Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

The Veritas Side Rabbet Plane - review *LINK*

Posts

Re: The Veritas Side Rabbet Plane - review *LINK*

#2

Re: The Veritas Side Rabbet Plane - review

Joe Grittani

>Derek -

I always look forward to your reviews and this one raised an interesting question. I recently bought a Stanley #46 and am having difficulty sharpening the narrower blades. The wide ones are easy enough to hand hold. I have a Veritas Mk.II honing guide and was planning on purchasing the skew attachment. It never occurred to me that it might not work on the 46 blades because of insufficient blade length. Do you happen to know how long a blade has to be useable in this jig or if all 46 blades do or not work?

Thanks in advance.

Joe Grittani

Dayton, Ohio

Re: The Veritas Side Rabbet Plane - review *LINK*

#3

Re: The Veritas Side Rabbet Plane - review

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>Nice review, Derek.

I have to look up time in Perth: you posted this at 1:00 a.m. Perth time. Do you ever sleep?

Re: The Veritas Side Rabbet Plane - review *LINK*

#4

Re: The Veritas Side Rabbet Plane - review

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>Hi Joe

There is no problem using the #46 blades in the Veritas skew jig.

The Stanley #46 Combination plane: blades have a 20 degree skew angle and the bevels are 25 degrees.

I do have an article on all this. Will post it to the website this week.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: The Veritas Side Rabbet Plane - review *LINK*

#5

Re: The Veritas Side Rabbet Plane - review

Brent in Montreal

>Thanks for the review Derek. I just received mine in the mail this morning and will be trying it out tonight.

Re: The Veritas Side Rabbet Plane - review *LINK*

#6

you got the history wrong

Larry Williams

>A wooden side snipe and a wooden side rabbet are different planes. While there can be some overlap in use the planes are different. Side rabbets usually aren't boxed and they have a wider bottom profile (sole)than the side snipe. The side snipe will have a very narrow sole, will be boxed, and is mainly intended to widen quirks and other such delicate features.

Re: The Veritas Side Rabbet Plane - review *LINK*

#7

Re: you got the history wrong

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Are you saying that those wooden side rebates with curved "soles" are all intended for trimming quirks rather than trimming rebates? If so, that certain explains the relatively wide soles. I bought a couple or four of these honeys, but couldn't get them to do much with rebates.

Thanks,

Pam

Re: The Veritas Side Rabbet Plane - review *LINK*

#8

Re: The Veritas Side Rabbet Plane - review

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Similar to the Preston is the use of twin blades. Where these two planes differ is that the Veritas blades are shorter � presumably to keep the cutting angles the same.

Derek, while I understand that the blade length could affect the cutting angle, I can't seem to parse the above. How does making the Veritas blades shorter keep the cutting angles the same?

Pam

Re: The Veritas Side Rabbet Plane - review *LINK*

#9

I'm not Derek; don't even play him on TV

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>but I'll essay an answer. If you look at the picture of the Preston side rebate, a ways into Derek's review - or, for that matter, any picture of a Preston or Record side rebate - you'll note that one cutting iron passes above the other one at the back, between blade clamp and knob (or is it properly a tote, being at the back of the plane?). To accomplish this, one iron has to bed at a higher angle - thus, different cutting angles. One would either have to sharpen the two blades at different angles (bevel, not skew) to accomplish the same effective cutting angle, or live with one being a higher angle than the other.

Re: The Veritas Side Rabbet Plane - review *LINK*

#10

Re: I'm not Derek; don't even play him on TV

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Thanks, Bill, had forgotten about the overlapping blades, only had the Preston for about a week (long story about buying, expensive, my company died, sold it to recoup).

Pam

Re: The Veritas Side Rabbet Plane - review *LINK*

#11

I'm not sure what you're saying

Larry Williams

>A side snipe is shaped like a snipe bill. The snipe bill is an entering plane used to sink a line and doesn't cut on the flat side. The side snipe will widen such a line. From the toe, they both look pretty much the same. From the side, a side snipe will have a vertical or nearly vertical iron. I've attached a photo of a snipe bill entering on a marking gauge line.


img

Re: The Veritas Side Rabbet Plane - review *LINK*

#12

side rabbets and snipe bills

Adam Cherubini

>Or is it snipes bill? Or snipes' bills?

I've never heard of a side cutting snipe plane. I have a pair of snipe bills (which cut at the bottom) and a pair of side rabbets (which cut on the side).

In the picture, the pair of side rabbets are (stupidly blade to blade) on the left. One of the snipe bills is to the right.

In truth, none of them see much use in my shop. I'm not sure what they were for or who used them. Obviously the snipe planes can create or change a quirk. But if you've got a quirk, why change it? I mean, what's wrong with the quirk you've got? I suspect carved moldings may have something to do with this. Carved moldings were popular in Victorian England. Consequently, these snipe planes are not hard to find if you hunt for them. Personally, I don't do much snipe hunting. But I've bagged a few snipe in my day.

Adam


img

Re: The Veritas Side Rabbet Plane - review *LINK*

#13

History or definition? *LINK*

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>Hi Larry

There is a great deal of conflicting and, for myself, confusing information about the definitions and use of the wooden side rabbet planes. In this area I most defnitely defer to you.

Garrett Hack, in his "Handplane Book" uses the term snipe bill to refer to a side rabbet plane. In my understanding this is incorrect. A more detailed description of the various types of wooden planes of this type comes from Ralph Brendler, who discussed them on the Old Tools list (link below).

Thanks for replying.

Regards from Perth

Derek


Ralph Brendler

Re: The Veritas Side Rabbet Plane - review *LINK*

#15

Re: side rabbets and snipe bills

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Thanks, Larry & Adam. I knew what a regular snipe bill looks like, but never even knew there were quirk cleaning versions.

Adam, my wooden side rebates look more or less like yours. The real problem with these planes, at least the ones I've bought, is the blades are worn so badly they're too narrow to cut properly, got to figure out what to do with those tiny blades, maybe make some marking/cutting gauges. :)

Pam

Re: The Veritas Side Rabbet Plane - review *LINK*

#16

The best design of the 3?

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>I'm going to have to disagree here Derek. One thing that you missed is that you can replace the fence on the 79 with a angled piece of wood or metal to make a angled fence. It's great for sliding DT's. One thing any of the other planes lack.

Re: The Veritas Side Rabbet Plane - review *LINK*

#17

#79 and sliding dovetails

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>Hi Scott

You may be right! :)

In spite of its foibles, I like the #79. I use it on dovetails as well. In fact, I want to build acouple of specialist fences for it.

A pic taken when I did the LV Router review:



Why do you think that the other side rabbet planes cannot also be used?

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: The Veritas Side Rabbet Plane - review *LINK*

#18

If I understand your question correctly...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>All the others have a single screw to hold the depth stop along with a slot to maintain it's position. I would think a home made aux. fence would tend to rotate off the set angle because it would be difficult to make a fence that would lock into the little slots.

Re: The Veritas Side Rabbet Plane - review *LINK*

#19

Gripping the Stanley 98 and 99 planes

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>Derek says, in his review, "The knob of the LN [takeoff of the Stanley 98/99 planes] is small and is grasped 'delicately' between a finger, thumb and palm. While the least comfortable of the three, it is still quite manageable. Overall, however, it lacks the sense of solidness of the other two planes."

I can't speak for the Lie-Nielsen takeoffs on the Stanley 98 and 99 - indeed, I can't speak for what a brand-new 98/99 would have been - but I grip my vintage Stanley 98/99 planes differently. The grip I use is quite solid feeling. Picture #1 below.

I also find that the little upturn of the body at the tip accommodates the thumb of the other hand when that's desired.


img

Re: The Veritas Side Rabbet Plane - review *LINK*

#20

More and another picture

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>On my Stanley set (well...is it a set when eBay provided them at different times?), the cutting iron does not stick out past the body, permitting the knob to serve as a sort of palm rest, similarly to the handles on the squirrel-tail mini-block planes, like the Stanley 100.

I note that the iron on the LN planes is rather longer, and might well irritate the fingers if the plane were gripped that way. I don't know if my planes were like that from the factory and just used, or shorter to start with. Easy enough to shorten the iron, though - hard for me to believe that any of us could use up a side rabbet iron in our working lives, so a lost 1/4" would probably not hurt.


img

Re: The Veritas Side Rabbet Plane - review *LINK*

#21

Here's the other side

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>Thanks to the miracle of bathroom mirrors, I can show you what this grip looks like on the opposite side. Cleverly, the old Stanley planes use a thumbscrew for the blade clamp that, on both of mine, aligns perfectly as a rest for the index finger when the clamp is tight. Undoubtedly coincidental.

It would appear that the middle and third fingers would brush against the wood; I find, in practice, that these kind of naturally move up out of the way.


img

Re: The Veritas Side Rabbet Plane - review *LINK*

#22

Re: Gripping the Stanley 98 and 99 planes

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>Hi Bill

I have used the LN #98/99 as you demo the Stanley version. It is a secure grip, but very uncomfortable. The edges of the body and the rear of the blade cut into ones palm. I just cannot believe that this is how Stanley intended its use if my experience with LN is the same. So I came to use it in two ways.

The first is as in my demo, but what was omitted was that I use my other hand to steady the front (you really do not want to see the state of my right hand - I have cuts everywhere!). This is a strong and comfortable grip.

The second method is to hold the knob in the same way, but when pulling the plane towards myself. This is also comfortable, but not as powerful as the first method.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: The Veritas Side Rabbet Plane - review *LINK*

#23

Re: Gripping the Stanley 98 and 99 planes

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>Your experience is more extensive than mine, but, in my limited use, I have't found discomfort. And, certainly, it's not because of the non-existent calluses on my bureaucratic hands. Perhaps my old Stanleys have just had their rough edges worn off; and, as I mentioned, the blades are considerably shorter than LN's from the factory, so they don't stick up past the top of the body.

Re: The Veritas Side Rabbet Plane - review *LINK*

#24

Re: Gripping the Stanley 98 and 99 planes

Dan Clermont in Burnaby

>I concur with Bill on this one and grip my 98/99 side rabbet planes in a similar manner. I use two hands and find the control to be good. I have the LN version and have not found the edges to rub me the wrong way.

FWIW I push my side rabbet planes and don't thing pulling would be as effective/controlled

Dan Clermont