Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fast and affordable laser cutting – so you can make the parts you can’t find anywhere else

Dovetail saw v Carcass saw

Posts

Dovetail saw v Carcass saw

#1

Dovetail saw v Carcass saw

Dan Collins

>Friends: I have a Lie Neilsen dovetail saw (pistol grip) that I use a lot for cutting dovetails. The wood is often 3/4 - 7/8 thick. I read somewhere that someone thought that it was much easier to cut dovetails in wood more than a 1/2 inch thick with a carcass saw. Lie Nielsen has a Rip Carcass saw that is a bit bigger and heavier than the regular dovetail saw. If it really is that much easier to cut through the thicker wood with a carcass saw, I think it is probably worth getting one, but they aren't cheap so I thought I would ask if anyone else has had any experience using the two saws. Have you noticed a significant difference? Thanks. Dan

Re: Dovetail saw v Carcass saw

#2

Re: Dovetail saw v Carcass saw

Dean J in MN

>I may have been that person to mention the use of a carcass saw. :)

I find my carcass saw is better suited for the thicker sides of case work, where the dovetail saw is better suited to the 1/2" pine/poplar drawer sides I use. I use my carcass saw for the case dovetails and small tenon cuts one may find in case work. My DT saw is only used on the thin drawer side stock.

If you are happy with your DT saw for case sides, I won't argue, but on the other hand -- another saw is always nice! :)

(I hadn't looked at the LN saw until now -- I see it is filed Xcut. I'd rather have it rip, but that is easy to change)

-Dean

Re: Dovetail saw v Carcass saw

#3

Re: Dovetail saw v Carcass saw

Dean J in MN

>... Rip Carcass ...

Geeze, guess I can't read! :) Ignore that Xcut comment above then...

Re: Dovetail saw v Carcass saw

#4

Thanks for asking this question Dan...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>I've been wondering about this myself. Especially when trying to gang cut two 3/4"-1" thick boards for case assembly.

Re: Dovetail saw v Carcass saw

#5

Re: Dovetail saw v Carcass saw

Adam Cherubini

>This is a complicated subject. This is my take on it:

http://www.adamcherubini.com/Dovetail_Saws.html

The reason it gets complicated is that saws can be optimized to a high degree. My opinion is that LN/Pete Taran did a good job of producing a saw that would work well in all situations. Technically speaking, blade length and rake also both effect what thickness of stock the saw is best for. For carcass work specifically, a longer, coarser toothed blade holds advantages over the LN. For thinner stock, a finer toothed saw with a shallower blade will be better. A bit more rake also helps saws like these.

You can do good work with the saw you have. I think you should just stick with it until it's really slowing you down. I worked with a Crown Tools Gent's saws for years. (Gent's saws are characterized by their turned handles- they are named for their occasional ww owners) That Gent's saw was my only dt saw. I made a number of carcasses in a week and made drawers the same week. Half way through that week my hand ached such that it was distracting me. I had trouble opening my fingers in the morning. That's when I made my first DT saw. I had outgrown my Gent's saw.

I think if you can get by with what you have, spend your money on something else. If you are jonesing for a new saw, there are many other types on the market that you may not have and would really like.

Adam

Re: Dovetail saw v Carcass saw

#6

Re: Dovetail saw v Carcass saw

MikeW

>Hi Dan,

Like Dean, I tend to use a longer and coarser saw for thicker joinery. I think that if you are finding yourself wondering if you'll ever get the carcass sides joined--because it is taking longer than you want to saw them--I think you would be happier to get LN's longer and coarser rip-filed carcass saw.

As I've written before, I like hand sawing but I also like to get done. If there is anyone you know who lives close to you that has one, consider a visit and cut a few lines alongside your DT saw.

Take care, Mike

Re: Dovetail saw v Carcass saw

#7

Re: Dovetail saw v Carcass saw

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>Dean, you don't give dimensions for your saws. I have used a pair of "dovetail saws" for about 20 years, an 8" 15 point saw and a 10" 13 point saw. I suppose the larger one could be considered a carcass saw.

I use the small one for 9/16 and under and the larger one for 7/8 , 15/16.

Re: Dovetail saw v Carcass saw

#8

Re: Dovetail saw v Carcass saw

Dean J in MN

>Warren --

Sorry, the specs would be of use.

DT:

9" blade length

19 ppi

Rip

.018" thick steel

1 3/8 to 1 5/8" tapered width blade

Carcass:

11" blade length

14 ppi

Rip

.020" thick steel

2 1/8 to 2 3/8" tapered width blade

Re: Dovetail saw v Carcass saw

#9

Still saving up . . .

steve mackay

>Don't own a carcas saw but I just KNOW I'd use it if I had it. The trick is saving enough pennies for Mr. Wenzloff's. Hey, a guy can dream right ?

Re: Dovetail saw v Carcass saw

#10

Ever considered a Japanese saw? Just curious...

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>

Re: Dovetail saw v Carcass saw

#11

Hey Dean...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>You ever gang cut thick wood with that carcass saw?

Re: Dovetail saw v Carcass saw

#12

So Mike, Wadda u use...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>When cutting case pieces? Especially gang cutting?

Re: Dovetail saw v Carcass saw

#13

Re: So Mike, Wadda u use...

MikeW

>Hi Scott,

It depends on how thick the carcasses. Gang cutting tails on a carcass a combined thickness of a good 1 5/8" or a bit thicker. I then use a 12", 12 ppi (might be 11 ppi) open-handled carcass saw, filed rip. When I made smaller carcasses, which was most often and the combined thickness was less, I typically used a 14 ppi 11" carcass saw.

On ganged drawer sides where the sides are around 3/8" thick or a little less, I would often use my DT saw, 9" and 16 ppi, though with enough drawer sides and or the softness of the wood involved, it was a little coarser DT saw with 15 ppi.

Take care, Mike

Re: Dovetail saw v Carcass saw

#14

Re: Hey Dean...

Dean J in MN

>I don't gang cut carcass sides with my carcass saw, I may if it were bigger and had fewer teeth. In general I don't gang cut, I'm not sure why really, I've just never found it to be a real time saver. For me, I spend more time messing around getting the sides lined up to gang cut than if I just cut them one at a time. The cutting step is the quickest portion of cutting dovetails, waste removal is a far larger chunk of time.

-Dean

Re: Dovetail saw v Carcass saw

#15

Re: So Mike, Wadda u use...

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Scott,

I counted 4 different saws that Mike mentioned.

Easy for him to say, huh?.....LOL

A woodworking hobby is almost as costly as golf.

Marv

Re: Dovetail saw v Carcass saw

#16

Re: So Mike, Wadda u use...

MikeW

>Hi Marv,

There are far more than those that see regular use...and some that see occassinaly use. All but one are vintage and the one that I made that I own was a mistake I made on an order.

My personal saws were picked up over time as the need and opportunity presented itself.

And that is the advice I would give--and have given--to anyone who will listen: Buy saws as the needs dictate. I have no compelling reason to make myself other saws until such time my needs dictate it.

If going for vintage saws, refashion great user saws to meet particular needs. Avoid crap saws that need too much work unless you are into tool restoration.

Restoring saws is a bit different than planes. I seldom cared if a wooden plane had a larger than wanted mouth, a metal plane had a bit of rust. On a vintage saw, stay away from pitted blades, broken handles (unless ya wanna replace the blades, make a new handle, etc.).

Take care, Mike

Re: Dovetail saw v Carcass saw

#17

Thanks Dean, I agree...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>Waste removal takes the largest chunk of time.

Re: Dovetail saw v Carcass saw

#18

Thank you Mike...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>Looks like I'll be getting a saw or two refiled.

Re: Dovetail saw v Carcass saw

#19

No way Marv...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>WW costs way more than golf IMO. That is if'in you don't loose as many balls as me... 8^)

Re: Dovetail saw v Carcass saw

#20

But not as expensive as children

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>perhaps the most expensive hobby of all. Worth it, though.

Re: Dovetail saw v Carcass saw

#21

Crap is my middle name...

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Hi Mike,

About all I do is crap saws, both backsaws and regular saws. Most of the old backsaws I encounter will have some pitting. I think of pitting on a scale of 1 to 10, 10 being nonrepairable. I apply the same scale to a handle that needs repair.

A blade with mild pitting in the 2 to 4 range will work just fine. Pitting in the 5 to 9 range will also do a good job of cutting as long as the pitting isn't too deep and or isn't down where it effects the setting of the teeth. Even that's ok if the pitting doesn't effect a lot of teeth that are close together or causes a tooth to break off.

Comparing the cost of a new saw, a reconditioned saw with pitting that can actually cut as well as a new saw, can be a bargain at half the price. It's a shame to put a saw out of commission merely due to some pitting.

I'm saying this to those who might find an old beat up neglected saw at a flea market and pass it up just because it's pitted. To those, I say, go ahead and pay the two bucks for it and then send it to me.

Handles aren't as critical as the blades. Most handles can be fixed. Those that I won't attempt to repair are ones that are rotten. There's a point at which it is easier to make a new handle. Other times it can be just a good challenge to see if in some way I can make it 98% whole again.

It's very rewarding to take a crap saw, spend a day or two on it and then put it to wood and watch it cut pretty much as it did when it was new. Won't look like new, but, hey, neather do I but I can still do a lot of the things I did when I was newer. Ok, that's a bad analogy.. *smirk*

Did you see the last crap backsaw Leif Hanson reconditioned? He gave it a new blade though, but it sure looks good. He has it on his website with a good tutorial.

Marv

Re: Dovetail saw v Carcass saw

#22

Never thought of my kids as a hobby, however.....

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>some of the process might be thought of as a hobby, but we won't go there.....:-))

Marv

Re: Dovetail saw v Carcass saw

#23

Leif Hanson's reconditioned backsaw  *LINK*

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>


Reconditioned backsaw by Leif Hanson