Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

SURVEY: THE IDES OF JULY

Posts

SURVEY: THE IDES OF JULY

#1

Ellis Walentine

SURVEY: THE IDES OF JULY

Ellis Walentine

>Hi folks,

It's time yet again to take your pulse on a compelling woodworking issue. This time around, it's about the nature of craftsmanship and our preference for the wood medium.

I assume that everyone who comes here is doing it because they are interested in wood craftsmanship. But, I'd like to know if you also enjoy working in other media besides wood? If not, why is wood the only medium that interests you? Is it because of the specific skills and tools and knowledge you need to work it? Is it because of the abundance of the materials? Or is the usefulness and purpose of the finished product your objective? What is it about wood?

As usual, we'll edit your replies and send them off to Woodworker West magazine for inclusion in their September/October issue. Thanks for participating!

Ellis Walentine, Host

Re: SURVEY: THE IDES OF JULY

#2

Re: SURVEY: THE IDES OF JULY

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>Having grown up in a car family, I was initially intrigued, when I started working on things, by metal and grease (motorcyles, cars). Although I still enjoy the occasional problem-solving mechanical problem, I spent so much time in my 20's and 30's keeping up a succession of clapped-out cars (all we could afford), that car stuff got old, as my interest in things covered in sawdust grew.

What it is about wood for me, I think, is that it's simultaneously simple and impossibly complex. I learned the difference between cross-grain and long-grain when I was a kid - I used to go into my grandfather's shop and endlessly crush little chunks of wood in his vise, first applying the pressure across the grain and watching it compress, then along the grain and watching it split (I suspect, looking back, that he saved me chunks the right size - maybe even made some!). It's not hard to get how it differs.

But learning how best to use this basically simple material to make things can take more than the lifetime I expect to get. And, in the meantime, the colors, grain shapes, twists and turns of the material make for a visual, tactile, sensory journey every bit as great as going to "2001" stoned, without the legal consequences.

Re: SURVEY: THE IDES OF JULY

#3

Re: SURVEY: THE IDES OF JULY

David Barnett - SW Florida

>"But, I'd like to know if you also enjoy working in other media besides wood?"

I find wood alone to be somewhat boring, both visually and in the crafting. Metals, cast glass, stone are three things that I prefer in the mix. Secondary are other once-living materials; hide, bone, ivory, horn, and so on. Also, I care little about primitive or period reproduction, eschewing mouldings and representational carving (acanthus leaves, shells, whatever) but do enjoy shaped and sculpted forms. I now prefer plainer, quieter woods than when I started, emphasizing color and matte finishes (on all materials). Pear is a current favorite and if I want a bit of figure, a narrow straight stripe is enough (qtr-sawn Braz. RW, for examptle). Perhaps an extreme of this is my recent fondness for stacked plywood showing only the edge laminations.

I often find it stimulating to employ wood as a 'cold' element in my work, with metals and glass coming off warmer due to form and finish. Just a phase I'm going through.

Re: SURVEY: THE IDES OF JULY

#4

Re: SURVEY: THE IDES OF JULY

David Miller from Iowa

>I like working in soil. Landscaping, yardening - whatever one likes to call it. Works out pretty well - woodshop in the winter, yard in the summer.

Re: SURVEY: THE IDES OF JULY

#5

Re: SURVEY: THE IDES OF JULY

ThomD

>It runs in the family a little. Wood is also very useful in the sense that so much we live with even today is made of it. That is falling away, but the Space age (39th birthday of the moon landing), really didn't deliver on much. We were still building and living with the same old stuff for years. That is changing. Kids today have different interests and preferences in materials. Nobody in response to distain for Iraq, hit the main street selling lacy wax candles and tie dye shirts, or leather belts.

I got very interested in the uses of wood as a structural material. It remains probably the most important structural material we have, the the neighbourhood. It can still be important in technical uses. For instance I got interested in a glider called the Carbon dragon, that is so light it can actually be difficult to press to the ground. It can exploit lifts otherwise felt only by birds. Turns out that while carbon is critical to getting the extra lift required, the CD is mostly made of wood. Mostly my interest was in wood in boats where it was the high performance material until the last decade or so.

Wood can be a very beautiful material, though as a builder it can end up dominating decors, and in and out of fashion. It can also end up as an excuse for good design, just highlighting the look of the stuff. One also tends to run into people who really like it or not, while the vast majority who like it have zero sophistication about what they are looking at. So while I love the beauty of wood it is not all that easy to share.

Re: SURVEY: THE IDES OF JULY

#6

Re: SURVEY: THE IDES OF JULY

Chuck Nickerson

>I also work in metal, perhaps 20% of my work. I most enjoy wood because I most enjoy the tools I use when working wood. I recently started blacksmithing, and I'm finding the same joy there that I get when working wood.