Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

Question for Rob Lee

Posts

Question for Rob Lee

#1

Question for Rob Lee

Patrick Gibbons, Houston, TX

>Once upon a time you were a bit skeptical about the benefits of cryogenically treating A2 steel and did not utilize this process with your own manufacture. Are you still unrepentent or have you seen the light of the way of freezing metal?

Re: Question for Rob Lee

#2

Re: And...

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>have you considered laid steel blades that are brine quenched?

Stephen

Re: Question for Rob Lee

#3

Re: Question for Rob Lee

Rob Lee

>Hi -

No cryo here... still don't see the benefit for A2, nor for some other steels where processes are well controlled...

If we can't see a demonstrable benefit, then we sure don't want to use it, and charge you extra for it...

We have tested cryo/non-cryo blades in an automated test platform, through tens of thousands of cuts...and found no difference.... our blades, and other peoples blades...

I'm satisfied with our decision... but am always open to empirical data...

Cheers -

Rob

Re: Question for Rob Lee

#4

others driven by science agree

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>This opinion is reinforced by the technical service staff at Crucible Products, suppliers of CPM3V.

It sure would be nice to see some data from LV on edge retention, sharpening and other factors of interest. There are journals that would publish this kind of work and we could order reprints from the catalog.

Re: Question for Rob Lee

#5

Re: others driven by science agree

paul womack

>It sure would be nice to see some data from LV on edge retention, sharpening and other factors of interest. There are journals that would publish this kind of work and we could order reprints from the catalog.

I'm sure some of LV's competitors would agree :-)

BugBear

Re: Question for Rob Lee

#6

Re: And...

Rob Lee

>Hi Stephen -

Short answer is no...

Nothing wrong with laminated steel - it's just not a "mass production" process, nor one we could have easily done locally. Not that out volumes would be so high - but laser or water jet cutting blades from sheet, and then running through a batch heat treat is *very* straight forward, controllable, and dependable.

Cheers -

Rob

Re: Question for Rob Lee

#7

Re: Question for Rob Lee

ThomD

>I had some chisels from Barr that were Chryod, and they were indistinguishable in use. I got the set of 4 and added in 3 others that weren't chryod in various sizes, as the chryo wasn't available outside the sets at the time. Hardly definative, but interesting.

Re: Question for Rob Lee

#8

Thanks Rob

Patrick Gibbons, Houston, TX

>I remember you stating you were testing the benefits of cryo but never saw anything else about it. I was interested to see what the testing revealed. It's interesting to think about the myths that A2 has generated. The first was that it couldn't be sharpened as keenly as other tool steels and then the necessity of cryo treating to finish the tempering process. Also that oil stones won't sharpen it. Most argue that Arkansas stones don't work so well with A2. But no one ever comments on India stones, which seem to abrade A2 as quickly as O2 in my experience. I agree that Arkansas stones are much slower with A2, so I use a charged leather for final honing sometimes. And yes, I'll break out my diamond medium on occasion. It's frustrating that one has to work through untruths first before the real points of consideration are reached. For me concerning A2, the real issues were the need to change my method of sharpening with different media or just use more time to do it balanced against increased time a blade remained sharp; and different optimal angles for sharpness and edge retention. After 4 or 5 years now I have preferences for when I prefer A2 over O2 and when I don't.