Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

Nicholson Workbench (I know, I know)

Posts

Nicholson Workbench (I know, I know)

#1

Nicholson Workbench (I know, I know)

Bjenk Ellefsen

>Ok, I know what you think:"Not again!"

Hear me out before you let the tomatoes fly! I have read Chris' book and it is superb. Chris has done an amazing job on the Roubo and his version of a Nicholson.

However, I would like to consider the original for a moment. In Nicholson's The Mechanic's companion, the bench is a very simple thing made out of a top, four legs, two rails, a side board, a stop and a vise. I like this design so much and I don't care for a tail vise. I have one on my current bench and it is very useful but I can live without it.

I have an old picture of an example from Williamsburg and it looks massive. I was wondering how the side board is made flush with the legs: a lap joint made into the legs?

The one I see from Williamsburg has a base that is more similar to the French bench. The legs look like they are bigger than 4X4 square.

Are the benches still like that at Williamsburg?

Anyone else has built one and could point to more pictures?

I really like what I have read in Nicholson's The Mechanic as it is a simple and economical bench to build.

I need to replace my old European bench which does not cut it for what I'm doing. I also need to decided if it will go in the garage or the basement (where my shop is currently located). The thing is that I will move next year and I can't build a Roubo or a Nicholson bench in the basement for fear of being forced to abandon it.

Any thoughts on a knock-down version of the Nicholson? How do you secure the top into the sides of the legs and on top of them while trying to make it so you can knock it down? Or maybe I should just go for the garage. I really like the one from Williamsburg.

Sorry if this has been discussed before. I have been away for awhile.

Re: Nicholson Workbench (I know, I know)

#2

Re: Nicholson Workbench (I know, I know)

John Jesseph

>Knockdown won't work with the Williamsburg bench. I have a whole boatload of stuff on my old laptop that would help you, let me see if I can resurrect it...

Re: Nicholson Workbench (I know, I know)

#3

Re: Nicholson Workbench (I know, I know)

Adam Cherubini

>" I was wondering how the side board is made flush with the legs: a lap joint made into the legs?"

Yes.

"The one I see from Williamsburg has a base that is more similar to the French bench. The legs look like they are bigger than 4X4 square."

They are 4x4's. Southern Yellow Pine.

"Are the benches still like that at Williamsburg?"

Yes.

"Anyone else has built one and could point to more pictures?"

I'll email some to you Brother. By the time I shrink them down here, they won't be worth your while.

"Any thoughts on a knock-down version of the Nicholson? How do you secure the top into the sides of the legs and on top of them while trying to make it so you can knock it down? Or maybe I should just go for the garage. I really like the one from Williamsburg."

I made a knock down Nicholson bench and I think it was a success. The legs are permanently attached to the sides with screws and glue. The front and back leg/apron pieces join together with stretchers and are secured with bed bolts. The tops of the legs join with Nicholson's "bearers", in my case, tulip poplar 1x12's. The bearers "skin" across the legs and are held on with hex head bolts that screw into threaded inserts in the legs. At the top inside edge of the apron, I permanently attached a piece of angle iron. Hex head bolts go up through the angle iron into threaded inserts in the underside of the workbench top.

Though the connections seem modern, they are structurally similar to what I would assume Nicholson used. They are all shear connections. The benches at williamsburg have thick upper stretchers. The tops are attached to these using lag bolts.

My bench, though made of the poorest quality lumber is light and stiff. I don't believe these were cabinetmaker's benches. I've not seen any evidence of their use before 1800 and the earliest images of them are all associated with joineries. In the few inventories that include workbenches (like Plumley) the values associated with the benches seem to indicate something more valuable than these "boarded" benches.

My point is that these benches are great at what they are good for. But I don't feel they represent a universal superiority of design. But I recommend them because they have 90% of what a cabinetmaker needs and cost less than a good dovetail saw and only take a weekend to build. Its crazy not to build one.

If you find you need to move a bench (as I do), they are quite nearly perfect. I can move mine myself and set it up in about 10 minutes. It's 8' long, has a twin screw vise, and planing stops at either end.

Adam

Re: Nicholson Workbench (I know, I know)

#4

Re: Nicholson Workbench (I know, I know)

Bjenk Ellefsen

>John,

Well, knock down is not a deal breaker. I found interesting pictures of the benches at Williamsburg so I'm getting a better idea. I wonder if they used the dimensions indicated by Nicholson? The legs look more massive.

I am very interested with anything you can show me John.

Thanks!

Re: Nicholson Workbench (I know, I know)

#5

Re: Nicholson Workbench (I know, I know)

Bjenk Ellefsen

>Adam, thank you so much for your insights.

I will take the time to digest all the info about your successful design.

I agree with you about the Nicholson bench.

So far, I much prefer Roubo's examples and how you can customize them however you like according to the trade you are in but this bench is so cheap and simple that it would suit my needs and how I work for now. I intend to build an exact replica of one of Roubo's bench but that will have to wait. I need something lighter and less costly while staying as close as possible to the original design. I need to "feel" it before I move on if you know what I mean.

I can't thank you enough for the photos Adam.

Re: Nicholson Workbench (I know, I know)

#6

I am sure

Dan Donaldson

>I am sure that many would like to see the pictures. If you send me the full size ones, I will format them to be small enough to post and still big enough to see here on the boards and post them for you.

Re: Nicholson Workbench (I know, I know)

#7

Try these #1 

Dan Donaldson

>


img

Re: Nicholson Workbench (I know, I know)

#8

Try these #2 

Dan Donaldson

>


img

Re: Nicholson Workbench (I know, I know)

#9

Text

Dan Donaldson

>This is the text that Adam put with the pictures.

Hay shop benches- Note upper stretcher is pegged hard. You can see the lag bolt heads. The stuff in front of that is the guide and guide support for the rotten single screw face vise. Behind the upper stretcher is a full depth "bearer" which is more similar to what Nicholson described.

This picture is a little funny because the bench has been pulled away from the wall (which is unfortunately very similar in color to the bench.) But you can see the hole at the lower stretcher where the head of the bed bolts lies. You can also make out the full depth "bearer" which spans the top side of the legs. This bearer isn't actually necessary. But it does help[ stiffen the bench for precisely this sort of work. You can't see the angle iron in this picture, but it lies just in that insider corner between the top and the sides. It is interrupted only at the legs.

Re: Nicholson Workbench (I know, I know)

#10

Thanks Dan!

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>

Re: Nicholson Workbench (I know, I know)

#11

Thank Adam

Dan Donaldson

>I just put the pictures up for him. He did all the work and the writeup.