Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

Glue selection for dovetails

Posts

Glue selection for dovetails

#1

Glue selection for dovetails

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>In the discussion and link below on dovetail angles it was stated several times that modern glue, presumably yellow(alipahtic, polyvinyl acetate), enabled dovetails to be assembled with steeper slopes because this glue was stronger than historical glue(presumably hide glue). So far this statement has gone unchallenged.

For may applications, particularly edge gluing, I am not convinced that hide glue is the best choice. However, hide glue seems, even to me, to have merit for dovetail assembly. Of all the joinery in furniture, it is this joint in drawers that does seem likely to need repair at some future time. And the long work time of the liquid product, as well as its lubricity, is attractive for dovetail assembly.

The whole discussion of dovetail strength and dovetail angle seemed lacking from the perspective of structural analysis. Any dovetail is mechanically locked and failure at any angle must involve wood failure. That being the case I don't see that adhesive strength plays a major role in dovetail strength. It seems to me that the relatively weak shear strength of wood will determine the ultimate joint strength and that the role of the adhesive is mainly to keep the pins from withdrawing.

To get to the bottom line of the question.... is there data or experience to suggest or prove that modern glue is better for dovetails. I'm about to assemble and need to know!

Re: Glue selection for dovetails

#2

You can't go wrong with hide glue.

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>

Re: Glue selection for dovetails

#3

Re: Glue selection for dovetails

Dean J in MN

>Bill --

On thing that keeps me using hide glue -- the lack of need to build a high bondline pressure. Something you can't do in dovetails, there is no way to clamp them to build that pressure. I use hot hide glue for my dovetails, in fact I just got up from the shop where I glued up a drawer. Apply the hide glue, knock the sides in place, make sure it is square and walk away. I'm not a fan of the "liquid" hide glue at all. Aside from its repairability (the positive), I really don't like that super long open time, the lack of grab, and the risk of having expired glue. If I need more open time I add urea to my hot hide glue.

Forest Product labs did a study on dovetails, if I recall you're right, it was the shear strength of wood that was the deciding factor. I'll try to dig up the study.

-Dean

Re: Glue selection for dovetails

#4

Re: Glue selection for dovetails

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>I wrote this in the thread below:

If you look at 18th and 19th century furniture there is not a problem with glue failure when the dovetail angle is small; usually if the joint comes apart it is sloppy work, and often a sloppy worker uses larger angles.

I think for most workers, myself included, the precision of the sawing is more a factor in joint strength than angle or type of glue.

Re: Glue selection for dovetails

#5

Re: Glue selection for dovetails

ThomD

>Depends what you mean by "major". Less than in butts holding a top together, but still lots. If, as often, the materials are disimilar the joint may tear itself apart regadless of the streses of everyday life. The only semi quality drawer I have ever seen come appart, is a silver drawer my parents had where the back came out. When one pulled it out, the silver either through the bottom or directly, tries to knock the back off the drawer. Same thing can happen with any drawer storing heavy stuff like office supplies. When pushed closed the same thing happens to the front except it is fully supported and not torn appart. The front was mechanically dovetailed the back was finger jointed, pretty decent Danish quality. The finger joints after a point just looked like they weren't glued.

I think that for a lot of work counting on the repairability of hide glue is pointless since unless a lot changes few will know how 100 years from now, and depressingly, no mater how good the work, a lot of stuff is going to the dumpster anyway.

White glue does everything one needs in this lifetime, though one needs to be choosy as to exact brand. I have a tabletop that has noticeable edges where the joint has shifted. It is thick pieces of cherry butted, as intended to optimize grain look, since reducing movement would not have worked in this case anyway. I doubt epoxy or hide glue would have stopped the shift, they might have split because they are strainger, less creep prone. On the other hand the top looks perfect and you have to run your finger across it to notice anything. A repair at this stage would require refinishing.

I;m currently visiting my aged parents, and comparing their house to mine, is very revealing as to the amount of stuff they have in particular. I think we have to be reasonable about anologies from antiques. My sock drawer as well as socks has a number of heavy itims in it like binoculars, overall it is pretty burdened. Just look at the cupboards in those old places, sometimes only 3 -5 feet wide in the "master". I have old climbing photos from teh 40s of guys way up major summits in their "other" suit, where today a guy would have half a room of equipment for the same exercise.

Conversely, examining pieces one finds drawers made out of material that could have been cut from cigar boxes, may have held only a few letters.

Then today, few people know how to treat anything for long life.

I always keep in mind that a trimaran made of wood say 40 feet and 10 thousand pounds, can be made with sheating of 1/4", or 3/8" more likely. So I don't think we need to overbuild stuff but I do think glue maters.

There is more than enough pressure in a dovetail joint to "clamp" white or yellow glue. I don't see that as a problem. I like enough open time, so it pays to learn a particular glue to know what one can get away with. I wouldn't get carried away on the merits of a particular glue only to find onself in a spot when using it for the first time on a complicated piece it started teaching some scarry lessons.

Re: Glue selection for dovetails

#6

Re: Glue selection for dovetails

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Bill,

I agree with your reasoning that the relative glue strength (modern vs. hide) is not critical to the drawer--the strength of the joint derives primarily from the mechanical lock of the dovetail. The glue does sort of turn a well-made joint into a monolith, but we know from surviving Period furniture examples (not to mention King Tut) that hide glue will outlast us all, until the day when someone wants the joint to come apart for some reason.

Getting down to cases, the thing I really like about hide glue for drawer assembly is the easy cleanup. I will always get some squeeze-out on the inside of the drawer. If that squeeze-out is hide glue, it cleans up one-two-nothing. If its TiteBond, I have to worry whether I got every last speck of it up. Cause it'll make a light place. It's a needless misery. I'm talking about even with the drawer parts prefinished (before glueup), and only detailing and final touchup left to do.

Wiley

Re: Glue selection for dovetails

#7

Re: Glue selection for dovetails

ThomD

>Wiley, I think that anyone at the point where their only distinction between hyde and white glue is on clean-up, should use the hyde glue. Seems to me to have no downsides if one has some around (I'm talking hot here), and if one has it mastered. I would argue that in most repects (what you said essentially) either will work, and a person not using hyde glue shouldn't worry about it. But for those who can, go to it.

In the clean-up situation you describe, one alternative is a pre-coat of shelac just to keep the inside corners clear. Another it to be one of those folks who uses minimal glue so there isn't any significant squeeze out.

I know that the cold glue is quite failure prone in musical instruments, and there are similar problems in furniture where the holding power is not up to it. I haven't used much of the cold glue though, I keep a bottle of the Franklin stuff around, but so far have not managed to reach for it.