Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

Very, very minor gloat, with question

Posts

Very, very minor gloat, with question

#1

Very, very minor gloat, with question

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>Today was Yard Waste to the Dump day, and, of course - I mean, of COURSE - I stopped by the recycling area. After I declined to pay $60 for an incomplete set of large-diameter dies (I go again Monday, maybe I'll offer $15 or $20 and see if they bite - not sure why I need 3/4" dies, but if I ever do, I'll have them), I was given a 6"x2" Norton oilstone, marked "No. 1 Washita," a little glazed but still flat.

The question: Norton's website doesn't offer any information on their Washita stones. Is the No. 1 a size or a quality measure, and, if quality, is No. 1 good (as in "We're No. 1!") or not so good ("On a scale of 1 to 5, with 5 as the highest...")?

Re: Very, very minor gloat, with question

#2

Re: Very, very minor gloat, with question

ThomD

>I don't know their grading system but in fineness it's black Ark, Ark, Washita (edge refining), and then something horrible leading up to it, like an SC stone or a cheap waterstone. Really pays to keep on top of the sharpening with these.

I think the grades are just different quality stones, last time I bought any. The Washita's can really look nice before they get all slimed up. CLouds of colour etc... consistancy is going to be an issue therefor.

As far as being number one is concerned they all apparently come from the same family enterprise so it's all inside baseball.

Re: Very, very minor gloat, with question

#3

#1 Washita

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>In the early 20th century #1 Washita was the standard grade. There were #2 stones (lower quality), but I am not sure they were so marked. There were also premium grades like Lily White and Rosy Red, stones with exceptional uniformity of color and texture. In my memory, only one grade was offered until Joel started marketing Lily White rather recently.

Re: Very, very minor gloat, with question

#4

Re: #1 Washita

Joel

>SAdly - Lily White Washita is going out of production again. Norton said that it's too expensive to quarry and that's that when I run out.

:(

Re: Very, very minor gloat, with question

#5

Re: Very, very minor gloat, with question

Tony Zaffuto

>I picked up a stone this past week, about 2" X 6" X 1". Stone is jet black and fairly soft. Doesn't appear to have ever been oiled and was dished pretty well in the center. I flattened it using 60 grit AO paper. Doesn't feel or look anything like a waterstone, and the back part of the stone looked almost like slate.

Anyone have any ideas about this baby? I have been visiting the dealer where I got it for half a dozen years, and in that time, have never seen any Japanese tools or stones.

T.Z.

Re: Very, very minor gloat, with question

#6

English Black Slate

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>I have one as well, still has the saw marks from the quarry on the sides. It is soft but very fine, you can use oil or water or nothing when you sharpen with this stone.

Mine is chipped on one corner but it is still usable. I would like to see these come back on the market (Hint, hint Joel).

Stephen


img

Re: Very, very minor gloat, with question

#7

Re: #1 Washita

Joe Rogers, Northern Virginia

>To Bad! Glad I got mine(minor gloat) a while back.

Cost is really encroaching on the Novaculite market.

Joe

Re: Very, very minor gloat, with question

#8

Re: English Black Slate

Joel

>what is English Black Slate? as far as I remember it isn't mentioned in Holzapfell so that's not it's trade name. Do you know the English name for it?

I have an English Charney Forest stone - soft slow cutting - not my cut of tea actually.

Re: Very, very minor gloat, with question

#9

Re: English Black Slate

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>Here are the English names of oilstones, I have heard them called English Black Slate:

Charnley Forest

Rag

Tam o'Shanter

Welsh

Water of Ayr

But then it could be a black Turkey stone?

Stephen

Re: Very, very minor gloat, with question

#10

Re: English Black Slate

Tony Zaffuto

>Stephen,

The back of mine looks similar to slate, but unlike any domestic slate, the striations/laminations are very, very tight. I flattened the stone, but have yet to try anything on it until I learn a bit more--don't want to oil it, etc., until I'm positive that's the way I'll go.

Thanks for your response!

Tony Z.

Re: Very, very minor gloat, with question

#11

Re: English Black Slate

Tony Zaffuto

>Joel,

What is it that makes this stone "not your cup of tea"? Too soft? Too slow cutting? Or both?

Thanks,

Tony Z.

Re: Very, very minor gloat, with question

#12

Re: English Black Slate

Joel

>Yes. Both.