Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

Wild West Handsaw - 2 Handles Back Saw

Posts

Wild West Handsaw - 2 Handles Back Saw

#1

Wild West Handsaw - 2 Handles Back Saw

charlie belden

>(So as not to get accused of being a shill for

Glen-Drake tools, let me state up front that

I have NO association with Glen-Drake or ANY

reseller of Glen-Drake tools. I own, and paid

list price for, a Glen-Drake Tite-Mark and

have found it to be a very good, and very

versatile marking - and measuring tool)

The July-August issue of Woodworker West has an article by Kevin Glen-Drake entitled An Alternative Approach for Hand Tool Joinery. The article suggests learning to cut BIG simple box/finger joints in THICK stock. The premise is "if you can't see it you can't figure out how to fix it". (sounds paradoxical but it does sort of make sense).

Anyway - three photos in the article show him using a two parallel handles back saw to cut most of the joints. Looking down on the top of the saw, think wishbone ( Y ). The text calls it the Wild West Saw (TM) and, in addition to the two parallel handles, which allows you to stand shoulders parallel to the part being cut, looking striaght down over the blade, the saw blade itself is different. The first and last inch or so has no teeth.

The "no teeth front and back" seems like another paradox. If you've made a saw blade, why no teeth front and back?

So I read on and found "Kerf Starter" (TM) - what looks like one of those short handled, short curved blade wittling/carving knives - but in fact has a thicker blade, no bevel(s) and acts as a scraper. cutting a shallow line - the width of the saw blade's kerf. The result is a shallow, square sided, flat bottomed "line" in which the saw can be set.

Since this is a handtools forum, and most here have used various handsaws, it's the start of the cut that determines how well the rest of the cut will go - regardless of whether you're using a push or pull saw. Normally the cut is started using your thumbnail to register the far end of the blade to the line (or just off it on the waste side) while you eyeball the blades position over the line at the back - and try and keep the blade from tilting left or right, seeing only the side closest to you. And then a little pulling back before making the first push stroke.

When you think about it, it's kind of like walking and chewing gum while humming and maybe juggling. Seems simple, 'til you've screwed up a dozen or two cuts. With practice and a bit of figuring out what went wrong and how to adjust for that, muscle memory takes care of things and the cuts get better and better. And if you use a saw regularly it becomes an automatic thing.

BUT - if you DON'T use a saw regularly . . .

This "system" seems to solve several common problems with sawing accurately.

- the wishbone arrangement, with parallel saw handles puts an eye on eithe side of the blade, a slight tilt of the head to see each side of the blade where it meets the wood

- by standing with your shoulders parallel tothe face of the part to be sawn, you can see if you're leaning the saw left or right

- by starting the cut with the toothless part of the blade in the shallow, square sides, "scribe line" you've got the blade registered and can create some foreward momentum BEFORE the teeth contact the wood and the same goes for the back stroke.

- the way the handles are set, you "steer" with your thumbs, not your wrist - which seems like it'd provide better control, though that would probably involve some mental and physical adjustments.

In theory, this saw and "kerf- starter" seem like an innovative improvement to hand sawing. Anyone with any experience with the Wild West Saw? Likes, dislikes, comments?

charlie belden

Re: Wild West Handsaw - 2 Handles Back Saw

#2

Re: Wild West Handsaw - 2 Handles Back Saw *LINK*

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>This has been discussed a couple of times since it was introduced. I found one thread, linked below, but not the longer one, on which, I must admit, I waxed negative in the absence of any evidence that it was a bad idea - my underlying conservative coming out. As I recall, on the later thread, no one had much if any direct experience with the saw.


The only thread I could find

Re: Wild West Handsaw - 2 Handles Back Saw

#3

Waiting for the 3-handle model

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>

Re: Wild West Handsaw - 2 Handles Back Saw

#4

Re: Wild West Handsaw - 2 Handles Back Saw

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>I followed the thread, didn't contribute because all I could think was this was a problem solved by a straight handled saw with a handle long enough to allow a two-handed stance, like just about every Japanese saw I know of (excepting most keyholes).

Pam

Re: Wild West Handsaw - 2 Handles Back Saw

#5

Worthless...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>That's MHO. There are so many saws, so many stances, way too many factors that will convince me that a 2 handled saw is a godsend.

Re: Wild West Handsaw - 2 Handles Back Saw

#6

Re: Not Worthless...

MikeW

>I don't think Kevin would consider it a godsend.

My eldest son and I both tried it at the LN even here in Portland a while back. He got on with it right off, it was less easy for this old cuss.

Here's Kevin using his saw. It works as described.


It may not be for me. May not be for you. But if another person finds utility in it?

Take care, Mike

Re: Wild West Handsaw - 2 Handles Back Saw

#7

Hmmm...

Ted Owen, Pittsburgh

>For many it's going to be an easier and more accurate technique. I have a set and used it at Marc Adams. Being able to see the kerf is very helpful. The toothless blade sections, along with the kerf starter, make getting started MUCH easier.

Personally I hope this product takes off. Kevin has put a lot of work into developing it, so I'm cheering for him to succeed. But aside from that, I think he's come up with a step forward.

Best, Ted

Re: Wild West Handsaw - 2 Handles Back Saw

#8

Re: Not Worthless...

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Hi Mike,

That old cuss looks like me...

If you were to make a regular handle with a larger grip hole, it could be used with both hands just like a saw with two handles.

I haven't had the opportunity to use that two handled saw, but I would think you'd still have to sight down one side to follow a pencil line, which would cause you to not be centered as is one of the selling points of the saw.

Marv

Re: Wild West Handsaw - 2 Handles Back Saw

#9

Re: Not Worthless...

MikeW

>Well, it depends (the sighting thing). But in general, yes.

However, though this saw has two handles, the technique it forces is not that much different than what Pam mentioned, the two-hand grip on Japanese saws. Which I have used to great success (though I still like using a single hand with smaller Japanese saws).

Take care, Mike

Re: Wild West Handsaw - 2 Handles Back Saw

#10

Re: Hmmm...

MikeW

>Hi Ted,

And I too applaud Kevin and wish him success.

I do not think that it is a step forward, nor do I think it is a step backward. I do think for some people it certainly is a means to partake in sawing joinery that they may not otherwise choose to do, or for what ever reason the WWW saw and the kerf starters are simply a more successful means to that end.

Take care, Mike

Re: Wild West Handsaw - 2 Handles Back Saw

#11

Not Worthless. I guess your right Mike...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>It probably has a place some where, but not in my shop. How the heck are you suppose to start a cut with it if you have both hands on the saw?

Re: Wild West Handsaw - 2 Handles Back Saw

#12

Kudos to Kevin

MikeW

>I think it works best used with the kerf starter. The kerf starter really does create a good groove for the beginning of the cut. The groove is the same width as the kerf of the saw. Think of the kerf starter as a wide marking knife.

With the graduated teeth, the saw glides into the cut fairly well without using the finger to guide the saw.

I don't believe it is difficult for someone to learn to use any hand saw for its intended purpose--but then again, I haven't tried to teach more than 50/60 people. So I remain positive about its utility for those people who try it and find success.

All I really care about is that more people try their hand at sawing joinery, dimensioning and refining stuff as a shop practice. So if this saw and kerf starter works for people, I think it's great. That Kevin has given it a lot of thought is a given.

Take care, Mike

Re: Wild West Handsaw - 2 Handles Back Saw

#13

Funny...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>That you need to buy another tool just to get this saw to work. Capitalism at its finest.

Re: Wild West Handsaw - 2 Handles Back Saw

#14

Re: Not Worthless...

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Hi Mike,

I really like the idea of having a toothless length of blade at the toe end of a saw such as the WWW saw has. I think it would be an added feature to the LN graduated dovetail saw. First no teeth, then very small teeth, 15PPI and then bigger and bigger teeth.

I have retoothed a few dovetail saws with no teeth for the first one inch or so for a few guys who said at first they forgot to use it but after getting used to using it they liked it.

What do you think about no teeth for about the first 3 inches on a regular handsaw? We normally don't saw that close to the toe end anyway. It would work best on the smaller teeth, especially on crosscut saws.

Marv

Re: Wild West Handsaw - 2 Handles Back Saw

#15

Re: Funny...

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Hi Scott,

I agree....however, with the saw not having any teeth for a short distance at the toe end, it should be easy to start a cut without an extra tool.

I feel that if one cannot start a saw cut where they want it to be, using a traditional saw, they should find a different hobby. It's pretty much a no brainer, especially with a dovetail saw with 14-15PPI.

Marv

Re: Wild West Handsaw - 2 Handles Back Saw

#16

Re: Hmmm...

charlie belden

>There seems to be a great deal of inertia in the world of handtools, the assumption seeming to be "Tried & True" must be best so why bother to question whether there's a better way since what we've got is the result of hundreds of years of use and refinement.

Then along comes Veritas. They examine a tool, its function and use - THEN - starting with a set of design criteria, develop a better and/or easier to set up and use tool that does the job, including modern manufacturing materials and methods. Case in point - their medium shoulder plane. The Tried & True configuration, be it Stanley, or Clifton or Lie Nielsen all could use more, and more comfortable gripping positions. And since the iron is slightly wider than the plane, removing the iron to sharpen it, or even reseting the depth of cut, was often and trial and error, nudge & bump process. Something as obvious and simple as two set screws solved that problem. Why it hadn't been done before may be explained by the Intertia Thing. Or putting a screw in. on either side of the plane body, handle makes using the shoulder plane on its side much more convenient and easier. By merely beveling the hole that allows the iron to extend beyond the sides of the plane's body and you get another gripping option.

And speaking of Veritas, their regular and dovetail guides, with the UMHW faces for the saw to ride against, held in postion by rare earth magnets behind the UMHW, guarantees consistency - though cutting with their saw is notably slower than cuts made with a "dovetail" saw, western or japanese. Of course you're stuck with one dovetail angle, but at least you can do thin pins and "houndstooth" dovetails with it.

Then there's Festool's approach to "tailed" handtools. They start with a blank piece of paper, like Veritas does, but with the retail price point of the end design not being quite as significant a factor as for other tool manufacturers. In most cases their designs make moderate to significant improvements to existing ways of doing things. Occassionally they come up with something that's not been done before - like the DOMINO mortiser system. But that's best left to another forum.

One of the many things I like about woodworking is the fact that there are so many ways to skin a cat, and there seems to be new ways coming out regularly.

I'm glad we have people like Glen-Drake and the folks at Veritas seeing problems or shortcomings and trying to come up with solutions and improvements.

charlie belden

Re: Wild West Handsaw - 2 Handles Back Saw

#17

No teeth on toe could be useful

Paul M.

>I know that some woodworkers (not me) prefer to cut half-blind dovetails with the saw at an oblique angle, and then use an unsharpened scraper to drive down the remaining grain of the socket cut along the kerf line. I'm more of a paring person myself.

But if you had a backsaw that had a back that ran all the way to the nose end of the blade and you had a blade like this with no teeth on the toe, you could use the nose of your dovetail saw in the kerf and whack on the back with a mallet to drive in the kerf. With this newfangled 2-handled saw, you could still hold the dovetail saw with the nose in the kerf with your off-hand while picking up the mallet for a whack with your strong hand.

I can see hundreds of you wincing at the thought of doing this... I would never advocate beating on your dovetail saw, but heck we're thinking out of the box here aren't we? ;-)

Re: Wild West Handsaw - 2 Handles Back Saw

#18

Re: Hmmm...

Joel

>If you grip a Clifton or Record or Preston Shoulder plane backwards and pull it towards you you will find it very very comfortable and most important you get tons of control and the cutting happens right under your eyeball so that you can see what you are doing. It really is a wonderful design (and that's why the textured surface is in the back).

The real problem with lots of the old designs is that common knowledge has lost the proper use of lots of tools. I am continually amazed as historical methods and tools are researched on how much we have lost.

ps - to set a shoulder plane blade - grasp plane iron with fingers around mouth. Center blade. Tighten wedge or iron with fingers in place. Adjust for depth. - elapsed time - 10 seconds or less.

Re: Wild West Handsaw - 2 Handles Back Saw

#19

Outta the box...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>I kinda like that saw idea. Nice thing is it only needs 1 handle.

Re: Wild West Handsaw - 2 Handles Back Saw

#20

Oh Yea!

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>I "pull" shoulder planes a lot. Works relatively well going cross grain as well. Now, how did we get here....

Re: Wild West Handsaw - 2 Handles Back Saw

#21

Hear hear Marv!

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>I totally agree with you. In all fairness, I hope it can serve the cross- eyed otherwise dysfunctional people (not all that far from my own ways) happy in one sort or the other. I'll just sit here and remember that a fool and his money...

Re: Wild West Handsaw - 2 Handles Back Saw

#22

Nothing new under the sun? :@)

wilbur

>A one handled saw with progressive tpi and a toothless length of blade at the toe end?

That's exactly how the rip side of a ryoba is set up.

The crosscut side also has a toothless area at the end of the blade as well. There is also a toothless area on the heel of the blade on both sides.

:@)

Re: Wild West Handsaw - 2 Handles Back Saw

#23

Re: Nothing new under the sun? :@)

Alan Schwabacher

>If you are going to have a toothless section at the start of the cut (toe or heel, depending on whether it's a push or pull saw) why not have that section sharpened to a knife edge that aligns with one side of the kerf? That would make the saw right or left handed, but would help a beginner to cut to the line. I suppose you could make it ambidextrous by having a few knife teeth without points, that could be set to match the kerf on both sides.

Since everything else seems to have been tried, has anyone heard of this?