motise and tenons rules of thumb (long)
Jerome Bias
>I guess this is an off shoot of Adam's interview and comments about expectations of reproductions made with hand tools.
I wondering what are some of the historical rules of thumb for the dimensions and configurations of tenons and the mortises that match them? Or at least where I can go look up some options.
In his article in Woodworking magazine Chris Schartz suggested a couple of rules of thumb that I used in the blanket chest that I am building. I tried them and I didn't love the results.
To make things more confusing I just toured the Museum of early Southern Decorative Arts (Mesda) during the Society of American Period Furniture Makers (SAPFM)(they have to work on these names. they are entirely tooooo long) conference. During the tour the museum allowed us to do just about everything but turn the pieces over and shake them to see if anything would fall out. Their acceptability was amazing.
In looking at the pieces in the collection it seemed that none of the pieces were following the conventions that Chris suggested. Most of the tenons went all of the way through, I couldn't discern any pattern of when people would decide when a single tenon needed to divided into multiple tenons, I couldn't tell a consistent pattern of how far from the edge of the boards that folks were starting their tenons (not face of board but edges of the board).
I don't know if what I was seeing was a matter of needing to take better notice of the evolution of these rules of thumb over time, or possible differences in ethnic background and the resulting differences in design and construction aesthetic. I know that the English tried to hide everything and the Germans tried to peg the daylight out of many things. To say the least a visible through tenon was probably not considered a horrible sight. Also it didn't seem to be a matter if the furniture was made in the back country or an area that had a high concentration of highly skilled cabinetmakers, ie. Roanoke River Valley
Unfortunately I didn't think to ask any of the experts what their opinions and rules of thumb were? So I'm asking y'all.
Jerome Bias
Mebane, NC



