Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

Handplane refeb help

Posts

Handplane refeb help

#1

Handplane refeb help

Jerry Samsen

>This was posted in the main forum by mistake.

I'm new to handplanes but have owned a small block plane for some time and found it very handy. I wanted to try other planes but investing in an expensive Lie-Nielsen or equivalent was too much and buying an el cheapo may be a mistake. So I bought a Stanley No5 Jack plan on eBay ($30) to referb and tune.

I noticed in my new, used plane that there was a small area on the base where the cast iron looked unusual almost like it had significant corrosion and someone tried to grind it off.

First step was lapping so I started lapping using some paraffin oil and Veritas lapping grit (started with lowest grit - 90) on a 1/4" plate glass. After grinding for considerable time I noticed that the suspect area was not touched by the grinding. I cleaned and placed a straight edge along the base and noticed that there was a gap in that area. I can't say how much (0.01"?) but seemed like enough that hand lapping would not work.

This area is about 2/3 of the way from the mouth to the back of the plane and offset to one side of the base in a area about the size of a nickle.

Would this small imperfection in the base cause problems? If so, I'll dump this one and look for another. I'm sure with the right tools this could be reground flat but the investment may not make sense. I don't have any tools (like a edge sander) to do aggressive power grinding / sanding.

Thanks.

Re: Handplane refeb help

#2

Re: Not a problem, use as is

Dave Mount

>A small depression like that is not going to make any difference at all, especially located where it is. Sharpen the iron and start using the plane!

Have fun, they're going to start following you home (more planes, I mean).

Dave

Re: Handplane refeb help

#3

As Dave has said, It will not cause a problem...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>If it's located away from the mouth of the plane there will be no issues.Get it cleaned up all tuned up and go make some shavings!

Re: Handplane refeb help

#4

As Scott has said that Dave has said, no problem

James Watriss

>

Re: Handplane refeb help

#5

what is most important......

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Is to learn to get the blade properly sharp and the blade & chip breaker assembly seated securely. With this accomplished you can do much useful work even if the sole is not perfect. Many find investment in a replacement blade helpful. I wouldn't say that diddling with the sole is unimportant but its not the first thing to worry about.

Warning....it is very easy to wind up with a convex sole by improper lapping. The fix for this problem is a trip to local machine shop and use of the surface grinder to get things perfect.

Re: Handplane refeb help

#6

Re: As Scott & Dave & James have said, no problem

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>

Re: Handplane refeb help

#7

Re: As Scott & Dave & James & Marv have said,

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>sorry, couldn't resist.

Re: Handplane refeb help

#8

My favorite source

James Watriss

>David Charlesworth's first book has a very thoroughly detailed article on getting planes up to snuff. It's my favorite resource for any beginner trying to get his planes in order.

There are two schools of thought with regard to a #5. It's an interesting size, since it's just between a smoother, and just a bit too small to use for a jointer. But historically, jack planes have been used for rough work.

First school... as a beginner, if you're using milled lumber, and you're not going back to historical methods of milling lumber, then a #5 is basically a very long smoothing plane. To get accurate results, a smoother should be straight from toe to heel... but a little bit of a hollow in the middle won't hurt any more than say, a corrugated sole. So a slight hollow won't hurt anything.

If you're going on a field trip to the pre-electric ages, and you're using a jack plane as it was originally intended to be... namely, a plane for rough work, then accuracy isn't such a big deal. In this case, a slight hollow won't hurt anything.

I can only think of one reason to make a new guy or a student go through all the hassle, and that is to impart a level of respect for the tools. But I think if you go through everything else that's required, then you'll have enough respect for your plane as it is.

Re: new steel, if you have an old enough plane, the iron may be plenty good as is. Back in the day they used laminated irons, and the tool steel they used was really good stuff. In this case, I'd make sure your chip breaker (cap iron) is well tuned, because the biggest weakness was that the old blades were so thin. Next upgrade is either a new iron, or aftermarket chip breaker. My personal MO is to go with a new Hock iron and chip breaker, since their steel is wonderful, and their cap irons are too. Together they make for a stout and rigid blade assembly that will work wonders.

There's more, of course. But go look for the book first. There's words, pictures, and lots of information, and that makes a better shop reference than a computer, IMO. If you run into snags after that, then come back with questions.

Re: Handplane refeb help

#9

Ahh Bill, between you and James...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>We won't be getting Jerry over to the quiet side. You must keep them in the dark and let them ask many questions, so they keep coming back to this side of the force.

Re: Handplane refeb help

#10

Re: Ahh Bill, between you and James...

James Watriss

>You mean suggesting that someone read a book instead of a message board won't dissuade them?

Funny that a message board devoted to non-power tools should be so focused on a means of communication that requires electricity. :)

Re: Handplane refeb help

#11

Re: My favorite source

Jerry Samsen

>Thanks all for the advice. And yes, I will try to locate that book. I always like a good reference that continues the woodworking in the easy chair.

Re: Handplane refeb help

#12

yes but.....

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>the poor guy probably wants to make something and grinding metal is not productive in that regard (as I have found out by experience). I wish I had all my time back diddling unproductively with metal. I particularly begrudge the time back flattening.

Re: Handplane refeb help

#13

Eh, I disagree

James Watriss

>Granted, some of the work is tedious. I still think it's worth going through the exercise to have a solid, well tuned plane. It usually takes me a good chunk of one afternoon, give or take. But I think the results are worthwhile.

Some folks geek out over their planes. Some of them don't. I don't regret the time spent at all, even if I don't go through it anymore.

(of course, once a plane is tuned, you don't have to go through it again...)

Re: Handplane refeb help

#14

Re: yes but.....

Ron In Sterling CT

>Bill

I agree, and I could probably mention several items we have wasted our time on over the past years, but I need to get back to making more sawdust and shavings.

Ron