Crap is my middle name...
Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.
>Hi Mike,
About all I do is crap saws, both backsaws and regular saws. Most of the old backsaws I encounter will have some pitting. I think of pitting on a scale of 1 to 10, 10 being nonrepairable. I apply the same scale to a handle that needs repair.
A blade with mild pitting in the 2 to 4 range will work just fine. Pitting in the 5 to 9 range will also do a good job of cutting as long as the pitting isn't too deep and or isn't down where it effects the setting of the teeth. Even that's ok if the pitting doesn't effect a lot of teeth that are close together or causes a tooth to break off.
Comparing the cost of a new saw, a reconditioned saw with pitting that can actually cut as well as a new saw, can be a bargain at half the price. It's a shame to put a saw out of commission merely due to some pitting.
I'm saying this to those who might find an old beat up neglected saw at a flea market and pass it up just because it's pitted. To those, I say, go ahead and pay the two bucks for it and then send it to me.
Handles aren't as critical as the blades. Most handles can be fixed. Those that I won't attempt to repair are ones that are rotten. There's a point at which it is easier to make a new handle. Other times it can be just a good challenge to see if in some way I can make it 98% whole again.
It's very rewarding to take a crap saw, spend a day or two on it and then put it to wood and watch it cut pretty much as it did when it was new. Won't look like new, but, hey, neather do I but I can still do a lot of the things I did when I was newer. Ok, that's a bad analogy.. *smirk*
Did you see the last crap backsaw Leif Hanson reconditioned? He gave it a new blade though, but it sure looks good. He has it on his website with a good tutorial.
Marv