Re: Interesting Plane Iron
Don McConnell
>Stephen,
There is, indeed, information available concerning an edge tool maker, by the name of Joseph Smith, who was contemporaneous with the publication of the _Key to the Various Manufactories of Sheffield_. As far as I've been able to establish, his data is:
Smith, Joseph 1814 - 1817
Townhead Street [1814 - 1816]
Rockingham Lane [1817]
Smith & Sons, Joseph 1822
51 Carver Street
Smith, Joseph 1825 - 1828
51 Carver Street
Smith & Son, Joseph 1833 - 1834
51 Carver Street
Despite the changes in the firm's names, I feel the continuity of the 51 Carver Street address clearly indicates the same principle firm member from 1822 to 1834. I tend to suspect the same Joseph Smith was also in business as an edge tool maker from 1814 to 1817, but can't be entirely sure.
On the other hand, John Kebabian, in his introduction to the EAIA reprint of the _Key_, recounts some early correspondence between Joseph Smith and Peter Stubs, then relates:
"The only other information we have about Smith (apart from the _Key_ itself) is his appearance in the Sheffield directory of 1821, where he is listed as an engraver and copperplate printer, at no. 34 Scotland Street. There are a number of other persons of the same name in the 1817 and 1821 directories (an iron founder, an edge tool manufacturer, a table knife and fork caster, a currier, a fork maker) but as all their addresses differ from the one noted above, it seems likely that none of these is the engraver of the _Key_."
Unfortunately, I don't have access to the 1821 directory to verify the listing of an edge tool maker separate from the engraver and copperplate printer, but tend to accept Kebabian's assessment. So, I think it unlikely that the maker of your plane iron is the same Joseph Smith who published the _Key_.
Don McConnell
Eureka Springs, AR