Low bench heights revisited, again...
John Aniano in NJ...
>Hello All,
In a recent post, several folks talked about ideal bench heights. I'm planning a French (Roubo-style) bench, probably around 10' long. Oak top, cherry legs, oak stretchers. I've got all the wood and I wish to begin rough sawing the legs to length, so...
A few folks mentioned the height of a top should be a "thigh height". Wilbur P. suggested "...let your hand fall to your side and make the top the height of the base of your thumb...". Adam C. suggested "...my current Nicholson bench is a good 1-1/2" under palm height wearing my favorite work shoes...".
Both Wilbur's and Adam's methods gets me around a 29-1/2" tall bench top when wearing my typical work shoes. Now I know I'm not all that tall (~5'-6") but if I make a bench ~29" tall it will be MUCH shorter than what I'm used to - namely around 33" tall.
Question 1 - will I really benefit that much by making the bench that short?
Question 2 - I know it will be MY bench, but someday in the future, someone else will no doubt use this bench - am I being an idiot to make the bench that low to suit only 5'-6" me? Or should I throw caution to the wind and be uncaring to the next generation of probably taller woodworkers?
John



