joint and it needed lateral stability without taking away too much material. No way to get the machine into the convex face of the scarph.

You can barely see the result here, is you look carefully around 9 seconds:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dNHd56Ub06k&feature=related

Re: motise and tenons rules of thumb (long)

#24

"... I don't have to be perfect either. "

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>to quote a therapist friend of mine who counsels people afflicted with these things, "perfection is highly overrated."

I still think the best dovetails I ever did were the first ones I sweated over some 25 years ago. Thank goodness I don't have to do that anymore.

Bruce

Re: motise and tenons rules of thumb (long)

#25

Re: motise and tenons rules of thumb (long)

Jerome Bias

>thanks that is what I was looking for.

Jerome