We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
>The October issue of Woodwork magazine arrived with this note at the end of the editorial. "Unfortunately Ross Periodicals will stop publishing Woodwork with December 2008 issue. Fortunately, there are plans in place for another publisher to take over the magazine and continue the spirit of Woodwork insto the future. More information about this transition will appear in the next issue."
This is disappointing news to me. Woodwork definately marched to a different drummer than other woodworking magazines which is why I value it. Each issue follows about the same formula with a nice mix of articles: one long, in-depth one about a woodworker, one or two on building a piece of furniture, a turning project, something on tools, frequently a bit of history, and some news. No basic how-to-do-it.
Hopefully it will continue in close to the current form.
>which ruined American Woodworker (although I've seen a couple of recent issues which are better than after the initial takeover, it's still not up to the standards Ellis set).
I'll be holding my breath. Although some of their articles are a bit hifalutin, they definitely touch on areas no one else does, and are well worth it for that reason. At the moment, they're one of the two magazines I'd keep if I had to cut back to two (Chris Schwarz, your ears should be burning, because Pop WW is the other).
I was nearly a charter subscriber (issue 3 or so), then dropped for a while when I was broke, then picked up again - but later tracked down the missing issues, so it's one of the magazines that I decided 'twas worthwhile to get all the issues.
>Woodwork is one of my favorites too. A little "artsy" from time to time but definitely a refreshing change from the norm ;>) I echo Bill's hope that Readers' Digest is not the successor, and I hope the new publisher keeps the flavor.
>I wish we weren't so dismisive of artsy or hifalutin content. Of course there can be pretentious stuff that isn't worth one's time. But I really don't see the point in paying big bucks for articles on how to set up a plane or bicuit joint a vanity that anyone here could probably write (even if they had never done either, as one sometimes suspects is the case in lessors mags). At the end of the day the mechanics of woodworking should only take a few years to pick up, even at a high level.
>They went downhill after their first few issues. IMHO there are enough weekend-project magazines. Woodwork's in-depth artist profiles would be sorely missed.
>Actually, I like some of the artsy stuff in Woodwork Magazine. That's part of what I meant when I said the magazine is a refreshing change from a lot of what's published under the woodworking banner. I do think, however, that some of the studio furniture featured in the magazine is over the top. It's more sculpture than furniture. That's O.K. too, if you're into that sort of thing. I'm not, so it interests me only for curiosity's sake. I don't get much out of it that I can use in my work. Didn't mean to be "dismissive."
>No problem, and I probably shouldn't attach my coments to fair opinions of others. I feel the same way about some of the self-absorbed studio furniture, though I suppose the best stuff out there would fall into the studio genre, even if I don't have a place for it.
I really like that magazine, better than FWW for that matter, which has come and gone out of favour with me thru the years.
The first part I always looked at, was the gallery of work. Even if I find some of the stuff really out there, I still can find inspiration, or just plain admires others's work, even if I have no expectation of measuring up to.
Like others have said here, its the mix of articles and their contents that I found refreshing.
And for the record, I too really got turned off by American Woodworker under Reader Digest ownership, yuckkk
Bob, who wonder if thats why Woodwork suddendly dissapeared off the bookshelves around here....
>They had stopped taking subscriptions a while back, and that was a curious thing.
Their offices are in the Bay Area, and we got to see and meet some of their folks fairly regularly. John Levine, their editor, came and spoke to our woodworkers' club a couple of years ago.
Their inclusion of work from Australia, and sometimes England, was a good thing, showing a broader swath of the craft than was often the case in other publications. We here in the Bay Area were spoiled, though, in that our locals were regulars in their pages.
I will look for who takes it over with some anticipation. It's been a favorite, because, even when the articles are of simple projects, they never seem to talk down to me. They feel as though there are real people behind each one.
>My sense is that artsy is the next level. The problem I see is that guys make furniture but don't themselves understand it. Hearing them talking about being inspired by the grain of the walnut is just useless drivel and a waste of my time.
Real artists understand their craft. They know why we like stuff and why we don't. Stuff that people like that is accidental is called a "happening" in the art world. But as "happenings" can't be controlled or produced on demand, they aren't taken seriously or respected.
I liken it to a NASCAR engine mechanic. Those guys know what it takes to make an engine produce more hp and torque. And they can explain it. They don't get lucky turning their wrenches and suddenly produce more power.
I'I guess I've not seen the artistic analysis done well in woodworking magazines. Regardless of what Garret Hack says, he's a reproduction furniture maker. His use of period tools and techniques probably also earns him the title of period woodworker as well. Artistically, he's got a lot more in common with Underhill than Nakashima. His work can be new and fresh, but it's not what I think of as either "modern" or "studio" furniture. It's Sheraton with some different materials. If you didn't know furniture style, you could easily pass Rob Millard's work off as modern.
If you really want to try something different, tune into Bravo's "Project Runway". What I like about it is that they actually discuss what they like and don't like about the designs (before they vote the designers off the island- I'm so over reality TV).
Some of the designs (and designers) are looney with little or no artistic merit. Its amzing how someone can take a gorgeous runway model and make her look like a female impersonator or drag queen. But others clearly have something in mind. They control their medium to make their point (I don't always like their point, but that's okay).
I think TV in general is a waste of time. But this show is on late at night here. So after I'm done working and emailing everyone on the planet, and I'm lying on the couch with my autographed copy of Schwarz' Workbench book (darn that's a good book) I tune in Project Runway and generally get something out of it. I think it's worth your while just because there's some objective analysis. I would like it more if there was more. Maybe Schwarz should vote me off the island as a sort of popularity stunt. I could cry and hug Glen Huey.
>Adam, I don't think you've followed his work that much...
A while ago, I pulled out a series of furniture pictures for some fellows around here to "judge". I left out Hack's pieces from that collection, because his style is too easily recognizable :-)
And his style is nowhere related to either Underhill or Nakashima, trust me...
>"Real artists understand their craft. They know why we like stuff and why we don't." I don't think that's necessarially true. I'm not even sure they necessarially know why they like it. Art critics like to think they know why folks like or don't like stuff. But art critics are neccessarialy artists, and vice-versa.
Most craftsman who manage to stay afloat financially know what people like and don't like. If they don't any financial success is accidental.
Is Andrew Wyeth an artist or craftsman? A quick look at one of his paintings might lead one to believe he's just a fellow who is talented at painting scenes. But after viewing a number of works in several museums I see more than just simple scenes.
A few weeks ago we visited the Center for Furniture Craftsmanship gallery in Rockport, Maine and viewed their "faculty" show. Garret Wade had a piece there, a simple wall cabinet. But it was much more than just a simple wall cabinet someone might knock together to store a few items in. The design had a number of subtle elements. And the craftsmanship was also exellent.
>> Real artists understand their craft. They know why we like stuff and why we don't. Stuff that people like that is accidental is called a "happening" in the art world. But as "happenings" can't be controlled or produced on demand, they aren't taken seriously or respected.
Adam, I agree with you that good artists understand their craft, but I hope you are not suggesting "real" artists would only create art that people would like. As I am sure you are well aware, art history is replete with movements that were initially disliked only to be embraced later. The artists that were at the forefront of these movements certainly knew what they were working on would be contrary to the existing public taste.
> I liken it to a NASCAR engine mechanic. Those guys know what it takes to make an engine produce more hp and torque. And they can explain it. They don't get lucky turning their wrenches and suddenly produce more power.
As far as this statement, I truly hope you are not equating artists to NASCAR engine mechanics.
>"Hearing them talking about being inspired by the grain of the walnut is just useless drivel and a waste of my time."
I wouldn't accept that as a blanket statement. I always like to mention the sculpture that was on the back of an issue of FWW many moons ago. It showed two long trunks that had been bent into U like shapes. The artist mentioned his search for form within the wood, and how he liked to liberate it, which was ludicrous in the context of a distorted tree.
There are lots of aesthetic decisions that figure does dictate. I suppose you may actually mean "grain" in which case it could just be terminology. But the pattern in a beautiful piece of wood can certainly inspire just like any other example of natural beauty. A bookmatched panel is a natural Rorschach test and could inspire a person in almost any direction.
"Real artists understand their craft. They know why we like stuff and why we don't. Stuff that people like that is accidental is called a "happening" in the art world. But as "happenings" can't be controlled or produced on demand, they aren't taken seriously or respected."
Found objects can be used to create artistic effects, and that takes them out of the accidental realm. Even so, there is little real art in furniture, depending on what definition one is using. "Artsy" can simply arise when people experience a distain for stuff that attempts more than they are happy to. It can be a rejection of refinement, ornamentation et... I am not looking for woodworking magazines to read like art magazine, particularly given the BS content in the art world. But I do know where crafts go if they grow. People accept to somehow become more present in their work than is required at the purely mechanical level. I've seen it happen in other crafts, if people hold back they are just restricting their own development. Nothing wrong with that, but it is depressing that we have more woodworking mags than ever and the discusion level is lower than ever, and the skills level of readers is higher than ever. Time to take a leap to the next step.
>It's a bit artys,yes to a point. The true form always comes thru. I can't remember a biscuit jointer article yet a how to with power tools in one of there issues. I really think you need to rethink your post.
And that's precisely just what I expect of artists. I don't possess much of an artistic vision, but I definitely appreciate the perspective of those who can take that next step. That's what I like about Woodwork.
>At the Williamsburg conference last year, Hack did a retrospective of his work and talked about his inspiration for each piece. His inspiration came from the wood, from found objects, and Shaker and Sheraton furniture in museums in New England (and he showed slides of the specific pieces).
If you just google "Garret Hack furniture", you'll see simple candle stands and hunt boards, and bow front chests of drawers, all in pleasing Sheraton styles. There are some material substitutions, some differences in ornamentation, but their form is unmistakably Sheraton. BTW, Shaker is a deconstructionistic style. It deconstructs Sheraton mostly.
It's important to be able to see these relationships in one's own work. I talked to Garret and I think he does see it. I'm not sure he would label himself as a reproduction furnituremaker (though the shoe certainly fits) , but he definitely sees his work as borrowing heavily from the past and on specific Sheraton pieces. His clearly isn't work that came to him in a dream.
Just in case anyone isn't following- I really like Garret Hack's work and I found him personally very affable and charming. I think it's really neat to take an old style and dress it up and make it your own. What we call Chippendale is exactly that. The style created no new furniture forms. Its a style of ornamentation only.
Adam said, "...Real artists understand their craft...."
There's a great deal known to us which supports this thought. To take a couple of examples from music.....J. S. Bach, who is generally recognized as being at the pinnacle of western music, was thoroughly grounded in every aspect of singing, playing, and composing. His employment forced him to produce creditable work almost daily, on demand, and his output over his lifetime was prodigious. And the quality of that output amazing. In one particular anecdote, he visited King Frederick of Prussia one time and was most warmly received. The King, who played flute himself in the court orchestra, cancelled practice when 'old Bach' arrived, and immediately took Bach to test out his 7 organs--Bach was the last word in organ playing and composing. Bach then asked the King to suggest a theme, and the King gave him some 21 notes in a string and asked if Bach could compose a three-voice fugue using them. Bach did this on the spot under the gaze of the King and everyone else present in a virtuoso show of skill--this is not an urban legend, it was reported in the papers of the day--then went back home and refined the proceedings into an expanded body of music including 4- and 6-voice pieces, all based on the King's theme, and presented it to the King at a later date. We know this music to this day as 'A Musical Offering'. Point: Bach knew his craft so well, that he could extemporaneously produce--under performance pressure--music that would be played and enjoyed centuries later.
Mozart wrote his last three symphonies--Nos. 39, 40, and 41--during a 3-month period in I believe 1788. Any one of these works would be considered the crowning glory of a composer's career. Each was highly innovative. And particularly the 40th and 41st were examples of craft taken to an extreme. Mozart's output was prodigious also.
I took Adam's point to be that art and craft blend together as one, for those practicing at a very high level.
>"...we have more woodworking mags than ever and the discusion level is lower than ever, and the skills level of readers is higher than ever. Time to take a leap to the next step."
I think the problem is that there are so many people who AREN'T at that level, and that there's a lot of work going on to take skill and craft out of the hobby that the magazines are trying to foster. Dominos and jeigh jigs and lunchbox planers and so on and so forth... it's easier than ever to do some really horrible things to some really nice wood. I think the discussion level in here is very high. Having spent 3 years selling tools to new woodworkers, I have to say that there are a lot of people who really don't know very much, but they're buying into whatever they read about in the glossy pages. I had one guy return a router, unopened, because he read a review that said something else was better... came in with the box in hand, and was mad that we at the store didn't tell him that the other one would be reviewed better.
I think that Adam makes a good point. There's a lot more to the art than just butchering wood. Anyone with time and a little intelligence can put the pieces together with a domino and a leigh jig. That doesn't mean that the end result is going to be pretty or worth building. The ability to cut joinery by hand, or by machine, does not translate into artistic vision, or any kind of sense about how the final piece should turn out. It just means you can put two pieces of wood together.
The discussion level in those magazines is necessarily low. They have sponsors to keep happy, and they're not trying to sell many of those tools to the experienced old hands. Experience will tell you if a tool is useful or not. They're pandering to the beginners... to the new blood that has helped woodworking swell to be a huge hobby market. The new guys don't know any better, so they'll buy what they're told is a good tool. That in turn serves the tool companies interests, which is why the magazines are there. Some are better than others, but the bottom line is still to make money, and that gets made through advertising.
And to be honest, the discussion level at the corporate level isn't always that high either. There's a very well known retailer of fine tools, whose new tool development team consists of a lady who ran a bike store, who's a confessed novice, a guy who restores motorcycles, but says he really likes power tools, and a career retail man. No woodworkers anywhere. And this is all on their website. And some of their choices lately on what the hot new products should be reflect that... last I heard, their big thing was pen and sheath knife kits. I'm sure that they're perfectly nice people, but that doesn't make them authorities on what real woodworkers need.
Artists and Artisans make objects of art, and of quality. Tool vendors make profits from the sale of tools. Magazines make profits by advertising for tool vendors and manufacturers. Doesn't make them great woodworkers, but that doesn't mean they're not good businessmen. (or businesswomen.)
Leave the high level discussion to the woodworkers, and leave the glossy pages and Taunton coffee table books to the hobbyists. And accept the fact that the retailers are looking at profit margins, because they're vendors, not artisans.
Many of the people reading the magazines think they can get what they need out of the box. Most of the high level conversations I have are with people who understand that out of the box is good, but modified to do what you need it to is better. Out of the box is not what they're looking for... but it's what the magazines are advertising and talking about.
>as it is the commentary. Often, the author seems to be describing air. Now, granted, there are very few ways to talk about the aesthetic without a certain amount of airspeak - words may not be the best language for such topics - but I have seen good artists talk about aesthetic subjects in down to earth, plain, clear ways. Not all the "Woodwork" authors have that skill.
Nevertheless, as others have said, I appreciate what this magazine has offered from its inception.
Re: For me, the artsiness isn't so much the furnit
Wiley Horne--So. Calif
>Bill,
You're right, it's the commentary. Making anything, even shiny furniture, is gonna be a dirty mess in the actual doing, which keeps the makers out of the clouds.
Regarding Woodwork, I just received the October issue today. Enjoyed it, too. I liked Drew Langsner's tribute to John Brown, and the major article on David Marks, and a piece on the sloyd tradition in Sweden. And a big retrospective on Martin Puryear's sculpture. And a good piece on furniture refinishing.
The thing is, none of the articles that I liked reflect my preferences, which tend toward furniture which holds a lot of stuff--that's the main criterion for me, I need to cram a lot of stuff in there. But. What Woodwork does is that it tells me a whole bunch of stuff that I didn't know before; introduces me to people that I haven't heard of; and generally helps keep brain-petrification at bay for a while longer. My definition of brain-petrification is where if something does not match my own specific preferences, then I hate it. I need to keep that away a while longer.
The Editor's remark was that the new owner is going to continue things as they are. We'll see.
"new owner is going to continue things as they are
Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA
>This is, of course, impossible. A different set of people, different publisher - it'll be different. I recall when Terrie Noll was editor - the magazine differed then from what it is now.
All that's fine - so long as the fundamental esprit of the magazine remains intact.