Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

Speaking of cambering

Posts

Speaking of cambering

#1

Speaking of cambering

wilbur

>I thought I had asked this question before, but I can't seem to find it.

How do you all go about establishing a camber on a smoothing plane blade? Do you establish it first with the coarser grit stages of sharpening, or wait for the finer grits?

My main sharpening routine involves 1000, 5000, and 8000 grit waterstones, along with a 325 grit diamond plate, and I'm not sure of the optimal method of getting a nice smoothing plane camber is with this setup. I have a method, but lately it seems to me that it could stand improving.

Just to be clear, I am fine with the amount of camber that I want (about 0.003" or thereabouts). What I am trying to figure out is the best way to get there.

Re: Speaking of cambering

#2

Re: Speaking of cambering

Dave Mount

>My sharpening process is a Tormek to hollow grind then 1000, 4000, and 8000 waterstones. I start the camber on the Tormek. After sharpening straight across in the basic jig, I just push a little on one corner of the iron, then on the other. It's pretty brief, maybe 5 seconds or so. I freehand on the stones. I take a few swipes with a couple fingers on the middle part of the bevel, then a swipe or two with just on finger on a corner, then the other. I don't change the angle of the iron relative to the stone, I just put pressure only on the corner of the iron to focus the wear there. I have no idea what the true dimensions of the camber are, it just works for me. It's also probably not an arc, but more of a straight with the last 1/4" or so dying away. Works for me. If I overdo the corners, I just take some more swipes on the 1000 grit with my fingers centered and work back up the grits without touch the center again.

Actually, after the 8000 I swipe the iron a couple times on a piece of MDF with LV green stuff on it. I use the same middle-then each corner process on that.

Pretty qualitative but it works for me.

Best,

Dave

Re: Speaking of cambering

#3

Re: Speaking of cambering

Marc in Luxembourg

>First I grind a 25� bevel on the Tormek - straight and square. Then I switch to a 800 grit King Stone and an Eclipse type honing guide. There I establish the camber, 30� microbevel. I pass to an 8000 grit waterstone by honing a second microbevel. For this I raise the blade a millimeter in the guide. Finally I come to honing compound on leather.

I always stopped at the 8000 grit waterstone, but shortly came to use a polished blade and was impressed by its sharpness. I'm not sure yet if I will continue on the leather. Maybe this rounds over the bevel...

Marc

Re: Speaking of cambering

#4

4 grits past Tormek?

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>I am surprised that so many grit steps are necessary when starting with a hollow grind. The main reasons to use a hollow grind is to be able to skip grits, as well as the advantages a hollow has on free hand honing.

The first step for you and Marc leaves a hollow grind with a scratch depth greatly less than what I get off a grinding wheel. Proceeding from this state on to a flat abrasive surface, in your case water stone , the abrasion occurs as a small band at the edge and heel of the bevel. It doesn't take much metal removal to remove the grinder scratches from this tiny band at the tool edge, even from an 80 grit wheel. If you haven't tried it, skip your coarser waterstone grits and try going to your final water stone grit, ideally, free hand.

If the edge from the Tormek is not straight, then indeed the coarser grits are required to straighten the edge before proceeding to the final grit. But with a bit of patience and confidence it should be a simple task to get a straight edge with the Tormek. The honing bright band at the edge from the previous sharpening is used as a guide to judge material removal in the wheel grinding. Many do it routinely with a 3600 rpm grinder.

Re: Speaking of cambering

#5

Re: Speaking of cambering

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>Hi Wilbur

I am not enamored with a machine creating a camber on a blade. I recall David Charlesworth mentioning that he sometimes uses the loose blade holder on his Tormek to do so.

I do not like the machine for a camber simply because each blade is a little different - the bevel edge is wider, thicker, thinner, harder steel, softer steel - and the camber needs to be developed for each. This may sound pedantic, but in practice it takes no extra time at all, just a little extra thought.

Whether I use a Tormek for a hollow grind or a belt sander for a flat grind, the next step is to follow up with waterstones, in my case Shaptons.

My method is a modified version of David Charlesworth's "honing by numbers" (my name for it). The camber is created on the 1000 grit waterstone. The remaining stones are there to polish the edge.

1. With the 1000 stone, hone a straight bevel and stop once you have a decent wire edge. Standard stuff.

2. Now remove the wire edge on your final polishing stone. This may be a 8000 or 12000. I know that some prefer to remove the wire edge at the end - in fact it should diminish in size with each successive polishing stone. However by removing the wire edge you are better able to determine the progress of the next step. I remove the wire edge at the completion of every stone.

3. Placing pressure on one side of the bevel, pull the blade back. Count the number of strokes it takes to create the wire edge size you want. This will equal the amount of camber created. Do the same on the other side of the blade. That is, hone the same number of strokes on that side. Again remove the wire edge.

4. Now progress to the polishing stones. I go 5000, 8000, and sometimes 12000. These are not going to remove much metal, less with each finer grit, and this is the reason the camber was created on the 1000 stone.

5. I continue to count the number of strokes taken on each side since I want to make sure that the camber is symmetrical. The essential element, however, is that you remove all the scratches of the previous grit before moving to the next stone. On average this may only require 5 or 6 strokes on each side - but this does depend on the size (thickness) of the secondary bevel.

Hope this helps.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Speaking of cambering

#6

Re: Speaking of cambering

Frank D. in Montreal

>I start small cambers on the 1000 stone when I use waterstones (or the fine India with oil stones). When I start on a finer stone it takes me too long (and wears the stone for nothing) to get a camber. I too just go with finger pressure on each side. For me it's 10 strokes with pressure on each side, then 10 strokes with pressure about a third of the way in (on each side of the blade). That's just an example though; after a few times you should be able to adjust and find the right number of strokes to get you where you want (I never measure my camber, I just try it out and correct it the next time I sharpen).

Re: Speaking of cambering

#7

Maintaining a camber

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>Wilbur, you asked this question around three weeks ago on another forum. At the time I noticed you did not get a response; sorry I forgot about it.

Generally shaping is done on the coarsest stone or a grinder. A more constant chore is keeping the camber where you want it. I use stones only, no grinder. It seems that the highly cambered irons tend to flatten out over time and the very mildly cambered irons tend to become more cambered. At every sharpening I spend a few extra seconds on the coarse stone compensating for these tendencies.

Re: Speaking of cambering

#8

Re: Maintaining a camber

wilbur

>Ah, yes. No response. Now I know why I couldn't find the answer to my question. :@)

Re: Speaking of cambering

#9

Re: Speaking of cambering

wilbur

>Thanks for the input, everyone! That did help. I think I had been trying to work the camber at a grit that was too high. I'll try establishing the camber on my 1000 grit stone and see how that goes.

Re: Speaking of cambering

#10

Re: Speaking of cambering *LINK*

Brent in Montreal

>I usually do it the same way as Frank. Sometimes I'll start on my Tormek. There are also these available;


Odate Crowning Plates

Re: Speaking of cambering

#11

Re: Maintaining a camber

Kevin Adams

>Warren--

Just curious with no grinder, can you provide a very brief description of your shapening routine? What grits/stones and do you go back to the coarse stone for each resharpening or just touch up the edge frequently on a fine stone/strop so it never becomes a big chore? Do you use micro-bevels? Have you ever tried a grinder/hollow grinding or is this just the way you have always done it?

Thanks.

Kevin

Re: Speaking of cambering

#12

Re: Maintaining a camber

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>I use flat bevels; it is never a big chore. I start with the same stone each time. I tried a grinder many years ago, but I found there was a loss of precision, especially in maintaining a very subtle camber. Toshio Odate wrote (1984) "Commonly 1200X is coarse enough to hone dull blades, so if it does not seem to be, perhaps you went to long without sharpening." The skill is to sharpen at the appropriate time for your initial stone.

For plane irons and wide chisels about 90 seconds:

800 King

1200 King

Washita

Soft Arkansas

Black Hard Arkansas (Sometimes)

strop

For carving tools about 40 seconds

Washita

Soft Arkansas

Black Hard Arkansas

strop

For turning gouges about 2 minutes

Coarse SiC

Medium SiC

Washita

Soft Arkansas

strop

Re: Speaking of cambering

#13

Re: Maintaining a camber

Kevin Adams

>Thanks, Warren. Anything on that strop or just untreated? Do you by chance have a website? I would enjoy seeing some of your pieces. You've made a living with just hand tools for years now, right?

Take care,

Kevin

Re: Speaking of cambering

#14

Re: Speaking of cambering - MyTormek Jig... *LINK*

John Aniano - in NJ...

>Folks,

In 2004 I posted this here at WC. It might not be applicable for smoothers - it produces a small tight radiused curve - I use it for scrub planes...

John


Tormek cambering jig

Re: Speaking of cambering

#15

Re: Maintaining a camber

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>I use a dry strop. The whole question of strop preparations is very complicated. Whether you want a powder or a paste or a waxy carrier, whether you want an abrasive of a certain size or one that breaks down into finer pieces as you go and just how fast it breaks down, the dubbing concern, the hardness of the leather, and the technique of the worker, are all interesting questions.

I work almost exclusively for other woodworkers; there are lots of shops in our area and a lot of cooperation amongst them. I will email you, Kevin.

Re: Speaking of cambering

#16

Re: Maintaining a camber

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>Joel at TFWW sells a marvelous strop. It is hard horse butt leather, and resists dubbing very well.

I use two, one charged with green rouge (.5 microns) and one plain leather, both glued (smooth side up) to hardwood boards to maintain flatness. Some like to use a strop leather without a backing, but it curls and that is when I think there is a great danger of dubbing. I tried .5 micron diamond paste instead of the green crayon, but found that the crayon worked best.

I am not sure whether one should correctly term the green rouge-on-leather as a strop since it removed metal. However both strops are wonderful at removing any vestige of a wire edge, and both create a mirror shine. Both will take an edge from sharp to extremely sharp.

The green rouge is particularly useful in maintaining an edge as you work. I keep the strops hanging on a hook under the bench and pull them out as needed.

I would be interested in the technique of others. What I do when stropping is to work on both the bevel face and the back of the blade. In particular, a strop is useful here with BU plane blades as it minimises the wear bevel.

With the exception of BU plane blades, I avoid secondary bevels at a different angle to the primary bevel angle. I hollow grind all my BD plane blades and chisels. Trying to strop a secondary bevel is difficult, too difficult for I. Stropping a hollow ground blade like this is no different from stropping a flat ground blade.

It works for me.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Speaking of cambering

#17

Re: Maintaining a camber

paul womack

>I am not sure whether one should correctly term the green rouge-on-leather as a strop since it removed metal.

In that case, what do consider a true "strop" to be, and what is its action?

BugBear

Re: Speaking of cambering

#18

Thanks, Warren.

Kevin Adams

>

Re: Speaking of cambering

#19

Re: Maintaining a camber

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>Hi BB

On reflection I think that what I have is correctly termed a strop (and not a hone, as I was contemplating). Strops are commonly used with polishing compounds. They remove metal. As do hones. So what is the technical difference between a hone and a strop? In my mind a hone removes more metal than a strop. But where is the dividing line (if there is one)?

And where does a plain leather strop fit into the schema? Mine certainly polishes. Not as aggressively as the compounded one, but it will create a shine.

Now my head hurts! :)

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Speaking of cambering

#20

Re: Maintaining a camber

paul womack

>I've had this phrase on my website for a long time:

All sharpening is, at heart, just the application of a succession of various size grits; Don't get hung up on the details.

Never seen a good enough reason to change it :-)

BugBear