Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

Welding Damaged Planes?

Posts

Welding Damaged Planes?

#1

Welding Damaged Planes?

David Miller from Iowa

>OK � so I have this new welder and I have been playing around with it. I have welded about 10 fence posts together and my bead is� well, significantly better than my first try, but not as good as some Chinese equipment I have.

SO � what�s the deal with welding cast iron � like planes? My brother said one doesn�t weld cast iron, they braze it � what�s the difference? I have heard other people say forget it, it will never work.

I see in FWW (or somewhere?) people have ads on to weld cast iron tools. Let�s skip over the part where it no longer makes the tool collectible and stick to the metallurgy.

Can a plane with a hairline crack be saved for a user? How about one busted in two? What is the trick?

Thanks, David

Re: Welding Damaged Planes?

#2

Re: Welding Damaged Planes?

Neal in San Jose

>Cast iron has properties that make welding it problematic at best. Mainly that it conducts heat very, very well. That can be a good thing; it makes good frying pans, etc. The bad thing is that instead of heating in a small, localized area like you are used to with steel, the entire plane will suddenly and without warning turn from a plane into a molten puddle. Or at least very big sections will turn into molten iron and the rest of the plane body will warp like a pretzel. It can be done, but it isn't a good thing to learn on. DAMHIKT! The usual repair for broken cast iron is brazing, which takes a much lower temperature so the cast iron doesn't get hot enough to melt, but it will probably still warp so badly that the end result will be unusable.

If you are going to try it, then back up the area you don't want to melt with some steel heat sinks to keep the heat from migrating. Then, practice with something you REALLY don't care about.

Re: Welding Damaged Planes?

#3

Re: Welding Damaged Planes?

Tony Zaffuto

>Earlier this year I brazed a severe crack in a Sargent Autoset plane. Warping did occur, but not that bad, and was easily taken care of on a surface grinder.

The braze sticks out like a sore thumb though! I've heard of using metals other than brass to braze with that blend into the cast iron and are hard to see (nickel????).

T.Z.

Re: Welding Damaged Planes?

#4

Re: Welding Damaged Planes?

Kenneth Martin Sacramento

>Last year I had a 3C plane with a crack in the side. I asked a teenage friend about welding it and he took it into his welding class. Working with his instructor they used a special wire and got a good weld on it. The only problem was they ground down the weld and got some gouges in the side. Oh well It makes a good user.

I gather it is not an easy thing to weld.

Re: Welding Damaged Planes?

#5

Re: Welding Damaged Planes?

ThomD

>Tinman is keeping alive old techniques. I looked at some tapes that showed all kinds of stuff that was routine at an earlier time, but has been superceeded these days or forgoten. I use his stuff for welding bike frames.

http://tinmantech.com/html/cast_iron_welding_supplies.php

http://tinmantech.com/html/vid_cast_iron_weld_torch_a.php

Re: Welding Damaged Planes?

#6

Sure....*PIX*

Rob Brophy...lost in Niagara

>Hi David,

Welding cast iron can be tricky. I have had good luck welding handplanes with a MIG welder....the weld is a different color than the cast but the repair is strong. Warping hasn't been a problem but there is always the risk if you have a heavy hand.

You didn't say what type of welder you have...MIG, TIG, stick?

Here's an example of a MIG repair...

Before...



After...


Another example of a broken plane I welded...


Re: Welding Damaged Planes?

#7

My 10-1/2 has been welded twice

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>The first time by a friend who had learned to weld but was not yet a welder. The crack was on the side, at the mouth, and, when he was done, the front of the sole on that side was a good 1/8" higher than the back.

I took it to my revered uncle, who, after sighing a bit about the ignorance of the young, cut out my friend's weld, clamped both ends of the sole to a cast iron plate, then welded it again, letting the plane cool while clamped. It's as close to dead flat as I can expect now. The side's a little rough (not much rougher than the picture Rob Brophy posted), but the plane's very usable.

Re: Welding Damaged Planes?

#8

Try Silver Soldering

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>The braze sticks out like a sore thumb though! I've heard of using metals other than brass to braze with that blend into the cast iron and are hard to see (nickel????).

I would try silver soldering. This has great strength and a matching colour. The amount of heat required (around the crack) is not too high to cause problems, and the solder should flow into the crack smoothly and fill it well if it is clean.

I have not fixed any planes this way myself, however, just used it to join metal. Others do report it is a successful method.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Welding Damaged Planes?

#9

Good one... ;)

Rob Lee

>

Re: Welding Damaged Planes?

#10

Re: Try Silver Soldering

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Silver solder is a good way to go but make sure you get silver solder that has a high percentage of silver and use the paste type flux that you mix with water. If the crack is fresh, the solder will tend to flow into it, but if it's an old crack that is dirty, forget it. If the solder doesn't flow into the crack, you might as well not do it.

If you braze, first dremel or grind a groove into the crack. This will give you clean metal to braze to and will allow you to file or grind off the excess brass. It doesn't have to be lumpy looking. Preheating will prevent warping.

Whether you silver solder or braze, preheat the metal in an oven and get it as hot as the oven will get it. If you have an oven that will get hot enough, you can actually do silver soldering this way. I'm not sure what the temperature has to be. I just do it by trial and error. Flux must be applied prior to preheating.

Brazing requires higher temps and is done with acetylene, but preheating is still a good idea to prevent warping.

Marv

Re: Welding Damaged Planes?

#12

Two kinds of silver solder....

John in New Mexico

>Hard and soft. Soft is a tin/silver alloy that melts around 600 C and is often used for plumbing joints. Some formulations will melt at lower temps, so you could probably use your oven.

Then there's hard solder, used for jewelry and gunsmithing and stuff, melts around 1200 C IIRC. There are many formulations here too, with varying melting temps, etc. Much stronger bond, like brazing. I'm not sure that the non-jewelry solders aren't nickel rather than silver alloys.

I've also seen cast iron arc welded with a "nickel rod" in a stick welder. Special rod and pre-heating, but I bet somebody knows how to do it with a little tig too.

Re: Welding Damaged Planes?

#13

Its like one of those Hummer limos!

John in New Mexico

>

Re: Welding Damaged Planes?

#14

Re: Two kinds of silver solder....

ThomD

>In the hard range, I use 46% silver a lot. It is still fairly yellow, the 56% flows better into cracks, but doesn't gap fill well.

Re: Welding Damaged Planes?

#15

Re: Welding Damaged Planes?

Hank Knight

>Garrett Hack's favorite 604 1/2 smoother has a brazed cheek. He told me he wouldn't allow anybody to touch it until he found a welder who really knew his stuff. The guy did a great job. As Marv mentioned, brazing requires the crack to be widened with a dremel or similar tool so the brass will have a larger surface area to stick to. The guy who brazed Hack's plane did the grinding on the inside and the repair was evident on the inside, but it had been filed smooth and looked nice. All that showed on the outside was a thin line of brass. Nice job and the sole was flat as a pancake.

Re: Welding Damaged Planes?

#16

Not at all...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>Rob showcased this locomotive a while back. If you ask nicely he might show the pic with shavings coming from all 3 blades!

Re: Welding Damaged Planes?

#17

Re: Welding Damaged Planes?

James Clark

>Many years ago a friend of mine showed me a technique to weld cast iron planes thats worked exceptionally well for me so i'll do the best that I can to explain it,

First-clean the metal wanting to be welded

Second-heat the metal on each side of the break roughly about a "1/4 on each side of the break.BE SURE NOT TO HEAT RED HOT ONLY UNTIL METAL STARTS TO CHANGE COLORS

Third-place heated plane in a 5 gallon pale with sand in it and bury the plane in the sand and leave in there until plane cools,usually about 8-10 hours to cool completly.

Fourth-put a slight bevel on broken edges.

Fifth-Tack weld broken edges together then once tacked where your happy with it, now weld it with a solid bead of weld but don't fill the beveled edges completly.

Sixth-using a small grinder or dremel smooth any high spots on the first bead of weld.

Seventh-Now you can fish filling beveled edges with the second bead of weld but be sure your bead is a bit higher than the peice of metal being welded this is so the weld can be ground,sanded then polished smooth.

Eighth-Now reheat the same area that you did before but this time heat it a bit hotter

Ninth-put repaired peice in cool water

Tenth-Finish polishing

I hope these methods can be of some help to some of you also I hope I was able to explain it fairly clear so its understandable.

Sincerely,

Jim C