Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Rare Exotic & Domestic Hardwoods, Milled In-House in Oregon. Browse Unique Stock.

Rust thoughts

Posts

Rust thoughts

#1

Rust thoughts

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>No, not rusty, though that's normal, but rust-hunting thoughts, at a very, very not-profound level.

So far, this hasn't been a great garage sale season. I finally found a non-reversible machinist's protractor (these are all on one side of the blade, and I believe will be helpful for taking off some angles hard to reach with the reversible one I've already got) for $1, rust at no extra charge and missing one of the retaining screws (note to Todd Hughes: no, I don't want to hear that you find them by the boxload, complete and in the original box, for 50 cents per box). One Arkansas stone, nearly new. Not much else to get excited over. We went out today, had a good time, which is 50% of going garage saling; I came home with two more saws (I think I WON'T count the saw total in my shop, and sure won't tell the love of my life), $1 each, one a product of the famous Warranted Superior firm on which I need to cut off the final 4" at the toe, where it can't decide whether to bend right or left so chooses both, and one nice skewback child's saw for the grandchildren who are not as yet even a trace of a glimmer in either son's eyes.

Anyway, I got to thinking: All the literature, from the Happy Homeowner's Guide to Fixin' Your House to the Young Carpenter's Helpful Book of Hints, has a basic tool list, and one or more planes always appear, in about the same number as the saws and boring implements listed. Yet, on any given weekend, I can come home with as many decent saws as I might want, and, usually, about as many braces as I might want, assuming I had none of either; but, unless the stars are aligning right, planes are a lot scarcer, and, of course, interesting planes even more so. What happened here? Did the planes get broken or fly away? Or do the kids hold onto them when they clean out Grandpa's garage?

Then I got to thinking about the electron-burners I see at garage sales, and realized that the proportion is similar: you can always come home with a circular saw and an electric drill, without breaking a sweat; but the shaping and refining tools (e.g., 'lectric routah) are a lot less common.

Big duh: even someone whose idea of carpentry consists of fence-building needs to make wood shorter and/or narrower, and make holes in it. Only the intermediate to advanced wood-wreckers get to making it fancy.

Re: Rust thoughts

#2

IMRO . . .

steve mackay

>( Read " Rookie " opinion ) The planes are being bought up by NY yuppies in their high-rise offices. Its "manly" to have a collection of Stanley planes on the bookshelf. Not sure if they know what they do but manly none-the-less. Also explains why prices go beyond a lot of woodworkers and the fact SOMEONE is being picky over wich ones go higher than others. There was also a story on The WSJ about "classic" farm tractors. The prices are going into orbit and they are being driven by New Yorkers around the Big Apple because its in fashion. Reminds me of when Harleys came into fashion for "The Respectable". Most don't know "rake" from "stretch" but they got LOTS of leather !

Re: Rust thoughts

#3

Re: IMRO . . .

Stuart Hough

>And we mustn't forget "trail" in the equation!

Re: Rust thoughts

#4

I have to confess (rambly - I'm avoiding working)

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>that I had a Chaplin jack plane in my office when I worked for a living, though I had it there because I was intrigued by the number of different ways people were trying out to advance a plane iron before Bailey's Windows-of-the-19th-century design dominated. Well, I will admit that it was also sending a message - I couldn't wear plaid flannel shirts and jeans, so this was as close as I could get.

I doubt that any of my acquaintances would mistake me for a yuppie. For one thing, every time I have to wear a tie, I can be detected from a distance by my constant whining and squirming.

It's, of course, easy to blame this kind of thing (the absence of planes) on someone not in the room - but I think there are probably not many more planes sitting on shelves in high rise offices than there are painted Disston (or Panther!) saws on the wall at county fairs, and there are still plenty of saws around.

I got to thinking overnight, and realized that every woodworking trade has to cut and make holes in wood, but only some have to make it smooth and pretty. Also, back when the trades used cholesterol and sweat rather than electrons, a carpenter would have had several saws, to ensure that one was always sharp. I imagine a lot of the framing carpenters of the 19th and early 20th centuries had four or five times as many saws as planes, while the trim carpenters maybe had more planes, but still had saws.

Doesn't explain the braces, though, which almost always appear as 10" sweep (took me years to find a 14" sweep, and I've never seen a 6" sweep in the wild - had to inherit it from my dad).

Re: Rust thoughts

#5

Re: IMRO . . .

Todd Hughes

>"The planes are being bought up by NY yuppies in their high-rise offices. Its "manly" to have a collection of Stanley planes on"

So that explains why I can't find that Stanley no. 1 at any of the the local garage sales or flea markets...those pesky NY Yuppies are driving down here and loading up thier BMWs with planes befor I can get to them !...Strange I get out a good bit and I don't recall seeing many other tool buyers that fit that description...think they are going undercover disguised as old smelly guys in beat up 1980 vans?...My favorite conspiracy is that they are really being bought up by Aliens and spirited back to the planet Collector.

The reason you see more saws and braces then planes is simple...more people back when these things were being bought had more use for them and more were sold then planes and other tools which they didn't need. Very few people were cabinet makers or even carpenters but lots of guys were farmers or homeowners that might have needed a saw or brace around the place. I ran a big horse farm for years and we used lots of saws and even braces but don't ever remember using a plane. If we built somthing that needed a plane our handyman did it using his few.

I still see lots of planes even in the old tool hell I live in. Many are cheap homeowner types and probably bought by guys for infrequant use doing handyman stuff...like maybe shaving down doors and drawers. This is why you see more Stanley no. 4 and 5 planes then No. 2s and 8s... they were a more all around tool that more people had a need for.

Still lots of stuff out there in the wild that hasn't been picked over. If you aint finding it I guess it is easy to blaime some conspiracy theory such as NY Yuppies buying it all up, In reality it is more likely that you are just not spending the time looking in the right places for it....Todd