Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

Low bench heights revisited, again...

Posts

Low bench heights revisited, again...

#1

Low bench heights revisited, again...

John Aniano in NJ...

>Hello All,

In a recent post, several folks talked about ideal bench heights. I'm planning a French (Roubo-style) bench, probably around 10' long. Oak top, cherry legs, oak stretchers. I've got all the wood and I wish to begin rough sawing the legs to length, so...

A few folks mentioned the height of a top should be a "thigh height". Wilbur P. suggested "...let your hand fall to your side and make the top the height of the base of your thumb...". Adam C. suggested "...my current Nicholson bench is a good 1-1/2" under palm height wearing my favorite work shoes...".

Both Wilbur's and Adam's methods gets me around a 29-1/2" tall bench top when wearing my typical work shoes. Now I know I'm not all that tall (~5'-6") but if I make a bench ~29" tall it will be MUCH shorter than what I'm used to - namely around 33" tall.

Question 1 - will I really benefit that much by making the bench that short?

Question 2 - I know it will be MY bench, but someday in the future, someone else will no doubt use this bench - am I being an idiot to make the bench that low to suit only 5'-6" me? Or should I throw caution to the wind and be uncaring to the next generation of probably taller woodworkers?

John

Re: Low bench heights revisited, again...

#2

Re: Low bench heights revisited, again...

Wiley Horne--So. Calif

>John,

I suggest simulating your work methods at the new height--and consult with your back-- before committing to something less than 33". One problem I can see with using rules of thumb (as it were), is that the rule is surely based on planing, and yet planes stand different heights off the bench. An 18th or 19th century wooden fore, try, or jointer has about a 3" block for the blade carrier, and a tote on top of that. So the heel of your paw is at bench height + 3". A metal plane has the tote right on the sole plate, so your hand is at bench height + 3/16", say. Do you ever edge joint by hand? If so, do you ever run a square down the edge as a check on squareness? If so, how far over do you want to lean to read the edge?

I'm also curious whether the low-bench bubbas saw joinery at that bench, or have a separate station. Seems like if you're going to plane and saw joinery at the same bench, then a compromise height will be in order. But then, that's just my take--I'm real curious to hear what others say about bench height in regard to planing vs. sawing joinery.

Wiley

Re: Low bench heights revisited, again...

#3

Re: Low bench heights revisited, again...

Ken P

>John, I have a Roubo bench I built a couple years ago. I struggled with the height also, I am about 5-5. I finally settled on 34 inches and it works for me with hand planing. I have on several occasions, when having a lot of planing to do, put a 2 x 12 on the floor to stand on. Obviously I have to lean over more, but it doesn't seem to make a lot of difference either way. I do have another bench I built about thirty years ago that is 37 inches. I use it a lot of times when I feel the need to be closer to my work. But I could not make myself build one at 29 inches. You will love the Roubo bench.

Ken

Re: Low bench heights revisited, again...

#4

Dale Lenz

Re: Low bench heights revisited, again...

Dale Lenz

>Back in the early 80's Ian Kirby stated in FWW to make a planing bench 4" below your waist. Has worked very well for me. Hurts my back if I do woodcarving but, once again I can plane all day with out discomfort. I'd build the bench for you, someone could always block the bench up if they wished. It's Your Bench!.

Re: Low bench heights revisited, again...

#5

Re: Low bench heights revisited, again...

ThomD

>That's like asking should your taylor make your suit to fit future geenrations or you. Face it, nobody really cares, or probaly will care about a Roubo bench in the future, the Roubo thing seems to have enough life to come back periodically, but in general benches are not a much prized item if ebay prices are anything to go by. If the person using your bench in the future is deserving of your consideration, they will make their own base or probably their own bench.

What maters is the integrity of your work now. Make your bench to suit you specifically. Bench height is the combination of your particular body type, the average size of your work, and the tools you use. I completely agree with the idea of a mock up. One of the stupider things that seems to happen when I build a bench is that I do the base first, party because it is fun, and it provides something to rest the top on as it progresses. There are disadvantages though including unanticipated changes stemming from how the wood yields, or even how hardware pans out. Also making the top first will allow you to mock it up for your tools and work.

Re: Low bench heights revisited, again...

#6

Re: Low bench heights revisited, again...

wilbur

>Hi John,

I was also nervous about the height of the bench using the "base of your thumb" rule. We're pretty much the same height, and my bench is just about 29".

The way I settled on the final height was to make the bench top, and put it on sawhorses so that it was about 31", a little above the "base of the thumb" recommended height. Then I tried using it. After a while, I cut the sawhorse legs down so that the bench top was at 29", and I am currently giving that height a workout.

For me, planing does seem easier at the lower height. There doesn't seem to be any impact on chisel work. If anything, chisel work might be a little easier, because if I am paring vertically, it's a little easier to get over the top of the chisel. Sawing is not much of an issue, but I use Japanese saws, so I usually just put the board down on the benchtop and use the pulling action of the saw to clamp the board down, while I am crouching down in front of the board. I could see how sawing using a vise might be more difficult at a lower height.

Having said that, for the work that you tend to do, which seems pretty detailed, bringing the work up higher might be better. I think that the most salient factor here is that your current bench height seems to work for you. If you don't have any issues with your bench, there's probably no need to rock the boat.

I wouldn't worry about future generations of woodworkers; just pass on your bench to someone who is 5'6". :@)

If you want a quick trial of a lower height bench, come on over sometime!

Re: Low bench heights revisited, again...

#7

Re: Low bench heights revisited, again...

Bob Rozaieski

>I'm 5'6" and my bench top is 33" from the floor. I wish it was about 3" shorter. It's ok for planing with metal bench planes but not ideal as I can't get over top of the plane as much as I would like. This results in more arms and back being used in the planing stroke and therefore increased fatigue, especially using a fore plane and taking a thick shaving on rough lumber. When I use woodies, it definately needs to be lower, maybe 4-5". For chiseling, as Wilbur said, I wish it was lower so I could get over the work more for vertical paring. Also, for using a brace and bit, you want to be able to get over the work and at this height, I can't. I rarely do rough sawing on my bench, preferring to use an 18" high saw bench instead, but on the rare occasions that I do, it is too high for that as well. I don't have a problem sawing joinery at this height, however, this is irrelevant as I can adjust the height of the workpiece in the vise when sawing joinery so a lower bench wouldn't affect this. For carving, I've found the 33" bench too low so I either sit on my sawbench or raise the workpiece up on a carving jack when carving, so again, in this case, a lower bench wouldn't matter.

I say make it a little higher than the rule of thumb, maybe 1-2" higher. Try it out, then stand on a 1x12 or piece of plywood and work some more, then stand on a 2X12 or 2 pieces of plywood and work some more. When you figure out what the most comfortable height for you is, cut the bottoms of the legs down to make it that height. Don't worry about who will use your bench in the future. Make it for you.

Re: Low bench heights revisited, again...

#8

Re: Low bench heights revisited, again...

Dean J in MN

>Do you use metal planes or wooden planes? This will make a difference in bench height choice. When I switched over from metal to woodies I lowered my bench nearly 2 inches.

My bench is about an inch under my palm now, and much better suited to my planes.

I suggest, as others have, mock up a bench and try. I don't know how much you do by hand, but if you work from rough as I do, I'd lean toward a lower bench.

Re: Low bench heights revisited, again...

#9

Your bench, YOUR way !

steve mackay

>

Re: Low bench heights revisited, again...

#10

Re: Low bench heights revisited, again...

Bjenk Ellefsen

>Like Dean said, the bench height depends on which tools you use and your height. You can always shorten the legs to tweak it later but you can't make it higher. Go for slightly higher if you are not sure then you can always cut it down later.

I'm 6 feet tall and I have built mine at 31.5 inches. It would have been great at 31.

The French bench was designed for hand tools and wooden planes. Here's exactly what Roubo said on this matter:

"The height of the workbench is ordinarily 30� but because workmen are not all of the same height, suffice it to say that the workbench must not be higher than the top of the thighs of the person working at the bench. If it were higher, it would deprive him of his strength and it would expose him to bad posture in a short time."

The french pouce was about 1.066 inches so its about 31.98 inches. This height is a general guide which must be adjusted to the worker, this is important.

Only through trying to do what you usually do will you find the truth! I planed wood on my kitchen table because it is 30 inches in height just to feel it (while my wife was out of course).

Re: Low bench heights revisited, again...

#11

Re: Low bench heights revisited, again...

John Aniano in NJ...

>Hello All,

Thanks for the many great suggestions! Wilbur, I plan to make a second higher bench for the "detailed" bow making work I do (it will have space for my feet since I generally do bow making while sitting down), so this French bench is more for regular woodworking tasks. Ever since "The Workbench Book" came out, I've always wanted to make the Roubo bench. With Chris Schwarz's new book, I only get more inspiration to take the plunge. And after buying the raw material a few weeks ago, I have no excuses anymore!

I generally use hand tools primarily since I don't own many large power tools, i.e. large planers, tablesaws, etc. I have both wooden and metal planes, and for regular task, I favor the latter. I've often felt lacking power when doing moldings since my current bench (~33") and a typical molding plane + the stock, is too tall for my height. Perhaps the lower bench sized to my body would be appropriate. As a mock up, I tried using my large tool box that is 29" high as a work surface and it seems OK but it would take some getting used to. I've used my current bench for maybe 16 years now...

Thanks,

John

Re: Low bench heights revisited, again...

#12

Roubo bench *LINK*

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>John, you may want to take a look at parts 1 and 2 of St. Roy's building a Roubo bench from scratch, season 27, shows 2705-6.

Pam


St. Roy's season 27 online

Re: Low bench heights revisited, again...

#13

Re: Low bench heights revisited, again...

Chuck Taylor

>I'm planning to build a new bench "soon", so I've been wrestling with this same issue. By the "palm" or "thumb" rule, it should be 30.5" high (I'm 6' tall). My current bench is 34.5" high. By standing on 2x6's, I've simulated working at various heights. I just can't picture working at 30.5", but 33" feels about right for me. I'd say that you should go with the height that feels right for you.

Chuck Taylor

Everett, WA

Re: Low bench heights revisited, again...

#14

Re: Low bench heights revisited, again...

Bjenk Ellefsen

>Chuck, we are the same height. I thought 31.5 would be too low... I was wrong.

Now that I am actually standing at the bench and testing it, I think its slightly too high. You might be surprised at how nice a bench at 30.5 feels with wooden planes.

Re: Low bench heights revisited, again...

#15

Point about wooden planes

Wiley Horne--So. Calif

>Hi Bjenk,

You bring up a good point in re wooden planes. I mentioned the height difference between wooden and metal planes earlier in this thread. The totes on my long woodies sit about 3" higher off the benchtop than the ones on my metal planes. That means the planing hand is 3" higher off the benchtop as well, when using a woodie fore, try, or jointer. I wonder if this fact has anything to do with one grouping of preferences around 33-34", and another grouping around 30-31".

Wiley

Re: Low bench heights revisited, again...

#16

Not so with Japanese wooden planes.

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>

Re: Low bench heights revisited, again...

#17

Re: Not so with Japanese wooden planes.

Wiley Horne--So. Calif

>Pam,

Very true!! I should have specified western woodies. Like yr. C&W jointer.

Wiley

Re: Low bench heights revisited, again...

#18

Re: Low bench heights revisited, again...

Charles

>If I were you I'd knock together a six footer out of sheet goods and dimensional lumber before I'd start the Roubo.

It would be a damned shame to do all that work with expensive stock and end up hating working at the bench.

Re: Low bench heights revisited, again...

#19

Re: Low bench heights revisited, again...

charlie belden

>You can always make a low bench higher. The converse is far more difficult.

With a lower bench height, assuming you're using hand tools mostly, you can use your body weight working for you. With a higher bench you use more muscle - mainly in your back and legs.

And with a lower bench you can kneel - or sit - when doing close work - without leaning over (not good for your lower back). Chopping dovetail sockets, you want your eyes closer to the tip of the chisel - the critical location. And by being low, you can't easily wack the crap out of the end of the chisel with a mallet cause its at head height. That tapping and hitting rather than pounding provides some fine control - and limits the damage of any one stroke.

With a low bench, you can always make a mini-bench that you can clamp to the top to get parts up to power routing height.

And remember, the bench top often serves as the assembly bench. Take just about anything you're likely to build, jack it up in the air 3 and a half feet - then try working on it. Things above shoulder height start getting to be a problem, and if it's above head height seeing joint closure and the like gets tricky..

Some will say build it high and stand on a box if you need to for some operations. Ever stepped of the end of a box while concentrating on what the cutting edge is doing? Ever hit your shin on the top edge of a box. And where the hell are you gonna keep it when not being used?

My vote - go with Arms Haning Down, Wrist Angled So Palm Is Horizontal. Floor to palm seems to be a first cut at bench top height.

What you sacrifice is storage space under the bench

Re: Low bench heights revisited, again...

#20

Re: Low bench heights revisited, again...

Charles

>I'd hate to build a Roubo and then find that it needs to sit on blocks.

That's like putting cheap tires on a Maserati.

Re: Low bench heights revisited, again...

#21

Re: Low bench heights revisited, again...

charlie belden

>Charles wrote:

I'd hate to build a Roubo and then find that it needs to sit on blocks.

That's like putting cheap tires on a Maserati.

=======

As opposed to P6s on a pick up truck?

Or standing on a platform to get high enough to use your body weight when planing? Then-

barking a shin on the platform later?

And let's face it - floors are seldom flat and

level - especially in converted garages so at

least one leg will need either a shim or two

or better yet - a leg leveler.

OR - after you get the bench where it's gonna

be for the next decade or two - you CAN plane

the top flat again if it twists because the floor

ain't flat and level and shims or a leg level offends your sense of aesthetics ; )

Re: Low bench heights revisited, again...

#22

Re: Point about wooden planes

Bjenk Ellefsen

>Wiley, exactly! My bench does ok with metal plane its definitely not the same. However, I am perfectly comfortable while using my Western wooden planes! Just like Roubo indicated, my strength is not robbed by the height and my posture is just great to push the planes.