Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

Be careful what you bid on *LINK*

Posts

Be careful what you bid on *LINK*

#1

Be careful what you bid on *LINK*

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>Not sure if this qualifies as a gloat or an "oh [bad word], what have I done?" Yesterday, I bid on a Stanley 20 plane that had received no action. I've been intrigued by the No. 20 plane since I read about it in Planecraft years and years ago. They commonly go on deBay for $100 and up, so I put in a what the heck bid on this one. I had checked in advance that the seller, who seems to know a little about planes and has a positive rating, had found no cracks in the body or sole.

Turns out I was the only bidder, so I got it for the opening bid. Not sure what I'll use it for, but maybe it'll inspire me to make a replacement for our circular dining room table in a year or two or three (wife wants oak; I guess, if it's fumed quarter-sawn white oak).

So, I got to thinking: I'm not aware of any of the new tool makers - at least not the big names - making circular/compass planes. If they did:

The Lie-Nielsen plane would be, of course, bronze, and would use the Bedrock design.

The Lee Valley plane would introduce some radical new design feature that required set screws, wavy washers, and, if possible, a magnet or two.

The Bridge City plane would have a device that calculated the radius of the curve at which you had set the plane and would list at [(cost of Lie-Nielsen's version) times (cost of Lee Valley's version)].


This one

Re: Be careful what you bid on *LINK*

#2

What could possibly go wrong?

John in NM

>Its ugly, but looks like a nice honest plane. I've been kinda looking for one too, ever since reading an article about them in FWW several years ago. I was even thinking of trying to make a wood one if I could get around to buying the spring steel for the sole. Maybe that's just a dream!

I think you'll find uses for it, curves can be fun.

Re: Be careful what you bid on *LINK*

#3

Looks like...

Ted Owen, Pittsburgh

>you got a real good price, Bill. Enjoy.

Best, Ted

Re: Be careful what you bid on *LINK*

#4

New compass plane?

Chuck Nickerson

>For a while LN was considering one. A few months ago a little bird told me it was far, far away. Sigh.

Re: Be careful what you bid on *LINK*

#5

Re: Be careful what you bid on

Neal in San Jose

>I have a 113, and when I first got it I didn't have any curves that needed attention, so I used it as a smoother "just because". It is a fun plane, and I'm sure you'll really like your 20.

Re: Be careful what you bid on *LINK*

#6

Re: What could possibly go wrong?

Ernie Miller

>Sweet plane bill Mine still had the hardware store price sticker on it had it forever and still never used it. Spring steel. here is an Idea in keeping with Todd Hughs. how about using a scrap of a warren & Ted hand saw that you can pick up 5 for a quarter at the garbage sale down the road. if you don't have one e-mail me and I will send you an extra blade. it is a thicker steel than the planes have so you may not get quite the radius. or a HF flush cut saw is thinner and may be wide enough?

Re: Be careful what you bid on *LINK*

#7

Re: Be careful what you bid on *LINK*

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>Kunz makes a copy of the 113, check this Amazon link...

DC


Kunz 113 plane

Re: Be careful what you bid on *LINK*

#8

Interesting

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>Leaving aside any judgments one might have about Kunz tools, it's odd that they'd have picked the 113 to copy. Those with both can no doubt tell me that I'm wrong, but the 113 design seems more complex and less robust than the No. 20 design.

Re: Be careful what you bid on *LINK*

#9

Re: Be careful what you bid on

Todd Hughes

>Plane looks kind of rough with no finish but if not broken should make a good user and price wasn't to bad I guess

I am always amazed that a person would take the trouble to put somthing up for sale on the ebay and then like this plane basicaly not even write a description for it! .. Its like they don't want it to sell or to make much money. A good description for this plane would have taken like maybe 3 min. to type up, heck at least say no damage or cracks.With an additional few min. to clean it properly and it would have perhaps doubled in price....Just cant figure that out......Todd

Re: Be careful what you bid on *LINK*

#10

spring steel

John in NM

>Hi Ernie,

How thick is the sole? If I ever get around to this project, I was planning to use spring stock from McMaster, maybe even leave it blued :)

I hadn't thought of an old saw blade though, that's a good idea.

Re: Be careful what you bid on *LINK*

#11

Seller's descriptions

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>But good descriptions require that one know something about the object.

Pam

Re: Be careful what you bid on *LINK*

#12

Re: Be careful what you bid on

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>I did contact the seller before bidding to confirm that there are no cracks visible in body or sole, though I realize now in looking at the pictures that the sole is shown in one position only (most sellers of compass planes post pics with the sole both concave and convex, to show the range of motion), so perhaps it'll be frozen in place when it arrives, requiring that I soak it for a while to free it up. Seller was quite prompt in getting back to me when I asked.

I was puzzled that the seller didn't bother to update his description after my question, or, as some sellers do, include my question and his response below the description.

I agree that it was poorly described, but if the poor description contributed to the limited price, that's fine with me.

I'm surprised, Todd, that you didn't mention your room full of these planes in mint in box condition, purchased in case lots for $2/case, right next door to the Anvil Museum. You must have been feeling kindly.

Re: Be careful what you bid on *LINK*

#13

Re: Be careful what you bid on

Todd Hughes

>I don't think I have one of those things , do have an early 13 and maybe a 113 too { I think] somwhere, but I just never got into buying these compass planes.

....Probably because in my experance they go very high in the wild because I guess they look rare and expensive to most of the slow heads that are selling or bidding on them. One of the tools that you can probably buy cheaper on the ebay then you can easly in the wild. I have had guys show me one of them and seriously think they had somthing that was worth like over a $1,000...have seen many examples priced at $200- $300 that on ebay would not go for half that....Todd

Re: Be careful what you bid on *LINK*

#14

Re: Seller's descriptions

Todd Hughes

>yeah that is true but I think the seller could have at least said it didn't have any cracks breaks etc....plus seemed like he knew at least a little about the thing....Todd

Re: Be careful what you bid on *LINK*

#15

Re: Be careful what you bid on

Wiley Horne--So. Calif

>Todd's subject line is exactly right, in my experience. Bill got a good price, as these things run, but then he took a risk also. Last time I bought a plane on ebay that looked right, but where the seller laid low with his description, I got a 'good buy'. Was a Mathieson plough, and I was going on the theory that 'the wood doesn't lie'. in other words, it had plainly had good enough care that I figured it would be sound all through. Didn't bother to ask the seller anything, which Bill was smart to do.

Guess what. Depth adjuster was stripped, to where the adjuster screw had almost zero engagement with the threads. The original owner hadn't stripped the threads--some other nitwit did it, no doubt. But I ended up being the dummy, for failing to find out.

Wiley

Re: Be careful what you bid on *LINK*

#16

Re: Be careful what you bid on

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Todd,

Do you write lengthly descriptions on everything you sell? Do you list the negatives that might cause a bidder to not bid?

I do. I let the potential buyer know everything about the tool that I would be looking for it I had the tool in my hands.

Once in awhile I get a message from someone telling me they don't have time to read a book, just tell me what it is.

I just don't want to end up with a problem buyer later.

Ebay has modified their policies regarding feedbacks. A seller can no longer leave negative feedbacks, but the buyers can. Hopefully this will cause more sellers to do a better job with their listings.

Marv

Re: Be careful what you bid on *LINK*

#17

Hi Bill...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>Well Todd might...

I do have a jappaned 20 in the "box sitting" in my closet. I also have a few parts in a box in the shop. Let me know if you need anything.

Re: Be careful what you bid on *LINK*

#18

Hey Marv, I take it you don't know *LINK*

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>Mrsdeadhorse...


Here you go...

Re: Be careful what you bid on *LINK*

#19

Oh, so THAT's MrsDeadHorse!

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Hi Scott,

I've seen those auctions numerous times. Always good auctions and items are always well described.

Marv

Re: Be careful what you bid on *LINK*

#20

It arrived today

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>in better shape (less rust) than the pictures on eBay, nothing frozen. Now, if I could get a good deal on round tuits...