Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

Froe & Drawknife

Posts

Froe & Drawknife

#1

Froe & Drawknife

Bob in GB

>After 15 years at my company, I was asked to pick a gift or cash. I took the cash since none of the gifts were something I desired. I have about $125 to "spend recklessly".

I never had any good green woodworking tools and am thinking that is what I probably want. I find myself more and more processing my own wood - especially short pieces. It makes sense to me to bust some of this out green and save the bandsaw and jointer and planer - at least a bit. I am also thinking I may find more fun things to do making things in the rough, quickly. this could be rewarding.

I am thinking Froe and Drawknife. Looking for recommendations from group at large. What I have found so far is:

Froe:

http://www.traditionalwoodworker.com/default.php/cPath/36_387

Draw Knife:

http://www.traditionalwoodworker.com/default.php/cPath/36_104

Any quality and use advice is appreciated.

I already have some hand boring tools handed down to me as well as framing chises - good augment.

Bob

Re: Froe & Drawknife

#2

Re: Froe & Drawknife

Dave Mount

>If new and shiny is what you crave, don't let me dissuade you. However, drawknives are common as dirt on the used market, and except for a few brands/models, they don't seem to take on much of a "collector's premium". Even if you don't want to commit the time to looking around at yard sales and flea markets, they are plentiful on Ebay for far less than even the low end of the new models. And, unlike many tools, you can see most of what you need to know in typical Ebay pictures. Tight handles, some life left in the blade, and something less than egregious rust is about all you need to look for. Unlike chisels, you can use a small backbevel to deal with a little bit of pitting if there is some -- in fact, many (including me) recommend a small backbevel to improve control when using the drawknife bevel up. Witherby, Greenlee, PS&W are common makers that you can assume will be good users. I would think you could pick up something in good shape for $20-$25 without too much trouble.

Froes are not as common. Unfortunately, I don't know anything about the models on the page you pointed to.

Green woodworking is fun, it's own little slippery slope. Have fun.

Best,

Dave

Re: Froe & Drawknife

#3

Re: Froe & Drawknife *LINK*

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Would be a good idea to study John Alexander's site, and even better to purchase his dvd (look for the "video" at the bottom of the home page) on making a chair, great stuff.

Pam


John Alexander, Green Woodworking

Re: Froe & Drawknife

#4

Re: Froe & Drawknife *LINK*

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Forgot to mention the Brian Boggs dvd on "Drawknives, Spokeshaves and Travishers--A Chairmaker's Tool Kit" available at LN.

Pam


Boggs dvd

Re: Froe & Drawknife

#5

Re: Froe & Drawknife

john l. blue

>Dave's right about drawknives! I found a good deal on one at a

flea market for only 10 dollars, no handle but the blade was in

good shape. It was fun putting a dogwood handle on it.

I made a froe from an old lawnmower blade. Blue

Re: Froe & Drawknife

#6

Re: Froe & Drawknife

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>Bob,

I concur with others that inexpensive drawknives are available fairly cheap. These are good prices, though, and you may find that shipping for individual purchases from different vendors kind of dilutes the virtue of buying cheap.

Two comments on the drawknife, from limited experience: I prefer the knives with a sort of spine along the back and a thinner cutting edge (example: the Two Cherries knife, item 500-1350) over those with a solid blade (example: the Iltis knife, item 598-2250); and I like the curved blade over a straight one. But these are simple tools, and, if you get a decent one, it's hard to go too wrong.

Re: Froe & Drawknife

#7

Re: Froe & Drawknife

Mike Jurnigan in Suffolk

>If you are looking for a decent new froe I would recommend the one Drew Langsner sells at Country Workshops. You can buy it with or without a handle. (Countryworkshops.org)

Mike in Suffolk

Re: Froe & Drawknife

#8

Re: Froe & Drawknife

Patrick Gibbons, Houston, TX

>Go to the hand tools vendors link here at WoodCentral and look at Sandy Moss's site, Sydnasloot, and look at his offerings. I just bought a nice James Swan drawkife from him. Oldriverhardgoods on the bay had a nice Greenlee one for sale around the Fourth of July that didn't even get a bid. I'll bet it's been relisted. I only mention these two vendors because I have been pleased with my transactions with them. There are many other good ones. For a brand new froe try Joel's Tools for Working Wood. He carries a froe made by Ashley Iles or his brother. I don't think you would go wrong there buying new.

Re: Froe & Drawknife

#9

Re: Froe & Drawknife

ThomD

>I agree you can buy a great drawknife used. There are a lot of clunkers also. I was just lucky to get a great one first and it was an education. I tend to look for ones with an aircraft wing shaped section. I really like the Barr drawknife, the very small one he makes for carving is what one wants for timeber framing. It's a great knife and very sturdy, I don't like the ones that have a planer blade type section as much, but they all work.

Of the ones you gave URls for, the Drawknives all look horrible. Of the froes the Grasford Bruks style is a good one, but LV used to sell something similar for about 40.

You can get a froe here and make your own handle for minimal dollars. I like these. I bought the small one for light chairmaking, and no criticism of it, I bent it badly, so clearly it should be used as intended.

http://countryworkshops.org/rivingtools.html

This is the spokeshave I like, it's also on the opening page. I really doubt the chairmakers version they sell is actually better. This is the classic blade.

http://barrtools.com/Merchant2/merchant.mvc?Screen=PROD&Store_Code=BST&Product_Code=DKK61CE5X11X1&Category_Code=DK

Re: Froe & Drawknife

#10

Re: Froe & Drawknife

ThomD

>I concur with Pam's advice on the vids, though they didn't come along until I was set in my ways, and I was lucy with that first knife.

Funny, when one lists a new response here, one gets two cherries, and that certainly isn't my recomendation here!

Re: Froe & Drawknife

#11

Re: Country workshops' froe - mild steel?

Dave Mount

>I was surprised to read that the Country Workshops froe is made from mild steel. Although I realize you don't want a froe to be super hard, I would think one would make a froe from a higher carbon steel but with heavy tempering. If that blade is made from mild steel as the description says, it might not be as surprising that you were able to bend it.

Anybody know what kind of steel froes are usually made of?

I bought that relatively inexpensive froe that Lee Valley used to sell (doesn't appear they still sell them). It is a massive piece of steel and rather crudely made (and this was made clear in the catalog description). If I were to do it again, would opt for something a little more refined for chair work. This is not a poke at LV -- as I said, the description was accurate, I was just not experienced enough to realize that though it was cheap, it was a false economy relative to my needs and uses.

Dave

Re: Froe & Drawknife

#12

Re: Country workshops' froe - mild steel?

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Actually a sharp hard steel froe would be exactly what you don't want. They are supposed to split along the grain, not cut anything.

Pam

Re: Froe & Drawknife

#13

Re: Country workshops' froe - mild steel?

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>Pam is correct, there is an old saying:

Dull as a Froe

Stephen

Re: Froe & Drawknife

#14

Re: Sharp v. hard

Dave Mount

>Hi Pam--

I agree with you on the sharp (not) part, but I don't see the hard part the same way. It seems to me that the resiliance and relative lack of malleability of higher carbon tempered to a high temperature (i.e., softer and tougher within the range of high carbon) would be exactly what you want in a froe. The high carbon isn't for holding a sharp edge, it's for imparting strength to the blade to resist the levering forces applied when riving. After all, Thom indicated that he was able to bend the blade of his (apparently) mild steel froe, even if that was partially due to using it a little more rigorously than its intended application. Seems to me that using something with a half point or so of carbon (like 1050 or 5160 aka old leaf springs) would resist this problem better, without being so brittle that it would snap.

Best,

Dave

Re: Froe & Drawknife

#15

Re: Country workshops' froe - mild steel?

Mike Jurnigan in Suffolk

>I have had Drew's froe since '89 or '90. I had to replace the handle once. In the approximately 20 years of use mine has only a slight twist. That is primarily from trying to split pieces that I shoud have beeen using wedges and a maul on. Over all it is a well made and a reasonable price for the product and I would highly recommend it for medium duty work. No affliation just a satisfied customer of his products and his classes.

Mike in Suffolk

Re: Froe & Drawknife

#16

Re: Sharp v. hard

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Maybe so, guess the best thing to do would be to make one and try it.

Pam

Re: Froe & Drawknife

#17

OK

Todd Hughes

>I have seen dozens of old froes and have paid attention to what they were made out of because I used to make them and I was interested in how they were made.

About half I see are made out of wrought iron which is softer then mild steel. The other half probably made out of high carbon steel using old buggy or car springs as stock....befor you say AH HA! High Carbon steel was prefered by half the makers of froes I think it was more likley done because these old springs are just the right size to make a froe out of and were common and availble to smiths. These spring froes usually look more modern to me.

Interestingly I don't think I have ever seen a wrought iron froe with an applied steel edge which was very common on axes and other hand forged tools. This makes me thing having a steel in a froe is not that important.

When I made froes I have used wrought iron as well as steel. Don't know if one worked better then the other..Never had any complaints about either...Boils down to probably doesn't matter....Todd

Re: Froe & Drawknife

#18

YIKES !

Todd Hughes

>"Dave's right about drawknives! I found a good deal on one at a

flea market for only 10 dollars, no handle but the blade was in

good shape"

10 bucks for a drawknife with no handles !?....I hope the guy that sold that to you went out and bought a lottery ticket because he was one lucky SOB. In my experance a tool like that is impossiable to sell. I used to get them in box lots at the auction and then toss them into the scrap pile, now I just leave them at the auction

Even in the old tool hell I live in good drawknives are very common and cheap..easy to get them for $10-$15 so no need to buy ones with problems, imagine same were you live

First thing I check for is if the handle is loose or not matching if so no need to look at it any further...no handles?...Well guess if you like making handles and such then it would give you some enjoyment but I think most will be better off buying ones that don't need such work ......Todd

Re: Froe & Drawknife

#19

Re: YIKES !

john l. blue

>Hell yes I like makin' handles!

I told the feller I wanted a 10 dollar drawknife outta that pile

o' knives, the one he handed me, no handles, he also told me it was

in better shape than the ones with handles. He was right!

I make handles fer walkin' sticks, also.